Parallax

4 August, 1347

Calais surrenders and six burghers walk out with ropes round their necks

After eleven months of siege, a starving town sent six of its richest men to the English king with the keys and with halters ready for their own hanging. What happened next is one of the best-known scenes of the Middle Ages, and one of the most argued over.

Calais, France

By the end of July 1347 the people of Calais had eaten their horses, their dogs and the rats. Their captain, Jean de Vienne, had written to King Philip VI that nothing was left but human flesh, and that unless help came the garrison would march out and die fighting. The letter never arrived. An English ship took the messenger, and the letter was brought to Edward III.

Edward had been outside the walls since early September 1346, a week after his victory at Crecy. Calais stood among marshes that made mining and siege engines useless, so he settled down to starve it, building a timber town for his army with streets, a market and a harbour of its own. In the winter Jean de Vienne turned out the poor to save food. A first group was let through the English lines with a meal and a little money; a later group of some five hundred, according to the English chronicler Henry Knighton, was not, and died of cold and hunger in the ditch between the walls and the camp.

On 27 July a French relief army at last appeared on the heights at Sangatte, with Philip at its head. It found every approach across the marsh fortified. After several days of negotiation and challenge, Philip burned his tents in the night and marched away. The garrison, watching from the walls, hauled down the royal banner.

Edward’s first demand was surrender without terms, which by the customs of war meant he could kill or ransom whom he liked. His negotiator, Sir Walter Manny, and other captains objected that this would be remembered when they in turn were besieged. The king relented so far: six of the leading citizens must come out bareheaded and barefoot, in their shirts, with halters round their necks and the keys of the town and castle in their hands, and he would do with them as he pleased.

The chronicler Jean le Bel, and Froissart who copied and enlarged him, tell the rest. The richest man in Calais, Eustache de Saint-Pierre, offered himself first; five others followed. Brought before Edward, they knelt and begged for mercy. The king called for the executioner. His lords pleaded and were refused. Then his queen, Philippa of Hainault, knelt in front of him weeping and asked for their lives for the love of Christ and of her. Edward said he wished she had been elsewhere, and gave them to her. She had them clothed, fed and sent safely away.

The English marched in on 4 August. Almost all the inhabitants were expelled, their houses given to settlers shipped over from England.

How it came to this

The war that brought Edward to Calais had begun ten years earlier, when Philip VI declared Edward’s duchy of Gascony forfeit. Edward answered by claiming the French crown itself through his mother Isabella, daughter of Philip IV, a claim the French had set aside in 1328 on the ground that the crown could not pass through a woman. In July 1346 he landed in Normandy, sacked Caen, marched to within sight of Paris and then north, and on 26 August destroyed a much larger French army at Crecy with archers and dismounted men-at-arms.

A battle won him no territory. What he needed was a harbour on the short crossing, close to his Flemish allies, through which armies and wool could pass. Calais was small, strongly walled and, in English eyes, a nest of pirates who had preyed on Channel shipping for years. Taking it tied down the largest English army of the whole war, perhaps 30,000 men at its height, supplied by hundreds of ships, at ruinous cost.

How each side saw it

Jean le Bel and Froissart

The story as the world knows it comes from two chroniclers from the Low Countries who wrote for noble patrons and admired chivalry wherever they saw it. Jean le Bel, a canon of Liege, set it down within about a decade; Froissart, who had served in Queen Philippa’s own household and was her fellow Hainaulter, reworked it more than once, adding names for all six men and speeches for everyone. Their theme is the hard king softened by a gentle queen. Froissart makes Philippa heavily pregnant, which the known birth dates of her children do not support.

The English court and chroniclers

English writers of the time barely mention the burghers. For Knighton, Geoffrey le Baker and the king’s own newsletters the event was the fall of a fortress after a long and expensive siege, and the submission of its captain and knights, who were sent to England for ransom. Edward’s concern was to keep what he had won: he repopulated the town with English merchants, gave it a mint and later the wool staple, and garrisoned it permanently. The submission of the townsmen, in this telling, was a formality.

The people of Calais and the French crown

The townspeople lost everything. Philip VI, who had failed to save them, issued ordinances granting the refugees offices, confiscated goods and privileges elsewhere in his kingdom. French opinion blamed the king and his nobles for marching away, and the estates that met later that year said so with some bluntness. Not everyone left: documents found in the eighteenth century show that Eustache de Saint-Pierre received property and a pension from Edward and kept a position in the English town, a discovery that led some French writers to call the hero a turncoat.

Later French tradition and Rodin

From the eighteenth century the six became national figures, citizens who offered their lives for their town when kings and knights had failed it, and the subject of patriotic plays and schoolbook engravings. After the defeat of 1870 the city commissioned a monument. Auguste Rodin’s group, unveiled in 1895, refused the expected single heroic figure and showed six separate men, gaunt and frightened, at the moment of setting out. The city council disliked it. Rodin wanted it placed at ground level, among passers-by, where a later generation finally put it.

What is disputed

The French historian Jean-Marie Moeglin argued in 2002 that the scene was a standard ritual of public submission, well known across medieval Europe, in which penitents with ropes round their necks acted out a guilt and a pardon already agreed. On that reading nobody’s life was in real danger and the chroniclers turned ceremony into drama. Others reply that Edward’s anger was real and executions after sieges were not rare. Jean le Bel names only four of the six; the other two appear first in a late version of Froissart. The surrender is dated to 3 August in some sources and 4 August in others, the latter being the day the English took possession.

What followed

Calais stayed English for 211 years. It was the gate through which later invasions passed, the home of the wool staple that financed the crown, and after 1453 the last English foothold in France. The Duke of Guise took it in a week in January 1558; Mary I is said to have declared that the name would be found written on her heart, a remark recorded only later. The six burghers outlived the fortress as a symbol, serving in turn as an image of civic sacrifice, of French endurance under occupation, and, in casts of Rodin’s bronze from London to Tokyo, of ordinary people facing death.

Read further

  • Jean Froissart, Chronicles, translated by Geoffrey Brereton (1968)
  • Jean le Bel, The True Chronicles of Jean le Bel, 1290-1360, translated by Nigel Bryant (2011)
  • Jonathan Sumption, The Hundred Years War, Volume I: Trial by Battle (1990)
  • Jean-Marie Moeglin, Les Bourgeois de Calais: Essai sur un mythe historique (2002)
  • Clifford J. Rogers, War Cruel and Sharp: English Strategy under Edward III, 1327-1360 (2000)

Same day, other years

1578

Three kings die at Ksar el-Kebir

Ksar el-Kebir, MoroccoAfrica

Sebastian of Portugal, twenty-four years old, unmarried and raised on the idea of crusade, crossed to Morocco with about 17,000 men and most of his kingdom’s nobility. His pretext was the cause of a deposed sultan, Abu Abdallah Muhammad. The reigning sultan, Abd al-Malik, who was gravely ill, met them near the Wadi al-Makhazin with a far larger army rich in cavalry and trained arquebusiers. In about four hours the Portuguese were surrounded and destroyed. Sebastian was killed in the fighting, the deposed sultan drowned in flight, and Abd al-Malik died in his litter during the battle. Thousands of captives were held for ransoms that drained Portugal of coin. Two years later Philip II of Spain took the vacant throne.

Seen from elsewhere. In Morocco the Battle of Wadi al-Makhazin is remembered as the defeat of an invasion, and it made the fortune of Abd al-Malik’s brother Ahmad, called al-Mansur, the Victorious. In Portugal the king’s body was doubted, and the belief that Sebastian would one day return, Sebastianism, lasted for centuries.

1789

The French nobility gives up its privileges in one night

Versailles, FranceEurope

For three weeks peasants across France had been attacking manor houses and burning the registers that recorded what they owed their lords. On the evening of 4 August the National Assembly met to discuss restoring order. Instead the Vicomte de Noailles, then the Duc d’Aiguillon, one of the richest landowners in the kingdom, rose to propose ending feudal rights. Deputy after deputy followed, each renouncing something: hunting rights, manorial courts, tithes, the sale of offices, the tax exemptions of provinces and towns. The session ran until two in the morning. The decree that emerged opened with the statement that the Assembly entirely destroyed the feudal regime.

Seen from elsewhere. The fine print said otherwise. Most dues were declared property, to be bought out by the peasants at twenty or more years’ value, and few could pay. Rural revolt continued until redemption was abolished without compensation in 1793. Some noble deputies thought the night a collective intoxication; historians still argue how far it was stage-managed beforehand.

1972

Idi Amin orders the expulsion of Uganda’s Asians

Tororo, UgandaAfrica

Speaking to soldiers at a barracks in eastern Uganda, President Idi Amin announced that Asians holding British passports must leave the country, and soon set a limit of ninety days. He said the decision had come to him in a dream. The order was quickly widened to nearly all people of South Asian descent, including many who were Ugandan citizens. Families whose grandparents had arrived under British rule were allowed to take a suitcase and fifty pounds. Between 50,000 and 80,000 left before the November deadline, some 28,000 of them for Britain, others for Canada, India and Kenya. Their shops, factories and estates were handed out to soldiers and officials, and the economy contracted sharply in the years that followed.

Seen from elsewhere. Amin called it an economic war to return Uganda’s wealth to Black Ugandans, and it was widely popular at the time. The resentment had colonial roots: British policy had placed Asians as a trading class between European rulers and African farmers. Uganda invited the expelled to reclaim their property from the 1980s onwards.

2020

The Beirut port explosion

Beirut, LebanonMiddle East

Shortly after six in the evening a fire in a warehouse at the port of Beirut set off some 2,750 tonnes of ammonium nitrate that had been stored there, unsecured, for more than six years after being unloaded from an abandoned cargo ship. The blast was among the largest non-nuclear explosions ever recorded. It destroyed the port and the grain silos beside it, wrecked whole neighbourhoods and was felt in Cyprus. At least 218 people were killed, about 7,000 injured and some 300,000 left without usable homes. It struck a country already in financial collapse. The government resigned six days later, and customs and port officials were shown to have written repeatedly to the courts about the danger.

Seen from elsewhere. Officials at every level say they warned someone else. The judicial investigation has been repeatedly suspended by legal challenges from the politicians it sought to question, and no senior figure has been held to account. Victims’ families, who march on the fourth of each month, and international human rights groups have called for an independent inquiry.

Also on 4 August