Parallax

29 August, 1842

The Treaty of Nanjing is signed on a British warship

With a fleet anchored under the walls of China’s southern capital, three Qing officials put their seals to a treaty that opened five ports, paid for the war and gave away an island. It did not mention the drug the war had been fought over.

Nanjing, Qing China

The signing took place in the after-cabin of HMS Cornwallis, a seventy-four-gun ship of the line moored in the Yangtze off Nanjing, on the morning of 29 August 1842. Three Qing commissioners came aboard: Qiying, a Manchu imperial clansman; the elderly Yilibu, who was seriously ill; and Niu Jian, governor-general of the region. Across the table sat Sir Henry Pottinger, an Irish-born officer of the East India Company. Four copies were laid out, in English and Chinese. The commissioners affixed their seals, Pottinger signed, and the ship fired a twenty-one-gun salute.

The commissioners had hardly read it. British interpreters noted with surprise that the Chinese side did not haggle over the wording and asked almost nothing about the clauses on trade. Their concern was the fleet. The British had come up the river in July, stormed Zhenjiang, where the Grand Canal crosses the Yangtze, and so cut the route by which grain reached Beijing. In Zhenjiang the Manchu garrison had fought to the end and many soldiers had killed their wives and children and then themselves. Nanjing was next, and the Daoguang Emperor had authorised his envoys to settle.

The terms had been dictated over the previous fortnight, with much of the go-between work done by Zhang Xi, a retainer of Yilibu who kept a diary of the talks. China would pay twenty-one million silver dollars: six for opium destroyed at Canton in 1839, three for debts owed by Chinese merchants, twelve for the cost of the war. Five ports, Canton, Amoy, Fuzhou, Ningbo and Shanghai, would be opened to British residence and trade, with consuls and a fixed tariff. The licensed merchant guild at Canton would be abolished. Officials of the two countries would correspond as equals. And the island of Hong Kong, which the British had occupied since January 1841, was ceded to the Queen in perpetuity.

Opium does not appear anywhere in the text. Pottinger raised it informally, suggesting that China legalise and tax the trade; the commissioners replied that the emperor would never hear of it. The traffic simply continued, illegal in Chinese law and unmolested in practice, and by the 1850s imports were roughly double what they had been before the war.

The fleet withdrew down the river as the first instalment was paid. Ratifications were exchanged at Hong Kong the following June.

How it came to this

For eighty years the Qing had confined Western sea trade to the single port of Canton, conducted through a guild of licensed merchants. Britain bought tea in enormous quantities and had little to sell in return except silver, until the East India Company began growing opium in Bengal and auctioning it to private traders who smuggled it into China. By the 1830s some forty thousand chests a year were arriving, silver was flowing out of China, and addiction had reached the army and the bureaucracy.

After a court debate on legalisation, the emperor sent Lin Zexu to Canton in 1839 to stamp the trade out. Lin blockaded the foreign merchants in their warehouses until they surrendered more than twenty thousand chests, and destroyed the lot in trenches by the sea. The British superintendent, Charles Elliot, had promised the merchants compensation from the Crown. Lord Palmerston’s government chose to extract it from China instead and sent an expeditionary force. The Commons upheld the decision by nine votes in April 1840. Steamships and modern artillery made the fighting one-sided. A first settlement in 1841 was disowned by both governments, and Pottinger was sent to finish the matter.

How each side saw it

The Qing court

In the memorials Qiying sent to Beijing, the treaty is an exercise in managing dangerous outsiders: concessions made to get the ships out of the river, in the tradition of soothing frontier peoples with trade. The Daoguang Emperor’s replies are full of pain at the cost but treat the matter as a coastal disturbance, not a turning point. Julia Lovell and the Chinese historian Mao Haijian have both shown how little the court understood of who it was dealing with, and how officials on the spot sent the emperor reports of victories that had not occurred. Lin Zexu was made the scapegoat and exiled to Xinjiang.

British critics of the war

The war was denounced at home from the start. William Gladstone, then a young Tory, told the Commons in 1840 that he knew of no war more unjust in its origin or more calculated to cover the country with permanent disgrace. Chartists, Quakers and missionary societies said the same. The government’s reply, then and afterwards, was that it fought not for opium but for the security of British subjects, compensation for seized property and the right to trade and negotiate on equal terms. The firm of Jardine, Matheson, the largest opium house, had advised Palmerston on strategy and on what to demand.

Modern Chinese memory

In the People’s Republic the treaty is the first of the ‘unequal treaties’ and the opening of a ‘century of humiliation’ that ended in 1949. School textbooks, museums at Humen and Nanjing, and the ceremony of Hong Kong’s return in 1997 all tell that story, with Lin Zexu as patriot and the people of Sanyuanli, who attacked British troops outside Canton in 1841, as heroes of popular resistance. Historians point out that the phrase ‘unequal treaties’ dates from the 1920s and that Nationalists and Communists alike built the narrative for their own purposes; they do not dispute that the terms were imposed by force.

The inhabitants of Hong Kong

When the British raised their flag in 1841 the island was not empty, whatever Palmerston said about a barren rock. A count published in the first government gazette that year listed about 7,450 people: farmers and quarrymen in a score of villages, and some two thousand who lived on fishing boats. None of them was consulted and no statement of their view survives. They appear in the record through British land registers, and through the tens of thousands of migrants from Guangdong who soon outnumbered them, drawn by work in the new port.

What is disputed

What to call the war is itself argued: the Opium War in China and most of the world, a war for free trade and diplomatic equality in the older British view associated with John K. Fairbank’s ‘clash of systems’. Stephen Platt has argued that it was avoidable and nearly did not happen; others see it as the logical end of the opium economy. The addiction figures used on both sides are estimates. Whether the treaty truly began modern Chinese history, as textbooks say, or was a regional shock whose meaning was assigned later, is contested between Chinese and Western scholars and among Chinese ones.

What followed

A supplementary treaty in 1843 exempted British subjects from Chinese law and promised Britain any privilege later granted to others; the United States and France obtained matching treaties in 1844. A second war in 1856-60 opened more ports, legalised opium and added Kowloon to Hong Kong. The New Territories were leased for ninety-nine years in 1898, and it was the expiry of that lease that brought the whole colony back to China on 1 July 1997. Shanghai grew from a county town into the largest city in Asia. The treaty remains a live reference in Chinese diplomacy.

Read further

  • Julia Lovell, The Opium War: Drugs, Dreams and the Making of China (2011)
  • Mao Haijian, The Qing Empire and the Opium War: The Collapse of the Heavenly Dynasty (2016)
  • Arthur Waley, The Opium War Through Chinese Eyes (1958)
  • Stephen R. Platt, Imperial Twilight: The Opium War and the End of China’s Last Golden Age (2018)
  • John K. Fairbank, Trade and Diplomacy on the China Coast (1953)

Same day, other years

1526

The kingdom of Hungary is destroyed at Mohacs

Mohacs, HungaryEurope

Sultan Suleiman had taken Belgrade five years earlier and in 1526 marched up the Danube with an army of perhaps sixty thousand and a large train of artillery. King Louis II, twenty years old, met him on a marshy plain with some twenty-five thousand men, without waiting for the forces of Transylvania and Croatia. The Hungarian heavy cavalry charged, broke through the first Ottoman line and rode into massed janissary fire and cannon. It was over in about two hours. Most of the army and much of the nobility and episcopate died; the king drowned under his horse in a stream while fleeing. Suleiman’s diary records that two thousand prisoners were beheaded the next day.

Seen from elsewhere. Ottoman chroniclers such as Kemalpashazade celebrated a victory granted by God. In Hungary ‘more was lost at Mohacs’ is still a proverb for any setback. Historians dispute whether Suleiman meant to conquer Hungary or only to break it into a buffer state, and whether the Transylvanian governor John Zapolya held back deliberately.

1910

Japan annexes Korea

Seoul, KoreaAsia

Korea had been a Japanese protectorate since 1905, its foreign relations and then its army taken over after Japan’s victories over China and Russia. A treaty of annexation was signed on 22 August 1910 by the Korean prime minister, Yi Wan-yong, and the Japanese resident-general, Terauchi Masatake, and proclaimed a week later, on the 29th. It transferred all rights of sovereignty to the emperor of Japan ‘completely and for ever’. The Joseon dynasty, which had reigned for more than five hundred years, ended. Colonial rule lasted until Japan’s defeat in 1945 and included the suppression of the 1919 independence movement and wartime forced labour.

Seen from elsewhere. Koreans call the date the day of national humiliation, and Korean scholars hold the treaty void because Emperor Sunjong never signed it and it was made under military occupation. Japanese governments long maintained that it was legally concluded; a 2010 statement by the prime minister acknowledged that rule was imposed against the will of Koreans. Some Korean groups at the time had petitioned for union.

1911

Ishi walks out of the hills

Oroville, California, United StatesThe Americas

Butchers at a slaughterhouse near Oroville found a starving man of about fifty crouched by the corral. The sheriff put him in a cell for his own protection. He spoke no language anyone present knew. Anthropologists from the University of California identified him as a Yahi, from a people of the Mount Lassen foothills who had been hunted almost to extinction by settler militias in the 1860s; a handful had lived in concealment for forty years, and he was the last of them. He spent his remaining years at the university’s museum in San Francisco, demonstrating crafts to visitors, and died of tuberculosis in 1916. ‘Ishi’ means ‘man’; he never gave his name.

Seen from elsewhere. Native Californians object to the label ‘the last wild Indian’: Yana-speaking descendants survive, and the museum made a living man an exhibit. Against his known wishes his body was autopsied and his brain sent to the Smithsonian. It was returned to the Redding Rancheria and Pit River peoples for burial in 2000.

1949

The Soviet Union tests its first atomic bomb

Semipalatinsk test site, Kazakh SSR (Kazakhstan)Asia

At seven in the morning a plutonium device code-named First Lightning was detonated on a tower in the Kazakh steppe, with a yield of about twenty-two kilotons. It was closely modelled on the American bomb dropped on Nagasaki, whose design Soviet intelligence had obtained through Klaus Fuchs and others. Igor Kurchatov directed the science; Lavrenti Beria, head of the secret police, ran the project and watched the test. Moscow made no announcement. American aircraft collected radioactive debris over the Pacific days later, and President Truman told the public on 23 September. The American monopoly had lasted four years.

Seen from elsewhere. The site was chosen as ‘uninhabited’; several hundred thousand people lived in the surrounding districts. Over forty years 456 tests were held there, more than a hundred above ground, and local Kazakhs were studied by a secret clinic without being told why. A mass movement led by the poet Olzhas Suleimenov forced the site’s closure on 29 August 1991.

Also on 29 August