Parallax

4 February, 1716

The Stuart claimant slips out of Scotland by night

James Francis Edward Stuart had been in his ancestors’ kingdom for six weeks, most of them ill, none of them in battle. He left by a back door in Montrose and never saw Britain again.

Montrose, Scotland

On the evening of 4 February 1716, by the calendar then used in Britain, the Jacobite army was drawn up in the streets of Montrose with orders to march north to Aberdeen. The man they called King James VIII and III had his horses brought to the door of his lodging and his guard mounted, as if he meant to ride with them. Then he went out on foot by a back way with the Earl of Mar and a servant, walked down to the shore, and was rowed to a small French ship, the Maria Teresa of St Malo. She sailed about nine o’clock. The Earl of Melfort and Lord Drummond were aboard; most of his officers knew nothing until morning.

James was 27. He had landed at Peterhead on 22 December after dodging British warships across the North Sea, with a handful of companions and none of the French troops, arms or money his supporters had been promised. He caught a fever almost at once. The rising he had come to lead was already failing: its two battles, at Sheriffmuir and Preston, had been fought in November. He made a formal entry into Dundee, then Perth, and held court at Scone, where a coronation was announced for 23 January and never took place.

Those who saw him were disappointed. He was tall, pale, grave and silent, and one of his own soldiers wrote that if they were let down in him he was no less so in them, and that they never saw him smile. He had expected an army; he found a few thousand men thinning daily. Meanwhile the Duke of Argyll, reinforced with six thousand Dutch troops and heavy guns, began to advance through the snow.

To slow him, James signed an order to burn the villages on the road to Perth. Auchterarder, Crieff, Blackford, Dunning and Muthill were fired in the last days of January, in deep winter, and their people turned out. It did not stop Argyll. On 31 January the Jacobites abandoned Perth, crossing the frozen Tay, and retreated up the coast.

At Montrose his advisers persuaded him that his presence only made terms harder for his followers to obtain. He left a letter for Argyll, enclosing what money he had and asking that it be given to the people of the burned villages, and a commission for General Alexander Gordon to lead the army away. Five days later he came ashore near Gravelines. The army reached Aberdeen, read his farewell, marched into the hills and dispersed.

How it came to this

James was born at St James’s Palace in June 1688, the son of the Catholic James II and VII and Mary of Modena. His birth, promising a Catholic succession, set off the invasion by William of Orange; opponents spread the tale that he was a substitute smuggled into the queen’s bed in a warming pan. Carried to France at six months old, he grew up at Saint-Germain as a pensioner of Louis XIV, who recognised him as king in 1701. An attempted landing in Scotland in 1708 was turned back. He refused more than once to change his religion to regain his thrones.

When Queen Anne, his half-sister, died in 1714 the crown passed by statute to the Elector of Hanover, George I, and the Tories were driven from office. In Scotland resentment of the 1707 Union and its taxes ran well beyond committed Jacobites. The Earl of Mar, dismissed by George, raised the Stuart standard at Braemar in September 1715 and soon had far more men than Argyll, but did not use them. Louis XIV had died days earlier, and the French regent wanted peace with Britain.

How each side saw it

The men he left behind

The bitterest account comes from inside the rising. John, Master of Sinclair, who served under Mar, wrote memoirs that damn the leadership as vain and incompetent and treat the flight from Montrose as desertion. Highland clansmen and north-eastern gentry who had risked everything were left to make their own terms or run. Some chiefs escaped to France; ordinary prisoners taken at Preston were tried in England, and several hundred were transported to the American and Caribbean colonies as indentured labour. Others in the army, by contrast, accepted the argument that the government would be gentler once the claimant had gone.

The Hanoverian government

To George I’s ministers this was an armed rebellion in the interest of a foreign-backed Catholic pretender against a king settled by Parliament, and they called James ‘the Pretender’ as a matter of law. Whig writers mocked his illness and his flight and nicknamed him ‘Old Mr Melancholy’. Yet the government’s own commander, Argyll, was thought too lenient to his countrymen and was removed from his post within months. Two peers, Derwentwater and Kenmure, were beheaded on Tower Hill; a third, Nithsdale, escaped from the Tower the night before in women’s clothes brought in by his wife.

James himself

His letters, preserved in the Stuart Papers at Windsor, show a conscientious, pious and unlucky man who believed that he had been called over on false assurances. He wrote that he had come to share his people’s danger, and left only when told that staying would destroy them. He blamed Bolingbroke, his secretary of state in France, for the missing supplies, and dismissed him. On the burnings he expressed regret and tried to pay. His defenders note that he was sick for most of the six weeks, and that he arrived after every military decision that mattered had already been taken.

What is disputed

Some accounts date the sailing to 5 February; the difference is mainly between the evening of embarkation and the night at sea. Dates here are Old Style, eleven days behind the calendar used in France, where it was 15 February. Whether the rising could have succeeded is argued. Daniel Szechi holds that it was a serious threat thrown away by Mar’s inertia; older Whig histories treated it as hopeless from the start. Responsibility for burning the Perthshire villages is shared uneasily in the sources between James, who signed, and Mar, who advised. The warming-pan story about his birth is not believed by any modern historian.

What followed

France expelled James under its new treaty with Britain. He moved to Avignon, then to Italy, and lived in Rome on a papal pension until his death in 1766, having been a king in name for 64 years. A Spanish-backed landing in 1719 failed. His son Charles Edward, born in 1720, led the last rising in 1745, which ended at Culloden. In Scotland the government built roads and forts and began the long dismantling of the chiefs’ military power. The cause survived longest in song, most of it written after there was any danger in singing it.

Read further

  • Daniel Szechi, 1715: The Great Jacobite Rebellion (2006)
  • Bruce Lenman, The Jacobite Risings in Britain, 1689-1746 (1980)
  • John, Master of Sinclair, Memoirs of the Insurrection in Scotland in 1715 (1858)
  • John Baynes, The Jacobite Rising of 1715 (1970)
  • Edward Corp, The Stuarts in Italy, 1719-1766 (2011)

Same day, other years

1794

The French Convention abolishes slavery

Paris, FranceEurope

On 16 Pluviose of the Year II, the National Convention voted that slavery was abolished in all French colonies and that every man living there, whatever his colour, was a French citizen. The vote followed the arrival of three deputies elected in Saint-Domingue, the richest sugar colony in the world: one white, one of mixed descent, and Jean-Baptiste Belley, born in West Africa and formerly enslaved. They reported that the republic’s commissioner, Sonthonax, facing a vast slave insurrection and British and Spanish invasion, had already proclaimed general emancipation the previous August. The deputies embraced and the hall rose to applaud.

Seen from elsewhere. Historians from C. L. R. James to Laurent Dubois stress that the enslaved of Saint-Domingue had freed themselves in arms from 1791 and that Paris ratified a fact. Planters lobbied against the decree, and colonists in the Indian Ocean simply refused to apply it. Napoleon restored slavery in 1802; France abolished it finally in 1848.

1899

Shots at a Manila outpost begin the Philippine-American War

Manila, PhilippinesAsia

Filipino revolutionaries had fought Spain, declared independence in June 1898 and proclaimed a republic at Malolos in January 1899. But Spain had sold the islands to the United States for twenty million dollars, and American troops held Manila with Filipino lines drawn around them. On the night of 4 February Private William Grayson of the Nebraska Volunteers fired on a Filipino patrol in the suburb of Santa Mesa. By morning there was fighting along the whole perimeter. Two days later the US Senate ratified the treaty of annexation by a single vote more than the two thirds needed. The war officially lasted until 1902; resistance went on for years longer.

Seen from elsewhere. Washington called it an insurrection against lawful authority; Filipinos call it a war for their republic. President Aguinaldo proposed a ceasefire the next day and the American commander refused. About 4,200 American and some 20,000 Filipino soldiers died. Civilian deaths, chiefly from hunger and disease, are put at 200,000 or more. In the United States, Mark Twain and the Anti-Imperialist League denounced the conquest.

1948

Ceylon becomes independent

Colombo, Ceylon (Sri Lanka)Asia

Six months after India and Pakistan, and without partition or large-scale bloodshed, the island of Ceylon ceased to be a British colony and became a self-governing dominion. D. S. Senanayake, who had negotiated the handover, became its first prime minister. Europeans had held the coasts since the Portuguese arrived in 1505; the British had ruled the whole island since deposing the last king of Kandy in 1815. The new state kept the British monarch as head of state, British bases at Trincomalee and Katunayake, and a constitution drafted in London. It became the republic of Sri Lanka in 1972.

Seen from elsewhere. The left opposition boycotted the celebrations as a transfer between elites. Within months parliament passed a citizenship law that left most of the Tamil plantation workers of Indian origin, about a tenth of the population, stateless. Tamil politicians date from these first years, and from the Sinhala Only Act of 1956, the grievances that ended in civil war.

1961

Angolans attack Luanda’s prisons

Luanda, AngolaAfrica

Before dawn, a few hundred men armed mostly with machetes attacked the Sao Paulo prison and police posts in Luanda, hoping to free political prisoners before they could be deported. They failed. Seven Portuguese policemen and some forty attackers were killed. The next day, at the policemen’s funeral, armed white civilians and police turned on the African shanty districts around the city, and over the following days several hundred Africans were killed. Foreign reporters were in town to cover a hijacked Portuguese liner and sent the story abroad. Angola marks the date as the start of its armed struggle, which lasted until Portugal’s own revolution in 1974.

Seen from elsewhere. Portugal insisted that Angola was an overseas province, not a colony, and blamed outside agitators. The MPLA, which has governed since independence in 1975, claims the attack as its own. Many historians credit loosely organised local nationalists around a Luanda priest, Canon Manuel das Neves, and regard the MPLA’s ownership of the day as a later construction.

Also on 4 February