Parallax

14 February, 1400

Richard II dies in Pontefract Castle

A deposed king was an impossible prisoner. Within weeks of a failed rising in his name, Richard was dead at thirty-three, and his successor had the corpse carried to London with its face uncovered so that everyone could see.

Pontefract Castle, Yorkshire, England

Some time in the middle of February 1400, in a chamber of the great Lancastrian fortress at Pontefract, Richard of Bordeaux, until five months earlier King of England, died. Nobody who was present left an account. The date usually given, 14 February, comes from chroniclers; what is certain is that by the 17th the government in London knew he was dead and was paying for his body to be brought south.

He had been moved north in secret the previous October, disguised by one account as a forester, and passed from castle to castle before reaching Pontefract, where his keepers were Sir Thomas Swynford, stepson of the new king’s father, and Robert Waterton, both Lancastrian servants of long standing. Parliament had ordered that he be kept for life in a place unknown to the public, with no one of his former household about him.

What made that sentence unworkable was the Epiphany Rising. In the first days of January 1400 a group of Richard’s closest friends, the earls of Kent, Huntingdon and Salisbury and Lord Despenser, plotted to seize Henry IV and his sons during a tournament at Windsor and restore the old king. A priest who resembled Richard was to impersonate him until the real one could be freed. The plot was betrayed. Henry rode for London; the rebels fled west and were caught and beheaded by townspeople at Cirencester, Bristol and in Essex without waiting for any trial.

A minute of the royal council from early February survives. It advises that if Richard is alive he should be kept securely, and that if he is dead his body should be shown openly to the people. The wording has seemed to many historians a hint as much as a recommendation.

The body came south on a bier, the face exposed from the forehead to the throat and the rest wrapped in lead. It lay for two days in St Paul’s, where Henry attended the requiem and thousands filed past. Then, instead of the tomb at Westminster that Richard had built for himself beside his first wife, Anne of Bohemia, it was taken by night to the Dominican friary at King’s Langley in Hertfordshire and buried with little ceremony. The official story was that the former king, hearing that his friends had failed and died, had refused to eat.

How it came to this

Richard had come to the throne in 1377 at the age of ten and at fourteen faced the rebels of the Peasants’ Revolt at Smithfield. He grew into a king with an exalted idea of his office, a patron of Chaucer and of the Wilton Diptych, impatient of the great nobles who expected to counsel him. In 1387-88 a group of them, the Lords Appellant, defeated his friends in battle and had several executed. He waited nine years. In 1397 he arrested the three senior Appellants: one was murdered in custody at Calais, one beheaded, one exiled. The following year he banished the two younger ones, among them his cousin Henry Bolingbroke, heir to the vast duchy of Lancaster.

When Henry’s father, John of Gaunt, died in February 1399, Richard extended the exile to life and took the Lancastrian estates into his own hands. No landowner in England could feel safe after that. In the summer he sailed to Ireland with his army. Henry landed in Yorkshire with a handful of men, saying he came only for his inheritance, and the country went over to him. Richard returned to find his support gone, surrendered in north Wales in August, and on 30 September was declared deposed in a parliament that then accepted Henry’s claim to the throne.

How each side saw it

The Lancastrian account

Henry IV’s government maintained that Richard had resigned the crown willingly and cheerfully, and entered on the parliament roll a list of thirty-three charges of misrule. Of the death, the St Albans chronicler Thomas Walsingham, well disposed to the new regime, reports that Richard starved himself out of grief, and adds that when he was at last persuaded to eat, his throat had closed. The public display of the body was meant to answer two questions at once: that he was truly dead, and that there were no wounds on him. Nobody was ever charged.

Richard’s partisans and the French court

Richard’s queen was Isabella, the ten-year-old daughter of Charles VI of France, and French writers took his side. Jean Creton, a valet who had travelled with Richard in 1399, wrote a verse history of his betrayal. The anonymous Chronicque de la Traison et Mort says that a knight called Sir Piers Exton came to Pontefract with seven men and cut the king down after he had killed four of them. Shakespeare took the story from there. In England the Percy family, who had helped Henry to the throne and rebelled in 1403, accused him in their manifesto of starving Richard to death over fifteen days.

Those who said he was alive

Many refused to believe the body was his. From 1402 a man kept at the Scottish court was said to be King Richard, escaped from Pontefract and found in the kitchens of the Lord of the Isles. The Scottish government maintained him until he died at Stirling in 1419, and he was buried there as a king. English officials said he was an impostor named Thomas Ward of Trumpington. Friars were hanged for preaching that Richard lived, and conspiracies in his name troubled Henry IV and Henry V for nearly twenty years.

Modern historians

Few now doubt that Richard was killed, or left to die, on Henry’s orders or with his knowledge, and that deliberate starvation, which leaves no mark, is the likeliest method. They disagree about the king himself. Victorian writers saw a tyrant justly removed; a mid-twentieth-century biography by Anthony Steel thought him mentally ill, a view now discounted. Nigel Saul describes a narcissistic ruler obsessed with obedience. Others stress that the deposition of an anointed king by force was the true novelty of 1399, whatever Richard’s faults, and that it left his successors’ title permanently open to challenge.

What is disputed

The date is conventional; some chroniclers imply a slightly different day, and the firm evidence shows only that he was dead by 17 February. The cause is unknown. The Exton story is doubted because no such knight can be traced and because when the tomb was opened in 1871 the skull attributed to Richard showed no blows, though the identification of the bones is not beyond question. Whether he starved himself, was starved, or was smothered cannot be settled. The claim that he escaped to Scotland has had modern defenders but is rejected by most scholars.

What followed

Henry V, who had been fond of Richard as a boy, had the body moved to Westminster Abbey in 1413 and laid in the tomb with Anne, partly as an act of atonement and partly to end the rumours. It did not end the larger problem. Henry IV’s reign was a sequence of revolts, and in the 1450s the house of York claimed the crown on the ground that the Lancastrians had taken it unlawfully in 1399. The Wars of the Roses were fought over that argument. Shakespeare’s play made Richard’s fall the starting point of a century of English civil strife.

Read further

  • Nigel Saul, Richard II (1997)
  • Chris Given-Wilson (ed.), Chronicles of the Revolution, 1397-1400: The Reign of Richard II (1993)
  • Chris Given-Wilson, Henry IV (2016)
  • Ian Mortimer, The Fears of Henry IV (2007)
  • Helen Castor, The Eagle and the Hart: The Tragedy of Richard II and Henry IV (2024)

Same day, other years

1349

The Jews of Strasbourg are burned

Strasbourg, Holy Roman EmpireEurope

The plague had not yet reached Strasbourg, but the rumour that ran ahead of it had: that Jews were poisoning the wells. Confessions to that effect had been extracted by torture in Savoy the previous autumn and sent from town to town. Strasbourg’s council, led by Peter Swarber, refused to act without proof and protected the community. On 9 and 10 February the craft guilds and a party of nobles overthrew the council. On Saturday 14 February, St Valentine’s Day, the city’s Jews were led to their own cemetery and burned on a wooden platform. Those who accepted baptism were spared, and children were taken from the fire and baptised. The city chroniclers put the dead at about two thousand.

Seen from elsewhere. Pope Clement VI had declared the poisoning charge false, noting that Jews were dying of plague like everyone else. The Strasbourg chronicler Jakob Twinger gave his own explanation: debts to Jews were cancelled and their goods divided, and had they been poor they would not have been burned. Modern estimates of the dead are lower, in the hundreds or more.

1556

A thirteen-year-old Akbar is enthroned in a garden

Kalanaur, PunjabAsia

The Mughal emperor Humayun had recovered Delhi only six months before he fell down the stone steps of his library and died. His heir, Jalal-ud-din Muhammad Akbar, was thirteen and away in the Punjab on campaign with his guardian, the general Bairam Khan. The death was concealed for more than two weeks, with a double shown at a palace window, while messengers rode north. On 14 February 1556 Bairam Khan had the boy proclaimed emperor on a brick platform put up in a garden at Kalanaur. The inheritance was a few insecure cities. Akbar ruled for forty-nine years and left an empire stretching from Kabul to Bengal and the Deccan, with a court where Hindu, Muslim, Jain and Jesuit debated before him.

Seen from elsewhere. The throne was nearly lost at once. The Hindu general Hemu took Delhi that October and had himself crowned, before an arrow struck him at Panipat. Court historians disagree on whether the boy Akbar beheaded the wounded prisoner himself or refused and left it to Bairam Khan. In India today both men are claimed as heroes.

1779

Captain Cook is killed at Kealakekua Bay

Hawai’i IslandOceania

James Cook had spent a month at Kealakekua Bay, received with great ceremony by priests and chiefs during the season of the god Lono. He sailed on 4 February, broke a foremast in a storm and returned a week later to a cooler welcome. Thefts and quarrels multiplied. When a ship’s cutter was taken in the night, Cook went ashore on the morning of 14 February with a party of marines to bring the ruling chief, Kalani’opu’u, on board as a hostage, a method he had used elsewhere in the Pacific. A crowd of several thousand gathered. News came that a chief had been shot across the bay. Cook fired, was struck from behind and stabbed at the water’s edge. Four marines and at least seventeen Hawaiians also died.

Seen from elsewhere. Whether Hawaiians took Cook for Lono is a celebrated quarrel: Marshall Sahlins argued they did, Gananath Obeyesekere that the god-captain is a European myth. Nineteenth-century Hawaiian historians such as Samuel Kamakau recorded the reverence and also the charge that still matters most to many Hawaiians, that his ships brought the diseases that devastated the islands.

1989

Khomeini calls for the death of Salman Rushdie

Tehran, IranMiddle East

A statement from Ayatollah Khomeini, read on Tehran radio, informed ‘the proud Muslim people of the world’ that the author of The Satanic Verses and all those knowingly involved in its publication were sentenced to death. The novel, published in London the previous September, includes dream sequences drawing on the life of the Prophet. It had been banned in India, burned in Bradford and protested in Islamabad, where police shot several demonstrators two days before the edict. Rushdie, a British citizen born in Bombay, went into hiding under police guard for most of a decade. His Japanese translator was murdered in 1991; his Italian translator and Norwegian publisher were attacked and survived. In 2022 Rushdie was stabbed on a stage in New York State and lost an eye.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Muslims who found the book a deliberate insult to what they hold sacred wanted it withdrawn, not its author killed, and a number of Muslim jurists held the edict invalid without a trial. Others read it as politics, issued months after Iran’s costly ceasefire with Iraq. Iran’s government distanced itself in 1998; the edict was never revoked.

Also on 14 February