Parallax

6 February, 1685

Charles II dies, a Catholic at the last

For four days a dozen physicians bled, blistered and purged the king of England. On the fifth night a priest was brought up the back stairs, and Charles settled the question his whole reign had avoided.

Whitehall Palace, London, England

On the evening of Sunday 1 February 1685 the diarist John Evelyn walked through the great gallery at Whitehall and was appalled. The king sat toying with three of his mistresses, the duchesses of Portsmouth, Cleveland and Mazarin; a French boy sang love songs; courtiers played basset round a table with two thousand pounds in gold on it. ‘Six days after,’ Evelyn wrote, ‘was all in the dust.’

Charles slept badly. At about eight on Monday morning, as he was being shaved, he cried out and fell back in a convulsion. A physician who happened to be present, Edmund King, opened a vein in his arm on the spot and took sixteen ounces of blood, an act that was technically treason without the Privy Council’s leave. The king recovered his speech. Then the full body of royal doctors arrived, and over the next four days, by the record their senior member Sir Charles Scarburgh kept, they applied nearly sixty different remedies: more bleeding, cupping, emetics, enemas, blistering agents on his shaved scalp, red-hot irons, plasters of pitch on his feet, and a distillation of human skull. He bore it with a patience everyone remarked on.

By Thursday it was clear he was dying. The bishops at the bedside urged him to take communion by the rite of the Church of England; he put them off, saying there was time enough. The Duchess of Portsmouth told the French ambassador, Barillon, that the king was at heart a Catholic and that someone must tell his brother. James bent over the bed and asked in a whisper whether he should fetch a priest. ‘For God’s sake, brother, do,’ Charles is reported to have answered, ‘and lose no time.’

The room was cleared of all but two Protestant earls. A Benedictine, John Huddleston, was led in by a concealed door in a wig and cassock. He was the priest who had helped hide Charles after the battle of Worcester in 1651, and James is said to have introduced him as the man who once saved the king’s life and now came to save his soul. Charles made his confession, was received into the Roman Church, and was given the last rites.

He lived through the night, clear-headed. He blessed his illegitimate sons, asked James to look after the Duchess of Portsmouth and, by Bishop Burnet’s report, not to let Nell Gwyn starve, and begged the queen’s pardon. He apologised to those watching for taking so long to die. At six he asked for the curtains to be drawn back so that he could see the daylight. He died shortly before noon on Friday 6 February, aged 54.

How it came to this

Charles had come to the throne in 1660 after eleven years of republican rule and nine of his own exile, on the understanding that the old quarrels would be buried. Religion would not stay buried. His wife, Catherine of Braganza, was Catholic and childless; his brother and heir James became a Catholic around 1669. In the secret Treaty of Dover of 1670 Charles promised Louis XIV, in return for money, that he would declare himself a Catholic when circumstances allowed. He never did, and went on taking Anglican communion.

Between 1679 and 1681, amid panic over an invented ‘Popish Plot’, the Whig opposition in three successive parliaments tried to exclude James from the succession. Charles outmanoeuvred them, dissolved the last of those parliaments, and ruled for his final four years without one, on French subsidies. By 1685 the Whig leaders were dead, exiled or cowed, and his eldest illegitimate son, the Protestant Duke of Monmouth, was abroad in disgrace. The crown would pass to a Catholic unopposed.

How each side saw it

The Catholic account

Huddleston published a short narrative of the conversion, and Barillon reported it to Louis XIV within days; James himself wrote it down. For English Catholics, a small and legally penalised minority, it was a moment of vindication: the king had died in the faith his mother had practised and his brother professed. James printed two papers in Charles’s handwriting, found in his strongbox, arguing for the Roman Church. In this telling Charles had been a convinced Catholic for years, and only fear for his throne had kept him from saying so.

The Anglican bishops and Protestant opinion

Thomas Ken, Bishop of Bath and Wells, who had pressed the king hard to repent, pronounced absolution, apparently unaware of what had happened while he was out of the room. Burnet, a Whig and no friend of the Stuarts, accepted that the conversion occurred but treated it as the act of a man without settled religion, taking the most confident offer at the end. Many Protestants found the secrecy more alarming than the fact. It confirmed what the exclusionists had said: that the court was Catholic at its core, and that the nation had been deceived by its own head of the Church.

The queen and the mistresses

Catherine of Braganza, overcome, had to be carried from the room, and sent to ask his forgiveness; Charles answered that it was he who should ask hers. Louise de Keroualle, Duchess of Portsmouth, the woman who actually set the conversion in motion, was kept from the bedside by propriety and left for France within months. None of the women left her own account of those days. Their parts are known through the ambassador’s dispatch and through male diarists, who recorded them chiefly as a measure of the king’s sins.

What is disputed

The cause of death was put down at the time to apoplexy, and rumours of poison followed at once. Raymond Crawfurd’s 1909 study argued for kidney disease ending in uraemic convulsions, still the commonest view; others have suggested mercury poisoning from the king’s own laboratory. The apology for being ‘an unconscionable time dying’ is given in that form by Macaulay in 1848, working from contemporary reports that Charles asked pardon for the trouble he caused; the wording is not a verbatim record. How sincere, or how long-standing, his Catholicism was is argued between Ronald Hutton, who doubts any firm belief, and writers who take the Dover promise seriously. The date is Old Style; it was 16 February in France.

What followed

James II succeeded without resistance. Within five months Monmouth landed in Dorset, was defeated at Sedgemoor and beheaded. James’s attempts to open offices to Catholics, and the birth of a Catholic heir in 1688, united his opponents; William of Orange invaded, James fled, and Parliament settled the crown on terms that have barred Catholics from it ever since. Charles was buried in Westminster Abbey at night with little ceremony. His reputation has swung between the lazy, charming ‘merry monarch’ and a shrewd survivor who kept his throne intact and left his brother a strong hand, which was then thrown away.

Read further

  • John Evelyn, The Diary of John Evelyn, edited by E. S. de Beer (1955)
  • Raymond Crawfurd, The Last Days of Charles II (1909)
  • Ronald Hutton, Charles the Second: King of England, Scotland, and Ireland (1989)
  • Antonia Fraser, King Charles II (1979)
  • Gilbert Burnet, History of His Own Time (1724)

Same day, other years

1819

Raffles signs a treaty for Singapore

SingaporeAsia

Stamford Raffles of the British East India Company wanted a port on the sea route to China that the Dutch did not control. Landing at the mouth of the Singapore River in late January 1819, he found a settlement of about a thousand people under a Malay chief, the Temenggong Abdul Rahman. The island belonged to the sultanate of Johor, whose ruler was under Dutch influence. Raffles sent for the sultan’s elder brother, Hussein, who had been passed over for the throne, recognised him as the rightful sultan, and on 6 February signed a treaty with both men allowing a British trading post in return for annual payments. Within five years the population had passed ten thousand.

Seen from elsewhere. The Dutch called it a plain violation of their sphere, and London nearly disowned Raffles before accepting the result in a treaty of 1824. Malay accounts stress that Hussein was a sultan made for the purpose, and that a second agreement in 1824 took the whole island. Nor was it an empty shore: a trading city had stood there in the fourteenth century.

1840

Maori chiefs and the British Crown sign at Waitangi

Waitangi, Bay of Islands, New ZealandOceania

Captain William Hobson had been sent to obtain Maori consent to British rule over New Zealand, where settlers and land speculators were arriving unchecked. A treaty was drafted in English and translated into Maori overnight by the missionary Henry Williams and his son. After a day of debate, in which several chiefs spoke strongly against, some forty-three chiefs signed on 6 February in front of the British Resident’s house; Hone Heke was first. Copies were then carried around the country and gathered more than five hundred signatures in all. Some powerful chiefs refused. In May Hobson proclaimed British sovereignty over the whole country.

Seen from elsewhere. The two texts do not say the same thing. The English cedes sovereignty; the Maori grants ‘kawanatanga’, governorship, and guarantees chiefs ‘tino rangatiratanga’, full authority over their lands and treasures. War and confiscation followed, and in 1877 a judge called the treaty a nullity. The Waitangi Tribunal concluded in 2014 that the northern chiefs who signed did not cede sovereignty.

1934

Paris police fire on a right-wing march to parliament

Paris, FranceEurope

A financial swindler with friends in government, Alexandre Stavisky, had been found dead in January, and the scandal brought down one cabinet. When the next prime minister, Edouard Daladier, removed the Paris police chief, a favourite of the right, the nationalist leagues and veterans’ associations called their members into the streets on the day he faced parliament. Tens of thousands converged on the Place de la Concorde and tried to force the bridge to the Chamber of Deputies. Police and mounted guards held it through hours of fighting and finally opened fire. Fifteen people were killed that night and well over a thousand injured. Daladier resigned the next day.

Seen from elsewhere. The left saw an attempted fascist coup, and answered with a general strike and the alliance that became the Popular Front. The right saw patriots shot down by a corrupt regime. Historians remain split: Serge Berstein and Rene Remond found no coordinated plan to seize power, while others argue that the leagues amounted to a real French fascism.

2023

Earthquakes devastate southern Turkey and northern Syria

Kahramanmaras, Turkey, and north-western SyriaMiddle East

At 4.17 in the morning, while most people were asleep, a magnitude 7.8 earthquake ruptured the East Anatolian Fault near the town of Pazarcik. Nine hours later a second shock almost as strong struck to the north. Tens of thousands of buildings fell across an area the size of a medium-sized country, in freezing weather. The ancient city of Antakya, the Antioch of antiquity, was largely destroyed. Turkey’s official death toll passed 53,000; in Syria, where twelve years of war had already wrecked housing and hospitals, between 6,000 and 8,000 died. It was the deadliest earthquake in the region in modern times.

Seen from elsewhere. The Turkish government called it a disaster beyond any state’s power to prepare for. Engineers and opposition politicians pointed to unenforced building codes and to amnesties that had legalised unsafe construction; contractors were arrested. In rebel-held north-western Syria almost no outside help arrived for days. Damascus blamed Western sanctions; aid agencies blamed restricted border crossings.

Also on 6 February