Parallax

12 February, 1554

Lady Jane Grey is beheaded in the Tower

She had been proclaimed queen at sixteen, deposed nine days later and kept alive for seven months. Then her father joined a rebellion, and Mary I decided she could no longer afford a living rival.

Tower of London, England

On the morning of Monday 12 February 1554, Lady Jane Dudley, born Grey, stood at a window in the house of the Tower’s gentleman gaoler and watched her husband go to his death. Guildford Dudley, about nineteen, was led out to the public scaffold on Tower Hill at around ten o’clock. He had asked to see her the night before. By one account she refused, saying it would only add to their grief and they would meet soon enough elsewhere. A little later she saw the cart come back through the gate with his body, the head wrapped in a cloth.

Her own scaffold had been built inside the walls, on the green by the White Tower, a privacy granted to royal blood. She walked to it in black, reading from a small prayer book, with two gentlewomen who wept and with John Feckenham, the Benedictine whom Queen Mary had sent to convert her. The execution had been put back three days to give him the chance. He had failed, after a formal disputation on the sacraments that Jane wrote up herself, but she had come to like him and let him stay with her to the end.

From the scaffold she spoke briefly. The anonymous Tower resident who wrote the Chronicle of Queen Jane records that she admitted the act against the queen had been unlawful, and her consent to it, but said of the seeking of it, ‘I do wash my hands thereof in innocency before God and the face of you, good Christian people.’ She asked them to witness that she died a true Christian woman who looked to be saved by the mercy of God in the merits of Christ alone, a Protestant formula spoken in a Catholic queen’s fortress. Then she knelt and recited the fifty-first psalm in English.

She gave her gloves and handkerchief to her attendant and her prayer book to the lieutenant’s brother; it survives in the British Library, with her farewell written in the margins. She untied her own gown and refused the executioner’s help. He knelt for her forgiveness, and she asked him to dispatch her quickly. Having tied the blindfold herself, she could not find the block. ‘What shall I do? Where is it?’ she said, groping, until a bystander guided her hands. Her last words were those of Christ in Luke’s gospel: ‘Lord, into thy hands I commend my spirit.’

She was buried without ceremony in the chapel of St Peter ad Vincula, a few yards away, near two other beheaded queens, Anne Boleyn and Catherine Howard. Her father followed her to the block eleven days later.

How it came to this

Jane was a great-granddaughter of Henry VII through her mother Frances Brandon, and one of the best-educated girls in England, reading Greek and corresponding in Latin with reformers in Zurich. In the spring of 1553 the fifteen-year-old Edward VI was dying. A convinced Protestant, he would not leave the crown to his Catholic half-sister Mary, and in a document in his own hand he set aside both Mary and Elizabeth as illegitimate and named Jane. She had just been married to Guildford, a son of John Dudley, Duke of Northumberland, who ran Edward’s government.

Edward died on 6 July. Jane was proclaimed on the 10th and lodged in the Tower. Mary, in East Anglia, refused to submit, and gentry and commons came in to her by the thousand. Northumberland marched against her; behind his back the council in London changed sides and proclaimed Mary on 19 July. Northumberland was executed that August. Jane and Guildford were tried for treason in November, pleaded guilty and were sentenced, but Mary let it be known she meant to spare her. Then, in January 1554, Sir Thomas Wyatt raised Kent against the queen’s planned marriage to Philip of Spain, and Jane’s father rode out to raise the Midlands.

How each side saw it

Mary I and her council

Mary had resisted the executions for months, telling the Imperial ambassador that her conscience would not let her kill a girl who had been used by others. Wyatt’s rising changed the calculation. His men had reached the gates of London, and Jane’s own father had been among the rebels. The ambassador, Simon Renard, whose dispatches are the main source for the queen’s thinking, pressed her that Philip could not safely come to England while claimants lived, and Bishop Gardiner preached that mercy to a few endangered the whole commonwealth. To the council, the death warrant was the lawful consequence of a sentence already passed.

Jane in her own words

Jane’s surviving writings do not sound like a passive victim. A letter to the queen, known through Italian versions, says she accepted a crown she never sought and was deceived by Northumberland. But her letter to Thomas Harding, a former family chaplain who returned to Catholicism, calls him a ‘deformed imp of the devil’, and her account of the debate with Feckenham concedes nothing. On the eve of death she wrote to her sister Katherine in the back of a Greek New Testament, urging her to ‘live still to die’. She saw herself as dying for true religion as much as for treason.

The Protestant tradition

Within months her speech and letters were printed, and John Foxe placed her in his Acts and Monuments among the martyrs of Mary’s reign, although she was executed for treason and not for heresy. For Elizabethan and later Protestants she was the learned, godly maiden destroyed by popery and ambition. The nineteenth century softened this into a helpless innocent, the blindfolded girl in white of Paul Delaroche’s painting of 1833. That picture, with its dungeon and straw, has fixed the popular image, though the real event took place outdoors and she wore black.

Historians on who was the usurper

The traditional view, shaped by Mary’s victory, makes Northumberland a schemer who married his son to a puppet queen. Many historians now think the plan was Edward’s own, driven by religion, with Northumberland carrying out his king’s will. Eric Ives went further and argued that Jane was the legal heir under a valid royal settlement and that Mary, strictly, was the rebel who won. Others reply that Henry VIII’s succession act of 1544, which named Mary, was statute and that a minor’s unconfirmed will could not override it. Leanda de Lisle stresses how actively Jane embraced her role.

What is disputed

Her age is uncertain: the traditional birth date of October 1537 has no good evidence, and recent work puts it in 1536 or early 1537, making her sixteen or seventeen. No portrait is accepted by all specialists as showing her. The much-quoted description of a small, freckled, red-haired girl at her proclamation comes from a letter that Leanda de Lisle traced to a 1909 book and showed to be invented. The tale that her parents beat her into the marriage comes from later hostile sources. Popular accounts sometimes have Northumberland die on the same day; he had been dead six months.

What followed

Wyatt was executed in April and the Princess Elizabeth, suspected of complicity, spent two months in the Tower. Mary married Philip that July and from 1555 her government burned some 280 Protestants, which did more than anything to turn Jane into a martyr. Mary died childless in 1558 and Elizabeth undid her settlement. Jane’s younger sisters, Katherine and Mary, inherited her claim and paid for it: both made secret marriages and both were imprisoned by Elizabeth. No English monarch has had a shorter reign, and whether Jane was ever lawfully queen is still an open question.

Read further

  • Eric Ives, Lady Jane Grey: A Tudor Mystery (2009)
  • Leanda de Lisle, The Sisters Who Would Be Queen (2008)
  • J. G. Nichols (ed.), The Chronicle of Queen Jane and of Two Years of Queen Mary (1850)
  • John Foxe, Acts and Monuments (1563)
  • Nicola Tallis, Crown of Blood: The Deadly Inheritance of Lady Jane Grey (2016)

Same day, other years

1502

Castile orders its Muslims to convert or leave

Seville, CastileEurope

When Granada surrendered to Ferdinand and Isabella in 1492, the treaty promised its Muslims their mosques, law and customs for ever. Within eight years Archbishop Cisneros was conducting mass baptisms and burning Arabic books in the city, and the resulting revolts in Granada and the Alpujarra mountains were put down by force. The crown held that rebellion had cancelled the treaty. A decree dated 12 February 1502 extended the choice to every Muslim in the kingdom of Castile, including communities that had lived peacefully under Christian rule for centuries: baptism or exile by the end of April. The conditions set for leaving were so restrictive that almost all stayed and were baptised.

Seen from elsewhere. The converts, called Moriscos, left few records of their own, but a legal opinion sent from Oran in 1504 told them how to remain Muslims in secret, praying inwardly and eating pork under protest. Secret texts in Spanish written with Arabic letters survive. A century of suspicion ended with their expulsion in 1609-14.

1818

Chile proclaims its independence

Santiago, ChileThe Americas

On 12 February 1817 an army that Jose de San Martin had led over the high passes of the Andes from Mendoza came down on the Spanish forces at Chacabuco, north of Santiago, and routed them, with the Chilean Bernardo O’Higgins leading the decisive charge. Exactly a year later, with O’Higgins now Supreme Director and a royalist army advancing again from the south, the act of independence was proclaimed and sworn in the main square of Santiago and in other towns. The date was chosen for the anniversary. Santiago itself had been founded by Pedro de Valdivia on the same day in 1541. Victory at Maipu that April made the declaration good.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Chileans fought for the king, above all in the south, where the war went on for years. Most Mapuche leaders also sided with Spain, which had recognised their frontier on the Biobio river by treaty. Their caution was justified: the republic invaded and annexed their territory between the 1860s and 1880s.

1909

A call goes out that founds the NAACP

New York, United StatesThe Americas

In August 1908 a white mob in Springfield, Illinois, Abraham Lincoln’s home town, spent two days burning Black homes and businesses and lynched two men. The shock, in the North, moved a small group of white reformers in New York to act. On the centenary of Lincoln’s birth, 12 February 1909, they published a call, drafted by the newspaper owner Oswald Garrison Villard, for a national conference on the denial of rights to Black Americans. Its sixty signatories included W. E. B. Du Bois, Ida B. Wells and Mary Church Terrell. The body that grew from it took the name National Association for the Advancement of Colored People in 1910 and made the courts its main battleground.

Seen from elsewhere. Booker T. Washington, the most powerful Black leader of the day, held that agitation for political rights would provoke white reaction and stayed away. Ida B. Wells found herself left off the first governing committee and complained that white patrons ran the organisation; Du Bois was for years its only Black officer.

1912

The last emperor of China abdicates

Beijing, ChinaAsia

The edict was issued in the name of a six-year-old. Puyi, the Xuantong emperor, knew nothing of it; his adoptive mother, the Empress Dowager Longyu, signed for him after weeks of pressure from the general Yuan Shikai, who had been negotiating with the revolutionaries while commanding the dynasty’s armies. An army mutiny at Wuchang the previous October had set off the secession of most provinces. The edict transferred sovereignty to the people and declared a republic, ending 268 years of Qing rule and an imperial system more than two thousand years old. In return the boy kept his title, the Forbidden City and a large annual subsidy. Sun Yat-sen resigned the provisional presidency in Yuan’s favour.

Seen from elsewhere. The edict spoke of a republic uniting Manchus, Han, Mongols, Muslims and Tibetans, and Chinese governments have since read it as passing on the whole Qing empire. Mongol and Tibetan leaders argued that their allegiance had been to the Manchu house and ended with it. For Manchus the revolution brought massacres in several garrison cities.

Also on 12 February