Cesena, on the old Roman road between Bologna and Rimini, had stayed loyal to the pope while most of his Italian territories rose against him. That was why Cardinal Robert of Geneva chose it as winter quarters in late 1376. Robert, 34 years old, a cousin of the French king and legate of Pope Gregory XI, had come over the Alps with several thousand Breton mercenaries hired to bring the Papal States to heel. He lodged himself in the citadel, the Murata, and his soldiers in and around the town.
The Bretons had not been paid enough to live on and took what they wanted. On 1 February 1377 a quarrel over meat seized from butchers turned into a riot. The townspeople took up arms and killed some hundreds of the Bretons; the rest fled to the citadel. Robert’s response, according to the Italian chroniclers, was to promise the citizens a full pardon if they laid down their weapons and returned to their homes. They did. He then sent to Faenza, a day’s ride away, for the English company of Sir John Hawkwood, which was also in papal pay.
On the night of 3 February the gates were closed and the English and Bretons were let loose together. The killing went on for three days. The Sienese chronicle has Hawkwood objecting that he could persuade the people to submit peacefully, and the cardinal replying that he wanted ‘blood and justice’. People were cut down in the streets and churches; many who jumped into the moat to escape drowned there. The town was stripped of everything that could be carried.
How many died is not known. Contemporary writers give figures from about 2,500 to 8,000 in a town of perhaps that many inhabitants, swollen by refugees. Several chronicles say that Hawkwood, having done what he was paid to do, sent about a thousand women under escort to Rimini, and allowed some other townspeople to slip away. Thousands of survivors scattered across Romagna as beggars.
News travelled fast. Within weeks Florence’s chancellor was sending letters about Cesena to the courts of Europe, and Robert of Geneva had acquired the names that followed him for the rest of his life: the butcher, the man of blood. He remained a cardinal in good standing. In September 1378, at Fondi, the French cardinals who had repudiated the newly elected Urban VI chose Robert as pope in his place. He took the name Clement VII.
How it came to this
The popes had lived at Avignon since 1309, when the Gascon pope Clement V settled there, and their lands in central Italy were governed for them by French legates whom Italians widely resented. In 1375 Florence, fearing papal expansion into Tuscany, went to war with Gregory XI and encouraged the cities of the Papal States to revolt under a red banner bearing the word Libertas. Bologna and dozens of other towns threw out their governors. The conflict is called the War of the Eight Saints, after the Florentine war committee. Gregory answered by placing Florence under interdict and by hiring soldiers.
Italian warfare was by then in the hands of professional companies, many of them veterans of the Anglo-French wars left unemployed by truces. Hawkwood, an Essex tanner’s son, led the most effective of them and changed employers as contracts ran out. Gregory himself had finally left Avignon in the autumn of 1376, urged on by Catherine of Siena among others, and entered Rome on 17 January 1377, two weeks before the massacre carried out in his name.