Parallax

25 August, AD 79

The second morning under Vesuvius

Pompeii survived the first day of the eruption under a rain of pumice. What killed the town came down the mountain the next morning, and the only eyewitness account we have was written by a teenager who stayed behind to finish his reading.

Bay of Naples, Italy

Around midday a column of gas and pumice burst from Vesuvius and climbed, by modern estimates, some thirty kilometres into the sky. At the naval base of Misenum, across the bay, the commander of the fleet was called outside by his sister to look at a cloud shaped like an umbrella pine. He was Pliny the Elder, author of an encyclopaedia of the natural world, and his first thought was to take a light boat and study it. Then a note arrived from a friend, Rectina, whose villa lay under the mountain with no escape except by sea. He ordered out the warships instead.

In Pompeii, ten kilometres downwind, pumice fell for about eighteen hours and piled up to nearly three metres. Roofs gave way under it. Many people left during those hours, wading through the fall with whatever they could carry; others shut themselves indoors. Herculaneum, on the western side, received only a dusting. But soon after midnight the towering column began to collapse under its own weight, and an avalanche of gas and ash at several hundred degrees ran down the slope and through the town. Hundreds who had gathered in the boat sheds on the beach, waiting for rescue, died there.

Pliny the Elder could not reach Rectina. He put in at Stabiae, at the house of a friend named Pomponianus, and to calm the household he bathed, dined and went to bed, where he was heard snoring. By the small hours the courtyard was filling with stones. The party went down to the shore with pillows tied to their heads, found the sea too wild to launch, and waited. Pliny lay down on a sailcloth and twice asked for cold water. When flames and a smell of sulphur drove the others on, he rose leaning on two slaves and fell dead.

That same morning, the second of the eruption, a series of surges reached Pompeii. One of them, a little after sunrise, went over the walls and killed everyone still in the town. At Misenum the admiral’s nephew, seventeen years old, who had declined the boat trip because he had some Livy to get through, finally fled with his mother among a panicking crowd. A black cloud came down over the sea and blotted out Capri. The darkness, he wrote, was not that of a moonless night but of a sealed room with the lamp put out. He heard people calling for children and parents, and some saying that there were no gods left and that this was the world’s last night.

When a thin daylight returned, everything was buried in ash as if in snow. Pompeii lay under four to six metres of it, Herculaneum under as much as twenty.

How it came to this

The towns around the bay were among the most comfortable in Roman Italy. Pompeii, an old Oscan and Samnite town that had been a Roman colony since 80 BC, had perhaps eleven thousand inhabitants, an amphitheatre, baths, bakeries, bars and a busy trade in wine and fish sauce. Herculaneum was smaller and smarter. Senators kept seaside villas along the coast. Vines grew high up Vesuvius, which nobody alive regarded as dangerous: the geographer Strabo had noticed scorched rock at the summit and guessed that it had once burned and gone out.

A severe earthquake had damaged both towns seventeen years earlier, in 62 or 63, and builders were still at work on the repairs when the eruption came. Pliny the Younger says that tremors had been felt for several days beforehand and alarmed no one, because in Campania they were ordinary. The emperor Titus had been on the throne for two months. Everything known about the sequence of events comes from two letters the younger Pliny wrote to the historian Tacitus about a quarter of a century later, set against what volcanologists have read in the layers of ash.

How each side saw it

Pliny the Younger and the Roman governing class

The two letters to Tacitus are polished literary pieces, written to secure an uncle’s fame. The first makes the Elder Pliny’s death a model of Stoic calm and public duty: the scholar who turns a research trip into a rescue and sleeps soundly to steady his friends. The second is the writer’s own story, and he is careful to record that he kept reading while the house shook. Historians value them as the earliest detailed description of an eruption, so exact that the type is still called Plinian, while noting that the author saw Pompeii’s fate only as a cloud across the water.

The people who left no account

No resident of Pompeii or Herculaneum is known to have written about that day. The enslaved, who may have been a third of the population, and the poor are known only through remains: more than 1,100 bodies recovered at Pompeii, some three hundred skeletons in the Herculaneum boat sheds, and the plaster casts first made in 1863. Even these have been spoken for by others. Excavators arranged casts into families and gave them stories; a DNA study published in 2024 found that one celebrated ‘mother and child’ were an unrelated man and a boy. The old assumption that only the poor stayed is not borne out by the jewellery found with the dead.

Jewish and early Christian readers

Nine years before the eruption Titus had destroyed Jerusalem and its Temple. The fourth book of the Sibylline Oracles, a Jewish text composed soon after 79, describes fire bursting from a cleft in the land of Italy and tells its readers to recognise the anger of heaven against those who destroyed the blameless people. Someone scratched the words ‘Sodom, Gomorrah’ on a wall in Pompeii, though whether before the disaster or by a later visitor cannot be known. Around 197 the Christian writer Tertullian turned the argument round: Pompeii, he pointed out, had been buried at a time when there were no Christians there to blame.

What is disputed

The date is contested. The best manuscripts of Pliny give the ninth day before the Kalends of September, 24 August, for the start, which puts the destruction of Pompeii on the 25th. But excavators have found autumn fruit, sealed wine vats and braziers, and in 2018 a charcoal scrawl dated to what would be 17 October. Many archaeologists at Pompeii now favour 24-25 October; Pedar Foss has defended the manuscript date. The death toll is unknown, with around two thousand often suggested for Pompeii alone. Whether victims died from heat or from suffocation is argued between research teams.

What followed

Titus sent two former consuls to oversee relief and used the estates of those who had died without heirs to help survivors, many of whom resettled in Naples, Cumae, Puteoli and Ostia. The towns were not rebuilt and their sites were forgotten. Digging began at Herculaneum in 1738 and at Pompeii in 1748 under the Bourbon kings of Naples, and has never stopped; about a third of Pompeii is still unexcavated. Vesuvius last erupted in 1944. Some 600,000 people now live inside the zone that Italian authorities plan to evacuate first.

Read further

  • Pliny the Younger, Letters, book 6, letters 16 and 20
  • Mary Beard, Pompeii: The Life of a Roman Town (2008)
  • Alison E. Cooley and M. G. L. Cooley, Pompeii and Herculaneum: A Sourcebook (2014)
  • Andrew Wallace-Hadrill, Herculaneum: Past and Future (2011)
  • Cassius Dio, Roman History, book 66

Same day, other years

1270

Louis IX dies outside Tunis

Carthage, near TunisAfrica

The king of France had landed on the North African coast in July with his second crusade, apparently hoping that the Hafsid ruler of Tunis, al-Mustansir, could be converted or forced into alliance before the army moved on towards Egypt. Instead the camp among the ruins of Carthage was ravaged by disease in the summer heat. Louis’s son John Tristan died on 3 August. The king followed on the 25th, lying on a bed of ashes according to his confessor. His brother Charles of Anjou arrived the same day and negotiated a treaty and a withdrawal. Louis was declared a saint in 1297.

Seen from elsewhere. Ibn Khaldun, a Tunisian writing a century later, treats the affair as an invasion bought off with tribute. Jewish memory of the saint-king is of the man who had the Talmud burned in Paris and ordered Jews to wear a badge. The illness, long called plague, was more probably dysentery, perhaps with scurvy.

1825

Uruguay declares itself free of Brazil

Florida, Banda Oriental (Uruguay)The Americas

The land east of the Uruguay river had been annexed by Portugal and then inherited by the new Empire of Brazil as its Cisplatine Province. In April 1825 a party of exiles led by Juan Antonio Lavalleja, remembered as the Thirty-Three Orientals, crossed from Buenos Aires and raised the countryside. On 25 August an assembly meeting in the small town of Florida declared all acts of incorporation void and the province independent of the emperor. The war between Brazil and Argentina that followed ended in 1828, under British mediation, with neither getting the territory: it became a separate republic between them.

Seen from elsewhere. The same assembly voted on the same day to unite with the United Provinces of the River Plate, so Uruguayan historians have long argued over whether 25 August marks independence at all. Brazil regarded the province as lawfully its own. The Charrua people of the interior were largely destroyed by the new state at Salsipuedes in 1831.

1944

The German garrison surrenders Paris

Paris, FranceEurope

After six days of strikes and street fighting by the Resistance, tanks of General Leclerc’s French 2nd Armoured Division and American infantry entered the city in force. The German commander, Dietrich von Choltitz, was taken at the Hotel Meurice and signed a surrender that afternoon; Henri Rol-Tanguy, the communist who led the insurgents, added his signature. That evening Charles de Gaulle spoke at the Hotel de Ville of a Paris outraged, broken and martyred but liberated by itself, by its people, with the help of the armies of France. Around 1,500 resisters and civilians had died in the rising.

Seen from elsewhere. De Gaulle’s phrasing left out the Americans and British, and much else. The first vehicles in, on the 24th, were crewed by Spanish Republican exiles. Allied planners had insisted the liberating French division be white, and its West African soldiers had been replaced. Choltitz’s later claim that he saved Paris by defying Hitler is doubted by most historians.

2017

The expulsion of the Rohingya begins

Northern Rakhine State, MyanmarAsia

In the early hours, fighters of the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army attacked about thirty police posts and an army base in northern Rakhine. The Myanmar military answered with what it called clearance operations across Rohingya villages. Within months more than 700,000 people had crossed the Naf river into Bangladesh, joining earlier refugees in what became the largest refugee settlement in the world. Survivors described mass shootings, rape and the burning of villages; Medecins Sans Frontieres estimated at least 6,700 violent deaths in the first month. A United Nations fact-finding mission concluded in 2018 that senior generals should be investigated for genocide.

Seen from elsewhere. Myanmar’s government described a lawful counter-insurgency against terrorists and rejected the charge of genocide; Aung San Suu Kyi defended that position at The Hague in 2019, conceding only that disproportionate force may have been used. Many in Myanmar regard the Rohingya as migrants from Bengal. Amnesty International has also accused the insurgents of massacring Hindu villagers.

Also on 25 August