Parallax

5 August, 1864

Farragut takes his fleet through the mines into Mobile Bay

A Union ironclad struck a mine and sank almost at once at the mouth of the last big Confederate port on the Gulf. The admiral behind her, tied into the rigging of his flagship, ordered the fleet on through the minefield. Whether he said the famous words is another matter.

Mobile Bay, Alabama, United States

At a quarter to six on the morning of 5 August 1864, eighteen Union warships got under way on the flood tide outside Mobile Bay. Four were ironclad monitors, low in the water with revolving turrets. The other fourteen were wooden, lashed together in pairs so that if the engines of one were shot out her partner could carry her through. Rear Admiral David Glasgow Farragut, sixty-three years old, climbed into the port main rigging of his flagship Hartford to see over the smoke, and a quartermaster was sent up to pass a line round him.

The usable channel was narrow. On the right stood Fort Morgan, a brick fortress with some forty-five guns. On the left the Confederates had driven piles and laid nearly two hundred mines, then called torpedoes, leaving a gap under the fort’s guns for blockade runners. Beyond waited Admiral Franklin Buchanan with three small gunboats and the ironclad ram Tennessee, plated with six inches of iron.

The fort opened fire a little after seven. The leading monitor, Tecumseh, turned towards the Tennessee, crossed into the minefield and struck a torpedo. She went down bow first in well under two minutes, her propeller still turning in the air, taking more than ninety of her 114 men. Her captain, Tunis Craven, is said to have stepped back from the escape ladder to let the pilot go first, with the words ‘After you, pilot’. The pilot lived.

The Brooklyn, heading the wooden column, stopped and began to back. The ships behind closed up into a knot directly under the fort’s guns. Farragut ordered the Hartford to pass her to the left, straight across the line of mines. Men below decks later said they heard the primers of the torpedoes snapping against the hull. None exploded; months in warm salt water had ruined most of them. The fleet followed him through.

Inside the bay the Union ships dealt with the gunboats, and the crews were sent to breakfast. Then Buchanan brought the Tennessee out alone against the whole fleet. For more than an hour she was rammed by wooden sloops and pounded at close range by the monitors’ heavy guns, until her steering chains were shot away, her funnel was gone and Buchanan lay with a broken leg. She surrendered at ten o’clock.

The Union lost about 150 dead, most of them in the Tecumseh, and 170 wounded; the Confederates twelve dead. Fort Gaines gave up three days later and Fort Morgan on 23 August.

How it came to this

From the first weeks of the Civil War the Union’s strategy included closing the South’s ports to starve it of arms and of the earnings from cotton. By 1864 New Orleans, Pensacola and most Atlantic harbours had fallen or been sealed. Mobile, protected by thirty miles of bay and by forts at the entrance, remained the chief Gulf haven for the fast steamers that ran the blockade from Havana. Farragut, who had taken New Orleans in 1862 by running past its forts at night, had wanted to attack Mobile ever since, and had been kept waiting for troops and ironclads.

Both admirals were Southerners in the old navy. Farragut, born in Tennessee and married in Virginia, left his home in Norfolk the day after Virginia seceded. Buchanan, a Marylander and the first superintendent of the Naval Academy, resigned expecting his state to secede, tried to withdraw the resignation when it did not, was refused, and went south. In the summer of 1864 the war was going badly enough for the Union that Abraham Lincoln privately expected to lose the November election.

How each side saw it

The Confederate defenders

Buchanan’s report presents the last sortie of the Tennessee as a duty: he had coal for only a few hours, and to stay under the fort’s guns was to be starved out without a fight. Some of his own officers thought it threw away the one ship that might have prolonged the defence. Brigadier General Richard Page held Fort Morgan for another eighteen days under bombardment and spiked his guns before surrendering, for which Union officers accused him of bad faith. The city of Mobile itself, thirty miles up the bay, was not taken until April 1865, after Lee’s surrender.

Black sailors and enslaved labourers

Much of the earthwork and obstruction at Mobile was built by enslaved men hired or impressed from Alabama planters, whose experience survives mainly in owners’ compensation claims. On the Union side Black sailors made up a substantial share of the crews; the navy, unlike the army, had never been segregated by ship. John Lawson, a landsman on the Hartford, was thrown against the bulkhead by a shell that killed or wounded the rest of his ammunition party, and went back to his station. He received the Medal of Honor.

The Union navy and the North

In Washington the victory was the first good news of a bleak summer, followed four weeks later by the fall of Atlanta; together they helped turn the election. Within the navy it was read as proof that ships could run past forts, a lesson that held until guns improved. There was also recrimination. Captain James Alden of the Brooklyn spent years defending his decision to stop, and the monitors’ officers disputed who had done most to disable the Tennessee. Congress created the rank of vice admiral for Farragut that December.

What is disputed

The line ‘Damn the torpedoes! Full speed ahead!’ does not appear in Farragut’s report, in the ships’ logs or in letters written at the time. It emerged in accounts published years later, in longer forms such as ‘Damn the torpedoes! Four bells! Captain Drayton, go ahead! Jouett, full speed!’ Some officers present remembered an oath; others doubted anything could have been heard from the rigging over the guns. His son’s 1879 biography gave the phrase its authority. Historians also argue over why the Tecumseh left the channel, and whether Farragut knew the mines were mostly dead or took a gamble that happened to succeed.

What followed

Mobile was closed to blockade runners for the rest of the war, leaving Wilmington in North Carolina as the Confederacy’s last major outlet until it fell in early 1865. Farragut, in poor health, saw no more fighting; he became the United States Navy’s first full admiral in 1866 and died in 1870. Buchanan kept his leg and lived quietly in Maryland. The Tecumseh still lies upside down in the mud off Fort Morgan with her crew inside, protected as a war grave. The phrase attributed to Farragut entered the language as a shorthand for pressing on regardless of risk.

Read further

  • Jack Friend, West Wind, Flood Tide: The Battle of Mobile Bay (2004)
  • Chester G. Hearn, Admiral David Glasgow Farragut: The Civil War Years (1998)
  • Craig L. Symonds, Confederate Admiral: The Life and Wars of Franklin Buchanan (1999)
  • James M. McPherson, War on the Waters: The Union and Confederate Navies, 1861-1865 (2012)
  • Loyall Farragut, The Life of David Glasgow Farragut, First Admiral of the United States Navy (1879)

Same day, other years

1772

Three empires sign the first partition of Poland

St Petersburg, RussiaEurope

In St Petersburg the envoys of Russia, Prussia and Austria signed conventions by which each took a slice of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth. The Commonwealth lost nearly a third of its territory and more than four million people. Frederick II of Prussia, who had pressed hardest for the scheme, gained the corridor linking his scattered lands; Catherine II took a broad strip in the east; Maria Theresa, despite her stated scruples, received the largest population, in Galicia. Troops were already in place. The Polish parliament, surrounded by foreign soldiers, was made to ratify the loss the following year, over the protest of a deputy, Tadeusz Rejtan, who lay across the doorway of the chamber. Two more partitions erased the state by 1795.

Seen from elsewhere. The three courts spoke of ancient legal claims and of ending Polish ‘anarchy’, pointing to civil war and a parliament any one member could paralyse. Polish tradition calls it robbery, and notes that Russia and Prussia had for decades blocked reform to keep the country weak. Historians weigh both: real dysfunction, deliberately preserved by the neighbours.

1944

The Cowra breakout

Cowra, New South Wales, AustraliaOceania

At about two in the morning a bugle sounded in the prisoner-of-war camp outside the farming town of Cowra, and more than a thousand Japanese prisoners rushed the wire with baseball bats, sharpened mess knives and blankets to throw over the barbs. Huts were set on fire behind them. Two Australian privates, Ben Hardy and Ralph Jones, kept a machine gun firing until they were overrun and killed. Over three hundred prisoners got clear and were rounded up across the countryside in the next nine days. In all, 231 Japanese died, many by their own hand, along with four Australians. No civilian was harmed, on the instructions, it was later learned, of the prisoners’ own leaders.

Seen from elsewhere. Japanese army regulations taught that capture was a disgrace to a soldier and his family, and many prisoners had given false names so that relatives would think them dead. Survivors later described a hut-by-hut vote in which few dared oppose the breakout. Japan said little for decades; a Japanese war cemetery and garden now stand at Cowra.

1962

Nelson Mandela is arrested on a country road

near Howick, Natal, South AfricaAfrica

After seventeen months underground, during which he had helped found the armed wing of the African National Congress and travelled across Africa and to London seeking support, Nelson Mandela was driving back from Durban to Johannesburg dressed as a chauffeur. Police cars stopped the vehicle outside the town of Howick. He gave the name David Motsamayi and was not believed. He was sentenced that November to five years for incitement and for leaving the country without a passport, and was already in prison when police raided the movement’s hideout at Rivonia in 1963. Tried again for sabotage, he was sentenced to life. He was released on 11 February 1990, more than twenty-seven years after the arrest.

Seen from elsewhere. The South African state regarded him as the commander of a sabotage campaign directed by communists. How the police knew his route is unsettled. A former American diplomat, Donald Rickard, said in an interview published in 2016 that he had passed on the tip for the CIA; the agency has never confirmed it.

2019

India revokes the special status of Jammu and Kashmir

New Delhi and Srinagar, IndiaAsia

Article 370 of India’s constitution had given Jammu and Kashmir, the country’s only Muslim-majority state, its own constitution and flag and limits on the reach of national law, on terms dating from its disputed accession in 1947. On 5 August the home minister, Amit Shah, announced in parliament a presidential order ending those arrangements and a bill dividing the state into two territories governed from Delhi. Tens of thousands of extra troops had been sent in beforehand. Telephone and internet services were cut, in places for months, and several thousand people were detained, including three former chief ministers. The Supreme Court upheld the revocation in December 2023 and directed that statehood be restored.

Seen from elsewhere. The government said the change brought equal rights, investment and an end to separatism. Kashmiri parties called it a breach of the terms on which the region joined India, imposed with their leaders locked up, and feared a change in its population. Pakistan, which also claims Kashmir, downgraded relations. Many Buddhists in Ladakh at first welcomed separate status.

Also on 5 August