Parallax

16 August, 1717

Prince Eugene attacks out of the fog at Belgrade

Caught between a fortress he was besieging and a relief army far larger than his own, with dysentery emptying his trenches, the Habsburgs’ best general chose to attack before dawn.

Belgrade, Serbia

By the middle of August 1717 Prince Eugene of Savoy was in the worst position of his career. He had crossed the Danube in June with one of the largest armies the Habsburgs had ever put in the field, close to 100,000 men, and dug in around Belgrade, the fortress at the meeting of the Danube and the Sava that was the key to the Balkans. The garrison of some 30,000 under Mustafa Pasha was strong and well supplied. Then, at the end of July, the Grand Vizier Haci Halil Pasha arrived with a relieving army that Habsburg reports put at 150,000 or more and that was certainly much larger than Eugene’s. Halil did not attack. He entrenched on the high ground behind the besiegers, brought up his heavy guns and began to bombard them from the rear, while the fortress fired on them from the front.

Eugene’s men were dying in their trenches of dysentery and fever in the marshy ground between the rivers; he could count on perhaps 60,000 fit to fight. To retreat across the bridges under fire from both sides was barely possible. To sit still was to be worn away. On 14 August a mortar bomb landed on a powder magazine inside Belgrade, and the explosion killed, by report, some 3,000 people. Eugene judged it the moment. He left a screen facing the fortress and ordered the rest, about 40,000, to attack the Grand Vizier’s lines before dawn on the 16th.

The night was clear at first. Then a thick fog rose from the rivers. The columns set off in the small hours, and cavalry on the right wing lost direction, blundered into an Ottoman trench and started the battle earlier than planned. For several hours men fought blind at a few paces. The Habsburg wings pushed forward on diverging lines, and a gap opened between them into which Ottoman infantry advanced, close to cutting the attacking army in two.

At about eight o’clock the fog lifted. Eugene, who was fifty-three and had been wounded many times in thirty years of war, saw the gap, put himself at the head of the second line and led it in; he was wounded again. The gap was closed. Bavarian infantry then stormed the great battery on the heights that had done the most damage and turned the guns round. By mid-morning the Ottoman army was withdrawing towards Nis, abandoning its camp, well over a hundred guns and its stores.

Habsburg losses were about 5,000 killed and wounded; Ottoman losses are usually given as 15,000 to 20,000. The garrison, having watched its relief march away, asked for terms two days later and was allowed to leave with its families and the city’s Muslim inhabitants. Eugene entered a city that was largely empty.

How it came to this

The Ottoman Empire had taken Belgrade in 1521 and reached Vienna twice, in 1529 and 1683. The failure of the second siege opened a long Habsburg counter-offensive. Belgrade itself was captured in 1688 and lost again in 1690, and at Zenta in 1697 Eugene, then thirty-three, destroyed a sultan’s army as it crossed the river Tisza. The Treaty of Karlowitz in 1699 gave the Habsburgs Hungary and Transylvania.

The new war began elsewhere. In 1715 the Ottomans recovered the Peloponnese from Venice in a single campaign, and the emperor Charles VI, Venice’s ally, intervened the following year. In August 1716 Eugene defeated and killed the Grand Vizier Silahdar Ali Pasha at Petrovaradin, then took Temesvar, the last Ottoman fortress in Hungary. Belgrade was the logical next step. The prince himself was by origin neither Austrian nor German: born in Paris to a branch of the house of Savoy, refused a commission by Louis XIV, he had offered his sword to the emperor at nineteen and risen to be president of the war council and the most admired soldier in Europe.

How each side saw it

The Ottoman court

The court chronicler Rasid Mehmed Efendi recorded the campaign for the Ottoman government, and his account, with later ones, puts the blame on the commander. Halil Pasha was a former head of the palace guard of gardeners with little experience of field command; he ignored officers who urged an immediate assault on the weakened besiegers and trusted to bombardment. He was dismissed and went into hiding to escape execution. In Istanbul the loss strengthened those who thought the empire needed peace and time. Damad Ibrahim Pasha, who soon became Grand Vizier, concluded the treaty and presided over a decade of diplomacy, building and court culture later named the Tulip Period.

The Muslims of Belgrade

Ottoman Belgrade had been a largely Muslim city of mosques, baths, markets and dervish lodges, one of the biggest in the empire’s European provinces. Its people left with the garrison under the terms of surrender and resettled further south. Under Habsburg rule most mosques were converted to churches, barracks or stores, or pulled down, and German Catholic settlers were brought in to build a baroque fortress town. The departed left few written records of their own; the city they knew is reconstructed from Ottoman tax registers and from the traveller Evliya Celebi, who had described it at length half a century before.

The Serbs

Orthodox Serbs fought on the Habsburg side as militia and frontier troops and hoped for a Christian government. What they got, in the Habsburg Kingdom of Serbia of 1718-39, was military administration, heavy taxes, and pressure from Catholic clergy on their church. When the Ottomans returned in 1739, many Serbs who had compromised themselves fled north across the rivers with Patriarch Arsenije IV, in the second of the migrations that shifted the centre of Serbian life into Habsburg Hungary. Serbian historians have tended to see both empires as foreign masters and 1717 as a change of garrison.

The German and Austrian tradition

In German-speaking Europe the victory lived on in a soldiers’ song, ‘Prinz Eugen, der edle Ritter’, which tells of the prince bridging the river and taking the city and fortress of Belgrade. Its details are muddled, and its authorship by a soldier in the ranks is tradition. Habsburg Austria made Eugene its model hero. So, later, did others: the Third Reich named a heavy cruiser after him, and an SS mountain division, recruited largely from ethnic Germans of the Banat region he had conquered, which committed massacres of civilians in occupied Yugoslavia. That association still complicates his memory in the Balkans.

What is disputed

Numbers are the chief problem. The figure of 150,000 to 200,000 for the Grand Vizier’s army comes from Habsburg reports and includes camp followers; Ottoman specialists think the fighting strength far lower, though still well above Eugene’s. Claims that he was outnumbered four to one count only the troops he attacked with. Whether the dawn attack was a calculated stroke or a gamble rescued by the lifting of the fog was argued among his own officers. Popular accounts say no quarter was given; killing of wounded and stragglers is reported, but so is the negotiated departure of the garrison. Whether this was his greatest victory is a matter of taste: Zenta and Turin have their advocates.

What followed

The Treaty of Passarowitz, signed in July 1718, gave the Habsburgs the Banat of Temesvar, northern Serbia with Belgrade and western Wallachia, the greatest extent their power ever reached in the Balkans. It lasted twenty-one years. After a badly run war the Austrians handed Belgrade back by treaty in 1739, and the Ottomans held it, with one brief interruption, into the nineteenth century. The Banat, resettled with German, Serbian, Romanian and other colonists, stayed Habsburg until 1918. Eugene died in Vienna in 1736. His summer palace, the Belvedere, is now one of Austria’s principal art museums.

Read further

  • Derek McKay, Prince Eugene of Savoy (1977)
  • Nicholas Henderson, Prince Eugen of Savoy (1964)
  • Caroline Finkel, Osman’s Dream: The Story of the Ottoman Empire 1300-1923 (2005)
  • Virginia H. Aksan, Ottoman Wars 1700-1870: An Empire Besieged (2007)
  • Charles W. Ingrao, The Habsburg Monarchy 1618-1815 (1994)

Same day, other years

1819

Cavalry ride into a reform meeting at St Peter’s Field

Manchester, EnglandEurope

On a fine Monday some 60,000 people, many in Sunday clothes and marching behind bands and banners, gathered on St Peter’s Field in Manchester to hear Henry Hunt speak for reform of Parliament. Manchester, a town of well over 100,000, had no member of its own. The magistrates, watching from a house on the edge of the field, ordered Hunt’s arrest and sent in the local yeomanry, part-time cavalry drawn from the town’s manufacturers and shopkeepers, who rode into the crowd striking with sabres. Regular hussars were then ordered to clear the field. Eighteen people are counted as having died, among them a two-year-old boy and several women, and more than 650 were hurt. A local paper coined the name Peterloo in mockery of Waterloo.

Seen from elsewhere. The magistrates said they had read the Riot Act and faced an insurrection in the making; the government thanked them and passed the Six Acts against meetings and the radical press. Few in the crowd heard any warning. Hunt was jailed for two and a half years. No soldier or magistrate was convicted.

1869

The children’s battle at Acosta Nu

Acosta Nu, ParaguayThe Americas

By 1869 Paraguay had been at war with Brazil, Argentina and Uruguay for nearly five years and had almost no adult soldiers left. With Asuncion fallen, President Francisco Solano Lopez retreated into the hills, and on 16 August a rearguard of about 3,500 under General Bernardino Caballero was caught on open grassland by some 20,000 Brazilian and allied troops commanded by the Count of Eu, son-in-law of Brazil’s emperor. Most of the Paraguayans were boys, some as young as nine or ten, alongside old men and wounded. Tradition says many wore false beards to look like men at a distance. They held for most of the day. About 2,000 were killed. Paraguay marks 16 August as Children’s Day.

Seen from elsewhere. Brazilian histories call it the battle of Campo Grande and stress that Lopez chose to put children in the line. Paraguayan accounts say the grass was fired with wounded lying in it, on the Count’s orders, which Brazilian historians such as Francisco Doratioto dispute. How much of Paraguay’s population the war killed is itself contested.

1946

Direct Action Day and the Calcutta killings

Calcutta (Kolkata), IndiaAsia

The Muslim League, having withdrawn its acceptance of a British plan for a united India, called for 16 August 1946 to be observed as Direct Action Day in support of Pakistan. In Calcutta, capital of Bengal, the League’s provincial government under H. S. Suhrawardy declared a public holiday. A huge rally was held on the Maidan; by the afternoon Muslim and Hindu crowds were fighting across the city with knives, iron bars and fire. The killing went on for four days before troops restored order. At least 4,000 people died, and some estimates are two or three times higher; around 100,000 were left homeless. Violence spread that autumn to Noakhali and Bihar and later to the Punjab, and made partition seem to many the only way out.

Seen from elsewhere. The League said it had called for peaceful protest and was met with provocation. Congress and Hindu organisations accused Suhrawardy of holding back the police. The British governor was criticised for delay in calling out the army. Research by Suranjan Das and others finds that armed groups on both sides had prepared.

2012

Police shoot striking miners at Marikana

Marikana, South AfricaAfrica

Rock drill operators at the Lonmin platinum mine at Marikana, north-west of Johannesburg, walked out on 10 August 2012 in an unofficial strike for a wage of 12,500 rand a month. Over the next days ten people were killed, including two policemen and two security guards. On 16 August police moved to disperse about 3,000 strikers gathered on a rocky hill, many carrying spears, machetes and sticks. In two bursts of shooting, the second among boulders several hundred metres away and out of sight of television cameras, officers killed 34 miners and wounded 78. It was the deadliest use of force by South African police since the end of apartheid, and was at once compared with Sharpeville.

Seen from elsewhere. Police said they fired in self-defence when armed strikers charged. A judicial commission under Ian Farlam rejected much of that account, criticised police commanders and the company, and cleared senior politicians, including Cyril Ramaphosa, then a Lonmin director. Families of the dead say nobody has been held to account.

Also on 16 August