Parallax

21 February, 1916

The guns open at Verdun

A nine-hour bombardment on a winter morning began the longest battle of the First World War. Ten months later the two armies stood almost where they had started, with some 700,000 men dead, wounded or missing between them.

Verdun, Lorraine, France

Snow and fog had held the attack up for nine days. On the morning of 21 February 1916 the weather cleared, and at about a quarter past seven some 1,200 German guns, among them the giant siege mortars that had broken the Belgian forts in 1914, opened fire on the French positions north of Verdun, on the right bank of the Meuse. The first heavy shell, fired from a naval gun twenty miles away, fell in the courtyard of the bishop’s palace in the town.

The bombardment went on for about nine hours along a front of a few miles. It was the heaviest the war had yet seen. Woods were reduced to stumps, trenches disappeared, telephone lines were cut within minutes. Late in the afternoon the German infantry of Crown Prince Wilhelm’s Fifth Army came forward in small groups, some carrying flamethrowers, to find out what was left.

In the Bois des Caures two battalions of light infantry, about 1,300 men, were commanded by Lieutenant Colonel Emile Driant, a 60-year-old member of parliament and popular novelist who had been warning for months that Verdun’s defences had been neglected. Enough of his men survived in their concrete shelters to hold the wood through that evening and most of the next day. Driant was shot dead on 22 February while ordering the remnant to fall back. Only a few hundred got out.

For four days the front gave way. On 25 February Fort Douaumont, the largest and most modern of the ring of forts, fell without a fight to a handful of Brandenburg infantrymen who climbed in through an unguarded embrasure; the French had stripped it of most of its guns and garrison the year before. Bells were rung across Germany. In Verdun civilians were leaving and officers were preparing to abandon the right bank.

That night General Philippe Petain was given the command. He ordered that there be no further retreat, reorganised the artillery, and turned the single road from Bar-le-Duc into a supply line along which lorries passed day and night at intervals of seconds. The advance slowed and stopped. What had been planned as a short, sharp blow became a battle that did not end until December. The road was later given the name the Sacred Way by the writer Maurice Barres.

How it came to this

By the end of 1915 the Western Front had been fixed for more than a year, and the German chief of staff, Erich von Falkenhayn, had concluded that a breakthrough was impossible. He judged Britain to be Germany’s principal enemy and France its exhausted instrument. An attack at a point the French could not afford to lose, he reasoned, would draw their reserves into a killing ground commanded by German artillery, and might force France to seek terms.

Verdun suited the purpose. The fortress town sat in a salient, exposed on three sides, with poor rail connections on the French side and good ones on the German. It had symbolic weight, as a frontier stronghold since the treaty that divided Charlemagne’s empire there in 843. And the French command under Joffre, having decided after 1914 that forts were death traps, had removed many of its guns for use elsewhere. Warnings from Driant and others were brushed aside until January 1916, when it was too late to do much.

How each side saw it

The German Fifth Army

The Crown Prince and his chief of staff, Knobelsdorf, believed they had been ordered to take Verdun, and planned accordingly; the Crown Prince’s memoirs say that by spring he thought the attempt had failed and wanted it stopped. Falkenhayn had kept the attack to the right bank and held back reserves, and the infantry paid for it when French guns on the left bank fired into their flank. German soldiers’ letters use the same images as French ones: the mill, the pump that sucked blood. Germans too were rotated back into the same ground until units broke. Falkenhayn was dismissed in August.

The French army and nation

Because Petain rotated divisions quickly through the sector, about three-quarters of the French army served at Verdun at some point, which is why it became the battle of the whole nation in a way the Somme never did. His order of 10 April ended with words every French schoolchild later learned: ‘Courage! On les aura!’, we shall have them. The memory was of endurance, not victory. It also made Petain’s name, with consequences in 1940, when the hero of Verdun took power and asked Germany for an armistice. Nine villages on the battlefield were never rebuilt and are officially recorded as having died for France.

Colonial soldiers

The troops who retook Fort Douaumont on 24 October 1916 included the Colonial Infantry Regiment of Morocco, with battalions of West African tirailleurs and Somalis attached, alongside Moroccan, Algerian and Tunisian units elsewhere on the field. They left few written accounts of their own, and for decades the national story of Verdun had little room for them. A memorial to Muslim soldiers was built beside the Douaumont ossuary only in 2006. The ossuary holds the mixed bones of some 130,000 unidentified dead of both armies.

What is disputed

What Falkenhayn intended is the central question. His memoirs of 1919 quote a memorandum, supposedly written for the Kaiser at Christmas 1915, proposing to bleed the French army white. No copy has ever been found in the archives, and historians including Holger Afflerbach and Paul Jankowski suspect it was composed afterwards to make a failed offensive look like a plan. Robert Foley argues that attrition was nonetheless his real strategy. Casualty figures are also uncertain: commonly cited totals are about 377,000 French and 337,000 German, with around 300,000 dead in all, but older works give figures approaching a million. The start time appears in sources as anything from 7.00 to 8.12, partly a matter of French and German clocks.

What followed

The French recovered Douaumont and Vaux in the autumn, and by 18 December the line was close to where it had been in February. Verdun pinned down the French forces intended for the Somme, making that offensive a largely British affair, and its strain contributed to the French army mutinies of 1917. Between the wars it stood for the futility of the whole conflict. In 1984 President Mitterrand and Chancellor Kohl stood hand in hand before the Douaumont ossuary, an image that became a symbol of Franco-German reconciliation.

Read further

  • Alistair Horne, The Price of Glory: Verdun 1916 (1962)
  • Paul Jankowski, Verdun: The Longest Battle of the Great War (2013)
  • Robert T. Foley, German Strategy and the Path to Verdun (2005)
  • Antoine Prost and Gerd Krumeich, Verdun 1916 (2015)
  • Erich von Falkenhayn, General Headquarters 1914-1916 and its Critical Decisions (1919)

Same day, other years

1921

Reza Khan’s Cossacks take Tehran

Tehran, IranMiddle East

In the small hours of 21 February 1921 a column of the Persian Cossack Brigade, perhaps 2,500 men who had marched from Qazvin, entered Tehran almost unopposed. At its head was Reza Khan, a tall officer of humble birth who had risen from the ranks. With him was a journalist, Sayyid Zia al-Din Tabatabai, who became prime minister while Reza took command of the army. Iran at the time had a weak young shah, an empty treasury, British troops in the south, Soviet-backed rebels in the north and tribal leaders ruling much of the rest. Within three months Reza had pushed Sayyid Zia out. In 1925 parliament deposed the Qajar dynasty and he became shah, the first of the Pahlavis.

Seen from elsewhere. Iranian nationalists have long called it a British coup. The diaries of General Edmund Ironside, commanding British forces in northern Iran, show that he picked Reza Khan and encouraged the march; how far London knew or approved is disputed among historians. The Pahlavi version, in which a patriot rescued his country from collapse, was state doctrine until 1979.

1934

Sandino is seized and shot after dinner with the president

Managua, NicaraguaThe Americas

Augusto Cesar Sandino had fought a guerrilla war for six years against the US Marines who occupied Nicaragua, and they never caught him. When the Marines left in January 1933 he made peace with the new president, Juan Bautista Sacasa, and settled his men on a farming cooperative in the north. But he demanded the dissolution of the National Guard, the force the Americans had created and left under Anastasio Somoza Garcia. On the night of 21 February 1934, as Sandino drove away from dinner at the presidential house, guardsmen stopped his car. He and two of his generals were taken to the airfield and shot. Hundreds of his followers were killed in the days after. Somoza seized the presidency two years later.

Seen from elsewhere. The Marines and Somoza called Sandino a bandit, and Somoza published a book listing atrocities by his men. Somoza later claimed the American minister, Arthur Bliss Lane, had approved the killing; Lane denied it, and the evidence is inconclusive. Somoza’s family ruled until 1979, when they were overthrown by rebels who had taken Sandino’s name.

1952

Police fire on students defending the Bengali language

Dhaka, East Bengal, PakistanAsia

Pakistan was created in 1947 in two halves a thousand miles apart. More than half its people lived in the east and spoke Bengali, but the government in Karachi insisted that Urdu alone would be the state language. When the policy was restated in early 1952, students in Dhaka called a strike for 21 February. The authorities banned gatherings. Students came out of the university gates in small groups to defy the ban, and that afternoon police opened fire near the medical college. Abul Barkat, Rafiq Uddin Ahmed and Abdul Jabbar were among those killed; more died the next day. A memorial put up overnight was demolished by police. Bengali was recognised as a state language in 1956.

Seen from elsewhere. The government argued that one language was needed to bind a new Muslim nation and blamed communists and Indian agents for the unrest. The number of dead has never been firmly established. In Bangladesh the day, Ekushey, is remembered as the first step towards independence in 1971, and since 1999 the United Nations has marked it as International Mother Language Day.

1965

Malcolm X is assassinated

Audubon Ballroom, New YorkThe Americas

Malcolm X had been the most compelling voice of the Nation of Islam until he broke with its leader, Elijah Muhammad, in 1964. After a pilgrimage to Mecca he abandoned its teaching that white people were inherently evil, and began building his own organisation. He was denounced in the Nation’s newspaper and his house was firebombed a week before his death. On 21 February 1965, as he began to speak to several hundred people in upper Manhattan, with his wife and daughters in the audience, a disturbance was staged in the hall and three men rushed the platform and shot him. He was 39. Three members of the Nation were convicted.

Seen from elsewhere. One of the three, Talmadge Hayer, confessed and always said the other two were innocent; their convictions were finally thrown out in 2021 after it emerged that the FBI and New York police had withheld evidence. The Nation denied ordering the killing. Malcolm’s family and many scholars hold that the authorities, who had informants around him, knew more than they have disclosed.

Also on 21 February