Parallax

1 February, 1896

La Boheme opens in Turin to a shrug from the critics

A 28-year-old conductor named Toscanini led the first night of Puccini’s new opera about penniless artists in a Paris garret. The public liked it. The reviewers gave it a season or two.

Teatro Regio, Turin, Italy

The Teatro Regio in Turin was full on the evening of Saturday 1 February 1896, and members of the royal house of Savoy were in their box. Three years earlier to the day, the same theatre had staged the first performance of Manon Lescaut and made Giacomo Puccini the most talked-about young composer in Italy. His publisher, Giulio Ricordi, had chosen the date and the house again on purpose. In the pit was Arturo Toscanini, 28 years old, who had spent the weeks before Christmas conducting the first Italian-language Gotterdammerung in the same building.

The new opera was short, quick and oddly domestic. Four young men, a poet, a painter, a musician and a philosopher, share a freezing attic in the Latin Quarter around 1830 and burn a manuscript to keep warm. A seamstress from the same staircase knocks to ask for a light for her candle. By the end of the fourth act she is dead of consumption on their bed, and the poet is the last person in the room to realise it. Cesira Ferrani, who had created Manon, sang Mimi. Evan Gorga, the Rodolfo, was struggling with the part, and Puccini had already lowered some of his music.

The audience applauded warmly and called the composer out several times, though the second act, with its crowded street scene and children’s chorus, puzzled people. The next morning’s reviews were cooler. Carlo Bersezio, writing in La Stampa, judged that the work made little impression on the listener and would leave little mark on the history of the Italian lyric stage, and he advised Puccini to treat it as a passing error. Others missed the passion of Manon, or complained that after Wagner this was thin, conversational stuff, an operetta with a death at the end.

Puccini, who had told friends that he wept like a child when he finished composing Mimi’s death at Torre del Lago, was hurt. Ricordi was not much troubled. The Turin run continued through February to full houses, some two dozen performances in all. Rome was polite later that month. Then, in April, a performance in Palermo under Leopoldo Mugnone ended in such an uproar of enthusiasm that, by the usual account, the final scene had to be repeated well after midnight with some of the singers already half out of costume.

Within two years the opera had reached Buenos Aires, Alexandria, Moscow, Lisbon, Manchester, Berlin, Los Angeles and Paris. It has not left the repertory since, and in most seasons it is among the three or four most performed operas in the world.

How it came to this

The story came from Henri Murger, a Parisian tailor’s son born in 1822 who left school at thirteen and lived for years on almost nothing among painters and writers on the Left Bank. From 1845 he sold sketches of that life to a small paper, Le Corsaire-Satan, for a few francs each. A stage version written with Theodore Barriere was a hit in 1849, and the collected Scenes de la vie de boheme followed in 1851. It made Murger’s name, and fixed the word ‘bohemian’ in several languages, but he died in 1861, aged 38, still short of money.

Puccini fixed on the book in 1893. His librettists were Luigi Illica, who built the scenario, and the poet Giuseppe Giacosa, who put it into verse and threatened to resign more than once as the composer demanded rewrites. A whole act was cut. They softened Murger considerably: his episodes are funny, hard and unsentimental, and the dying girl with the muff is in the book a minor figure called Francine, while his Mimi is unfaithful and far less innocent.

How each side saw it

Ruggero Leoncavallo

The composer of Pagliacci believed the subject was his. By his account he had drafted a libretto from Murger and offered it to Puccini, who declined, and then learned in a Milan cafe in March 1893 that Puccini was setting the same book. His publisher’s newspaper, Il Secolo, announced his prior claim; Puccini answered in the Corriere della Sera that he had not known, and that both should compose and let the public decide. Leoncavallo’s La Boheme, closer to Murger’s rougher tone, opened in Venice in May 1897 to a good reception. The public decided against him all the same, and the two men never mended the quarrel.

The Turin critics, and the musicians who agreed with them

Bersezio and his colleagues were not fools. Their case was that the piece had no grand situations, that its characters chattered where they should have sung, and that it traded in easy tears. That charge has never gone away. Eduard Hanslick in Vienna found the opera coarse. Benjamin Britten wrote in the 1950s that he was repelled by what he heard as the cheapness of the music, and for much of the twentieth century academic writers on opera treated Puccini as a skilled manufacturer of sentiment, not a serious composer. His standing among scholars has risen sharply since the 1980s.

The women Murger wrote about

The working women of the Latin Quarter, the grisettes who sewed, made artificial flowers and lived with students and artists, left almost no account of themselves. We know them through the men who wrote them up. Murger’s Mimi draws on several women, among them Lucile Louvet, a flower-maker who died of tuberculosis in a Paris public hospital in 1848; by his own telling he learned of her death too late and her body went to the dissecting room unclaimed. Historians such as Jerrold Seigel point out that the bohemia of the stage is a young man’s memory of a few years of chosen poverty, set beside women whose poverty was not chosen.

What is disputed

Who thought of the subject first cannot now be settled: there are only the two composers’ statements and their publishers’ rival newspapers. The story that the premiere was a failure is exaggerated. The press was lukewarm, but the house was not hostile and the run sold out. The Palermo anecdote of the repeated finale rests on later recollection and has grown in the telling. How far Murger’s characters match real people is also argued; the musician Schaunard was certainly Alexandre Schanne, who wrote his own memoirs, but the rest are composites, and Murger romanticised his own past as he went.

What followed

La Boheme, followed by Tosca in 1900 and Madama Butterfly in 1904, made Puccini rich and made Ricordi’s firm the dominant force in Italian opera. Toscanini conducted the work again in a famous 1946 broadcast, fifty years after the premiere. The opera fixed an image of the starving artist in a garret that has shaped films, novels and the 1996 musical Rent, which moved the story to New York during the AIDS epidemic. Murger, whose book supplied all of it, is now read mostly by people curious about the opera.

Read further

  • Henri Murger, Scenes de la vie de boheme (1851)
  • Arthur Groos and Roger Parker, Giacomo Puccini: La Boheme (1986)
  • Julian Budden, Puccini: His Life and Works (2002)
  • Mosco Carner, Puccini: A Critical Biography (1958)
  • Jerrold Seigel, Bohemian Paris: Culture, Politics, and the Boundaries of Bourgeois Life, 1830-1930 (1986)

Same day, other years

1835

Slavery ends in Mauritius, and the owners are paid

MauritiusAfrica

Britain’s Abolition Act took effect in most colonies in August 1834, but in Mauritius, taken from France in 1810 and dominated by French-speaking sugar planters, the date was 1 February 1835. More than 60,000 people, most of them of Malagasy and East African descent, ceased to be property. They were not yet free to leave: the law bound them to their former owners as unpaid ‘apprentices’ until 1839. Parliament voted about two million pounds in compensation for Mauritius, all of it to the owners. When apprenticeship ended, most of the freed people walked off the estates for good, and the planters replaced them with indentured labourers shipped from India.

Seen from elsewhere. The freed left almost no written testimony; their experience is known from magistrates’ reports and from Creole oral tradition, including the story that fugitives on Le Morne mountain leapt to their deaths on seeing soldiers approach. Planters called abolition confiscation. Mauritius now marks 1 February as a public holiday, and descendants have pressed for reparations through a Truth and Justice Commission that reported in 2011.

1908

The king of Portugal and his heir are shot in an open carriage

Lisbon, PortugalEurope

King Carlos I was returning from his country palace with his family when two men opened fire as the carriage crossed the Terreiro do Paco, the great riverside square of Lisbon. Carlos died at once. His elder son, Luis Filipe, was mortally wounded; Queen Amelie struck at one attacker with a bouquet of flowers. The younger son, hit in the arm, became King Manuel II at eighteen. The gunmen, Manuel Buica, a schoolteacher and former army sergeant, and Alfredo Costa, a shop clerk, were killed on the spot by police. The king had been ruling through a prime minister, Joao Franco, who governed by decree with parliament closed.

Seen from elsewhere. Monarchists saw a murdered father and son. Many republicans saw tyrannicide: crowds visited the assassins’ graves and money was raised for Buica’s children. Both men were linked to the Carbonaria secret society, but the official inquiry was never completed and its papers vanished after the republic was declared in October 1910, so who else knew remains open.

1968

A police chief shoots a prisoner in a Saigon street, on camera

Saigon, South VietnamAsia

On the second day of the Tet offensive, with fighting inside the South Vietnamese capital, soldiers brought a bound man in a checked shirt to Brigadier General Nguyen Ngoc Loan, chief of the national police. Loan drew a revolver and shot him in the head. Eddie Adams of the Associated Press caught the instant of the shot, and an NBC cameraman filmed it. The prisoner was Nguyen Van Lem, a Viet Cong officer. The photograph ran on front pages around the world, won a Pulitzer Prize, and became one of the images most often cited for turning American opinion against the war.

Seen from elsewhere. Loan’s defenders said Lem had just been caught after the killing of a South Vietnamese officer’s family, a claim that has been repeated often but never proved in any court. Adams came to regret the picture, writing that the general killed the Viet Cong and he killed the general with his camera. In Vietnam Lem is honoured as a martyr; his widow learned of his death from the newspaper.

1979

Khomeini flies home to Tehran

Tehran, IranMiddle East

Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini had been in exile for more than fourteen years, in Turkey, in the Iraqi shrine city of Najaf and finally in a village outside Paris, when a chartered Air France jumbo jet brought him back on the morning of 1 February 1979. The Shah had left Iran two weeks earlier. Crowds counted in the millions lined the road from the airport. Asked on the aircraft by an American reporter what he felt, he answered, through an interpreter, ‘nothing’. He drove straight to the Behesht-e Zahra cemetery, where the dead of the revolution were buried, and announced that he would appoint a government himself. Ten days later the army stood aside.

Seen from elsewhere. The crowds included liberals, nationalists, Marxists and women’s groups who had marched against the Shah and expected a pluralist republic. Many were in prison, in exile or dead within three years. Supporters of the Islamic Republic mark the day as the start of the Ten Days of Dawn; monarchists and much of the diaspora date from it the loss of their country.

Also on 1 February