Parallax

8 August, AD 117

Trajan dies, and Hadrian inherits on the strength of a letter

The emperor who had pushed Rome’s frontier to the Persian Gulf died in a small port on the coast of Cilicia without, so far as anyone could show, having named an heir. Within days his widow’s favourite was emperor. Ancient writers suspected a deathbed fraud, and nobody has been able to prove or disprove it.

Selinus, Cilicia (now Gazipasa, Turkey)

In the summer of 117 the emperor Trajan, in his early sixties and partly paralysed by what sounds like a stroke, left Syria by sea for Rome. He had spent three years at war with Parthia, had taken its capital Ctesiphon and stood on the shore of the Persian Gulf, and had then watched the conquests come apart behind him in a string of revolts. He believed, according to the historian Cassius Dio, that he had been poisoned. His ship put in at Selinus, a harbour town on the rocky coast of Cilicia, when he grew suddenly worse. There, in the first days of August, he died.

The people around him were few. His wife Pompeia Plotina was there, with his niece Matidia, the praetorian prefect Publius Acilius Attianus, and his personal attendants. Attianus had been joint guardian, with Trajan, of a boy from their home town in Spain who was now forty-one, governor of Syria and commander of the eastern army: Publius Aelius Hadrianus. Plotina had long promoted his career. Matidia was his mother-in-law.

What was announced was that Trajan had adopted Hadrian on his deathbed. The late Roman biography of Hadrian says he received the letter of adoption at Antioch on 9 August and the news of the death on the 11th, the day the army acclaimed him and the day he afterwards kept as the anniversary of his accession. He wrote to the Senate apologising that the soldiers had not waited for its decision, on the ground that the state could not be without an emperor.

Dio tells a different story, and gives his source: his own father, who later governed Cilicia and made inquiries. On this account Trajan adopted nobody. Plotina concealed the death for several days so that the adoption could be put about first, and the letters to the Senate announcing it bore her signature, not his, something she had never done before. The biography adds a rumour that a man was brought in to impersonate the dying emperor’s faint voice from behind a curtain.

One curious fact is fixed in stone. An inscription records that Trajan’s young wine-steward and attendant, Marcus Ulpius Phaedimus, died at Selinus on 12 August, aged twenty-eight, and that his remains were not brought to Rome for thirteen years. It may be coincidence. Trajan’s ashes went home in a golden urn and were placed in the base of his column.

How it came to this

Rome had no law of succession. An emperor was made by a combination of family, the army’s oath and the Senate’s vote, and since the year 96 the problem had been eased by adoption: the elderly Nerva had adopted the general Trajan, a provincial from Italica in southern Spain. Trajan and Plotina had no children. For nineteen years he declined to settle the question. Hadrian, his cousin’s son and former ward, had married his great-niece Sabina and held the usual run of commands, but had never been given the titles that would mark an heir, and other men were spoken of.

Trajan’s reign had been one of expansion. He conquered Dacia, north of the Danube, in two wars and paid for a vast building programme in Rome with its gold. In 114 he annexed Armenia and invaded Mesopotamia. By 116 the new provinces were in revolt, and Jewish communities in Cyrenaica, Egypt and Cyprus had risen in a savage war that drew off troops. The army Hadrian inherited was overstretched from the Tigris to Britain.

How each side saw it

Hadrian’s own version

Hadrian wrote an autobiography, now lost, which later writers used and distrusted. Its line is visible in the coins struck in his first months: Trajan and Hadrian clasping hands, with the single word ADOPTIO. He claimed that Trajan had long intended him, pointing to the diamond ring passed from Nerva to Trajan to himself, and that giving up the lands beyond the Euphrates followed the example of the elder Cato, who had held that peoples who could not be kept should be set free. He had Trajan deified and held a Parthian triumph in the dead man’s name.

The Senate’s tradition

Nearly everything that survives was written by or for senators, and they did not forgive him. Within a year of the accession four former consuls, among them Trajan’s most successful generals, were put to death on a charge of conspiracy without a trial before the Senate. Hadrian swore he had not ordered it and blamed Attianus. Dio, a senator himself, and the Latin biography both treat the adoption as a stratagem of Plotina’s and dwell on the emperor’s jealousy and changeable temper. At his death in 138 the Senate tried to refuse him divine honours.

Jewish memory

Hadrian took power as the Jewish revolts of the diaspora were being put down with enormous bloodshed. Fifteen years later his decision to refound Jerusalem as a Roman colony, Aelia Capitolina, with a temple of Jupiter, was followed by the rising under Simon bar Kokhba. Dio says 580,000 Jews were killed in its suppression and Judaea left a desert; the province was renamed Syria Palaestina. Rabbinic literature, compiled over the following centuries, records decrees against circumcision and teaching the Torah and the deaths of the sages, and attaches to his name the phrase ‘may his bones be crushed’.

The Greek East and the provinces

Outside the Senate house the record is warmer. Hadrian spent more than half his reign travelling, and cities from Britain to Egypt put up inscriptions thanking him as restorer and founder. In Athens he finished the temple of Olympian Zeus, begun six centuries earlier, and created a league of Greek cities; the travel writer Pausanias, a generation later, calls him the emperor who did most for the happiness of his subjects. On the frontiers he replaced conquest with fixed lines, the wall across northern Britain among them.

What is disputed

The day of Trajan’s death is not recorded directly. It is reckoned from Hadrian’s accession on 11 August and Dio’s figure for the length of the reign, and is given as 7, 8 or 9 August by different scholars. Whether the adoption was genuine cannot be settled: Anthony Birley thought Plotina probably did stage it but that Trajan had left no realistic alternative. The Historia Augusta, source of the dates at Antioch and of the story of the impersonator, is a late fourth-century compilation whose authorship and reliability have been doubted since Hermann Dessau’s study of 1889, though its life of Hadrian is among its better-founded.

What followed

Hadrian abandoned Mesopotamia and Assyria at once and returned Armenia to a client king, a retreat for which Trajan’s officers despised him and which most modern historians think unavoidable. He ruled for twenty-one years, largely at peace except in Judaea, and left the empire with defined borders, a professional administration and buildings such as the Pantheon and his villa at Tivoli. His own succession he arranged with care, adopting Antoninus Pius on condition that Antoninus adopt the young Marcus Aurelius in turn. His mausoleum on the Tiber became the papal fortress of Castel Sant’Angelo.

Read further

  • Cassius Dio, Roman History, Books 68-69
  • Historia Augusta, Life of Hadrian
  • Anthony R. Birley, Hadrian: The Restless Emperor (1997)
  • Julian Bennett, Trajan: Optimus Princeps (1997)
  • Thorsten Opper, Hadrian: Empire and Conflict (2008)

Same day, other years

1588

The Armada is beaten off Gravelines

off Gravelines, FlandersEurope

The Spanish Armada, about 130 ships, had come up the Channel in tight formation to collect the Duke of Parma’s army from Flanders and carry it to England. Parma’s troops were not ready, and there was no deep harbour where the fleet could wait. On the night of 7 August, by the new calendar Spain used, the English sent eight fireships into the anchorage off Calais, and the Spanish captains cut their cables and scattered. Next morning the English closed to short range for the first time and fought for about nine hours. Spain lost several ships and perhaps a thousand men, and the wind drove the rest north. Storms off Scotland and Ireland wrecked dozens more on the way home.

Seen from elsewhere. England was still using the old calendar and dated the battle 29 July. Protestants credited the weather to God; a remark of Philip II’s about not having sent his ships to fight the winds is poorly attested. Spain rebuilt its fleet within a few years, an English expedition to Portugal in 1589 failed badly, and the war lasted until 1604.

1942

Congress tells Britain to quit India

Bombay, IndiaAsia

With Japanese forces in Burma and on India’s eastern border, and after the failure of a British mission offering self-government once the war was over, the All-India Congress Committee met at Gowalia Tank in Bombay. On 8 August it passed a resolution demanding an immediate end to British rule and authorising a mass non-violent struggle under Gandhi. He told the delegates the mantra was ‘Do or die’. Before dawn Gandhi, Nehru and the entire Congress leadership were arrested. Leaderless protest spread across the country, turning in places to attacks on railways, telegraph lines and police stations. The government used troops and aircraft. By the end of the year more than a thousand people had been killed and some 60,000 arrested.

Seen from elsewhere. The Viceroy called it the gravest rebellion since 1857, and British ministers a stab in the back in wartime. Indians were not united either: the Muslim League under Jinnah stood aside, as did the Communists, the Hindu Mahasabha and B. R. Ambedkar. With Congress in jail for three years, the League greatly strengthened its position.

1974

Nixon announces his resignation

Washington, DC, United StatesThe Americas

At nine in the evening Richard Nixon told a television audience that he would resign the presidency at noon the next day, the only American president to do so. Three days earlier, under a unanimous Supreme Court order, he had released a tape of 23 June 1972 on which he could be heard approving a plan to have the CIA block the FBI’s inquiry into the burglary at the Watergate offices of the Democratic Party. Republican leaders in Congress then told him that he would be impeached by the House and convicted in the Senate with no more than a handful of votes in his favour. In the speech he said he no longer had a strong enough political base in Congress to continue.

Seen from elsewhere. Nixon admitted errors of judgment and never a crime, and told David Frost in 1977 that when the president does it, that means it is not illegal. His defenders saw a hostile press and Congress overturning a landslide election. Gerald Ford’s pardon a month later, meant to end the affair, probably cost Ford the 1976 election.

1988

Burma’s 8888 uprising

Rangoon, Burma (Myanmar)Asia

After twenty-six years of military-backed one-party rule that had made a rice-exporting country one of the poorest in Asia, and months of student protest, activists chose an auspicious date, the eighth day of the eighth month of 1988, for a general strike. Dockworkers walked out in Rangoon at eight minutes past eight. Hundreds of thousands of students, monks, civil servants and, later, some servicemen marched in cities across the country. That night troops opened fire, and went on shooting for days. The demonstrations continued for six weeks, and Aung San Suu Kyi, daughter of the independence leader, emerged as their voice. On 18 September the army took direct power and cleared the streets.

Seen from elsewhere. The generals said they had stepped in to stop anarchy and a communist plot, pointing to the lynching of suspected informers by crowds, and put the dead at about 350. Opposition groups, diplomats and human rights organisations estimate around 3,000 or more. No independent count was possible, and thousands of students fled to the borders.

Also on 8 August