Parallax

14 August, 1385

Portugal keeps its crown at Aljubarrota

A king elected four months earlier and a constable of twenty-five dug ditches across a ridge and waited. In under an hour the army of Castile, several times larger, was running for the Tagus.

Sao Jorge, near Aljubarrota, Portugal

Late in the afternoon of 14 August 1385, the eve of the Assumption, the army of the king of Castile came up to a low ridge on the road from Leiria to Lisbon and found the Portuguese drawn up across it. Juan I of Castile was ill with fever. His army, perhaps 20,000 to 30,000 strong by modern estimates and including a large body of French men-at-arms, had been marching all day in the heat and was strung out for miles. The Portuguese numbered about 6,500 or 7,000, among them a few hundred English archers and men-at-arms, veterans of the French wars.

The position had been chosen by the Portuguese constable, Nuno Alvares Pereira, who was twenty-five. That morning he had faced north on a strong slope; the Castilians had declined to attack it and marched round. Pereira turned his army about and took up a new line on the same ridge facing south, on a front narrowed by two streams to a few hundred metres. While the enemy deployed, his men dug: a ditch across the front and rows of pits, in the manner the English had used in France. King Joao, acclaimed only four months earlier, commanded the rear division.

The older Castilian captains advised waiting for the next day. By the king’s own account they were overruled by younger knights who saw a small army in front of them and wanted the honour. The vanguard, largely French, dismounted and advanced on foot as the sun was getting low. The streams and ditches squeezed it inwards until men could hardly move their arms, while arrows and crossbow bolts came in from the wings. It reached the Portuguese line already in disorder and was cut down. The main Castilian body came on behind into the same funnel, and for a short time broke into the Portuguese vanguard, until Joao brought up the rear division on foot.

When the royal standard of Castile went down the army behind it broke. The fighting had lasted well under an hour. Juan was put on a horse and rode through the night to Santarem, some thirty miles away, took a boat down the Tagus to his fleet and sailed home to Seville. Behind him the pursuers and the country people killed fugitives for days. According to the chronicler Froissart, the Portuguese, seeing the main Castilian body approach, had already killed the prisoners taken from the vanguard.

Castile lost a great part of its nobility in an evening, and the court went into mourning. Joao kept the field for the customary three days, then vowed a monastery to the Virgin, on whose vigil he had won. Building began within a few years a short distance from the battlefield. It is known simply as Batalha, the Battle.

How it came to this

King Fernando of Portugal died in October 1383 leaving one legitimate child, the ten-year-old Beatriz, who had been married that spring to Juan I of Castile. By the marriage treaty Fernando’s widow, Leonor Teles, was to rule as regent until Beatriz had a son of age, and the kingdoms were to stay separate. Few trusted the arrangement. Leonor was unpopular, and her adviser and reputed lover, the Galician count Joao Fernandes Andeiro, more so. On 6 December 1383 Joao, Master of the military Order of Aviz and an illegitimate son of the late King Pedro I, killed Andeiro in the palace at Lisbon. The city rose in his support and named him defender of the realm.

Leonor called in her son-in-law, who then pushed her aside and claimed the throne in his wife’s name. Much of the high nobility sided with Castile, while Lisbon, Porto and many towns backed the Master. Juan besieged Lisbon by land and sea in 1384 until plague destroyed his army. In April 1385 the Cortes at Coimbra, persuaded by the lawyer Joao das Regras that every other claimant was illegitimate or had forfeited the right, elected the Master king and he named Pereira his constable.

How each side saw it

Castile

The Castilian chancellor Pero Lopez de Ayala fought in the battle, was captured and spent more than a year a prisoner in Portugal. His chronicle of Juan I is sober and close to the event: the army was tired, the ground was against it, experienced men counselled delay and were ignored. Juan’s own letter to the city of Murcia, written soon afterwards, makes the same points and pleads his illness. In the Castilian view he was no invader but the lawful king in right of his wife, opposed by a usurping bastard and a rebellious capital. He wore mourning and never gave up the title.

Beatriz and Leonor

Beatriz, in whose name the war was fought, was twelve when her husband was defeated and left no words of her own. By the treaty her father had sealed and the realm had sworn, she was queen of Portugal; the Coimbra assembly disposed of her claim by arguing that her parents’ marriage was invalid and that she had allied herself with a schismatic enemy. Leonor Teles, blackened by the chronicler Fernao Lopes as an adulteress and schemer, was shut in a Castilian convent by her own son-in-law. Recent Portuguese historians have reread both women as casualties of a narrative written, decades later, for the dynasty that displaced them.

Portuguese national tradition

Fernao Lopes, keeper of the royal archives, wrote his chronicle of Joao I in the 1430s and 1440s for Joao’s sons. It is one of the great histories of the Middle Ages, and it is partisan: the common people of Lisbon are its heroes, the Master their chosen leader, and Aljubarrota God’s verdict. Later ages built on it. Nuno Alvares Pereira, who ended his life as a Carmelite lay brother, was beatified in 1918 and canonised in 2009. The Salazar regime made the battle and the constable symbols of a Catholic and independent nation, and the field was excavated in its last decades.

The English

For the English the campaign was a side theatre of the Hundred Years War. Castile was France’s ally and its galleys raided the Channel coast; John of Gaunt, Duke of Lancaster, claimed the Castilian crown through his wife. The small company at Aljubarrota was recruited privately by Portuguese envoys, and its numbers are uncertain. Jean Froissart, who gathered his account from Gascon and Portuguese informants years later, gives the English a large part. The Treaty of Windsor followed in May 1386, Gaunt landed in Galicia that summer, and his daughter Philippa married Joao in 1387.

What is disputed

Army sizes are estimates built on chronicles that exaggerate; the Castilian figure in particular ranges from under 20,000 to over 30,000. Froissart’s narrative differs from those of Lopes and Ayala on the order of events and on the killing of prisoners. Excavations begun by Afonso do Paco in 1958 confirmed the ditches and pits and found a mass grave. The story of the baker of Aljubarrota, who killed seven Castilians hiding in her oven with her bread shovel, is legend. Historians also dispute the nature of the crisis: a national and popular revolution, as nationalist and Marxist writers held, or a succession war between noble factions.

What followed

Castile never again came close to absorbing Portugal by force, though a lasting peace was not agreed until 1411. The new dynasty of Aviz, with its English queen, turned outward: Joao’s army took Ceuta in Morocco in 1415, and his son Henry sponsored the voyages down the African coast that opened both the sea route to India and the Atlantic slave trade. The Anglo-Portuguese alliance of 1386 has never been revoked and was invoked as late as 1943, for bases in the Azores. In 1580 a king of Castile, Philip II, did inherit Portugal, and his line held it for sixty years.

Read further

  • Fernao Lopes, The English in Portugal 1367-87, edited by Derek W. Lomax and R. J. Oakley (1988)
  • P. E. Russell, The English Intervention in Spain and Portugal in the Time of Edward III and Richard II (1955)
  • Joao Gouveia Monteiro, Aljubarrota 1385: A Batalha Real (2003)
  • Jean Froissart, Chronicles
  • Pero Lopez de Ayala, Cronica del rey don Juan I

Same day, other years

1791

The gathering at Bois Caiman

Northern plain, Saint-Domingue (Haiti)The Americas

Saint-Domingue was the richest colony in the world, producing a large share of Europe’s sugar and coffee with the labour of nearly half a million enslaved people, most of them born in Africa. According to tradition, on the stormy night of 14 August 1791 delegates from plantations across the northern plain met in a wood called Bois Caiman. A ceremony was held, led by the coachman and religious leader Dutty Boukman and a priestess; a black pig was sacrificed, and those present swore to rise. A week later the plain was in flames. Within weeks hundreds of plantations had been burned. The revolt became the only uprising of enslaved people to found a state, Haiti, in 1804.

Seen from elsewhere. The earliest account is by a hostile colonist, Antoine Dalmas, and Boukman’s famous prayer first appears in print in 1824. David Geggus argues that the planning meeting of 14 August and the ceremony, probably a week later, were separate events. Some evangelical writers have called the ceremony a pact with the devil, which Haitians widely resent.

1900

Foreign armies take Beijing

Beijing, ChinaAsia

For fifty-five days the foreign legations in Beijing, sheltering several hundred foreigners and about 3,000 Chinese Christians, had been besieged by Boxer militants and Qing troops. On 14 August an improvised army of roughly 20,000 men from eight nations, its largest contingents Japanese and Russian, fought its way into the city. British Indian troops reached the legations first, through a water gate under the wall. The Empress Dowager Cixi left the next morning in a cart, dressed as a countrywoman. What followed was weeks of looting by soldiers, diplomats and missionaries alike, and punitive expeditions into the countryside in which thousands of Chinese, many with no Boxer connection, were killed. The peace of 1901 imposed an indemnity of 450 million taels.

Seen from elsewhere. Western accounts long told a story of rescue. Chinese memory files the event under national humiliation. The Boxers themselves, who had killed more than 30,000 Chinese Christians and some 200 missionaries, have been cast in China as patriots, as superstitious reactionaries, and as both, depending on the period.

1947

Pakistan comes into being

Karachi, PakistanAsia

On 14 August 1947 Lord Mountbatten, the last viceroy, addressed Pakistan’s Constituent Assembly in Karachi and handed over power to a state whose very name had been coined only in the 1930s. Muhammad Ali Jinnah, leader of the Muslim League, became governor-general. He had argued since 1940 that the Muslims of India were a nation entitled to a homeland; three days earlier he had told the assembly that citizens were free to go to their temples, mosques or any other place of worship, and that religion was not the business of the state. The country came in two wings a thousand miles apart, with a makeshift capital and no agreed share yet of the army and treasury.

Seen from elsewhere. The Indian National Congress accepted partition as a tragedy forced by the League. Several Muslim religious scholars opposed Pakistan too. Ayesha Jalal argues that Jinnah wanted leverage within a loose union rather than separation. The legal date of independence was 15 August, as for India; Pakistan has marked the 14th since 1948.

2013

The clearing of Rabaa square

Cairo, EgyptAfrica

Six weeks after the army removed Mohamed Morsi, Egypt’s first freely elected president, following mass protests against his rule, tens of thousands of his supporters were still camped at two squares in greater Cairo, Rabaa al-Adawiya and al-Nahda. Early on 14 August 2013 police and soldiers moved in with armoured vehicles, bulldozers and snipers. Clearing Rabaa took about twelve hours. Human Rights Watch, after a year’s investigation, documented at least 817 deaths there and judged the true number probably above a thousand, calling it one of the largest killings of demonstrators in a single day in recent history. Egypt’s official human rights council counted 632 dead, eight of them police. A curfew followed.

Seen from elsewhere. The government said the sit-ins were armed, that warnings and a safe exit were given, and that police came under fire first. Morsi’s supporters and most outside investigators say the great majority of the dead were unarmed. In the following days mobs attacked dozens of Coptic churches. No officer has been tried.

Also on 14 August