Parallax

23 February, AD 303

Diocletian’s soldiers tear down the church at Nicomedia

On the feast of the god of boundaries, the Roman government set out to put an end to Christianity. It was the last and most systematic persecution, and within ten years the empire had a Christian emperor.

Nicomedia, Bithynia (Izmit, Turkey)

The date was chosen with care. The 23rd of February was the Terminalia, the festival of Terminus, god of boundary stones and endings. At first light on that day in the year 303 the praetorian prefect, with military officers and treasury officials, arrived at the Christian church in Nicomedia, the city on the Sea of Marmara where the emperor Diocletian kept his court. The building stood on high ground, in plain view of the palace.

They forced the doors and looked for an image of the god. There was none. They found the scriptures and burned them, and the furnishings were handed over to plunder. From the palace Diocletian and his junior colleague Galerius watched and argued about what to do next. Galerius wanted the building set alight. Diocletian, afraid that a fire would spread to the houses around it, sent in the guard with axes and iron tools instead, and within a few hours the church had been levelled to the ground.

The next day an edict was posted. Churches throughout the empire were to be destroyed and scriptures surrendered for burning. Christians were forbidden to assemble. Those of high rank lost their privileges, which meant they could be tortured in court; Christians could not bring lawsuits; those in the imperial household could be enslaved. A Christian of some standing in the city tore the notice down, with a sarcastic remark about victories over barbarians. He was arrested, tortured and roasted to death, the first to die.

All this is told by Lactantius, a Christian teacher of rhetoric who was living in Nicomedia at the time. He says Diocletian had insisted that the business be carried through without bloodshed. That restraint did not last. Twice within a fortnight fire broke out in the palace. Christians were blamed, Galerius left the city declaring he would not stay to be burned alive, and Diocletian turned on his own household. Palace servants were tortured and killed, and Anthimus, bishop of the city, was beheaded.

Further edicts followed over the next year. The clergy were to be imprisoned; then they were to be released if they sacrificed and tortured if they refused. Finally, in 304, every inhabitant of the empire was ordered to sacrifice to the gods on pain of death. Eusebius, who saw it enforced in Palestine and Egypt, describes prisons so full of clergy that no room was left for criminals.

How it came to this

Diocletian had come to power in 284 after half a century in which emperors were murdered every few years, the frontiers collapsed and the currency lost its value. He rebuilt the state, dividing rule among four emperors, enlarging the army and reforming taxes. He believed, as most Romans did, that the empire’s safety depended on the favour of the gods, earned by correct worship. An edict against the Manichaeans denounced new sects that set themselves against the old religion.

Christians had by then lived almost undisturbed for forty years. They were perhaps a tenth of the population, far more in parts of the East, with bishops, property and large churches; there were Christians at court and, Christian writers claim, in Diocletian’s own family. Trouble began in the army. Around 299 the diviners at an imperial sacrifice failed to find the usual signs and blamed Christians present who had crossed themselves. Soldiers and officials were then required to sacrifice or leave the service. In the winter of 302-3, Lactantius says, Galerius pressed for a general measure, and an oracle of Apollo, consulted for advice, gave an answer hostile to the Christians.

How each side saw it

The emperors and traditional Romans

No statement of Diocletian’s reasons for the edict survives, but his other laws show the cast of mind: the immortal gods had established what was good and true, and it was criminal for a new teaching to find fault with the old. A people who refused sacrifice endangered everyone. Educated pagans made the argument in print. The philosopher Porphyry had written at length against the Christians, and Sossianus Hierocles, a governor who helped urge the persecution, published a work comparing Christ unfavourably with the wonder-worker Apollonius of Tyana. To such men the measures were a restoration of order, not an innovation.

Christians who suffered it

Lactantius, in On the Deaths of the Persecutors, and Eusebius of Caesarea, in his Church History and Martyrs of Palestine, wrote as witnesses and as partisans, sure that God had tested the Church and then destroyed its enemies. Court records preserved by the churches are plainer. At Carthage in 304 a group arrested at Abitina for meeting to worship told the proconsul, according to their acts, that they could not live without the Lord’s supper. Bishop Felix of Thibiuca, ordered to hand over his books, said he had them and would not give them, and was executed.

Christians who complied

Many more gave way than died. Clergy handed over scriptures, or passed off medical treatises and heretical books as scripture to officials content to be deceived; laypeople sacrificed or bought certificates. Their side is known mostly through accusations. In North Africa those who had surrendered the books were called traditores, handers-over, and rigorists held that sacraments from such hands were void. Minutes of a hearing at Cirta show a bishop and his staff meekly listing the chalices and clothing they gave up. The moderates’ case, later argued by Augustine, was that the Church was a body of sinners, and that weakness under terror could be forgiven.

What is disputed

Lactantius makes Galerius the driving force and Diocletian a reluctant old man; many historians, including Timothy Barnes, broadly accept this, while others think it a device to load the blame on the emperor Christians hated most. Enforcement varied enormously. In Gaul and Britain Constantius did little more than pull down some buildings, and Geoffrey de Ste Croix argued that the fourth edict was never applied in the West at all. Numbers are guesswork: Gibbon reckoned about two thousand deaths, W. H. C. Frend three thousand or more, and Candida Moss has argued that later martyr stories inflated the whole picture. The precise dates of the later edicts are reconstructed, though 23 February itself is firmly given by Lactantius.

What followed

Diocletian abdicated in 305. In the East the persecution continued in waves until Galerius, dying of a hideous disease in April 311, issued an edict conceding failure and asking Christians to pray for him. Constantine and Licinius extended full toleration in 313. The quarrel over those who had lapsed split the African church for three centuries in the Donatist schism, and a similar dispute divided Egypt. The Coptic Church still numbers its years from Diocletian’s accession, calling it the Era of the Martyrs.

Read further

  • Lactantius, De Mortibus Persecutorum, edited and translated by J. L. Creed (1984)
  • Eusebius, The History of the Church, translated by G. A. Williamson (1965)
  • W. H. C. Frend, Martyrdom and Persecution in the Early Church (1965)
  • Timothy D. Barnes, Constantine and Eusebius (1981)
  • G. E. M. de Ste Croix, ‘Aspects of the Great Persecution’, Harvard Theological Review (1954)

Same day, other years

1763

The enslaved of Berbice rise

Berbice, Dutch Guiana (Guyana)The Americas

Berbice was a small Dutch colony of sugar, coffee and cacao plantations strung along a river on the north coast of South America, where some 350 Europeans held four to five thousand Africans and their descendants in slavery. On 23 February 1763 the workers of Plantation Magdalenenburg on the Canje river rose, and within weeks the revolt had spread to the Berbice river and the colonists had fled downstream to the coast. A leader known as Coffy, or Kofi, took the title of governor. For most of a year the rebels held the greater part of the colony. They were finally broken by soldiers sent from neighbouring colonies and the Netherlands, by hunger, and by their own divisions. About 125 were executed, many by burning or on the wheel.

Seen from elsewhere. Unusually, the rebels’ own words survive: Coffy dictated letters to the Dutch governor naming planters whose cruelty had caused the rising and proposing to divide the colony between Black and white. The historian Marjoleine Kars has shown that many enslaved people tried to stay out of the fighting, and that Indigenous allies were decisive for the Dutch. Guyana became a republic on the anniversary in 1970.

1903

The United States leases Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo, CubaThe Americas

After driving Spain out of Cuba in 1898, the United States occupied the island and agreed to leave only when Cubans wrote into their constitution the Platt Amendment, which gave Washington a right to intervene and to buy or lease naval stations. Under it the first Cuban president, Tomas Estrada Palma, signed a lease for about 45 square miles around Guantanamo Bay, and President Theodore Roosevelt signed on 23 February 1903. The rent was two thousand dollars a year in gold. A treaty of 1934 cancelled the Platt Amendment but kept the lease in force until both governments agree to end it. Since 2002 the base has held prisoners taken in the ‘war on terror’, most of them never charged.

Seen from elsewhere. The Cuban government since 1959 has held that the lease was imposed on an occupied country and is void, and it has refused to cash the annual rent cheques. The United States maintains that the treaties are valid and that Cuba cannot end them alone. Legal scholars disagree on whether an agreement with no end date, made under such pressure, can bind indefinitely.

1944

The Chechens and Ingush are deported

Chechen-Ingush republic, Soviet UnionEurope

On 23 February 1944, Red Army Day, men in the villages of the Chechen-Ingush republic in the North Caucasus were called to meetings and found themselves surrounded. About 100,000 NKVD troops, directed on the spot by Lavrenty Beria, then went from house to house. Families were given minutes to pack, driven to railheads in lorries supplied by the United States under Lend-Lease, and locked into freight wagons. Within about a week nearly half a million people, the entire Chechen and Ingush nations, were on their way to Kazakhstan and Kirghizia. The republic was abolished and its place names changed. Tens of thousands died on the journey and many more of hunger, cold and typhus in the first years of exile.

Seen from elsewhere. Moscow accused both peoples of collaborating with the German invaders, who had barely reached the republic; tens of thousands of Chechens and Ingush were serving in the Red Army. Khrushchev called the deportation a crime in 1956 and they were allowed home. Chechens and the European Parliament call it genocide. Russian officials have disputed the reported burning of villagers at Khaibakh.

1966

The Baath party’s officers turn on its founders

Damascus, SyriaMiddle East

The Baath party had held power in Syria since a coup in 1963, but it was split between its civilian founders, Michel Aflaq and Salah al-Din al-Bitar, who dreamed of a single Arab nation, and younger army officers of rural and minority background who wanted radical social change in Syria first. On 23 February 1966 the officers struck. After hours of fighting in Damascus and other cities, President Amin al-Hafiz was wounded and captured, and the founders were arrested or fled abroad. The strongman of the new regime was General Salah Jadid. Its defence minister was the air force commander, Hafez al-Assad, who in 1970 overthrew Jadid in turn and kept him in prison until his death in 1993.

Seen from elsewhere. The ousted leaders called it the hijacking of a political party by a military clique. The breach became permanent when Aflaq’s wing took power in Iraq, leaving two hostile Baath regimes. Opponents stressed that Jadid, Assad and many of their allies were Alawites; the officers and some historians describe the conflict as ideological and generational, not sectarian.

Also on 23 February