Parallax

9 February, 1567

The king’s house blows up at Kirk o’ Field

Mary, Queen of Scots, said goodnight to her sick husband and rode off to a wedding party. A few hours later his lodging was a heap of rubble, and he lay dead in an orchard without a mark from the blast on him.

Kirk o’ Field, Edinburgh, Scotland

On the evening of Sunday 9 February 1567, the last Sunday before Lent, Mary rode up from Holyrood with a party of nobles to visit her husband. Henry Stewart, Lord Darnley, twenty-one years old and titled King of Scots by her gift, was recovering from a disfiguring illness in the Old Provost’s Lodging at Kirk o’ Field, a modest house just inside the town wall on the south side of Edinburgh. He wore a taffeta mask over his face. The company played dice and talked. Mary had slept in the room beneath his on two nights that week and was expected to do so again.

Some time after ten o’clock she was reminded that she had promised to attend the wedding masque of a favourite servant, Bastian Pagez, at the palace. She gave Darnley a ring, according to later testimony, and left by torchlight. Darnley was said to be put out. He ordered his horses for five the next morning and went to bed, with his valet William Taylor sleeping in the same chamber.

At about two in the morning of Monday 10 February an explosion shook the town. People who ran to Kirk o’ Field found the lodging levelled to its foundations. One servant, Thomas Nelson, was found alive in the wreckage. Darnley was not in the ruins. He and Taylor were found some distance away, on the far side of the wall, in an orchard. Both were dead, both in their nightshirts, and neither was burned or broken as men thrown by gunpowder should have been. Beside them lay a chair, a length of rope, a cloak and a dagger. The assumption then and since has been that they heard something, got out by a window, and were caught and smothered in the garden.

A drawing of the scene, made for the English government within days, still survives in the National Archives at Kew. In Edinburgh, anonymous placards went up at night naming James Hepburn, Earl of Bothwell, as the murderer. One showed a crowned mermaid, a common emblem for a prostitute, above a hare, the Hepburn badge.

Mary’s conduct over the next three months destroyed her. Bothwell was tried on 12 April in a town packed with his armed followers; Darnley’s father, the Earl of Lennox, dared not appear to accuse him, and he was acquitted. On 24 April Bothwell intercepted the queen on the road and carried her to Dunbar. On 15 May she married him by Protestant rites. A month later a confederacy of lords faced them at Carberry Hill. Bothwell fled, Mary was led through Edinburgh to shouts that she should be burned, and on 24 July, a prisoner on an island in Loch Leven, she signed away her crown to her infant son.

How it came to this

Mary had returned from France in 1561, a Catholic widow of eighteen ruling a kingdom that had just made itself Protestant. In July 1565 she married her cousin Darnley, tall, handsome, and like her a descendant of Henry VII with a claim to the English throne. Within months she knew it was a mistake. He drank, sulked and demanded the crown matrimonial, which would have made him king in his own right. In March 1566 he joined a group of Protestant lords who dragged her Italian secretary, David Rizzio, from her supper table at Holyrood and stabbed him to death while she, six months pregnant, was held back.

Their son James was born in June. By the autumn Darnley had managed to alienate every faction: the queen, the lords he had betrayed after the Rizzio murder, and those he had helped to exile. In late 1566 her leading councillors met her at Craigmillar Castle and discussed how she might be rid of him. Divorce risked the child’s legitimacy. What else was said, and what she understood by it, is the heart of the matter. When Darnley fell ill at Glasgow in January, Mary went to fetch him back herself.

How each side saw it

Mary’s accusers

The lords who deposed her needed her to be guilty, and built the case that she was. George Buchanan, once her Latin tutor, set it out in his Detectio: an adulterous queen, besotted with Bothwell, who lured her husband to a house chosen for his murder. Their evidence was the Casket Letters, eight letters and some sonnets said to be hers and found in a silver box in June 1567. Shown to English commissioners at York and Westminster in 1568, they appeared to prove she knew what was coming. Confessions were also taken from Bothwell’s servants, who were then hanged.

Mary and her defenders

Mary always denied any part in it and said the Casket Letters were forged. In a letter written the day after the explosion she told her ambassador in Paris that the plot had been aimed at her as much as at the king, and that only chance had kept her from sleeping there. Her champion John Lesley, Bishop of Ross, argued in print that the men who accused her, Morton and Maitland among them, had themselves signed a bond for the killing. Catholic Europe was less sure. The Pope and her Guise relatives were appalled by the Bothwell marriage and for a time gave her up.

The Lennox Stewarts

Darnley’s parents never doubted. The Earl of Lennox drew up his own narrative of his son’s murder for the English inquiry, and the family commissioned a painting, the Darnley Memorial, in which the infant James kneels by his father’s tomb with a scroll calling on God to avenge his blood. Darnley’s mother, Margaret Douglas, a niece of Henry VIII, at first blamed Mary without reserve. Some years later she was reconciled with her by letter and wrote of the treachery of those who had misled her, which Mary’s defenders have treated as a retraction.

Modern historians

Scholars divide roughly as Mary’s contemporaries did. Jenny Wormald judged her a failed ruler who, at the least, knew and let it happen. Antonia Fraser and John Guy hold that she was innocent of the murder itself; Guy, working from the surviving transcripts, argues the most damaging passages of the Casket Letters were doctored or spliced. Alison Weir points to the Douglases, kinsmen of Morton, as the men in the garden. Almost all agree that Bothwell organised the gunpowder, and that several of the lords who later prosecuted the queen had known about the plan beforehand.

What is disputed

Almost everything. The death fell in the early hours of 10 February, not the 9th, which is the date of Mary’s last visit. Darnley’s illness was called smallpox at the time; syphilis is a later suggestion. Who killed him in the orchard is unknown: neighbours said they heard a man beg his kinsmen for pity, which points to the Douglases, but the testimony is second-hand. The Casket Letters vanished in the 1580s and survive only in copies and translations, so their authenticity cannot be tested. Whether Bothwell abducted and raped Mary, as she and some contemporaries said, or whether the abduction was arranged between them, is still argued.

What followed

Mary escaped from Loch Leven in 1568, lost a battle at Langside and fled to England, where Elizabeth kept her captive for nineteen years and had her beheaded in 1587. Bothwell died insane in a Danish prison in 1578. The Earl of Morton, who ruled Scotland as regent, was executed in 1581 for having had foreknowledge of the murder. The baby crowned at thirteen months grew up to be James VI of Scotland and, from 1603, James I of England, uniting the two crowns his parents had both coveted.

Read further

  • John Guy, My Heart Is My Own: The Life of Mary Queen of Scots (2004)
  • Antonia Fraser, Mary Queen of Scots (1969)
  • Jenny Wormald, Mary Queen of Scots: A Study in Failure (1988)
  • Alison Weir, Mary, Queen of Scots and the Murder of Lord Darnley (2003)
  • George Buchanan, Ane Detectioun of the Duinges of Marie Quene of Scottes (1571)

Same day, other years

1822

Haiti takes Santo Domingo and ends slavery there

Santo Domingo, HispaniolaThe Americas

Ten weeks earlier the Spanish-speaking east of Hispaniola had declared itself independent of Spain under Jose Nunez de Caceres, who hoped to join Simon Bolivar’s Gran Colombia. Bolivar did not answer. The Haitian president, Jean-Pierre Boyer, did. He crossed the border with an army of several thousand, and on 9 February 1822 Nunez de Caceres handed him the keys of Santo Domingo. Boyer’s first act was to abolish slavery in the east. The whole island was then ruled from Port-au-Prince for twenty-two years, until Dominican conspirators proclaimed a separate republic in February 1844.

Seen from elsewhere. Dominican national history remembers an occupation: land confiscated, the university closed, Spanish sidelined, heavy taxes to pay Haiti’s indemnity to France. Haitian accounts stress that several eastern towns had invited Boyer in, that he came without a battle, and that for the enslaved people of the east this was the day of emancipation.

1904

Japan strikes Russia before declaring war

Port Arthur, Manchuria, and Chemulpo, KoreaAsia

Late on 8 February 1904 Japanese destroyers slipped into the roadstead at Port Arthur and torpedoed three ships of Russia’s Pacific squadron at anchor. The next day Admiral Togo’s battleships exchanged fire with the fleet and the forts, and at Chemulpo, the port of Seoul, the Russian cruiser Varyag and a gunboat steamed out against a Japanese squadron, were beaten back and scuttled by their own crews. Japanese troops were already landing in Korea. The formal declaration of war followed on 10 February. Within eighteen months Russia had lost two fleets and an army, the first defeat of a European great power by an Asian one in modern times.

Seen from elsewhere. Russia called it treachery. Japan replied that it had broken off relations two days earlier, and no rule then required a declaration; one was written at The Hague in 1907. Korea, which had declared itself neutral, was the real casualty: occupied in the first week, a protectorate by 1905, annexed in 1910.

1913

Ten Tragic Days begin in Mexico City

Mexico City, MexicoThe Americas

Before dawn on 9 February 1913 army cadets and mutinous troops freed two imprisoned generals, Bernardo Reyes and Felix Diaz, nephew of the old dictator, and marched on the National Palace. Reyes was shot dead at its gates. Diaz dug in at the Ciudadela arsenal, and for ten days the two sides shelled each other across the middle of the capital while civilians died in the streets. President Francisco Madero gave command to General Victoriano Huerta, who was quietly bargaining with the rebels. On 18 February Huerta arrested Madero. Four days later the president and vice-president were shot, officially while trying to escape.

Seen from elsewhere. Huerta’s backers, among them much of the business class and the American ambassador Henry Lane Wilson, who hosted the pact that sealed the coup, said they were restoring order. To revolutionaries Madero became a martyr, and Woodrow Wilson, taking office weeks later, refused to recognise what he called a government of butchers.

1950

McCarthy says he has a list

Wheeling, West Virginia, United StatesThe Americas

Joseph McCarthy, a little-known Republican senator from Wisconsin, was sent to address a women’s Republican club in Wheeling for Lincoln’s birthday. He told them the State Department was riddled with Communists and that he held in his hand a list of names. Local reports gave the number as 205; within days he was saying 57. No recording survives. The charge came months after the Soviet atomic test, the Communist victory in China and the conviction of Alger Hiss, and it made him the most feared politician in the country. Four years of hearings, blacklists and ruined careers followed before the Senate censured him in December 1954.

Seen from elsewhere. A Senate committee under Millard Tydings called the charges a fraud and a hoax. His defenders have since pointed to decoded Soviet cables showing that espionage in Washington was real. Most historians of those cables, including John Earl Haynes and Harvey Klehr, add that McCarthy’s own accusations rarely matched the people in them.

Also on 9 February