Parallax

24 August, 1572

The St Bartholomew’s Day massacre

A royal wedding meant to reconcile France’s Catholics and Protestants ended six days later with the Protestant leadership murdered in their beds and the people of Paris hunting their neighbours through the streets.

Paris, France

Paris in August 1572 was hot, crowded and angry. The Protestant nobility of France had come to the capital in their hundreds for the wedding, on 18 August, of their young leader Henry of Navarre to the king’s sister Marguerite. The city was fiercely Catholic, its preachers had denounced the marriage from the pulpits, and bread was dear. The Protestants, known as Huguenots, rode about armed.

On the morning of Friday 22 August, Admiral Gaspard de Coligny, the Huguenots’ military chief and an increasingly influential voice at court, was walking back from the Louvre when a shot from an upper window tore off a finger and shattered his arm. He had bent down at that instant, some said to adjust a shoe. The gunman escaped by a back door. The house belonged to a dependant of the Guise family, who held Coligny responsible for the murder of their duke nine years before. King Charles IX visited the wounded man and swore to find the culprits. Huguenot gentlemen talked loudly of taking justice themselves.

On the evening of Saturday the 23rd the king’s council met at the Louvre, and at some point that night the decision was taken to kill the Huguenot leaders before they could act. The city gates were shut, the boats on the Seine chained, and the militia called out. In the small hours of Sunday, the feast of St Bartholomew, the young Duke of Guise led a party to Coligny’s lodging in the rue de Bethisy. The admiral was run through in his bedroom and thrown from the window into the courtyard, where Guise confirmed who it was. At the Louvre, Huguenot noblemen lodged as wedding guests were called down to the courtyard and cut down by the royal guard. Navarre and his cousin Conde were spared and told to choose between the Mass and death.

What followed was not in anyone’s plan. As church bells rang and word spread that the king had ordered the heretics dead, militiamen and ordinary Parisians began killing Protestants of every rank: booksellers, goldsmiths, women, children. Houses were looted and bodies stripped and thrown in the river. On the Monday a hawthorn in the cemetery of the Innocents was reported to have flowered out of season, and was taken as a sign of divine approval. The royal order to stop went unheeded for days. Perhaps two to three thousand people died in Paris.

On 26 August Charles went before the Parlement and declared that everything had been done at his command, to forestall a Huguenot plot against the crown.

How it came to this

Calvinist Protestantism had spread quickly in France from the 1550s, winning perhaps a tenth of the population and a much larger share of the nobility. From 1562 the kingdom fought three civil wars in which religion, noble faction and foreign intervention were tangled together. The Catholic cause was led by the Guise family, the Protestant by the Bourbon princes and by Coligny. Between them stood a weak crown: Charles IX had become king at ten, and his mother, Catherine de’ Medici, governed for and then alongside him, trying by turns conciliation and force.

The Peace of Saint-Germain in 1570 gave the Huguenots limited freedom of worship and four fortified towns. Catherine sought to seal it with the Navarre marriage. Coligny returned to court in 1571 and pressed the king to send an army into the Netherlands to support the Protestant revolt against Spain, arguing that a foreign war would unite Frenchmen. Catherine and most of the council feared it would mean ruinous war with Philip II. To Catholic Paris, the peace, the marriage and the admiral’s favour all looked like surrender to heresy.

How each side saw it

The Huguenots

Protestant survivors were certain that the whole thing had been planned, the wedding a trap to bring their leaders within reach, and they placed the guilt on Catherine de’ Medici, whom their pamphlets portrayed as an Italian schooled in Machiavelli. The Genevan pastor Simon Goulart gathered testimonies in his Memoires de l’estat de France sous Charles IX, and the massacre entered the Protestant martyrologies. Writers such as Francois Hotman now argued that a king who murders his subjects may be resisted, a step earlier Huguenot thinkers had avoided. The massacre remains central to French Protestant memory.

Catholic Paris

Barbara Diefendorf’s study of the city shows a population taught for a decade by preachers such as Simon Vigor that heresy was a pollution which brought God’s anger on the whole community, and that rulers who tolerated it failed in their duty. To those who did the killing, the king’s order, as they understood it, was a long-awaited permission. They did not think of themselves as a mob but as executing justice, sometimes mimicking the forms of official punishment. Many other Catholics sheltered Protestant neighbours, and the municipal authorities tried, without success, to halt the looting.

Rome and Madrid

Pope Gregory XIII received the news as the deliverance of France from heresy. He ordered a Te Deum sung, had a medal struck showing an angel striking down Huguenots, and commissioned Giorgio Vasari to paint the scenes on the walls of the Sala Regia in the Vatican, where they remain. Philip II of Spain is reported by the French ambassador to have laughed, which was remarked on as unusual. Both understood it as a calculated royal blow. In 1997 Pope John Paul II, speaking in Paris, acknowledged that Christians had done things on that day which the Gospel condemns.

Protestant Europe

Elizabeth I kept the French ambassador waiting for days and then received him in silence, with her court dressed in mourning. Her envoy in Paris, Francis Walsingham, had sheltered English Protestants in his house during the killing and never trusted the French court again. In Geneva, a day of fasting was proclaimed as refugees arrived. German Lutheran princes and the Dutch rebels, who had been counting on French help against Spain, drew the conclusion that no agreement with a Catholic monarch could be relied on.

What is disputed

Who ordered the shot at Coligny is unknown: Catherine, the Guises and agents of Spain have each been accused. Older histories followed the Huguenot view of long premeditation; N. M. Sutherland and most later scholars reject it. Jean-Louis Bourgeon argues the crown was forced into it by a Guise-led Parisian revolt, Denis Crouzet emphasises religious panic, and Arlette Jouanna sees a limited, improvised ‘crime of state’ that the city then turned into a massacre. Charles’s supposed cry to kill them all, and the tale that he fired on fugitives from a Louvre window, come from hostile or late sources. The dead across France are estimated at anything from 5,000 to 30,000, with about 10,000 commonly accepted.

What followed

Over the next six weeks the killing was repeated in a dozen provincial cities, among them Orleans, Lyon, Rouen, Bordeaux and Toulouse. Thousands of Protestants abjured or fled abroad, and the movement never regained its earlier numbers, but it was not destroyed: La Rochelle held out against a royal siege the following year, and the wars went on for a generation. Navarre escaped from court in 1576, returned to Protestantism, and in 1589 inherited the throne as Henry IV. He became a Catholic to secure it and in 1598 issued the Edict of Nantes, granting his former co-religionists a guarded toleration that lasted until 1685.

Read further

  • Arlette Jouanna, The Saint Bartholomew’s Day Massacre: The Mysteries of a Crime of State, translated by Joseph Bergin (2013)
  • Barbara B. Diefendorf, Beneath the Cross: Catholics and Huguenots in Sixteenth-Century Paris (1991)
  • Mack P. Holt, The French Wars of Religion, 1562-1629 (1995)
  • N. M. Sutherland, The Massacre of St Bartholomew and the European Conflict, 1559-1572 (1973)
  • Robert M. Kingdon, Myths about the St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacres, 1572-1576 (1988)

Same day, other years

AD 79

Vesuvius buries Pompeii and Herculaneum

Bay of Naples, ItalyEurope

About midday a column of ash and pumice rose from Vesuvius to a height of some thirty kilometres, spreading at the top, wrote the seventeen-year-old who watched it from across the bay, like an umbrella pine. Pumice fell on Pompeii for hours, collapsing roofs. The watcher’s uncle, Pliny the Elder, commander of the fleet at Misenum, launched his galleys to rescue people from the shore, landed at Stabiae, and died on the beach the next morning. Before dawn the column had collapsed into surges of hot gas and ash that swept over Herculaneum and then Pompeii, killing everyone still there. The towns lay buried until the eighteenth century.

Seen from elsewhere. The date is the one given in most manuscripts of Pliny the Younger’s letters, written a quarter of a century later, and it is probably wrong. Autumn fruit, wine already sealed in jars, braziers and warm clothing in the ruins, and a charcoal graffito found in 2018 dated to mid-October, all point to an eruption around 24 October.

1516

The Ottomans destroy the Mamluk army at Marj Dabiq

Marj Dabiq, north of Aleppo, SyriaMiddle East

The Mamluk sultanate, ruled by a caste of soldiers who had begun as slaves, had governed Egypt and Syria for more than 250 years and guarded the holy cities of Mecca and Medina. Its sultan, Qansuh al-Ghawri, well into his seventies, marched north to face the Ottoman sultan Selim I on a plain near Aleppo. The Mamluk cavalry charged with their usual skill and were met by field guns and musketeers. The governor of Aleppo, Khayr Bey, went over to the enemy with his wing. Al-Ghawri collapsed and died on the field, and his body was never found. Syria fell within weeks and Cairo the following January, opening four centuries of Ottoman rule over the Arab lands.

Seen from elsewhere. The Cairo chronicler Ibn Iyas recorded the news as a calamity and blamed treachery; Egyptians punned on Khayr Bey’s name to call him ‘Khain’, the traitor. Mamluk writers also said their men scorned firearms as unworthy of horsemen. Ottoman tradition presents Selim as rescuing Sunni Islam’s holy places from a regime unable to defend them.

1814

British troops burn Washington

Washington, DC, United StatesThe Americas

After scattering a larger American force at Bladensburg in the afternoon, some 4,000 British soldiers under Major General Robert Ross and Rear Admiral George Cockburn marched into the American capital at dusk. President James Madison and his government had fled. The British set fire to the Capitol, with the Library of Congress inside it, and then to the President’s House, where officers first ate a dinner that had been laid for forty. The Treasury and other public buildings followed next morning. Private property was for the most part left alone. A violent storm on the 25th put out the fires, and the British withdrew to their ships that night.

Seen from elsewhere. The British called it retaliation for the burning by American troops of York, now Toronto, the capital of Upper Canada, in 1813. For enslaved people in the Chesapeake the invaders were a route to freedom: several thousand escaped to British ships, and some returned in uniform as Colonial Marines. Some British politicians and newspapers condemned the burning at the time.

1954

Getulio Vargas shoots himself in the presidential palace

Rio de Janeiro, BrazilThe Americas

Getulio Vargas had ruled Brazil from 1930 to 1945, for eight of those years as a dictator, and returned in 1951 as an elected president with a programme of state-led industry and labour rights. In August 1954 gunmen tried to kill his fiercest critic, the journalist Carlos Lacerda, and instead shot dead an air force major. The trail led to the head of Vargas’s own bodyguard. The armed forces demanded that he resign. After a cabinet meeting that ran through the night, Vargas went to his bedroom in the Catete Palace and shot himself through the heart. A letter left behind said he had fought the plunder of Brazil and now left life to enter history.

Seen from elsewhere. Crowds wrecked opposition newspapers, and Lacerda went into hiding; the coup his allies wanted was put off for ten years. His opponents remembered a former dictator whose police had tortured prisoners and who had deported the Jewish communist Olga Benario to Nazi Germany. The typed testament was drafted with an aide, and how much of it is Vargas’s own wording is disputed.

Also on 24 August