Parallax

8 February, 1587

Mary, Queen of Scots, is beheaded at Fotheringhay

She had been Elizabeth’s prisoner for nearly nineteen years. She came to the scaffold dressed as a queen, stripped to the colour of a martyr, and left her cousin to explain a death that Elizabeth swore she had never intended.

Fotheringhay Castle, Northamptonshire, England

The earls of Shrewsbury and Kent came to Mary Stuart’s rooms on the evening of Tuesday 7 February 1587 and told her she would die at eight the next morning. She thanked them, by the account of her physician, and asked for her own chaplain; it was refused. She spent the night dividing her money and jewels among her servants, making her will, and writing to her former brother-in-law, Henri III of France, that she died for her religion. She lay down for a few hours without sleeping.

The great hall of Fotheringhay held some three hundred spectators and a low platform draped in black. Mary entered in black satin with a long white veil, a crucifix in her hand, and climbed the steps without help. The Dean of Peterborough, Richard Fletcher, began to exhort her to renounce her faith. She told him she was settled in the ancient Catholic religion and meant to spend her blood in its defence, and when he persisted she prayed aloud in Latin and then in English over his voice, for the Church, for her son and for Elizabeth.

The executioner, a man named Bull, and his assistant knelt to ask her forgiveness, which she gave. Her women took off her gown. Beneath it she wore a bodice and petticoat of dark red, which Catholics present understood as the liturgical colour of martyrdom. One of them bound her eyes with a gold-embroidered cloth. She knelt, felt for the block, and repeated in Latin, ‘Into thy hands, O Lord, I commend my spirit.’

The first stroke missed the neck and cut into the back of her head. The second severed it but for a sinew, which Bull cut through with the axe. When he lifted the head to cry ‘God save the Queen’, it fell from his hand, leaving him holding an auburn wig; her own hair was grey and cropped short. The eyewitness report sent to Lord Burghley says her lips moved for a quarter of an hour. The Dean called out, ‘So perish all the Queen’s enemies.’ Only the Earl of Kent answered amen.

A small dog was then found hiding in her skirts; it would not leave the body and had to be carried away and washed. Everything touched by her blood, the block, her clothes, the cloths, was burned so that nothing could be kept as a relic. She was 44.

How it came to this

Mary became queen of Scotland at six days old in 1542, was raised in France, and was briefly its queen consort. Returning as a widow of eighteen to a country that had just turned Protestant, she ruled with some success until her second husband, Lord Darnley, was murdered in 1567 and she married the Earl of Bothwell, the chief suspect, three months later. Her nobles rose, imprisoned her and forced her to abdicate in favour of her infant son, James. She escaped in 1568, lost a battle, and crossed into England to ask Elizabeth for help. Elizabeth kept her in custody for the rest of her life.

The difficulty was that Mary, a great-granddaughter of Henry VII, had the strongest hereditary claim to succeed the childless Elizabeth, and in Catholic eyes a better claim to the throne than Elizabeth herself. She became the focus of every plot: the northern rising of 1569, Ridolfi, Throckmorton. In 1586 Elizabeth’s secretary, Francis Walsingham, opened a channel for Mary’s secret letters, smuggled in beer barrels, and read them all. In July she answered a young Catholic, Anthony Babington, who had written of a plan to free her and kill Elizabeth. That reply was the evidence on which she was tried and condemned in October.

How each side saw it

Mary and Catholic Europe

Mary denied to the end that she had sought Elizabeth’s death, and insisted that as an anointed sovereign of another realm no English court could try her. In her last letter and on the scaffold she presented herself as dying for the Catholic faith alone. That was the version that spread across the Continent within weeks, through the narrative of her physician Dominique Bourgoing and Adam Blackwood’s Martyre de la Royne d’Escosse, printed in 1587. Paris went into mourning and crowds demanded vengeance. Philip II of Spain, already preparing an invasion fleet, now had a martyr to avenge.

Elizabeth

Elizabeth had signed the warrant on 1 February and given it to her secretary William Davison. When told it had been carried out she wept, raged, refused food and declared that she had meant it to be held in reserve. Davison was tried, fined and sent to the Tower; she wrote to James VI calling the death a miserable accident. Yet she had also had her ministers ask Mary’s gaoler, Amias Paulet, to do away with his prisoner quietly, which he refused in writing. Whether her grief was sincere, staged for foreign courts, or both, her contemporaries could not agree.

Burghley, Walsingham and the Protestant Parliament

To the men around Elizabeth, Mary alive was a standing invitation to assassinate their queen and bring in a Catholic ruler under whom they would burn. Both houses of Parliament had petitioned for her execution, and thousands had sworn the Bond of Association to kill anyone in whose name Elizabeth was attacked. The Privy Council sent the warrant north without telling Elizabeth precisely so that she could not recall it. London rang bells and lit bonfires. For this side the trial was lawful, the evidence was plain, and the delay had been the danger.

Scotland and her son

James VI, twenty years old, had not seen his mother since he was ten months old and had been raised by her enemies on George Buchanan’s account of her as an adulteress and murderer. He protested formally, and some Scottish nobles called for war, but he had a pension from Elizabeth and hopes of her throne, and did nothing. Scottish opinion had long been split between Buchanan’s version and that of her defender Bishop John Leslie. As king of England, James moved her body to Westminster Abbey in 1612, to a tomb grander than Elizabeth’s.

What is disputed

The date is Old Style; Catholic Europe, on the new Gregorian calendar, recorded 18 February. Mary’s letter to Babington survives only in a copy made by Walsingham’s decipherer, Thomas Phelippes, who is known to have forged a postscript to it; she claimed the text had been tampered with, and historians divide on how far it proves consent to murder. Older arguments continue over the ‘casket letters’ said to show her part in Darnley’s death, whose originals vanished in 1584. Among modern biographers, John Guy sees a capable ruler destroyed by her enemies and Jenny Wormald a study in political failure. Details of the scaffold scene differ between the Protestant and Catholic eyewitness accounts.

What followed

The Armada sailed the following year and failed. Davison was quietly released and went on drawing his salary. Mary was buried at Peterborough after a delay of nearly six months. In 1603 her son inherited the English throne without opposition, which was the outcome she had wanted for herself, and every British monarch since has been her descendant. The execution of a crowned queen after a form of trial was a precedent that her grandson Charles I met in 1649. She has since been the subject of more plays, novels, operas and films than Elizabeth’s entire council put together.

Read further

  • John Guy, My Heart Is My Own: The Life of Mary Queen of Scots (2004)
  • Antonia Fraser, Mary Queen of Scots (1969)
  • Jenny Wormald, Mary Queen of Scots: A Study in Failure (1988)
  • Conyers Read, Mr Secretary Walsingham and the Policy of Queen Elizabeth (1925)
  • George Buchanan, Ane Detectioun of the Duinges of Marie Quene of Scottes (1571)

Same day, other years

1250

A crusader charge is destroyed in the streets of Mansurah

Mansurah, EgyptAfrica

Louis IX of France had taken the port of Damietta and was marching on Cairo when his army was halted by a canal in front of the fortified town of Mansurah. At dawn on 8 February 1250 a vanguard under his brother, Robert of Artois, crossed by a ford that a local man had revealed for payment, and overran the Egyptian camp, killing its commander. Against orders, Robert then charged into the town itself. In the narrow streets his knights could not manoeuvre; the sultan’s slave-soldiers, the Mamluks, barricaded the exits and killed nearly all of them, including Robert and almost three hundred Templars. Within two months Louis’s starving army had surrendered and the king was a prisoner.

Seen from elsewhere. Arabic historians, notably Ibn Wasil, who was in Egypt at the time, tell it as the victory that made the Mamluks: weeks later they murdered the new sultan and took power, ruling Egypt for over 250 years. The French account, by Louis’s companion Joinville, blames Robert’s rashness and turns the defeated king’s captivity into the making of a saint.

1887

The Dawes Act breaks up Native American reservations

Washington, DC, United StatesThe Americas

President Grover Cleveland signed the General Allotment Act, named for its sponsor, Senator Henry Dawes of Massachusetts. It allowed the government to survey reservations held in common by Native nations, assign each family head a plot of 160 acres, to be held in trust for 25 years, and sell whatever was left over as ‘surplus’ to settlers. Those who took allotments were to become United States citizens. Its backers, many of them eastern reformers, believed that private property would turn Indians into farmers and save them from extinction. When the policy was ended in 1934, Native landholdings had fallen from about 138 million acres to about 48 million.

Seen from elsewhere. Few Native leaders were consulted and most who spoke opposed it; the Five Tribes of Indian Territory, exempted at first, were forced in by a later act. Even in Congress a minority had warned that the true purpose was to open Indian land to settlement. Mismanagement of the trust accounts led to a 3.4 billion dollar legal settlement in 2009.

1904

Japanese torpedo boats attack the Russian fleet at Port Arthur

Port Arthur (Lushun), ChinaAsia

Negotiations between Japan and Russia over who should dominate Korea and Manchuria had dragged on for months, and Tokyo broke off diplomatic relations on 6 February. Two nights later, without a declaration of war, destroyers sent by Admiral Togo Heihachiro slipped into the outer anchorage of Russia’s leased naval base at Port Arthur and torpedoed two battleships and a cruiser as they lay with lights showing. The declaration followed on 10 February. Over the next nineteen months Japan took Port Arthur after a murderous siege, defeated the Russian army at Mukden and sank the Baltic Fleet at Tsushima, the first modern defeat of a European great power by an Asian state.

Seen from elsewhere. Russia called the attack treachery; Japan held that the rupture of relations was warning enough, and much of the British and American press agreed. The war was fought on Chinese and Korean soil, with neither people asked. Korea became a Japanese protectorate in 1905 and a colony in 1910, even as nationalists from India to Egypt took heart from Japan’s victory.

1963

Baathist officers overthrow Qasim in Baghdad

Baghdad, IraqMiddle East

Brigadier Abd al-Karim Qasim had ruled Iraq since leading the 1958 coup that killed the royal family. On the morning of 8 February 1963, the fourteenth day of Ramadan, army units allied with the Baath party and Arab nationalist officers assassinated the air force chief and bombed the Ministry of Defence, where Qasim held out for a day while supporters from Baghdad’s poor districts fought tanks in the streets. He surrendered on the 9th, was given a hearing lasting minutes, and was shot in a studio of the broadcasting station; his body was displayed on television. In the following weeks the Baath party’s militia hunted down communists, killing them in numbers put between 1,500 and 5,000.

Seen from elsewhere. The plotters said they had removed a dictator who cut Iraq off from Arab unity. To many of the urban poor Qasim was the ruler who had built them houses. Iraqi communists and some historians allege that the CIA encouraged the coup and supplied names; American officials denied it, and the surviving evidence is contested.

Also on 8 February