Parallax

18 February, 1478

The king’s brother dies in the Tower, perhaps in a butt of wine

Edward IV had his own brother condemned for treason and put to death in private. Within five years people across Europe were saying the Duke of Clarence had been drowned in a barrel of malmsey.

Tower of London, England

George, Duke of Clarence, was 28 when he died, the middle one of three royal brothers. Edward IV, the eldest, had been king since 1461. Richard, Duke of Gloucester, the youngest, would be king in 1483. George had been arrested in June 1477 after bursting into a council meeting at Westminster to protest at the execution of one of his retainers, and he had been in the Tower ever since.

In January 1478 a parliament met, and the king himself brought the charge. The surviving act of attainder accuses Clarence of spreading the story that Edward was a bastard with no right to the throne, of saying the king worked by necromancy and poisoned his subjects, of keeping a document from 1470 that named him heir to the Lancastrian line, and of preparing a new rebellion. The chronicler of Crowland Abbey, who was probably present, wrote that nobody spoke against the duke except the king and nobody answered the king except the duke. Clarence denied everything and offered to prove his innocence in single combat. Parliament found him guilty.

The Duke of Buckingham, appointed steward of England for the occasion, pronounced sentence of death on 7 February. Then nothing happened for more than a week. Edward seems to have hesitated, and the Speaker of the Commons had to come to the Lords and ask that the matter be brought to an end.

On 18 February it was. There was no scaffold and no crowd. The Crowland writer says only that the execution, whatever its manner, was carried out secretly in the Tower. But the Italian visitor Dominic Mancini, writing in 1483, says the duke was plunged into a jar of sweet wine, and the Burgundian-born memoirist Philippe de Commynes and several London chronicles say the same, naming malmsey, the heavy sweet wine shipped from Greece. A butt was a cask holding more than a hundred gallons.

Edward paid for a grand funeral and for his brother’s debts. Clarence was buried beside his wife Isabel in Tewkesbury Abbey, where a vault still holds bones said to be theirs. His small son and daughter were left as royal wards, with a claim to the throne that would be fatal to both. He had been one of the richest men in England, and his lands passed into the king’s hands.

How it came to this

Clarence had betrayed his brother before. In 1469 he married Isabel Neville, daughter of the Earl of Warwick, against the king’s wishes, and joined Warwick in a revolt that briefly made Edward a prisoner. In 1470 the two of them went over to the exiled Lancastrians and drove Edward out of England. Clarence changed sides again just in time for Edward’s return in 1471, was forgiven, and then quarrelled bitterly with Richard over the vast Warwick inheritance.

Isabel died after childbirth in December 1476. Clarence, apparently convinced she had been poisoned, had one of her former attendants, Ankarette Twynyho, seized, dragged to Warwick, tried and hanged within a day, an abuse of justice that shocked contemporaries. Edward blocked his hopes of marrying the heiress of Burgundy. Then in May 1477 an Oxford astronomer and a member of Clarence’s household, Thomas Burdet, were convicted of using sorcery to forecast the king’s death. Burdet was hanged, and Clarence’s public protest gave Edward his occasion.

How each side saw it

Edward IV and his government

The act of attainder is the king’s own statement of the case. It rehearses how often he had pardoned his brother and loaded him with lands, and says that Clarence had answered with a plot worse than any before, aimed at the king, the queen and their children. It presents the trial as a painful duty forced on a ruler by the safety of the realm. Read from this side, a man who had already helped depose Edward once, and who was telling people the king was illegitimate, had made himself impossible to leave alive.

Clarence

No defence in his own words survives beyond the bare report that he denied the charges and asked for trial by battle. He was allowed no counsel, and the witnesses, according to the Crowland chronicler, behaved more like accusers. His conduct in 1477 suggests a man who believed his wife and his servant had been judicially murdered and that the court was closing in on him. The later tale that he chose the manner of his own death, as a favour from his brother, cannot be traced to anyone who was in a position to know.

Those who blamed the queen’s family, or Richard

Mancini, gathering London gossip in 1483, reported that Queen Elizabeth Woodville feared her children would never reign while Clarence lived, and that Richard was overcome with grief and blamed her kin. Tudor writers turned the story round. Thomas More says some thought Richard privately welcomed the death, though he opposed it openly, and Shakespeare made him the murderer outright, with a prophecy that ‘G’ would disinherit Edward’s heirs. The contemporary record shows Richard receiving grants in the days around the execution, but nothing to show that he sought it.

What is disputed

The malmsey is the heart of the dispute. It is reported by several independent writers within a few years, which is why historians such as Charles Ross and Michael Hicks have been unwilling to dismiss it, yet no official record states how he died. Some suggest a garbled memory of a body moved in a cask, or a joke about a hard drinker. A portrait once thought to show Clarence’s daughter Margaret wearing a tiny barrel as a charm is no longer securely identified. Motive is argued too: Hicks sees a show trial on thin evidence; others think Clarence may have known of doubts about the validity of Edward’s marriage.

What followed

The attainder barred Clarence’s children from the succession, which mattered in 1483 when Richard set aside Edward’s sons and took the crown himself, passing over his dead brother’s boy. Henry VII kept that boy, Edward, Earl of Warwick, in the Tower from the age of ten and beheaded him in 1499. Clarence’s daughter Margaret Pole, Countess of Salisbury, lived to 67 before Henry VIII had her executed in 1541. The Crowland chronicler wrote that Edward often privately repented the deed.

Read further

  • Michael Hicks, False, Fleeting, Perjur’d Clarence: George, Duke of Clarence 1449-78 (1980)
  • Charles Ross, Edward IV (1974)
  • Dominic Mancini, The Usurpation of Richard III, edited by C. A. J. Armstrong (1969)
  • Nicholas Pronay and John Cox (eds), The Crowland Chronicle Continuations 1459-1486 (1986)

Same day, other years

1229

Jerusalem changes hands by treaty

Jaffa, PalestineMiddle East

The Holy Roman Emperor Frederick II arrived in the Holy Land in 1228 on a crusade he had long postponed, with a small army and under excommunication by Pope Gregory IX. He spoke Arabic, had grown up in Sicily among Muslims, and preferred to bargain. The Ayyubid sultan of Egypt, al-Kamil, was distracted by a family struggle over Damascus. On 18 February 1229 the two agreed a ten-year truce: Jerusalem, Bethlehem and Nazareth, with a corridor to the coast, went to the Christians, while the Haram al-Sharif with the Dome of the Rock and the al-Aqsa mosque stayed in Muslim hands. A month later Frederick wore his crown in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre.

Seen from elsewhere. Almost nobody was pleased. The Latin patriarch placed Jerusalem under interdict because an excommunicate had won it without a blow, and the Templars were hostile. In Damascus the preacher Sibt ibn al-Jawzi moved crowds to tears over the loss, and the chronicler Ibn Wasil records Muslim anger at al-Kamil. The city was lost to the Christians for good in 1244.

1930

A farm boy finds Pluto

Flagstaff, ArizonaThe Americas

Clyde Tombaugh was 24, the son of Kansas farmers, with no university degree. Lowell Observatory had hired him on the strength of drawings he made with a home-built telescope, and set him to the tedious search for a ninth planet that its founder, Percival Lowell, had predicted. The work meant photographing the same patch of sky nights apart and flicking between the plates in a device called a blink comparator, looking for a dot that moved among hundreds of thousands that did not. On the afternoon of 18 February 1930, comparing plates taken in January, he found one. The discovery was announced in March, and the name was suggested by Venetia Burney, an eleven-year-old in Oxford.

Seen from elsewhere. Lowell’s prediction rested on supposed irregularities in the orbits of Uranus and Neptune that later proved not to exist, so the find was luck rewarded by thoroughness. In 2006 the International Astronomical Union reclassified Pluto as a dwarf planet. Some planetary scientists, including Alan Stern, who led the New Horizons mission, still reject that definition.

1932

Manchuria is declared independent of China

Mukden (Shenyang), ManchuriaAsia

Five months after officers of Japan’s Kwantung Army blew up a stretch of railway near Mukden and used it as a pretext to overrun China’s three north-eastern provinces, a committee of local Chinese notables assembled under Japanese supervision announced, on 18 February 1932, that the region had separated from China. The state of Manchukuo was proclaimed on 1 March, with Puyi, the last Qing emperor, deposed as a child in 1912, as its head and from 1934 its emperor. Real authority lay with the Japanese army. A League of Nations commission under Lord Lytton concluded that the new state was not the product of a genuine independence movement, and Japan walked out of the League in 1933.

Seen from elsewhere. Japan presented Manchukuo as self-determination for the Manchus and a realm of harmony among five peoples, and some Qing loyalists did welcome it. In China it is always ‘false Manchukuo’. Puyi told the Tokyo war crimes tribunal he had been coerced; in his later memoir, written in Communist custody, he admitted he had gone willingly, hoping to regain his throne.

1943

The Scholls are caught with their leaflets

Munich, GermanyEurope

Hans Scholl, 24, a medical student who had served on the Russian front, and his sister Sophie, 21, belonged to a small circle calling itself the White Rose, which since 1942 had duplicated and posted leaflets urging Germans to resist Hitler and naming the mass murder of Jews in Poland. On the morning of 18 February 1943 they carried a suitcase of the sixth leaflet into the main building of Munich University and left stacks outside the lecture rooms. Sophie pushed the last pile off a balustrade into the atrium. A caretaker, Jakob Schmid, saw her and held them for the Gestapo. Four days later the People’s Court condemned them and their friend Christoph Probst, and they were guillotined the same afternoon.

Seen from elsewhere. The same evening Goebbels asked a chosen crowd in Berlin whether they wanted total war, and they roared yes. In Munich, students cheered Schmid at a loyalty rally and he was given a reward. The court treated the leaflets as treason in wartime. Postwar Germany made the Scholls emblems of conscience, and historians have asked why other resisters, especially Communists, were long given less attention.

Also on 18 February