Parallax

15 February, 1898

The USS Maine explodes in Havana harbour

An American battleship on a ‘friendly visit’ to Spanish Cuba blew up at her mooring and took 266 men with her. Nobody has ever proved why. Within ten weeks the question had been settled by a war.

Havana, Cuba

The Maine had been lying at buoy number four in Havana harbour for three weeks. She had been sent from Key West in late January 1898, after riots in the city by Spanish loyalists, on what Washington called a courtesy call and Madrid understood as a warning. Her captain, Charles Sigsbee, kept his crew aboard to avoid incidents, exchanged formal visits with the Spanish authorities and posted extra sentries at night.

At 9.40 on the evening of Tuesday 15 February, a still, overcast night, the forward third of the ship erupted. Witnesses on shore and on nearby vessels described two reports, a sharp one and then a vast roar, and a column of flame and debris. More than five tons of powder in the forward magazines had gone up. The bow was torn apart and the wreck settled quickly into the mud with her mangled superstructure above water.

The enlisted men’s berths were forward, the officers’ aft. Of about 355 men on board, 260 died that night or were never found, and six more died of their injuries; only two of the dead were officers. Boats from the Spanish cruiser Alfonso XII, moored close by, and from the American passenger steamer City of Washington pulled survivors from the water while ammunition was still going off. Havana’s hospitals took in the wounded, and two days later the city gave the first of the dead a state funeral.

Sigsbee’s telegram that night asked that public opinion be suspended until there was a report. It was not. William Randolph Hearst’s New York Journal announced within two days that the warship had been destroyed by an enemy and offered a 50,000 dollar reward; Joseph Pulitzer’s World was scarcely more cautious. A slogan did the rest: ‘Remember the Maine, to hell with Spain!’

A US Navy court of inquiry under Captain William Sampson sat in Havana, sent down divers, and reported in March that the keel plates were bent inward and that a submarine mine had set off the magazines. It did not say who had laid it. A Spanish naval inquiry, refused access to the wreck’s interior, had concluded that the explosion was internal: there had been no column of water, no dead fish, no cable. Spain offered arbitration and, under pressure, an armistice with the Cuban rebels. President McKinley, who did not want war, sent the question to Congress on 11 April. By the 25th the two countries were at war.

How it came to this

Cuba was the largest remnant of Spain’s American empire, and Cubans had been fighting to end Spanish rule on and off since 1868. The last rising began in 1895, planned by the poet Jose Marti, who was killed in its first weeks, and led in the field by Maximo Gomez and Antonio Maceo. The rebels burned cane fields to make the colony worthless. Spain’s commander, Valeriano Weyler, answered in 1896 by herding the rural population into fortified towns to cut the insurgents off from food and recruits. Disease and hunger in these camps killed well over a hundred thousand people.

Reports of the camps, some accurate and some invented, filled American newspapers engaged in a circulation war. There were also American investments in Cuban sugar, a long-standing belief that the island belonged naturally in the orbit of the United States, and a new steel navy looking for employment. A liberal government in Madrid recalled Weyler and granted Cuba home rule from January 1898, which satisfied neither the rebels nor the Spanish loyalists who rioted against it. Six days before the explosion, the Journal printed a stolen private letter in which Spain’s ambassador called McKinley weak.

How each side saw it

Spain

Spanish officials in Havana had nothing to gain from sinking the ship and knew it. Their navy helped with the rescue, and their inquiry, led by Captain Pedro del Peral, pointed to a fire in a coal bunker beside a magazine, a known hazard in ships of the type. Madrid proposed a joint investigation and was refused. To Spaniards the American verdict looked like a pretext prepared in advance. Defeat that summer, remembered simply as el Desastre, cost Spain the last of its overseas empire and set off a generation of national self-examination among its writers.

Cuban independence fighters and Cuban historians

The Cuban army had been fighting for three years and controlled much of the countryside. Its leaders welcomed American arms and were then shut out: Cuban forces were kept from the surrender of Santiago, and no Cuban signed the peace. Independence came in 1902 with the Platt Amendment attached, giving Washington a right to intervene and a naval base at Guantanamo. Cuban historians call the conflict the Spanish-Cuban-American War and treat the Maine as the occasion for an intervention already intended. After 1959 the Maine memorial in Havana was given an inscription to the victims of ‘imperialist voracity’.

The American public and McKinley’s government

Most Americans in 1898 took the mine for granted and many saw the war as a rescue of Cubans from a brutal colonial regime, a view sincerely held in churches and labour halls as well as in newspaper offices. Congress wrote into its war resolution a pledge, the Teller Amendment, not to annex Cuba. McKinley, a Civil War veteran, had resisted the clamour for weeks and was burned in effigy for it. Business opinion, at first against war, came round. Critics at home, among them Mark Twain and the Anti-Imperialist League, turned against the enterprise when it ended with the taking of the Philippines.

Naval engineers

In 1911 the wreck was enclosed in a cofferdam and examined dry; a second navy board again found for an external explosion, though at a different place on the hull. In 1976 Admiral Hyman Rickover had two engineers study the photographs and records. They concluded that the damage was consistent with an internal explosion alone, most probably started by spontaneous combustion of coal in a bunker next to the reserve magazine. A computer study commissioned by National Geographic in 1998 found that either a bunker fire or a small mine could have produced the damage.

What is disputed

The cause remains formally unresolved. Most naval historians lean to Rickover’s coal-bunker fire; a minority still argue for a mine, laid by Spanish extremists, by Cuban rebels hoping to draw in the United States, or by persons unknown. The suggestion sometimes made in Cuba that Americans destroyed their own ship has no evidence behind it. The death toll appears as 260, 266 or higher depending on who is counted. Hearst’s supposed cable to an artist in Cuba, ‘You furnish the pictures and I’ll furnish the war’, rests on one memoir of 1901 and is probably invented. How far the press actually caused the war is also questioned.

What followed

The war lasted under four months. Spain’s squadrons were destroyed at Manila Bay and off Santiago, and by the Treaty of Paris that December it gave up Cuba and ceded Puerto Rico, Guam and, for twenty million dollars, the Philippines. Filipinos who had declared their own republic then fought the United States in a war that cost several hundred thousand lives. The wreck of the Maine was refloated in 1912, towed out to sea and sunk with honours. Her mast stands in Arlington cemetery. The episode is still cited whenever an unexplained incident is offered as a reason for war.

Read further

  • Hyman G. Rickover, How the Battleship Maine Was Destroyed (1976)
  • Louis A. Perez Jr., The War of 1898: The United States and Cuba in History and Historiography (1998)
  • John L. Offner, An Unwanted War: The Diplomacy of the United States and Spain over Cuba, 1895-1898 (1992)
  • John Lawrence Tone, War and Genocide in Cuba, 1895-1898 (2006)
  • Charles D. Sigsbee, The Maine: An Account of Her Destruction in Havana Harbor (1899)

Same day, other years

1942

Singapore surrenders to Japan

SingaporeAsia

Britain had spent two decades and a fortune on a naval base at Singapore that was meant to anchor its power in Asia. In seventy days from December 1941 a Japanese army under General Yamashita Tomoyuki came down the Malay peninsula, much of the way on bicycles, outflanking every defence line. It crossed to the island on 8 February. A week later, with the reservoirs lost and a million civilians under bombardment, Lieutenant-General Arthur Percival walked to the Ford motor factory at Bukit Timah under a white flag. Some 80,000 British, Indian and Australian troops went into captivity, where many thousands died. Yamashita, who had about 30,000 men and was short of shells, later said his demand for immediate surrender was a bluff.

Seen from elsewhere. For Singapore’s Chinese the surrender began the Sook Ching, a screening in which Japanese military police took away and shot men suspected of hostility; Japan later acknowledged about 5,000 deaths, local estimates run to 25,000 or more. Across Asia, nationalists drew the lesson that European rule could be beaten. Many Indian prisoners joined an army to fight Britain.

1944

Allied bombers destroy the abbey of Monte Cassino

Monte Cassino, ItalyEurope

The mother house of the Benedictine order, founded by St Benedict in about 529, stood on a mountain commanding the road to Rome and the centre of the German Gustav Line. Allied infantry dying on the slopes below were convinced that it was being used to direct fire on them. The New Zealand commander, Bernard Freyberg, asked that it be bombed before his troops attacked, and his superiors agreed. On the morning of 15 February more than 220 American bombers dropped over a thousand tons of bombs and reduced the abbey to its foundations. German troops had not been inside. They moved into the ruins afterwards, which made a better fortress, and held them for three more months.

Seen from elsewhere. The dead were Italian civilians who had taken refuge with the monks, probably more than two hundred. The German command, which had earlier trucked the library and art treasures to Rome, made propaganda of Allied barbarism. The Vatican protested. The American general Mark Clark, who had opposed the bombing, later called it a mistake.

1989

The last Soviet soldier leaves Afghanistan

Termez, on the Afghan-Soviet borderAsia

Lieutenant-General Boris Gromov, commander of the Soviet Fortieth Army, rode an armoured vehicle to the middle of the Friendship Bridge over the Amu Darya, got down and walked the rest of the way into Soviet Uzbekistan, where his teenage son met him with flowers. He told reporters there was not a single Soviet soldier behind his back. The army had entered Afghanistan in December 1979 to prop up a communist government and had stayed nine years, losing about 15,000 dead. Afghan deaths are counted in the hundreds of thousands, by some estimates more than a million, and about five million people had fled to Pakistan and Iran. The withdrawal had been agreed at Geneva the previous April.

Seen from elsewhere. The resistance and its American and Pakistani backers expected Kabul to fall within weeks. President Najibullah’s government held on for three years, until Moscow’s money stopped. Soviet veterans insist they left undefeated; many Afghans who had sided with them felt abandoned. The factions that had fought the occupation then turned on one another and wrecked the capital.

2013

A meteor explodes over Chelyabinsk

Chelyabinsk, RussiaAsia

At 9.20 on a winter morning, a fragment of asteroid about twenty metres across entered the atmosphere over the southern Urals at some nineteen kilometres a second. It came from the direction of the rising sun and no telescope had seen it. For a few seconds it outshone the sun, and it broke up roughly thirty kilometres above the ground with the energy of about 500 kilotons of explosive. The shock wave reached the city of Chelyabinsk more than two minutes later, when many people had gone to their windows to look. About 1,500 people were treated for injuries, nearly all from flying glass, and several thousand buildings were damaged. Dashboard cameras recorded it from dozens of angles. A half-tonne fragment was later raised from a frozen lake.

Seen from elsewhere. Rumour in Russia at first ran to missile tests and secret weapons. The scientific unease was different: sky surveys had been built to find large asteroids, and studies of this event suggested that objects of its size strike several times more often than had been assumed. A larger tracked asteroid passed Earth harmlessly that evening, by coincidence.

Also on 15 February