Parallax

12 August, 1822

The Foreign Secretary cuts his throat

Lord Castlereagh had held together the coalition that beat Napoleon and was the most hated minister in Britain. In three days he went from a royal audience to a penknife in his dressing room.

North Cray, Kent, England

On Friday 9 August 1822 the Marquess of Londonderry, known to everyone by the title he had carried for most of his career, Lord Castlereagh, went to see George IV, who was about to leave for Scotland. Castlereagh was Foreign Secretary and Leader of the House of Commons, and he was due to set out for a congress of the European powers. The king found him incoherent. He said he was being watched, that he was accused of the same crime as the Bishop of Clogher, an Irish prelate caught three weeks earlier with a soldier in a London tavern, and that he must flee the country. The king told him he was ill and must see a doctor.

The same day the Duke of Wellington, his colleague and friend, heard much the same from him and answered with a soldier’s directness that he could not be in his right mind. Castlereagh, by the Duke’s account, covered his face and said that if Wellington said so it must be true. Wellington wrote at once to Castlereagh’s physician, Charles Bankhead, who bled him and went down with him to his country house at North Cray in Kent. There his wife Emily had his pistols and razors removed, and Bankhead stayed in the house.

He spent the weekend in bed, feverish and suspicious, asking why his wife and the doctor were whispering. Early on Monday morning, 12 August, he sent for Bankhead. In the moment it took the doctor to reach him, he went into his dressing room. Bankhead told the inquest that he found him standing with his back to the door, looking upwards, and that he said: “Bankhead, let me fall upon your arm; ‘tis all over.” He had cut the artery in his neck with a small penknife that the household had overlooked. He was fifty-three.

The inquest sat in the house the next day and found that he had killed himself while of unsound mind, which permitted Christian burial. On 20 August the coffin was taken to Westminster Abbey to lie near that of William Pitt. As it was lifted from the hearse at the Abbey door, part of the crowd cheered. Byron, in Italy, wrote an epitaph inviting travellers to relieve themselves on the grave.

The man so hated had done as much as anyone to bring down Napoleon. As Foreign Secretary from 1812 he held together the coalition of Austria, Russia and Prussia, bound it by the Treaty of Chaumont, and at Vienna helped design a settlement meant to restrain France without ruining it. But he was also the government’s voice in the Commons, and so the man who stood up to defend the suspension of habeas corpus, the Manchester magistrates after Peterloo and the Six Acts that followed. He spoke badly, in tangled sentences, and seemed cold. He had carried both offices for ten years, and a long parliamentary session had ended only days before.

How it came to this

Robert Stewart was born in Dublin in 1769 into an Ulster Presbyterian family that had risen into the peerage. He entered the Irish parliament in 1790 as a reformer, backed by Presbyterian radicals, and moved steadily towards government. As Chief Secretary for Ireland he oversaw the suppression of the 1798 rebellion, in which some 30,000 people are thought to have died, and then carried the Act of Union through a reluctant Irish parliament by a generous distribution of peerages, pensions and compensation. He had expected Catholic emancipation to follow and resigned with Pitt in 1801 when George III refused it.

In London he served as Secretary for War, backed Arthur Wellesley for the command in Portugal, and in 1809 fought a duel on Putney Heath with his colleague George Canning, whom he shot in the thigh. After 1815 Britain was in depression, with unemployment, dear bread and a mass movement for parliamentary reform. Lord Liverpool’s government answered with repression, and in 1820 a group of radicals plotted in Cato Street to murder the whole cabinet at dinner. Castlereagh, the Home Secretary Lord Sidmouth and the Lord Chancellor Eldon became the faces of the system.

How each side saw it

Radicals and poets

Shelley’s Mask of Anarchy, written in Italy on the news of Peterloo, begins its procession of tyrants with Murder, who ‘had a mask like Castlereagh’, and Byron’s dedication to Don Juan calls him an ‘intellectual eunuch’. To reformers he was the minister who had helped restore the Bourbons and the old order abroad and gagged the press at home. William Cobbett greeted his death in the Political Register with open satisfaction, addressing the article to a radical then in prison. For this tradition the cheering at the Abbey was the honest verdict of the people on a servant of despotism.

Ireland

In Irish nationalist memory he was ‘Bloody Castlereagh’, the Irishman who put down the United Irishmen with the lash and the gallows and then bought the Irish parliament out of existence. Ballads and pamphlets treated him as a traitor to the country of his birth. His defenders reply that he tried to restrain the worst military reprisals in 1798, supported the lenient policy of the viceroy Lord Cornwallis, and wanted the Union accompanied by Catholic emancipation, which he went on supporting for the rest of his life. Among the Ulster Presbyterians who had backed him as a young reformer, he was remembered as a turncoat.

His colleagues and his wife

Those who worked with him described a different man: courteous, calm, generous in private, and brave. Wellington, Liverpool and the diarist Harriet Arbuthnot, a close friend, recorded their shock and their belief that overwork had destroyed his mind. Lady Londonderry, criticised by some for keeping up their social round while he sickened, insisted on the Abbey funeral and lived quietly afterwards. On the Continent, Metternich wrote that the loss was irreparable and that Castlereagh was the one man in England who understood European affairs. His half-brother later published his papers to defend his name.

Historians on the blackmail story

In 1959 H. Montgomery Hyde argued that the delusion had a basis: that Castlereagh had been entrapped some years earlier by a gang who lured him to a brothel with a man dressed as a woman, and had been paying them since. The source is a clergyman’s recollection printed decades later. Castlereagh certainly told both the king and Wellington that he was accused of what was then a capital crime. John Bew and other recent biographers think the blackmail unproven and read the last weeks as a psychotic depression in an exhausted man. Older suggestions of syphilis have no firm evidence.

What is disputed

The cause of the breakdown is the main dispute: blackmail, overwork, an organic illness, and the drugs given for his gout have all been proposed, and the medical record is too thin to decide. Bankhead’s version of the last words rests on his own testimony. The inquest verdict of insanity was convenient, since a finding of deliberate suicide would have meant burial without rites, and radicals said so at the time. Death tolls for Peterloo and for the 1798 rebellion, both laid at his door, vary considerably. His foreign policy is contested too: Charles Webster saw a far-sighted European, his critics the architect of a reactionary peace.

What followed

Canning, the man he had shot, succeeded him at the Foreign Office and in the Commons, and took Britain further from the continental monarchies, recognising the new republics of Spanish America. Castlereagh had in fact begun that withdrawal himself in a state paper of May 1820 rejecting any general right of the powers to intervene against revolutions. His system of regular great-power conferences faded within a few years but was admired by later statesmen, notably Henry Kissinger, whose first book is a study of him and Metternich. The law requiring a suicide to be buried at a crossroads was repealed in 1823.

Read further

  • John Bew, Castlereagh: Enlightenment, War and Tyranny (2011)
  • H. Montgomery Hyde, The Strange Death of Lord Castlereagh (1959)
  • C. K. Webster, The Foreign Policy of Castlereagh, 1815-1822 (1925)
  • Wendy Hinde, Castlereagh (1981)
  • Henry Kissinger, A World Restored (1957)

Same day, other years

1676

Metacom, ‘King Philip’, is killed

Mount Hope, Rhode IslandThe Americas

Metacom, whom the English called King Philip, was sachem of the Pokanoket Wampanoag and son of Massasoit, who had kept the peace with Plymouth for forty years. By the 1670s the colonies had taken most of his people’s land, forced him to surrender guns and hanged three of his men for the death of a Christian Indian informer. The war that began in June 1675 destroyed a dozen English towns and, in proportion to population, killed more people than any later American war. Hunted back to his home at Mount Hope, Metacom was shot on 12 August 1676, by the English calendar, by John Alderman, a Native man serving with Benjamin Church’s rangers. His head stood on a pole at Plymouth for some twenty years.

Seen from elsewhere. Puritan historians such as Increase Mather wrote of a providential deliverance. Metacom left no account, though the Rhode Island Quaker John Easton recorded his grievances before the fighting. His wife and young son were sold into slavery. In 1836 the Pequot minister William Apess called him a patriot equal to Washington.

1898

The Hawaiian flag comes down at Iolani Palace

Honolulu, HawaiiOceania

At noon on 12 August 1898 the Hawaiian flag was lowered at Iolani Palace in Honolulu and the American flag raised. Five years earlier a committee of mostly American and European businessmen, backed by marines landed from the USS Boston, had overthrown Queen Liliuokalani; President Cleveland called the act unlawful and refused annexation, and the plotters formed a republic under Sanford Dole. In 1897 Hawaiian patriotic leagues gathered more than 21,000 signatures against annexation, over half the Native Hawaiian population, and a treaty failed in the Senate. After war with Spain broke out, Congress annexed the islands by joint resolution, which needed only a simple majority. Most Hawaiians stayed away from the ceremony.

Seen from elsewhere. Annexationists argued that the islands were vital to Pacific defence and already tied to the American economy by sugar. Hawaiian sovereignty advocates hold that a resolution of one country’s legislature cannot lawfully annex another. In 1993 Congress formally apologised for the overthrow, though courts have held that the apology creates no legal claims.

1952

The Night of the Murdered Poets

Moscow, Soviet UnionEurope

On 12 August 1952 thirteen Soviet Jews were shot in the Lubyanka prison in Moscow. They had been members of the Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee, set up under Stalin in 1942 to win support abroad for the Soviet war effort. Among them were the Yiddish writers Peretz Markish, David Bergelson, Leib Kvitko, David Hofstein and Itsik Fefer, the actor Benjamin Zuskin and the old Bolshevik Solomon Lozovsky. Arrested in 1948-49 as Stalin turned against ‘rootless cosmopolitans’, they were tortured and tried in secret for espionage and nationalism. Lozovsky took the charges apart so thoroughly in court that the presiding judge asked for the case to be reopened. He was overruled.

Seen from elsewhere. The Soviet state said nothing; families were left for years without news. The sentences were quietly annulled in 1955 and the trial record opened only after 1991. The usual name misleads, since most of the victims were not poets, and one defendant, the scientist Lina Shtern, was spared and exiled.

1976

The fall of Tel al-Zaatar

Beirut, LebanonMiddle East

Tel al-Zaatar was a Palestinian refugee camp of tens of thousands of people in the industrial eastern suburbs of Beirut, an armed enclave inside territory held by Lebanese Christian militias. In the second year of the civil war those militias besieged it for fifty-two days, cutting off water and shelling it daily, at a time when Syrian forces had entered Lebanon and were fighting the Palestinians and their allies. The camp surrendered on 12 August 1976. As the inhabitants walked out under an arrangement with the Red Cross, militiamen pulled out men and boys and shot them, and killed others along the road. Estimates of the dead during the siege and at its end run from 1,500 to about 3,000.

Seen from elsewhere. The militias described the camp as a fortress that shelled Christian districts and blocked their roads, and pointed to the killing of Christian civilians at Damour that January. Palestinians hold Syria complicit. Some survivors and Palestinian writers also blamed their own leadership for refusing earlier offers of evacuation.

Also on 12 August