Parallax

11 August, 1239

A king walks barefoot to meet the Crown of Thorns

Louis IX of France redeemed Christendom’s most prized relic from a Venetian pawnbroker, carried it into Sens on his own shoulders, and then built a chapel of glass to keep it in.

Sens, France

On 10 August 1239 Louis IX of France, twenty-five years old, rode out to the small town of Villeneuve-l’Archeveque, east of Sens, to meet two Dominican friars who had been travelling for months. They carried a wooden chest. Inside it was a silver casket bearing the seals of the barons of Constantinople and the doge of Venice, and inside that a vessel of gold. When the seals had been checked against the letters that came with them, the gold vessel was opened in front of the king, his mother Blanche of Castile, his brothers and the Archbishop of Sens. It held a circlet of plaited rushes: the Crown of Thorns.

The archbishop, Gautier Cornut, wrote down what followed. The next day, 11 August, the king took off his royal robes and his shoes. In a plain tunic, with his brother Robert of Artois dressed the same way, he took the litter on his shoulders and carried the relic into Sens through streets hung with cloth, behind a procession of clergy bearing every relic the city owned. From Sens it went by boat down the Yonne and the Seine. A week later, outside the walls of Paris, it was shown from a high platform to a great crowd, and the two brothers again carried it barefoot, first to Notre-Dame and then to the chapel of the royal palace on the Ile de la Cite.

The crown had been kept for centuries in the imperial chapels of Constantinople. Since 1204 that city had been in the hands of western crusaders, and their emperor, Baldwin II, a kinsman of Louis, was so short of money that his barons had pledged the crown to a Venetian banker, Nicolo Quirino, as security for a loan of 13,134 gold pieces. If the debt was not repaid the relic would stay in Venice. Baldwin, touring Europe to beg for help, offered it to Louis. Louis paid off the pledge and had the crown brought across the Alps before the Venetians could find a reason to keep it.

He did not stop there. In 1241 a second consignment arrived from Constantinople: a large piece of the True Cross, the iron of the Holy Lance, the Sponge, and more. To house them Louis pulled down the old palace chapel and built a new one on two levels, the lower for the household, the upper for the king and the relics. The upper chapel is almost without walls. Fifteen windows, each about fifteen metres high, carry more than a thousand scenes running from Genesis to the arrival of the relics in Paris, with Louis himself shown carrying the crown.

The Sainte-Chapelle was consecrated on 26 April 1248. The figures usually quoted are 135,000 livres for the crown, 100,000 for the great jewelled shrine that held the relics and 40,000 for the building itself; the first was something like half the monarchy’s annual income. Four months later the king sailed on crusade for Egypt.

How it came to this

Relics of Christ’s Passion had been gathered in Constantinople since late antiquity. Pilgrims describe a crown of thorns shown in Jerusalem in the fifth and sixth centuries; by the eleventh century it was in the Byzantine emperors’ chapel of the Pharos, alongside the Cross, the Lance and the burial cloths. For Greek Christians these objects were a guarantee that the empire stood under divine protection. In April 1204 the army of the Fourth Crusade, diverted from Egypt by its debt to Venice and by a disputed imperial succession, stormed and looted the city. Relics by the hundred went west as plunder. The imperial collection passed more or less intact to the new Latin emperors.

Their state was weak from birth, hemmed in by Greek successor states and by Bulgaria, and by the 1230s it was stripping lead from its palace roofs to sell. Louis IX, meanwhile, ruled the richest kingdom in the West. He had come to the throne at twelve under the regency of his mother, survived baronial revolts, and was developing a view of kingship in which the French were a chosen people and their king its consecrated guardian. Possession of the instruments of the Passion suited that idea exactly.

How each side saw it

The French court, through Archbishop Gautier Cornut

Gautier Cornut’s account of the crown’s reception, written at the king’s request to be read on the annual feast, states the royal view plainly. As Christ chose the Holy Land to display the mysteries of redemption, he has now chosen France to venerate the triumph of his Passion. The transfer was not a purchase, since holy things cannot be bought and sold, but the redemption of a pledge and a gift between kinsmen. The king’s bare feet were his penance and his honour at once. The liturgy composed for the feast, kept each 11 August, presented France as a new promised land.

The Greeks of Constantinople

Byzantine writers recorded 1204 as a sacrilege. Niketas Choniates, a senior official who fled the sack, describes crusaders stripping altars and carrying off holy things as loot. In the Orthodox understanding the Passion relics belonged to the Roman emperors and the Great Church, held in trust, and a Latin usurper had no right to pawn them. When the Greeks retook Constantinople in 1261 the Pharos chapel was empty. The grievance outlived the empire: in 2004 Pope John Paul II returned the relics of two Greek church fathers to the Patriarch of Constantinople, with an expression of sorrow for 1204.

The Jews of Paris

The years in which Louis built his chapel for the instruments of the Passion were hard ones for the Jews of his kingdom. In 1240, on the complaint of a convert, Nicholas Donin, the Talmud was put on trial in Paris before the queen mother; Rabbi Yehiel of Paris led the defence, and a Hebrew account of the disputation survives. In 1242, by the usual dating, cartloads of Talmud manuscripts were burned in the city. Rabbi Meir of Rothenburg, who is said to have watched, wrote a lament still recited on the fast of Tisha B’Av. Louis later ordered Jews to wear a badge.

Sceptics, medieval and modern

Doubt about such relics was voiced inside the medieval church and loudly outside it later. John Calvin’s Treatise on Relics of 1543 listed the many churches that claimed thorns or pieces of the crown and treated the multiplication as proof of fraud. Catholic scholars answer that the Paris relic is a bare circlet of rushes from which the thorns were detached and given away over centuries, some by Louis himself. No test can establish where it was before pilgrims first mention it, some four hundred years after the Crucifixion, and the church today presents it for veneration without ruling on its origin.

What is disputed

Popular accounts sometimes say the crown later vanished. It did not. What is uncertain is the chronology of the chapel. No document records when building began; estimates run from 1239 to 1244, and the often repeated claim that it took thirty-three months has no medieval authority. The architect is unknown, the old attribution to Pierre de Montreuil being a guess. The price of 135,000 livres comes from later tradition rather than surviving accounts. Sources place the entry into Paris on 18 or 19 August. The date of the Talmud burning is also contested, and the crown’s history before the fifth century cannot be traced at all.

What followed

At the Revolution the shrine was melted down and the Sainte-Chapelle became a flour store and then an archive; the crown itself was sent to the national library and survived. Returned to the church under Napoleon, it has been kept at Notre-Dame since 1806. When the cathedral roof burned on 15 April 2019, firefighters and the brigade’s chaplain carried it out, and it returned in December 2024. About two thirds of the chapel’s thirteenth-century glass survives. Louis was captured in Egypt in 1250, died on a second crusade at Tunis in 1270 and was canonised in 1297.

Read further

  • Jacques Le Goff, Saint Louis (1996)
  • William Chester Jordan, Louis IX and the Challenge of the Crusade (1979)
  • Meredith Cohen, The Sainte-Chapelle and the Construction of Sacral Monarchy (2015)
  • Jean de Joinville, The Life of Saint Louis
  • Niketas Choniates, O City of Byzantium, translated by Harry J. Magoulias (1984)

Same day, other years

3114 BC

Day zero of the Maya Long Count

MesoamericaThe Americas

The Maya of the Classic period counted days in an unbroken sequence from a fixed starting point, written 13.0.0.0.0 4 Ahau 8 Cumku. Under the correlation most scholars use, that day corresponds to 11 August 3114 BC in the Gregorian calendar projected backwards. Nothing historical happened on it: the date lies thousands of years before the first Maya cities, and inscriptions such as Stela C at Quirigua describe it as the moment the gods set three stones in place and the present world was put in order. The count itself is older than the Maya who perfected it. The earliest surviving Long Count dates, from the first century BC, come from Chiapas and the Gulf coast.

Seen from elsewhere. A rival correlation places day zero two days later, on 13 August, and the matter is not closed. The count completed a great cycle on 21 December 2012, which popular writers turned into a prophecy of doom. Maya inscriptions predict nothing of the kind, and some refer to dates far beyond it.

1492

Rodrigo Borgia is elected pope

RomeEurope

Rodrigo Borgia, a Valencian who had been vice-chancellor of the church for thirty-five years under five popes, was elected in the Sistine Chapel in the early hours of 11 August and took the name Alexander VI. He was about sixty-one, immensely experienced, rich, and the acknowledged father of several children. The conclave had begun with Ascanio Sforza and Giuliano della Rovere as the leading figures. Contemporary reports say Borgia won Sforza’s bloc by promising him the vice-chancellorship, his own palace and a string of benefices. In office he restored order in Rome, divided the newly found Atlantic lands between Spain and Portugal, and used the papacy to build a state for his son Cesare.

Seen from elsewhere. Romans celebrated the election, and some historians consider him a capable ruler by the standards of his day. Much of the Borgia legend of poison and incest comes from enemies: the diarist Infessura, Florentine writers, and della Rovere, who later became Julius II. Buying votes with offices was common, though seldom on this scale.

1786

The East India Company takes Penang

Penang, Malay PeninsulaAsia

Francis Light, a private trader who had spent years in the ports of the Malay Peninsula, landed on the thinly settled island of Penang with a small East India Company force and on 11 August 1786 raised the British flag, renaming it Prince of Wales Island. The Company wanted a harbour on the route to China and a base against the Dutch and French. Sultan Abdullah of Kedah, to whom the island belonged, had offered it in the hope of armed protection against Siam and Burma. Light let him believe that protection would come. The Company’s council in Calcutta refused to commit itself. In 1791 the sultan tried to take the island back, was beaten, and accepted an annual payment instead.

Seen from elsewhere. Kedah’s rulers held that the island was occupied on a promise never kept; in 1821 Siam invaded Kedah and Britain did not intervene. British accounts long described a legal cession. The historian R. Bonney, working from the Company’s own letters, concluded that Light misled both his employers and the sultan.

1960

Chad becomes independent

Fort-Lamy (N’Djamena), ChadAfrica

Chad became independent from France on 11 August 1960 with Francois Tombalbaye, a former teacher and trade unionist from the south, as its leader. France had conquered the region around 1900 and governed it as the poorest territory of French Equatorial Africa, investing chiefly in the south, where cotton was grown under compulsion and mission schools produced a small educated class. The Muslim north and east, home to perhaps half the population, had few schools and little share in government. Tombalbaye banned opposition parties in 1962. Tax riots at Mangalme in 1965, in which hundreds died, opened a rebellion that has shaped the country since. He was killed in an army coup in 1975.

Seen from elsewhere. Northerners saw the new state as southern rule inherited from the coloniser; southerners recalled centuries of slave raiding from the north. French troops administered the far north until 1965 and have returned repeatedly, which critics call independence on a lead and French governments call assistance requested by Chad.

Also on 11 August