Parallax

18 August, 1227

Genghis Khan dies and is buried in secret

The conqueror of an empire from the Pacific to the Caspian died on campaign in north-west China. His generals hid the death until a city had been destroyed, and nobody has ever found the grave.

Near the Liupan Mountains, Western Xia (now north-west China)

In the summer of 1227 the Mongol army was finishing off the Tangut kingdom of Western Xia, a Buddhist state on the upper Yellow River that had submitted to Genghis Khan in 1210 and then, in his eyes, betrayed him by refusing troops for his western war. He had marched against it in 1226 with the intention, according to the Mongols’ own chronicle, of leaving nothing alive. By August the Tangut capital, Zhongxing, near modern Yinchuan, had been under siege for months, and its ruler was negotiating a surrender.

The khan himself was not at the siege. He had moved south to cooler ground near the Liupan Mountains, and he was ill. The Secret History of the Mongols says that during a hunt for wild horses the previous winter his mount had shied and thrown him, and that he had been in pain and feverish afterwards. His commanders urged him to withdraw and return when he had recovered. He refused: the Tangut would say his heart had failed him.

He died some time in the second half of August. He was probably in his sixties. The sources agree that he gave orders on his deathbed: his third son Ogedei was to succeed him, the war against the Jin empire of north China was to be carried on by a route through Song territory, and his death was to be kept quiet until Zhongxing had opened its gates. So it was done. The Tangut ruler came out to submit, was killed, and the city’s population was put to the sword. A state that had lasted almost two centuries, with its own script and printed books, disappeared so completely that its language was not read again until the twentieth century.

The body was carried north across the Gobi towards the Mongol homeland, a journey of several weeks. Later writers say the escort killed every person and animal it met on the road so that word of the death could not run ahead; Marco Polo tells the story of a later khan’s cortege and the Persian historians tell it of this one. It may be true, or it may be the kind of story that grew up to explain a silence.

He was buried, by most accounts, on or near Burkhan Khaldun, the mountain in the Khentii range where he had hidden from enemies as a young man and which he held sacred. No mound was raised. The ground is said to have been trampled by horses and left to the forest, and a wide area around it was closed off as the Great Taboo, guarded for generations by a clan charged with keeping everyone out.

How it came to this

He was born Temujin, somewhere near the Onon River, in a year the sources put variously at 1155, 1162 or 1167. His father, a minor chief, was poisoned by Tatars when the boy was about nine, and the family was abandoned by its clan and lived on roots and fish. He was at one point a captive in a wooden collar. Over three decades, through alliance, betrayal and war, he broke the Tatars, Kereit and Naiman, and in 1206 an assembly on the Onon proclaimed him Genghis Khan, ruler of all who lived in felt tents.

He reorganised the steppe peoples into decimal military units that cut across tribe, promoted by merit and loyalty, and gave them a written law and a script borrowed from the Uighurs. Then he turned outward: against Western Xia, against the Jin, whose capital near modern Beijing fell in 1215, and from 1219 against the Khwarazmian empire in Central Asia and Iran after its governor killed a Mongol trade caravan. Bukhara, Samarkand, Merv and Nishapur were sacked. By 1227 his armies had ridden as far as the Crimea and the Indus.

How each side saw it

The Mongol court

The Secret History of the Mongols, written for the ruling family within a generation or so of his death, is the only substantial source from the Mongol side. It is frank in ways a court chronicle rarely is: it records that the boy Temujin was afraid of dogs, that he killed his half-brother over a fish, and that his wife Borte was carried off by enemies. But its hero is Heaven’s chosen, and the destruction of the Tangut is told as justice done to oath-breakers. In modern Mongolia he is the founder of the nation, his cult suppressed under Soviet influence and restored since 1990.

Muslim chroniclers

The Mosul historian Ibn al-Athir, a contemporary, wrote that for years he could not bring himself to record the Mongol invasion, calling it a calamity greater than any since the creation of Adam. Juzjani, who fled to Delhi, calls the khan the accursed. Juvaini, a Persian who served the Mongols a generation later and had to praise them, still passes on a refugee’s summary of the fall of Bukhara: they came, they sapped, they burned, they slew, they plundered and they departed. The figures these writers give for the dead of Merv and Nishapur run into millions and are not credible as counts, but the devastation of Khurasan is confirmed by archaeology.

The Tangut and the Chinese record

The Tangut left no account of their own end. What is known comes from the Mongol chronicle, from the Yuan Shi, the Chinese dynastic history compiled in 1370 under the Ming, and from Tangut-language documents recovered by a Russian expedition at Khara-Khoto in 1908-09. Chinese official historiography treats Genghis as Taizu, founding ancestor of the Yuan dynasty, and the People’s Republic presents him as a figure in the history of a multi-ethnic China. That claim is resented by many Mongolians, and a memorial to him at Ejin Horo in Inner Mongolia holds relics, not a body.

What is disputed

Almost everything. The date of 18 August is one of several traditional reckonings; the Yuan Shi gives a day that converts to 25 August, and neither can be verified. The cause is variously given as the riding fall, an illness, an arrow wound at a siege (Marco Polo), or, in later Mongol legend, a wound inflicted by a captive Tangut queen. A 2021 medical study proposed plague. The burial place is unknown: Burkhan Khaldun is the leading candidate, but other sites in Mongolia and China have been argued for. His birth year, and so his age, is also unsettled.

What followed

An assembly in 1229 confirmed Ogedei as Great Khan, and under him and his nephews the conquests went on: the Jin fell in 1234, Russia in 1237-40, Baghdad in 1258, the Song in 1279. The unified empire lasted barely a generation after that before dividing into four khanates. Its legacy is argued over still, between those who stress the trade and exchange carried along Mongol roads, and those who count the cities that never recovered. Many Mongolians oppose any search for the grave, and the area around Burkhan Khaldun remains protected.

Read further

  • The Secret History of the Mongols, translated by Igor de Rachewiltz (2004)
  • Paul Ratchnevsky, Genghis Khan: His Life and Legacy, translated by Thomas Nivison Haining (1991)
  • Ata-Malik Juvaini, The History of the World-Conqueror, translated by J. A. Boyle (1958)
  • Peter Jackson, The Mongols and the Islamic World: From Conquest to Conversion (2017)
  • Timothy May, The Mongol Conquests in World History (2012)

Same day, other years

1868

An eclipse over India reveals an unknown element

Guntur, IndiaAsia

Astronomers from several countries travelled to southern India to observe a long total eclipse of the Sun. At Guntur the Frenchman Pierre Janssen turned a spectroscope on the flame-like prominences at the Sun’s edge and saw bright lines, among them a yellow one close to, but not matching, the known lines of sodium. He realised the lines were bright enough to be studied without an eclipse and did so the following day. In England that October, Norman Lockyer made the same observation independently, and with the chemist Edward Frankland proposed that the yellow line belonged to an element not known on Earth. They named it helium, after the Greek word for the Sun.

Seen from elsewhere. Janssen is often credited with discovering helium, but he did not claim a new element; that was Lockyer’s inference, and most chemists doubted it for a quarter of a century. Others at the eclipse, including Norman Pogson at Masulipatam, also recorded the line. Helium was accepted only after William Ramsay isolated it from a uranium mineral in 1895.

1920

Tennessee gives American women the vote

Nashville, Tennessee, United StatesThe Americas

The Nineteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, barring the denial of the vote on grounds of sex, needed ratification by 36 states. By August 1920 it had 35, and Tennessee was the last realistic hope that year. Lobbyists for both sides filled Nashville’s Hermitage Hotel, wearing yellow roses for suffrage and red for opposition. The state house appeared deadlocked. Harry Burn, at 24 its youngest member, wore a red rose, but had in his pocket a letter from his widowed mother, Febb Burn, telling him to be a good boy and vote for ratification. He voted aye, and the amendment passed the house by 50 to 46.

Seen from elsewhere. Opponents, many of them women, argued that the vote would damage the family and, in the South, that it would reopen the question of Black voting. On that point the result was limited: poll taxes, literacy tests and violence kept most Black women in the southern states from voting until 1965, and many Native American women were not yet citizens.

1976

Two American officers are killed over a poplar tree

Panmunjom, Korean Demilitarised ZoneAsia

A poplar in the Joint Security Area at Panmunjom blocked the line of sight between two United Nations Command posts. When an American and South Korean work party began pruning it, a group of North Korean soldiers ordered them to stop, and then attacked with clubs and with the axes the workmen had dropped. Captain Arthur Bonifas and Lieutenant Mark Barrett were beaten to death. Three days later, in Operation Paul Bunyan, engineers cut the tree down while infantry, helicopter gunships, B-52 bombers and an aircraft carrier offshore stood ready. The North Koreans watched and did nothing. The Joint Security Area, until then open to both sides, was afterwards divided along the demarcation line.

Seen from elsewhere. North Korea said the Americans had come in force to provoke an incident, had ignored a warning that the tree could not be touched without agreement, and had struck first. Kim Il Sung then sent a message calling the deaths regrettable, the nearest thing to an apology Washington had received from him. It did not accept responsibility.

1989

Luis Carlos Galan is shot dead at a campaign rally

Soacha, ColombiaThe Americas

Luis Carlos Galan, a Liberal senator and the clear favourite to win Colombia’s 1990 presidential election, climbed on to a wooden platform in the main square of Soacha, outside Bogota, and raised his arms to the crowd. A gunman below fired a submachine gun into him. He was 45. Galan had campaigned against the drug traffickers’ penetration of politics and in favour of extraditing them to the United States, and the Medellin cartel had already tried to kill him. President Virgilio Barco responded that night with emergency decrees restoring extradition and seizing traffickers’ property. The cartel answered with car bombs and the destruction of an airliner in flight.

Seen from elsewhere. The traffickers, calling themselves the Extraditables, said they preferred a grave in Colombia to a cell in the United States and presented their war as a defence of sovereignty. Colombian courts later found the killing was not theirs alone: the politician Alberto Santofimio was convicted of instigating it, and a former intelligence chief of deliberately weakening Galan’s bodyguard.

Also on 18 August