Parallax

31 January, 1943

A German field marshal surrenders at Stalingrad

Hitler promoted Friedrich Paulus on the understanding that field marshals do not get taken alive. The next morning Paulus walked out of a department store basement into Soviet captivity.

Stalingrad (now Volgograd), Soviet Union

By the last days of January 1943 what remained of the German Sixth Army held two shrinking patches of ruins in Stalingrad, cut off from each other. Its headquarters was in the basement of the Univermag department store on the central square. The last airfield had been lost a week earlier. The daily bread ration had fallen to a few slices, the wounded lay untreated in cellars in their thousands, and men were dying of cold, typhus and plain starvation as well as of shellfire.

On 30 January, the tenth anniversary of Hitler’s coming to power, Hermann Goering made a broadcast comparing the army to the Spartans at Thermopylae. Soldiers who heard it on their sets in the cellars understood that they were listening to their own funeral speech. That night a signal arrived promoting the army’s commander, Friedrich Paulus, to field marshal. No German of that rank had ever been captured, and Paulus took the message as it was meant: he was being invited to shoot himself.

He did not. Early on the 31st Soviet troops of the 64th Army surrounded the store. A young lieutenant, Fyodor Ilchenko, was led down into the basement, which was packed with unwashed men and stank, and was taken to the chief of staff, General Arthur Schmidt, and General Roske, who commanded in that sector. They arranged a local ceasefire. Paulus stayed in a side room throughout, lying on a cot, gaunt and with a nervous tic in his face, and maintained afterwards that he had not surrendered his army but had merely been taken prisoner with his staff.

Later that morning he was driven in a staff car to the headquarters of General Mikhail Shumilov at Beketovka, where he was given a meal and filmed, and then on to the front commanders Rokossovsky and Voronov. Asked to order the northern pocket to stop fighting, he refused, saying that a prisoner could give no orders. Those troops, under General Strecker in the wreckage of the tractor factory, gave up on 2 February.

Hitler learned the news on 1 February. The record of his military conference that day survives. He could not understand, he said, how a man could fail to take the step that so many of his soldiers had taken, and choose Moscow over immortality; he would create no more field marshals in this war. About 91,000 men went into captivity, twenty-two generals among them. Most were already close to death, and only some five or six thousand ever returned to Germany, the last in 1955.

How it came to this

In the summer of 1942 the German army drove across southern Russia towards the oilfields of the Caucasus and the Volga. The Sixth Army reached Stalingrad in late August, after an air raid that set the city on fire and killed tens of thousands of civilians whom Stalin had not allowed to leave. Through the autumn the Soviet 62nd Army under Vasily Chuikov, with its back to the river, fought for individual factories, houses and staircases, kept alive by ferries crossing under fire at night. Both dictators had invested their prestige in a city that bore one of their names.

On 19 November the Red Army attacked the thinly held flanks north and south of the city, which were manned largely by Romanian troops short of anti-tank guns. Within four days the pincers met and some quarter of a million German and allied soldiers were encircled. Hitler forbade a breakout, trusting Goering’s promise to supply the army by air; the airlift never delivered more than a fraction of what was needed. A relief attempt under Manstein failed in December. A Soviet offer of terms on 8 January was refused on Hitler’s orders.

How each side saw it

The Red Army

Soviet soldiers and commanders saw Stalingrad as the moment the invader was stopped by ordinary people who refused to give way. Chuikov’s memoirs, the wartime reports of the novelist Vasily Grossman, and the interviews recorded on the spot in 1943 by a commission of Moscow historians, published by Jochen Hellbeck, describe exhaustion, pride and hatred of an enemy who had devastated their country. The cost was enormous: Soviet casualties in the campaign were over a million, nearly half of them dead. The victory became the central event in the Soviet, and later Russian, memory of the war.

German soldiers in the pocket

The letters flown out before the airfields fell, many intercepted by the army’s own censors, move from confidence in December to despair and bitterness in January. Men wrote that they had been betrayed and sold. A collection published in 1950 as Last Letters from Stalingrad is widely regarded as doctored or invented, but the genuine field post tells a similar story. Survivors’ memoirs dwell on hunger, lice and frostbite and say little about what the same army had done on its way east, including its part in the killing of Jews in Ukraine in 1941.

Hitler and the Nazi leadership

The regime could not admit a surrender. The official communique of 3 February announced that the Sixth Army, true to its oath, had succumbed to superior force, and implied that it had fought to the last man; the radio played solemn music and three days of mourning were declared. Families were not told that tens of thousands were prisoners. Two weeks later Goebbels used the shock to demand ‘total war’ in his speech at the Berlin Sportpalast. Hitler blamed Paulus, the Luftwaffe and his allies, and never accepted that the order to stand fast had been his own.

Germany’s allies

Romanian, Italian and Hungarian armies held the long flanks along the Don and lost several hundred thousand men between them that winter. German accounts at the time and long afterwards blamed their collapse for the disaster. Their own officers pointed out that they had been given fronts too wide to hold, with few heavy weapons and obsolete anti-tank guns that could not stop Soviet armour, and that their warnings of a build-up were ignored. In Romania, Hungary and Italy the losses turned opinion against the war and against the governments that had joined it.

What is disputed

Figures vary. The number encircled is given as anything from 250,000 to 300,000, and the prisoners taken at the end as 91,000 to about 110,000. Antony Beevor’s statement that some 13,500 Soviet soldiers were executed by their own side at Stalingrad has been challenged by Hellbeck and by Russian historians, who find far fewer cases documented. Tens of thousands of Soviet citizens were serving with the Sixth Army as auxiliaries, willingly or not, and their fate is poorly recorded. Whether Paulus could have broken out in November, and whether he or Hitler bears more blame for not trying, is still argued. A remark attributed to him about not shooting himself for a ‘Bohemian corporal’ is unverified.

What followed

Stalingrad did not decide the war by itself, but after it Germany never again held the initiative in the east for long, and both sides knew it. Paulus broadcast against Hitler from captivity after the bomb plot of July 1944, testified for the prosecution at Nuremberg, and lived his last years in Dresden in East Germany, dying in 1957. The city was rebuilt and renamed Volgograd in 1961, when Stalin’s name was removed from the map. Whether it should take the old name back is a recurring argument in Russian politics.

Read further

  • Antony Beevor, Stalingrad (1998)
  • Jochen Hellbeck, Stalingrad: The City that Defeated the Third Reich (2015)
  • David M. Glantz and Jonathan M. House, Endgame at Stalingrad (2014)
  • Vasily Grossman, A Writer at War: Vasily Grossman with the Red Army 1941-1945, edited by Antony Beevor and Luba Vinogradova (2005)
  • Vasily Chuikov, The Beginning of the Road (1963)

Same day, other years

1606

Guy Fawkes is executed at Westminster

Old Palace Yard, Westminster, EnglandEurope

Fawkes had been arrested in a cellar beneath the House of Lords on the night of 4 November 1605, with thirty-six barrels of gunpowder meant to kill King James I and the assembled Parliament. Questioned under torture authorised by the king, he gave up the names of his fellow Catholic conspirators. On 31 January 1606, by the English calendar of the time, he and three others were drawn on hurdles to the yard in front of the building they had tried to destroy, to be hanged, cut down alive and quartered. Fawkes, the last to mount the ladder and barely able to climb it, fell or jumped and broke his neck, and so was dead before the butchery.

Seen from elsewhere. English Catholics, most of whom knew nothing of the plot, paid for it in harsher laws and two centuries of suspicion. Catholic writers argued that it grew from persecution and broken promises of toleration, and some, like the Jesuit John Gerard in 1897, that the government had contrived it. Most historians reject that but agree ministers exploited it.

1703

The forty-seven ronin take their revenge

Edo (now Tokyo), JapanAsia

In 1701 Asano Naganori, lord of Ako, drew his sword on a senior court official, Kira Yoshinaka, inside the shogun’s castle in Edo and wounded him. He was ordered to kill himself the same day and his domain was confiscated; Kira was not punished. Asano’s retainers became ronin, samurai without a master. Nearly two years later forty-seven of them, led by Oishi Kuranosuke, broke into Kira’s mansion on a snowy night, killed him, and carried his head across the city to their lord’s grave at the temple of Sengakuji. They then gave themselves up. After weeks of debate the shogunate ordered them to commit ritual suicide, which forty-six did.

Seen from elsewhere. Scholars of the time were divided. Ogyu Sorai held that they had acted honourably but broken the law and must die; others called it a model of loyalty, or a private feud. Kira’s home district remembers him as a good lord. The Japanese date, the fourteenth of the twelfth month, falls on the night of 30-31 January 1703 in the western calendar.

1865

The House votes to abolish slavery

Washington, DC, United StatesThe Americas

The United States House of Representatives passed the Thirteenth Amendment to the Constitution by 119 votes to 56, a handful more than the two-thirds required. The Senate had approved it the previous April, but the House had then fallen short. After his re-election Abraham Lincoln pressed for a second attempt, and his allies worked on outgoing Democrats with argument, patronage and promises. When the result was announced members cheered and wept and the galleries, which now admitted Black spectators, erupted. The amendment declared that neither slavery nor involuntary servitude should exist in the United States, except as punishment for crime. It was ratified by the states in December 1865.

Seen from elsewhere. Opponents argued that the Constitution gave no power to abolish property recognised by the states. Frederick Douglass warned that slavery was not ended until Black men had the vote. The exception for convicts was later used in the South to lease prisoners as forced labour. Historians also stress that enslaved people had been freeing themselves by flight throughout the war.

1968

Nauru becomes independent

NauruOceania

The Pacific island of Nauru, twenty-one square kilometres of coral and phosphate rock, became the world’s smallest independent republic under its first president, Hammer DeRoburt. It had been a German colony and then, from the First World War, was administered by Australia on behalf of itself, Britain and New Zealand, whose farmers were supplied with its phosphate at below world prices. The date was chosen by the Nauruans: on 31 January 1946 the survivors of some 1,200 islanders deported by the Japanese to Truk had come home, more than a third having died. Nauru bought the phosphate industry in 1970 and for a time was among the richest states per head on earth.

Seen from elsewhere. Australia had proposed resettling the whole population on an island off Queensland, which the Nauruans refused in 1964. Nauru later sued at the International Court of Justice over land left as bare rock by mining before independence; Australia denied liability, then settled in 1993. The deposits ran out, and the investments made with the proceeds were largely lost.

Also on 31 January