The earls of Shrewsbury and Kent came to Mary Stuart’s rooms on the evening of Tuesday 7 February 1587 and told her she would die at eight the next morning. She thanked them, by the account of her physician, and asked for her own chaplain; it was refused. She spent the night dividing her money and jewels among her servants, making her will, and writing to her former brother-in-law, Henri III of France, that she died for her religion. She lay down for a few hours without sleeping.
The great hall of Fotheringhay held some three hundred spectators and a low platform draped in black. Mary entered in black satin with a long white veil, a crucifix in her hand, and climbed the steps without help. The Dean of Peterborough, Richard Fletcher, began to exhort her to renounce her faith. She told him she was settled in the ancient Catholic religion and meant to spend her blood in its defence, and when he persisted she prayed aloud in Latin and then in English over his voice, for the Church, for her son and for Elizabeth.
The executioner, a man named Bull, and his assistant knelt to ask her forgiveness, which she gave. Her women took off her gown. Beneath it she wore a bodice and petticoat of dark red, which Catholics present understood as the liturgical colour of martyrdom. One of them bound her eyes with a gold-embroidered cloth. She knelt, felt for the block, and repeated in Latin, ‘Into thy hands, O Lord, I commend my spirit.’
The first stroke missed the neck and cut into the back of her head. The second severed it but for a sinew, which Bull cut through with the axe. When he lifted the head to cry ‘God save the Queen’, it fell from his hand, leaving him holding an auburn wig; her own hair was grey and cropped short. The eyewitness report sent to Lord Burghley says her lips moved for a quarter of an hour. The Dean called out, ‘So perish all the Queen’s enemies.’ Only the Earl of Kent answered amen.
A small dog was then found hiding in her skirts; it would not leave the body and had to be carried away and washed. Everything touched by her blood, the block, her clothes, the cloths, was burned so that nothing could be kept as a relic. She was 44.
How it came to this
Mary became queen of Scotland at six days old in 1542, was raised in France, and was briefly its queen consort. Returning as a widow of eighteen to a country that had just turned Protestant, she ruled with some success until her second husband, Lord Darnley, was murdered in 1567 and she married the Earl of Bothwell, the chief suspect, three months later. Her nobles rose, imprisoned her and forced her to abdicate in favour of her infant son, James. She escaped in 1568, lost a battle, and crossed into England to ask Elizabeth for help. Elizabeth kept her in custody for the rest of her life.
The difficulty was that Mary, a great-granddaughter of Henry VII, had the strongest hereditary claim to succeed the childless Elizabeth, and in Catholic eyes a better claim to the throne than Elizabeth herself. She became the focus of every plot: the northern rising of 1569, Ridolfi, Throckmorton. In 1586 Elizabeth’s secretary, Francis Walsingham, opened a channel for Mary’s secret letters, smuggled in beer barrels, and read them all. In July she answered a young Catholic, Anthony Babington, who had written of a plan to free her and kill Elizabeth. That reply was the evidence on which she was tried and condemned in October.