Parallax

27 February, 1933

The Reichstag burns

A young Dutchman was found half-naked in the blazing parliament and said he had done it alone. By the next afternoon Germans had lost their civil liberties, and the argument over who really lit the fire has never ended.

Berlin, Germany

Shortly after nine on the evening of Monday 27 February 1933 a passer-by heard glass breaking at the Reichstag building in Berlin and saw a figure with a burning brand moving behind the first-floor windows. Police and firemen entered within minutes. They found small fires along the corridors and, in the debating chamber, a wall of flame that soon brought down the glass and steel dome. In a hall at the back a constable arrested a sweating young man, stripped to the waist. His passport gave his name as Marinus van der Lubbe, born in Leiden, aged 24.

Van der Lubbe was an unemployed building worker, his eyesight damaged in an accident with lime, who had left the Dutch Communist Party for a small group of council communists who distrusted all parties. He had walked to Berlin to rouse the German workers against the new government. Two days earlier he had tried and failed to set light to a welfare office, the town hall and the old royal palace. He told the police at once, and never changed the account, that he had fired the Reichstag with firelighters and his own clothes, and that nobody had helped him.

Adolf Hitler had been chancellor for four weeks, at the head of a coalition, with an election due on 5 March. Hermann Goring, who was both president of the Reichstag and the minister in charge of the Prussian police, reached the building first. Hitler arrived from dinner at the home of Joseph Goebbels. Sefton Delmer of the Daily Express, who followed them in, reported Hitler saying that if this was the work of the Communists, as he believed, they would be crushed with an iron fist. Before any evidence had been gathered the fire was announced as the signal for a Communist uprising.

The arrests began that night from lists drawn up in advance. Around four thousand Communist officials, together with Social Democrats, pacifists and writers, were taken in Prussia within days. On the morning of 28 February the cabinet agreed an emergency decree and President Hindenburg signed it. The Decree for the Protection of People and State suspended personal liberty, freedom of speech, of the press and of assembly, and the privacy of post and telephone, and allowed Berlin to take over the governments of the states. It carried no expiry date and remained in force until 1945.

Five men were tried before the Supreme Court in Leipzig that autumn: van der Lubbe, the Communist parliamentary leader Ernst Torgler, and three Bulgarian Communists, of whom Georgi Dimitrov turned his cross-examination of Goring into an attack on the regime. On 23 December the court acquitted the four Communists and condemned van der Lubbe under a law made retroactive for the purpose. He was beheaded on 10 January 1934.

How it came to this

The Weimar Republic had been governed by presidential decree since 1930, as the depression put six million out of work and the parliament produced no majority. In the two elections of 1932 the National Socialists became the largest party, and the Communists also gained, taking close to six million votes that November. Conservatives around President Hindenburg, sure they could use and contain Hitler, made him chancellor on 30 January 1933 in a cabinet with only two other Nazi ministers.

Hitler obtained a dissolution of parliament at once. During February Goring purged the Prussian police, enrolled some fifty thousand stormtroopers and other nationalists as auxiliaries, and told officers he would cover any of them who used their weapons against enemies of the state. Communist meetings and newspapers were banned and the party headquarters raided. The leadership in Moscow and Berlin, which still treated the Social Democrats as its chief enemy, expected the government to fall quickly and had planned no rising. Nazi leaders spoke and wrote as though one was imminent, and some of them plainly believed it.

How each side saw it

The Nazi leadership

The government’s account, given that night and maintained at Leipzig, was that the fire was the opening act of a Communist revolution and that the decree had saved Germany. Goring claimed to hold documents proving plans for terror and poisonings; none was ever produced. Goebbels’s diary records the news as a surprise and then an opportunity. When the court acquitted the Communist defendants for lack of evidence, Hitler was furious and removed treason cases from the ordinary judges, creating the People’s Court in 1934. Tried at Nuremberg in 1946, Goring denied any part in the fire.

The Communist International

From exile in Paris the publicist Willi Munzenberg produced the Brown Book of the Hitler Terror within months. It argued that a squad of stormtroopers had entered through the heating tunnel that ran from Goring’s official residence, and that van der Lubbe was their tool. A counter-trial of jurists held in London in September 1933 reached a similar finding. The tunnel existed; several of the book’s documents were invented and it smeared van der Lubbe’s character. Dimitrov’s defiance in the dock made him famous across the world and later head of the Comintern. For decades this version was the accepted one in both East and West.

Van der Lubbe and his comrades

The accused left his own words in police interrogations and in letters. He said he acted because the workers would do nothing, that he chose a building belonging to the system, and that he had no accomplices. He was lucid at first and by the trial sat slumped and almost silent, which some put down to drugs and others to months in chains. His friends among the Dutch council communists published a Red Book in 1933 defending him against the Nazi charge that he was Moscow’s agent and the Communist charge that he was a Nazi stooge. German federal prosecutors announced in January 2008 that his conviction had been annulled.

What is disputed

Whether one man could have set the fire is the oldest quarrel in modern German history. Fritz Tobias argued around 1960 that van der Lubbe acted alone and the Nazis merely exploited it; Hans Mommsen and later Richard Evans agreed, and that became the majority view. Fire experts at the trial had thought a single arsonist impossible in the time. Benjamin Hett argued in 2014 that the single-culprit case rested on post-war testimony from former Gestapo men with reason to lie, and that Nazi involvement is likely. A 1955 affidavit by a former stormtrooper, found in 2019, says he drove van der Lubbe to a building already alight. No proof of a Nazi order has been found.

What followed

The decree was the legal foundation of the dictatorship; the first concentration camps opened under it within weeks. In the election of 5 March the Nazis took just under 44 per cent, short of a majority even with the campaign conducted under terror. The Communist deputies were barred or in custody when the Reichstag, meeting in an opera house, passed the Enabling Act on 23 March and handed its powers to the cabinet. The ruined building stood empty, was fought over in 1945, and reopened in 1999 as the seat of the parliament of a reunited Germany.

Read further

  • Fritz Tobias, The Reichstag Fire: Legend and Truth (1963)
  • Benjamin Carter Hett, Burning the Reichstag: An Investigation into the Third Reich’s Enduring Mystery (2014)
  • Richard J. Evans, The Coming of the Third Reich (2003)
  • World Committee for the Victims of German Fascism, The Brown Book of the Hitler Terror and the Burning of the Reichstag (1933)
  • Sefton Delmer, Trail Sinister (1961)

Same day, other years

AD 380

Theodosius defines the faith by decree

Thessalonica, Roman EmpireEurope

The emperor Theodosius I, a Spanish general raised to the throne a year earlier, spent the winter of 379-80 at Thessalonica preparing to fight the Goths. On 27 February 380 he issued an edict, addressed to the people of Constantinople and known from its opening words as Cunctos populos. It declared the emperors’ wish that all peoples under their rule should follow the religion handed down by the apostle Peter and now taught by Bishop Damasus of Rome and Bishop Peter of Alexandria, belief in Father, Son and Holy Spirit as one equal Trinity. Those who did so were to be called Catholic Christians. The rest were judged demented, their meeting places were not to be called churches, and they were to expect punishment.

Seen from elsewhere. The target was other Christians, above all the Arian clergy who held the churches of Constantinople and whose bishop Theodosius expelled that November. Textbooks often say the edict made Christianity the state religion. Historians such as Malcolm Errington and Neil McLynn read it as a narrower measure aimed at one city, and note that laws against pagan worship came a decade later.

1844

A shot at the gate begins Dominican independence

Santo Domingo, HispaniolaThe Americas

Haiti had governed the whole island of Hispaniola since 1822, when President Boyer’s army marched into the Spanish-speaking east and ended slavery there. In 1838 Juan Pablo Duarte and a few friends in Santo Domingo founded a secret society, La Trinitaria, to separate from it. Duarte was in exile when the moment came. On the night of 27 February 1844 Ramon Matias Mella fired a blunderbuss at the Puerta de la Misericordia as the signal, and Francisco del Rosario Sanchez raised a new flag at the Puerta del Conde. The Haitian garrison, cut off by turmoil at home, capitulated within days. Haitian attempts at reconquest over the next twelve years were beaten off.

Seen from elsewhere. Haitians remember unification as the act that abolished slavery in the east and guarded the island against the return of European powers. Dominican tradition recalls closed institutions, seized church lands and taxes raised to pay Haiti’s indemnity to France. The republic’s own leaders handed it back to Spain in 1861. The memory still shapes relations between the two countries.

1989

The Caracazo

Caracas, VenezuelaThe Americas

Carlos Andres Perez returned to the presidency of Venezuela in February 1989 and, with the oil price low and the reserves spent, agreed an austerity programme with the International Monetary Fund. Petrol prices rose, and on the morning of Monday 27 February commuters in Guarenas, outside Caracas, found bus fares raised well beyond the permitted amount. Protest turned to burning buses and then to mass looting that spread through the capital and other cities. The next day the government suspended constitutional guarantees and sent the army into the hillside districts with live ammunition. The official count of the dead was 276. Human rights groups and many scholars put it far higher, in some estimates over a thousand, and unmarked graves were later found in a Caracas cemetery.

Seen from elsewhere. The government said it had restored order in a city given over to looting. The Inter-American Court of Human Rights held Venezuela responsible for unlawful killings, and the state accepted the finding in 1999. Hugo Chavez, who led a failed coup in 1992, treated the Caracazo as the origin of his movement. Almost nobody was convicted under any government.

2002

A train burns at Godhra

Godhra, Gujarat, IndiaAsia

On the morning of 27 February 2002 the Sabarmati Express, carrying Hindu volunteers home from a campaign to build a temple on the site of the demolished Babri mosque at Ayodhya, stopped just outside Godhra station in Gujarat. After an altercation on the platform a crowd from the adjoining Muslim neighbourhood stoned the train, and coach S-6 caught fire. Fifty-nine people died, among them women and children. Over the following weeks mobs attacked Muslims across Gujarat. The official toll was 1,044 dead, 790 of them Muslim; other estimates approach two thousand. Tens of thousands were driven from their homes.

Seen from elsewhere. How the fire began is itself contested. A state commission found a planned attack, and a court in 2011 convicted 31 Muslim men; a railway ministry inquiry called it an accident. Survivors and rights groups accuse the state government of Narendra Modi of letting the reprisals run. A Supreme Court-appointed team found no case against him, a conclusion upheld in 2022.

Also on 27 February