Parallax

13 February, 1945

The firestorm at Dresden

On Shrove Tuesday, twelve weeks before the end of the war in Europe, nearly 800 British bombers set the centre of a baroque city alight. Whether it was a legitimate act of war has been disputed since before the ruins had cooled.

Dresden, Saxony, Germany

Tuesday 13 February 1945 was the last day of carnival, and in Dresden children had gone about in fancy dress. The city, capital of Saxony and famous for its domes and galleries on the Elbe, had been bombed only lightly in five and a half years of war, and many of its people had persuaded themselves that it would be spared. Its anti-aircraft guns had been sent east. Its population of some 630,000 was swollen by refugees from Silesia, fleeing the Red Army, which stood about seventy miles away.

The sirens went at about a quarter to ten. At 10.13 pm the first of 244 Lancasters of the Royal Air Force’s No. 5 Group began bombing on red markers dropped over a sports stadium just west of the old town. The plan laid a fan-shaped pattern of high explosive and incendiaries across the medieval and baroque centre, the explosive to blow in roofs and windows, the fire bombs to catch in the timber beneath. It took about fifteen minutes.

Three hours later, when fire crews from the region were in the streets and survivors were coming up from cellars, a second force of more than 500 Lancasters arrived. The crews could see the glow from a great distance and needed no markers. They bombed around and into the fire. The blazes merged into a firestorm, a single furnace that drew in air at ground level with the force of a gale, pulling people off their feet and suffocating thousands in shelters as it consumed the oxygen. Asphalt melted. Many who had fled to the open space of the Grosser Garten park were caught there by the second attack.

At noon on Ash Wednesday 316 American B-17s bombed through smoke and cloud, aiming for the railway yards, and more came the following day. On the morning of the 15th the sandstone dome of the Frauenkirche, which had stood through the fire, cracked as it cooled and fell in.

Some 1,600 acres of the inner city were burned out. For weeks the dead were dug out of cellars and laid in rows for identification. When the numbers overwhelmed the cemeteries, the authorities cordoned off the Altmarkt, built grates from steel shutters and girders, and burned nearly seven thousand bodies there on pyres. Among those who lived was a group of American prisoners of war quartered in a slaughterhouse, one of them a private named Kurt Vonnegut, who were put to work carrying out the corpses.

How it came to this

Britain had turned to bombing whole cities by night in 1942, after finding that its crews could not hit precise targets in the dark. Under Air Marshal Sir Arthur Harris, Bomber Command set out to destroy Germany’s industrial towns and the housing and morale of their workers. Hamburg in 1943 had shown what a firestorm could do. The policy had the backing of the War Cabinet, and it followed German raids on Warsaw, Rotterdam, London and Coventry. By early 1945 most large German cities were in ruins and Dresden was among the few left on the list.

In January 1945 the Soviet winter offensive reached the Oder. British planners proposed heavy attacks on cities behind the eastern front, Berlin, Leipzig, Chemnitz and Dresden, to block the movement of German reinforcements and add to the confusion of the refugee columns; Churchill pressed for it before meeting Stalin at Yalta. Dresden was a rail junction and garrison town and had more than a hundred factories working for the war, making optical instruments, fuses and aircraft parts, many of them in the suburbs that the night raids largely missed.

How each side saw it

Bomber Command and its crews

To the men who flew it, Dresden was one long trip among many, briefed as an attack on a transport and communications centre in support of the Russians. Harris never apologised. Weeks afterwards he wrote that he did not regard all the remaining cities of Germany as worth the bones of one British grenadier, and that the feeling about Dresden could be explained by any psychiatrist: it was connected with German bands and Dresden shepherdesses. His crews had lost more than 55,000 dead in the war, and veterans resented being treated, as they saw it, as an embarrassment once victory was won.

The people of Dresden

Survivors’ accounts, collected by the Dresden historian Gotz Bergander, himself a schoolboy in the city that night, and by many others since, describe the heat, the burning phosphorescent air, shoes sticking in tar, the shrunken bodies in the cellars. For most it was an undefended city of women, children, the old and the displaced, attacked when the war was plainly lost. Many insisted they had been machine-gunned by low-flying fighters on the Elbe meadows the next day. Bergander’s research, and later a commission of historians, found no evidence in flight records or on the ground that this happened.

Victor Klemperer and the city’s last Jews

Victor Klemperer, a dismissed professor of French literature, was one of fewer than two hundred Jews still living in Dresden, protected until then by marriage to a non-Jewish wife. On the morning of 13 February he had been made to help deliver notices ordering most of the others to report for deportation three days later. His diary records that in the chaos of the night his wife Eva cut the yellow star from his coat with a pocket knife, and the two walked out of the city as bombed-out Germans. For him the raid that killed his neighbours was also what saved his life.

German memory, east and west

Goebbels’s ministry was first to give the raid a meaning, leaking a death toll in the hundreds of thousands to the neutral press. The East German state took up the theme, commemorating each anniversary as the crime of Anglo-American imperialists against a city of culture. Since reunification the far right has marched in Dresden on 13 February, some calling the raid a bombing holocaust, and citizens have answered by forming human chains around the old town. The rebuilt Frauenkirche, completed in 2005, carries a cross made by a London goldsmith whose father flew in the raid.

What is disputed

The death toll is the oldest argument. A commission of historians appointed by the city reported in 2010 that between 22,700 and 25,000 people were killed, close to the police count of March 1945. Nazi propaganda had added a nought to that figure. David Irving’s 1963 book gave 135,000, and far higher numbers still circulate; an English court in 2000 found his handling of the evidence dishonest. Legality and morality are separate disputes. Frederick Taylor argues Dresden was a functioning military and industrial target by the standards of the time. A. C. Grayling and the German writer Jorg Friedrich hold that area bombing of civilians was a crime wherever it fell.

What followed

An Allied press briefing days later spoke of deliberate terror bombing, and the report caused alarm in London and Washington. On 28 March Churchill, who had urged the raids, drafted a minute saying that bombing German cities ‘simply for the sake of increasing the terror’ should be reviewed; the air staff protested and he withdrew it for a milder text. Harris alone among the senior commanders received no peerage after the war. Dresden became shorthand for the bombing of civilians, cited in arguments from Hiroshima to Vietnam, and through Vonnegut’s Slaughterhouse-Five, published in 1969, it entered world literature.

Read further

  • Frederick Taylor, Dresden: Tuesday 13 February 1945 (2004)
  • Paul Addison and Jeremy A. Crang (eds), Firestorm: The Bombing of Dresden, 1945 (2006)
  • Richard Overy, The Bombing War: Europe 1939-1945 (2013)
  • Victor Klemperer, To the Bitter End: The Diaries of Victor Klemperer, 1942-1945, translated by Martin Chalmers (1999)
  • Gotz Bergander, Dresden im Luftkrieg (1977)

Same day, other years

1692

Soldiers kill their hosts at Glencoe

Glencoe, ScotlandEurope

The Highland chiefs who had fought for the exiled James II were given until 1 January 1692 to swear allegiance to William III. Alasdair MacIain, the elderly chief of the MacDonalds of Glencoe, went to the wrong official, was delayed by snow, and took the oath five days late. The Scottish secretary in London, Sir John Dalrymple, saw a chance to make an example. At the start of February about 120 soldiers of the Earl of Argyll’s regiment were billeted on the people of the glen and lived with them for nearly two weeks. At five in the morning on 13 February they turned on them. MacIain was shot getting out of bed. About thirty-eight people were killed, and more died in the snow.

Seen from elsewhere. A Scottish parliamentary inquiry in 1695 called it murder under trust and blamed Dalrymple, who lost office; no one was tried, and the king who signed the order was cleared. Popular memory makes it a Campbell crime against MacDonalds. Historians point out that it was a government operation, and that many of the soldiers were not Campbells.

1960

France explodes its first atomic bomb in the Sahara

Reggane, AlgeriaAfrica

At four minutes past seven in the morning a plutonium device on a steel tower was detonated in the desert south of Reggane, in what was then French Algeria. Code-named Gerboise Bleue after a desert rodent and the first colour of the tricolour, it yielded about seventy kilotons, several times the power of the Hiroshima bomb and by far the largest first test of any nuclear state. President de Gaulle cabled his congratulations: ‘Hurrah for France!’ The explosion made France the fourth nuclear power and gave de Gaulle the independent deterrent he wanted. Three more atmospheric tests followed at Reggane, then thirteen underground in the Hoggar mountains, the last in 1966, four years after Algerian independence.

Seen from elsewhere. The test took place in the middle of Algeria’s war of independence, and the nationalist provisional government denounced it. Newly independent African states protested; Ghana froze French assets. People of the oases and French conscripts were exposed to fallout that drifted far beyond the announced zone. A French compensation law of 2010 has paid very few Algerian claimants.

1991

American bombs hit the Amiriyah shelter in Baghdad

Baghdad, IraqMiddle East

In the fourth week of the air war over Iraq, two American stealth aircraft each dropped a 2,000-pound laser-guided bomb on a concrete building in the Amiriyah district of western Baghdad at about half past four in the morning. The first cut through ten feet of reinforced roof; the second followed it in. The building was a public air-raid shelter, and that night it was full of families from the neighbourhood, mostly women and children. More than four hundred people were killed, many by fire. American commanders said that the building had been converted into a military command post, that they had intercepted signals from it, and that they had not known civilians slept there.

Seen from elsewhere. Iraqis pointed out that the shelter was signposted and that people had used it nightly for weeks. Human Rights Watch concluded that the United States had not taken the precautions the laws of war require before attacking. The strike led Washington to restrict further bombing of central Baghdad. The gutted shelter was kept as a memorial.

2008

Australia apologises to the Stolen Generations

Canberra, AustraliaOceania

As the first business of a new parliament, Prime Minister Kevin Rudd rose in the House of Representatives and apologised on behalf of the nation to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, and in particular to those taken from their families as children. From the early twentieth century until about 1970, state and federal authorities and church missions had removed Indigenous children, especially those of mixed descent, to institutions and white foster homes, with the stated aim of absorbing them into white society. A national inquiry in 1997 estimated that between one in ten and one in three Indigenous children were taken in those decades. Rudd said sorry three times. Crowds watched on screens across the country, many in tears.

Seen from elsewhere. The previous prime minister, John Howard, had refused for a decade, arguing that the present generation should not accept guilt for past policies; a few opposition members stayed away. The apology carried no compensation, which was left to the states. Indigenous critics note that more of their children are in state care now than then.

Also on 13 February