Parallax

2 August, 216 BC

Hannibal surrounds a Roman army at Cannae

Rome put the largest army it had ever raised into the field to finish Hannibal in a single afternoon. He let it push his centre back, closed his wings around it, and killed most of the men inside.

Cannae, Apulia, Italy

On the morning of the battle the two consuls of Rome, Lucius Aemilius Paullus and Gaius Terentius Varro, led their combined armies across the river Aufidus in Apulia and formed up on the flat ground near the ruined hill town of Cannae. The Greek historian Polybius, writing about two generations later, gives them eight legions with an equal number of Italian allies: some 80,000 infantry and 6,000 cavalry. Hannibal had about 40,000 foot and 10,000 horse, a mixed force of Africans, Spaniards, Gauls and Numidians, far from home and living off the country.

The Romans packed their infantry deeper and narrower than usual, meaning to break straight through the middle. Hannibal offered them the middle. He pushed his Gauls and Spaniards forward in a bulging crescent, stood there himself with his brother Mago, and kept his African infantry, many of them wearing mail stripped from Roman dead in earlier battles, back in column on each side. A hot wind blew dust from the south into Roman faces.

On the flank beside the river the heavy cavalry under Hasdrubal rode down the Roman horse almost at once. Paullus, wounded early by a slingstone according to Livy, fought on among the infantry. Hasdrubal then led his squadrons right round the back of the Roman army to fall on the allied cavalry on the other wing, who were already held by the Numidians, and scattered them too. Varro went with the fugitives.

In the centre the legions were winning, as planned by both sides. The crescent bent back and became a hollow, and the Romans pressed into it, crowding inward. Then the Africans turned in on both flanks, and Hasdrubal’s cavalry came down on the rear. The largest army Rome had ever raised was now a mass of men too tightly packed to use their weapons, being cut down from the edges inward. The killing lasted until evening.

Polybius says about 70,000 Romans and allies died. Livy gives 48,200 dead and more than 19,000 taken prisoner. Either way, the dead included Paullus, the previous year’s consul Servilius Geminus, and some eighty men of senatorial rank. Hannibal lost between 5,700 and 8,000, most of them Gauls.

Varro reached Venusia with a handful of riders. A group of survivors, among them a young officer named Publius Cornelius Scipio, gathered at Canusium. At Rome, Livy says, the authorities consulted the sacred books and buried two Gauls and two Greeks alive in the cattle market, a rite he himself calls most un-Roman.

How it came to this

Rome and Carthage had fought once already, from 264 to 241 BC, for Sicily. Carthage lost, paid a huge indemnity, and rebuilt its fortunes in Spain under Hamilcar Barca and then his son Hannibal. In 219 BC Hannibal took Saguntum, a Spanish town under Roman protection, and war followed. Instead of waiting to be attacked, he marched from Spain across the Pyrenees, the Rhone and the Alps and came down into northern Italy late in 218 BC with perhaps 26,000 men and a few surviving elephants.

He beat one Roman army on the Trebia that winter and trapped and destroyed another beside Lake Trasimene in 217 BC. Rome then appointed Quintus Fabius Maximus as dictator, who followed Hannibal about without fighting him, a policy that kept the army alive and let Italian farmland burn. It was deeply unpopular. For 216 BC the Romans elected consuls expected to fight, and gave them an army roughly twice the usual size. Hannibal seized the grain depot at Cannae and waited for them.

How each side saw it

The Carthaginian side

No Carthaginian account survives. Hannibal took two Greek writers with him, Silenus and Sosylus, and their histories are lost except for fragments; what we know of his plans comes through Polybius, who read them, and through Livy. Carthage’s own records were destroyed or dispersed when Rome razed the city in 146 BC. Livy describes Mago pouring out gold rings taken from dead Roman knights on the floor of the Carthaginian senate, and Hanno, the Barcids’ opponent there, asking whether a single Latin town had yet come over or Rome had sued for peace.

The Roman senatorial tradition

Roman writers blamed Varro. Livy makes him a butcher’s son and a demagogue who dragged a cautious, aristocratic Paullus into battle. Modern historians are wary: Polybius was the friend and client of Scipio Aemilianus, Paullus’s grandson, and had every reason to spare the family. An army of this size was a decision of the Senate and people, not of one consul, and it is striking that the Senate formally thanked Varro on his return for not having despaired of the republic and went on employing him in commands for years afterwards.

The Italian allies and the survivors

Half the dead were not Romans but allies obliged by treaty to send troops. After Cannae much of southern Italy went over to Hannibal, including Capua, the second city of the peninsula, whose leaders hoped to replace Rome as its head. The Latin and central Italian communities stayed loyal, which decided the war. Rome refused to ransom its captured soldiers, many of whom Hannibal sold into slavery in Greece. The survivors who had fled were formed into two legions and sent to serve in Sicily in disgrace, barred from returning to Italy until the war ended.

Soldiers and military historians

Cannae became the model battle of encirclement. Count Alfred von Schlieffen, chief of the German general staff, wrote a set of studies under its name and designed his plan for war against France in its image; staff colleges still teach it. Critics, among them the historian Hans Delbruck in Schlieffen’s own day, replied that the lesson was the opposite one. Hannibal won the most complete tactical victory on record and lost the war, because Rome would not treat a lost battle, or three, as a lost war.

What is disputed

The date, 2 August, comes from a fragment of the annalist Claudius Quadrigarius preserved by Aulus Gellius, and is a date in the Roman civil calendar of the time, which was running out of step with the seasons; the true date may have been weeks earlier, in early summer. The numbers are argued over: some scholars accept Polybius’s 86,000 Romans, others think the army smaller and prefer Livy’s lower death toll. Which bank of the river the battle was fought on is unresolved. Maharbal’s taunt that Hannibal knew how to win a victory but not how to use one is Livy’s, and probably literary, and historians remain divided on whether a march on Rome could have succeeded without siege equipment.

What followed

Rome raised new legions from boys, debtors and slaves bought from their owners, went back to avoiding battle with Hannibal himself, and fought him everywhere else: in Spain, Sicily and eventually Africa. He stayed in Italy, undefeated, for thirteen more years. In 202 BC Scipio, the young officer from Canusium, beat him at Zama with an army that included the disgraced survivors of Cannae. Carthage was reduced to a dependency and destroyed half a century later. The war left Rome the dominant power in the western Mediterranean, with a habit of fighting on after any defeat.

Read further

  • Polybius, The Histories, Book 3
  • Livy, History of Rome, Book 22
  • Adrian Goldsworthy, Cannae (2001)
  • Gregory Daly, Cannae: The Experience of Battle in the Second Punic War (2002)
  • J. F. Lazenby, Hannibal’s War: A Military History of the Second Punic War (1978)

Same day, other years

1100

William Rufus is killed in the New Forest

New Forest, Hampshire, EnglandEurope

William II of England, called Rufus, third son of the Conqueror, went hunting after a late dinner and was hit in the chest by an arrow. He died where he fell. The chroniclers name the archer as Walter Tirel, a French lord in the hunting party, who rode for the coast and crossed to Normandy without waiting to explain. The king’s companions scattered to look after their own estates, and the body was taken to Winchester on a cart by local men and buried under the cathedral tower. His younger brother Henry, who was in the forest that day, went straight to Winchester, secured the royal treasury, and was crowned at Westminster three days later.

Seen from elsewhere. Accident or murder is an old argument. Hunting deaths were common, and Tirel reportedly swore on his deathbed that he had not even been near the king. The speed of Henry’s actions has made others suspect a plot. The monks who wrote the history disliked Rufus for plundering the Church and described his death as a judgment of God.

1943

The prisoners’ revolt at Treblinka

Treblinka, occupied PolandEurope

Treblinka was a killing centre north-east of Warsaw where, in little more than a year, the SS and their auxiliaries murdered between 800,000 and 900,000 people, nearly all of them Jews, most within hours of arrival. A few hundred Jewish prisoners were kept alive to sort belongings and burn bodies. Knowing the transports were slowing and that they would be killed last, an underground committee planned a break-out. On the hot afternoon of 2 August prisoners opened the arsenal with a copied key, set buildings alight and rushed the fences. Several hundred got out. Most were hunted down in the following days; about seventy are known to have lived to see the end of the war.

Seen from elsewhere. The camp was dismantled that autumn and a farm planted over it, so the survivors’ testimony is the core of the record: Jankiel Wiernik’s account, published secretly in 1944, and later Chil Rajchman’s and Samuel Willenberg’s. The commandant, Franz Stangl, told the journalist Gitta Sereny in prison that he had come to see the victims as cargo.

1964

Shots in the Gulf of Tonkin

Gulf of Tonkin, off North VietnamAsia

The American destroyer Maddox was gathering electronic intelligence off the North Vietnamese coast when three torpedo boats came out to attack her. The Maddox fired first, as warning shots by her captain’s account; the boats launched torpedoes that missed, and carrier aircraft damaged all three. One bullet struck the destroyer. Two nights later the Maddox and a second destroyer, in bad weather, reported a further attack. President Lyndon Johnson ordered air strikes on North Vietnam and asked Congress for authority to use force. The resolution passed on 7 August with two dissenting votes in the Senate and none in the House, and served as the legal basis for an American war that eventually involved more than half a million troops.

Seen from elsewhere. Hanoi has always acknowledged the first engagement, which it tied to South Vietnamese commando raids on its coast run with American support, and denied the second. It was right: the National Security Agency’s own historian, Robert Hanyok, concluded in a study released in 2005 that no attack occurred on 4 August and that intercepts had been presented misleadingly.

1990

Iraq invades Kuwait

Kuwait City, KuwaitMiddle East

At about two in the morning Iraqi armoured divisions crossed the border while helicopter-borne troops landed in Kuwait City. The emir, Sheikh Jaber al-Ahmad al-Sabah, escaped by road to Saudi Arabia; his younger brother Sheikh Fahd was shot dead at the gates of the Dasman Palace. Resistance ended within two days. The UN Security Council condemned the invasion the same day and imposed sanctions four days later, and Iraq announced the annexation of Kuwait on 8 August. A coalition led by the United States assembled in Saudi Arabia and drove the Iraqi army out in February 1991. During seven months of occupation, hundreds of Kuwaitis were killed, about six hundred disappeared into Iraqi custody, and retreating troops set fire to more than six hundred oil wells.

Seen from elsewhere. Saddam Hussein’s government said Kuwait was a province detached from Iraq by Britain, and accused it of flooding the oil market, pumping from the shared Rumaila field and demanding repayment of loans made during the war with Iran. Whether the American ambassador’s remarks a week earlier led Baghdad to expect no response is still disputed.

Also on 2 August