Parallax

26 August, 1346

Crecy: the French cavalry rides into the arrows

An English army that had spent six weeks burning its way across Normandy turned to fight on a hillside in Picardy. By nightfall much of the French nobility was dead, and so was a blind king who had asked to be led into the battle.

Crecy-en-Ponthieu, Picardy, France

Edward III had chosen his ground by the morning of Saturday 26 August: a slope near the village of Crecy, with a wood behind and his men drawn up on foot in three divisions. The forward one was given, in name, to his sixteen-year-old son Edward, the future Black Prince, with experienced earls at his side. Thousands of archers with longbows stood on the flanks. The men-at-arms dismounted and sent their horses to the rear. Pits were dug in front of the line. Then the army sat down, ate and waited.

Philip VI of France arrived late in the afternoon at the head of a much larger force strung out for miles along the road from Abbeville. His advisers urged him to camp and fight in the morning. The order to halt was given and could not be made to stick: the leading contingents stopped, those behind pressed on, and the army drifted into contact. A sharp shower passed over. The sun came out behind the English and shone in French faces.

Philip sent forward his Genoese crossbowmen, hired professionals under Ottone Doria and Carlo Grimaldi. They had marched all day and their large shields were still with the baggage. A crossbow outranged nothing that day and took far longer to load than a longbow. Caught in a storm of arrows they fell back, and the mounted French nobles behind them, led by the king’s brother the Count of Alencon, rode them down and charged up the slope.

There was no single assault but a succession of them, fifteen or more by one count, continuing into the dark. Horses were shot down or went mad with wounds, and riders who reached the line met dismounted men with lances and axes. The prince’s division was hard pressed. John, king of Bohemia, who had been blind for years, had his knights tie their bridles to his and lead him in so that he could strike a blow; they were found together the next day. Philip, wounded by an arrow, was pulled away by John of Hainault and rode through the night to the castle of La Broye.

In the fog of Sunday morning fresh French levies, marching up in ignorance of the result, blundered into the English and were cut to pieces. Edward’s heralds then went over the field. They counted 1,542 dead lords and knights on the French side. Nobody counted the common soldiers.

How it came to this

The war had begun in 1337 over Gascony, which the English king held as a vassal of the French crown, and over the crown itself. Edward III was the grandson of Philip IV through his mother Isabella, and in 1340 he formally took the title king of France, a claim French lawyers rejected on the ground that it could not pass through a woman. Early fighting in Flanders and Brittany was expensive and indecisive.

In July 1346 Edward landed on the Cotentin peninsula with perhaps fourteen thousand men and marched east in a broad front, burning villages, crops and towns. Caen was stormed and sacked with heavy loss of civilian life. This was a chevauchee, a mounted raid meant to ruin the enemy’s revenue and show that his king could not protect him. Edward came within sight of Paris, then turned north, forced the Seine at Poissy and the Somme at the tidal ford of Blanchetaque on 24 August with Philip’s army close behind. Two days later he stopped running, if running is what it had been.

How each side saw it

French chroniclers and the court

The official Grandes Chroniques de France and other French writers looked for an explanation that spared the king. They blamed the disorder and pride of the nobles, each of whom wanted the honour of striking first, and they blamed the Genoese, whom Alencon was said to have accused of treachery as he rode over them. Moralists went further. One strand of comment held that God had punished the French aristocracy for vanity, down to its fashion for short, tight clothes. Philip himself appears as brave and unlucky, unable to restrain an army that would not obey.

The Genoese crossbowmen

The hired crossbowmen left no account of their own; their side is known mainly through the Florentine chronicler Giovanni Villani, who gathered news from Italian merchants and died two years later. In his telling they were sent in exhausted, without their shields and against their captains’ advice, and were then killed by their own employers. The story that rain had slackened their bowstrings while English archers kept theirs dry comes from the French friar Jean de Venette and is doubted. After the battle Philip is reported to have ordered Genoese in other garrisons killed as traitors before the order was withdrawn.

The people of Normandy and Picardy

For those who lived along the line of march the great event of 1346 was not the battle but the six weeks before it. English campaign letters, written to be read out at home, list the towns burned without embarrassment: Barfleur, Carentan, Saint-Lo, Caen, the suburbs of Beauvais. At Caen several thousand townspeople are said to have been killed, though no figure is reliable. Peasants who could not flee to a walled place lost stock, harvest and often their lives. Their experience survives in tax petitions and local records asking for relief from ruin, not in chronicles.

English tradition and its critics

Jean Froissart, writing decades later for noble patrons, turned Crecy into a pageant of chivalry and gave England its favourite scene: the king refusing to send help to his son, saying the boy should win his spurs. English memory made it the triumph of the yeoman archer over the armoured aristocrat. Modern historians such as Andrew Ayton point out that the army was a paid, practised force under noble command, that its tactics had been worked out against the Scots, and that the victory belonged to discipline and position as much as to the bow.

What is disputed

Numbers are guesses: perhaps ten to fifteen thousand English against twenty to thirty thousand French. Edward’s reported loss of a few dozen men is not credible. Clifford Rogers argues that Edward wanted a battle all along; Jonathan Sumption and others think he was retreating to Flanders and was caught. In 2015 Michael Livingston and Kelly DeVries proposed that the battle was fought several kilometres south of the traditional site, which most specialists have not accepted. The ‘win his spurs’ speech rests on Froissart alone. The tale that the Prince of Wales’s feathers and motto came from the dead king of Bohemia has no contemporary support.

What followed

Edward marched to Calais and took it after an eleven-month siege; it stayed English until 1558. The French defeat was repeated at Poitiers in 1356, where Philip’s successor was captured, and at Agincourt in 1415. Crecy did not end heavy cavalry, which French armies went on using, but it fixed the English method of dismounted men-at-arms flanked by archers for a century. It also confirmed that the war would be long. Fighting continued, with truces, until 1453, and English kings did not drop the title king of France until 1801.

Read further

  • Andrew Ayton and Philip Preston, The Battle of Crecy, 1346 (2005)
  • Jonathan Sumption, The Hundred Years War, Volume I: Trial by Battle (1990)
  • Michael Livingston and Kelly DeVries (eds), The Battle of Crecy: A Casebook (2015)
  • Clifford J. Rogers, War Cruel and Sharp: English Strategy under Edward III, 1327-1360 (2000)
  • Jean Froissart, Chronicles

Same day, other years

1071

A Roman emperor is captured at Manzikert

Malazgirt, eastern Anatolia (Turkey)Middle East

The Byzantine emperor Romanos IV Diogenes had marched to the far east of his empire to stop Turkish raiding and met the army of the Seljuk sultan Alp Arslan near Lake Van. Half his force, sent off on a separate task, never returned. In the battle itself the Turkish horse archers gave ground all day and closed in at dusk when the emperor ordered a withdrawal; the rearguard under Andronikos Doukas, from a rival family, left the field. Romanos fought on until he was wounded and taken. The sultan treated him courteously and released him within about a week in return for a ransom and a treaty.

Seen from elsewhere. In Turkey the battle is commemorated as the opening of Anatolia to the Turks. The eyewitness Michael Attaleiates blamed treachery at court, and many historians now hold that the losses were modest: what ruined Byzantine Asia Minor was the civil war that followed, in which Romanos was deposed and blinded by his own side.

1789

The Declaration of the Rights of Man is completed

Versailles, FranceEurope

After a week of debate the National Constituent Assembly voted the last of seventeen articles of a declaration meant to preface a constitution. Men, it said, are born and remain free and equal in rights; sovereignty resides in the nation; law is the expression of the general will; no one may be arrested except by law or troubled for his opinions, including religious ones; property is inviolable. Lafayette had prepared an early draft with advice from Thomas Jefferson, then American minister in Paris. The king withheld his acceptance until a crowd marched on Versailles in October.

Seen from elsewhere. Who counted as a man was argued at once. Olympe de Gouges answered with a Declaration of the Rights of Woman in 1791 and was guillotined in 1793. Free men of colour in Saint-Domingue cited the text; slavery in French colonies lasted until 1794 and was restored in 1802. Pope Pius VI condemned it, and Jeremy Bentham called natural rights nonsense upon stilts.

1896

The Ottoman Bank is seized, and a massacre follows

Constantinople (Istanbul), Ottoman EmpireMiddle East

About two dozen armed members of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation stormed the headquarters of the Imperial Ottoman Bank, a largely European-owned institution, and held its staff for some fourteen hours. Their leader was killed at the door; a twenty-three-year-old, Armen Garo, took over. They threatened to blow up the building unless the European powers imposed reforms to protect Armenians, tens of thousands of whom had been killed in the provinces over the previous two years. After negotiation they were given safe passage to France. Over the next two days crowds armed with clubs killed Armenians across the capital, by most estimates five to six thousand.

Seen from elsewhere. The Ottoman government presented the raid as terrorism and the killings as the spontaneous anger of Muslims. The foreign ambassadors, in a joint note, said the mobs had been organised and armed in advance and that police looked on. Armenian opinion was and is divided on whether the raid was a desperate appeal or a reckless provocation.

1966

The first shots of Namibia’s war of independence

Omugulugwombashe, Ovamboland, South West Africa (Namibia)Africa

South Africa had ruled the former German colony since the First World War under a League of Nations mandate and applied its apartheid laws there. In July 1966 the International Court of Justice declined on a technicality to rule on a challenge to that rule, and the liberation movement SWAPO declared that it had no choice but to fight. On 26 August South African police with helicopters attacked a guerrilla training camp at Omugulugwombashe in the north. Two fighters were killed and others captured. The war went on for twenty-three years, spilling into Angola, until a settlement led to independence in 1990.

Seen from elsewhere. South Africa called the conflict the Border War and described it as defence against Soviet-backed terrorism; its conscripts were told little else. Namibia marks 26 August as Heroes’ Day. SWAPO’s own record is disputed by former members it detained and tortured as suspected spies in camps in Angola during the 1980s.

Also on 26 August