Parallax

6 August, 1806

The Holy Roman Empire is declared at an end

A herald rode to a church in Vienna and read out that the emperor laid down a crown worn since Charlemagne. Under an ultimatum from Napoleon, Francis II did more than abdicate: he announced that the empire itself no longer existed, which he arguably had no power to do.

Vienna, Austria

On the morning of 6 August 1806 the imperial herald, in his tabard, rode with an escort through Vienna to the Jesuit church of the Nine Choirs of Angels on the square called Am Hof. From its balcony, after a fanfare of trumpets, he read a proclamation to the crowd below. Francis II, by the grace of God elected Roman Emperor, declared that he considered the bond which had tied him to the body of the German Empire dissolved, that he laid down the imperial crown, and that he released the electors, princes, estates and all imperial officials from their duties to him.

It had been coming for months. In December 1805 Napoleon had destroyed the Austrian and Russian armies at Austerlitz, and the peace signed at Pressburg stripped Francis of the Tyrol and Venetia and made the rulers of Bavaria and Wurttemberg kings. On 12 July 1806 sixteen German princes signed a treaty in Paris forming the Confederation of the Rhine under Napoleon’s protection. On 1 August their envoys told the imperial diet at Regensburg that they no longer recognised the empire. Napoleon’s envoy said the same of his master.

Behind this lay an ultimatum. On 22 July Napoleon had let Vienna know that if Francis had not abdicated by 10 August, French troops would cross the Inn. Francis’s foreign minister, Count Johann Philipp Stadion, tried to bargain the crown for concessions and got none. The court’s lawyers were asked a different question: how to give up the dignity in a way that would stop Napoleon, or a prince of his choosing, from picking it up.

Their answer was the wording read from the balcony. A simple abdication would have left a vacant throne and electors free to fill it. So Francis declared the office and the empire extinguished, and in the same document detached his own hereditary lands from it. He was not left without a title. Two years earlier, when Napoleon made himself Emperor of the French, Francis had proclaimed himself hereditary Emperor of Austria, and as Francis I he went on reigning until 1835.

Reactions were muted. Goethe, travelling home from Carlsbad, noted in his diary the next day that a quarrel between his coachman and servant on the box had stirred the passengers more than the split in the Roman Empire. His mother wrote from Frankfurt, the city where emperors had been elected and crowned, that it felt like the death of an old friend long given up by the doctors. The crown, orb and sceptre, moved to Vienna a few years earlier to keep them from the French, stayed in the Habsburg treasury, where they still are.

How it came to this

The empire traced itself to Charlemagne’s coronation in Rome in 800 and, more continuously, to that of the Saxon king Otto I in 962. By the eighteenth century it was a legal and political order covering some three hundred territories of every size, from Austria and Prussia to free cities, abbeys and the estates of imperial knights, with an elected emperor, a standing diet and two supreme courts. Voltaire’s remark that it was neither holy, nor Roman, nor an empire dates from 1756. It could not act like a state, and was not meant to; its purpose was to keep the peace among its members and to protect the weak ones from the strong.

The wars of the French Revolution broke that balance. France annexed the left bank of the Rhine, and in 1803 the princes who lost land there were compensated on the right bank at the expense of the Church and the cities: nearly all ecclesiastical states and all but six free cities were abolished and absorbed. The middle-sized states that gained, Bavaria, Baden and Wurttemberg above all, now owed their fortunes to France.

How each side saw it

The Habsburg court

For Francis and his ministers the declaration was damage control. The imperial title had brought the Habsburgs prestige and obligations but, by 1806, no troops or revenue they could count on, and Austria was too exhausted to fight for it. The real fear was that Napoleon would have himself or a client elected and so acquire a legal claim over German lands, including Habsburg ones. Stadion’s advice was to give the crown up in a form that destroyed it. The Austrian imperial title of 1804 had been created as insurance against exactly this day.

Napoleon and the princes of the Rhine

Napoleon regarded the old empire as an Austrian instrument and wanted a belt of dependent German states that would supply men and money. The rulers who joined his Confederation presented their secession as recognition of a fact: the empire had failed to protect them in three wars. They had also done well out of its ruin, gaining crowns, territory and full sovereignty over neighbours they had long wanted to swallow. The arch-chancellor, Karl Theodor von Dalberg, who had hoped to reform the empire with French help, ended as prince-primate of the new league.

The small estates

The losers were those the empire had existed to shelter: imperial knights, counts, abbots and free cities whose independence rested on imperial law and the right to sue a powerful neighbour in the imperial courts. Hundreds of them were ‘mediatised’, placed under the sovereignty of the larger states, between 1803 and 1806. Their petitions and memoirs speak of a legal order overturned by force. Britain’s George III, as Elector of Hanover, and the King of Sweden, as a prince of the empire, refused to accept that the dissolution was lawful.

Historians, then and now

Nineteenth-century German historians writing in the Prussian tradition, Heinrich von Treitschke most forcefully, described the old empire as a rotting hulk whose end cleared the ground for a real nation state. That verdict lasted a long time. Since the 1960s scholars such as Karl Otmar von Aretin, and more recently Peter Wilson and Joachim Whaley, have argued that it worked better than its critics allowed, as a system of law and negotiation that let small communities survive for centuries, and that it was destroyed from outside while still functioning.

What is disputed

Whether Francis could lawfully dissolve the empire is the oldest question. He could abdicate; the constitution gave an emperor no authority to abolish the empire or release its members from their oaths, and contemporaries said so. In practice nobody was in a position to convene an election. Historians also disagree about how alive the institution was: whether 1806 was the registration of a death that had occurred in 1803, or earlier, or the killing of something viable. Goethe’s diary line is often quoted as proof of general indifference, but other letters and diaries of the same weeks record grief, and public comment was constrained by French occupation.

What followed

Prussia, which had stood aside, went to war with France that autumn and was crushed at Jena. After Napoleon’s fall the Congress of Vienna did not restore the empire, though some small princes petitioned for it. It set up a loose German Confederation of thirty-nine states under Austrian presidency, which lasted until Prussia expelled Austria from German affairs in 1866 and founded a new German Empire in 1871. That state called itself the second Reich and the Nazi dictatorship the third, borrowing a continuity the old empire’s defenders would not have recognised. Its federal habits survive in modern Germany’s constitution.

Read further

  • Peter H. Wilson, The Holy Roman Empire: A Thousand Years of Europe’s History (2016)
  • Joachim Whaley, Germany and the Holy Roman Empire, Volume II: The Peace of Westphalia to the Dissolution of the Reich, 1648-1806 (2012)
  • James J. Sheehan, German History, 1770-1866 (1989)
  • Brendan Simms, The Struggle for Mastery in Germany, 1779-1850 (1998)

Same day, other years

1538

The founding of Bogota on Muisca land

Bogota, ColombiaThe Americas

Gonzalo Jimenez de Quesada, a lawyer from Andalusia, left the Caribbean coast in 1536 with some eight hundred men to follow the Magdalena River inland. Fewer than two hundred were alive when they climbed onto the high plateau of the Muisca, a farming people organised in confederations whose rulers controlled salt, emeralds and worked gold. The Spaniards overran the territory in 1537; the ruler known as the zipa was killed, and his successor was later tortured to death in an attempt to find hidden treasure. By tradition, on 6 August 1538 Quesada marked out a settlement of twelve huts and a chapel at a place called Teusaquillo, where a friar said mass. It became the capital of the New Kingdom of Granada.

Seen from elsewhere. The Muisca had no writing, and their conquest is known from Spanish chronicles composed decades later. The date is itself a tradition: the legal foundation, with a town council, took place in April 1539. Muisca communities still exist in districts of the modern city and have won official recognition since the 1990s.

1890

The first execution by electric chair

Auburn Prison, New York, United StatesThe Americas

William Kemmler, a pedlar from Buffalo, had killed his partner Tillie Ziegler with a hatchet. He became the first person condemned under a New York law that replaced hanging with electricity, a method a state commission had recommended as quicker and more humane. His appeals, which went to the Supreme Court, were quietly financed by George Westinghouse, whose alternating-current system would power the chair and whose rival Thomas Edison was publicly arguing that this current was too deadly for homes. At Auburn a first charge of seventeen seconds left Kemmler unconscious but breathing. The current was switched on again for a minute or more while witnesses smelled burning. Several were sick.

Seen from elsewhere. The officials and doctors in charge pronounced the method a success and an advance for civilisation, and other states soon adopted it. Newspapers that had sent reporters called it far worse than hanging. Westinghouse is reported to have said that they would have done better with an axe. Debate over whether any method of execution is humane has not ended.

1945

The atomic bombing of Hiroshima

Hiroshima, JapanAsia

At a quarter past eight in the morning an American B-29, the Enola Gay, released a single uranium bomb over the centre of Hiroshima, a city of perhaps 300,000 people and an army headquarters. It exploded about 600 metres above a hospital. Heat and blast destroyed almost everything within a mile, and fires merged into a firestorm. Tens of thousands died that day. By the end of 1945, with burns and radiation sickness, the city estimates that about 140,000 were dead; other estimates run from 90,000 upward. The dead included thousands of Koreans brought to Japan as labourers and a small number of American prisoners of war. A second bomb fell on Nagasaki three days later, and Japan surrendered on 15 August.

Seen from elsewhere. President Truman and his officials held that the bombs ended the war and spared the far greater loss of an invasion; many veterans agreed. Survivors, the hibakusha, have campaigned for abolition ever since. Historians dispute how far surrender was caused by the bombs or by the Soviet declaration of war on 8 August.

1962

Jamaica becomes independent

Kingston, JamaicaThe Americas

At midnight in the new National Stadium in Kingston the Union flag was lowered and a black, green and gold one raised, ending 307 years of British rule that had begun with Cromwell’s seizure of the island from Spain. For most of that time Jamaica had been a sugar colony worked by enslaved Africans and their descendants. Britain had intended its Caribbean territories to become independent together as a federation, but in a referendum in September 1961 Jamaicans voted to leave it, and the federation collapsed. Alexander Bustamante, a former labour leader who had campaigned for withdrawal, became the first prime minister. Princess Margaret opened parliament on behalf of her sister, who remained queen of Jamaica.

Seen from elsewhere. Norman Manley, who had staked his government on federation and lost, saw a larger Caribbean nation thrown away. Rastafarians and many of Kingston’s poor said a change of flag left land, wealth and colour lines as they were. Whether to replace the British monarch with a Jamaican head of state is still being debated.

Also on 6 August