Parallax

3 February, 1377

A cardinal’s mercenaries sack the town of Cesena

The people of a papal town had been promised pardon if they put down their weapons. The papal legate then sent for more soldiers. Nineteen months later the same man was elected pope by a rival college, and the Church split in two.

Cesena, Romagna, Italy

Cesena, on the old Roman road between Bologna and Rimini, had stayed loyal to the pope while most of his Italian territories rose against him. That was why Cardinal Robert of Geneva chose it as winter quarters in late 1376. Robert, 34 years old, a cousin of the French king and legate of Pope Gregory XI, had come over the Alps with several thousand Breton mercenaries hired to bring the Papal States to heel. He lodged himself in the citadel, the Murata, and his soldiers in and around the town.

The Bretons had not been paid enough to live on and took what they wanted. On 1 February 1377 a quarrel over meat seized from butchers turned into a riot. The townspeople took up arms and killed some hundreds of the Bretons; the rest fled to the citadel. Robert’s response, according to the Italian chroniclers, was to promise the citizens a full pardon if they laid down their weapons and returned to their homes. They did. He then sent to Faenza, a day’s ride away, for the English company of Sir John Hawkwood, which was also in papal pay.

On the night of 3 February the gates were closed and the English and Bretons were let loose together. The killing went on for three days. The Sienese chronicle has Hawkwood objecting that he could persuade the people to submit peacefully, and the cardinal replying that he wanted ‘blood and justice’. People were cut down in the streets and churches; many who jumped into the moat to escape drowned there. The town was stripped of everything that could be carried.

How many died is not known. Contemporary writers give figures from about 2,500 to 8,000 in a town of perhaps that many inhabitants, swollen by refugees. Several chronicles say that Hawkwood, having done what he was paid to do, sent about a thousand women under escort to Rimini, and allowed some other townspeople to slip away. Thousands of survivors scattered across Romagna as beggars.

News travelled fast. Within weeks Florence’s chancellor was sending letters about Cesena to the courts of Europe, and Robert of Geneva had acquired the names that followed him for the rest of his life: the butcher, the man of blood. He remained a cardinal in good standing. In September 1378, at Fondi, the French cardinals who had repudiated the newly elected Urban VI chose Robert as pope in his place. He took the name Clement VII.

How it came to this

The popes had lived at Avignon since 1309, when the Gascon pope Clement V settled there, and their lands in central Italy were governed for them by French legates whom Italians widely resented. In 1375 Florence, fearing papal expansion into Tuscany, went to war with Gregory XI and encouraged the cities of the Papal States to revolt under a red banner bearing the word Libertas. Bologna and dozens of other towns threw out their governors. The conflict is called the War of the Eight Saints, after the Florentine war committee. Gregory answered by placing Florence under interdict and by hiring soldiers.

Italian warfare was by then in the hands of professional companies, many of them veterans of the Anglo-French wars left unemployed by truces. Hawkwood, an Essex tanner’s son, led the most effective of them and changed employers as contracts ran out. Gregory himself had finally left Avignon in the autumn of 1376, urged on by Catherine of Siena among others, and entered Rome on 17 January 1377, two weeks before the massacre carried out in his name.

How each side saw it

Florence and the Italian chroniclers

Nearly everything known about Cesena comes from the pope’s enemies or from horrified neutrals: the Sienese chronicle attributed to Donato di Neri, the chronicles of Bologna, Rimini and Ferrara, and the state letters of the Florentine chancellor Coluccio Salutati, who used the massacre as proof that priests were unfit to rule cities. The poet Franco Sacchetti took to calling Gregory a destroyer of the world. Their accounts agree on the broken promise and the three days of killing. They differ widely on numbers, and they were written by people with every reason to make the Church’s servants look as bad as possible.

The papal side

No defence by Robert of Geneva survives, and Gregory XI issued no condemnation. From the Curia’s point of view the Papal States were the Church’s lawful property, the revolt was rebellion stirred up by a city under interdict, and Cesena’s citizens had murdered several hundred of the legate’s soldiers. Exemplary punishment of a rebellious town was within the accepted customs of war. To the cardinals who elected Robert in 1378 he was a capable, well-born administrator, and the adherents of the Avignon line, including France, Scotland, Castile and Aragon, accepted him as true pope without visible difficulty over Cesena.

Hawkwood and the companies

The mercenaries left contracts and pay records, not reflections. Hawkwood’s modern biographer William Caferro treats the story of his reluctance with caution, since it comes from Italian sources that had cause to shift blame on to the foreign cardinal, and since Hawkwood’s company took a full share of the plunder. What is documented is that he left papal service soon afterwards, married a daughter of Bernabo Visconti of Milan, and ended his career as the honoured captain of Florence, the city that had denounced Cesena loudest. His painted monument is still in its cathedral.

What is disputed

The death toll is the largest uncertainty; modern historians mostly settle on somewhere between 2,500 and 5,000 and regard the higher chronicle figures as rhetorical. The exchange in which Robert demands blood is reported speech in a hostile chronicle. Some accounts date the start of the killing to 1 February, running the riot and the reprisal together. It is also too simple to say that Cesena caused the schism: that arose from the disputed, riotous conclave of April 1378 and Urban VI’s treatment of his cardinals. Whether Urban or Clement was the lawful pope divided canon lawyers at the time, and the Catholic Church now lists Clement as an antipope.

What followed

Gregory XI died in March 1378 and the war with Florence ended that summer. The schism that followed lasted until 1417, with two and eventually three rival popes each excommunicating the others’ followers, and it did lasting damage to papal authority, feeding the conciliar movement and, in the longer run, the arguments of reformers. Clement VII ruled from Avignon until 1394. Cesena passed to the Malatesta family, who rebuilt it. The massacre is still commemorated locally as the ‘sacco dei Bretoni’, and it remains the standard example of what papal government by hired armies could mean.

Read further

  • William Caferro, John Hawkwood: An English Mercenary in Fourteenth-Century Italy (2006)
  • Frances Stonor Saunders, Hawkwood: Diabolical Englishman (2004)
  • Walter Ullmann, The Origins of the Great Schism (1948)
  • Joelle Rollo-Koster, Avignon and Its Papacy, 1309-1417 (2015)
  • Barbara Tuchman, A Distant Mirror: The Calamitous 14th Century (1978)

Same day, other years

1509

A Portuguese fleet destroys its rivals off Diu

Diu, Gujarat, IndiaAsia

Eleven years after Vasco da Gama reached India, the Portuguese viceroy Francisco de Almeida sailed into the harbour of Diu with eighteen ships and attacked a combined fleet sent to drive his countrymen out of the Indian Ocean. It was made up of a Mamluk squadron from Egypt under Amir Husain, built with Venetian and Ottoman help, the galleys of Diu’s governor Malik Ayyaz, and light craft from the Zamorin of Calicut. Portuguese gunnery and boarding parties wrecked it in an afternoon. Almeida, whose son had been killed by the same fleet the year before, had his prisoners hanged, burned or blown from cannon.

Seen from elsewhere. For the Muslim and Gujarati merchants who had run the spice routes to the Red Sea for centuries, this was the arrival of armed toll-collectors in a sea that had been open to all. Malik Ayyaz hedged throughout and made his peace at once. Historians such as Sanjay Subrahmanyam warn against overstating the result: Asian trade adapted and largely carried on.

1966

Luna 9 lands softly on the Moon

Oceanus Procellarum, the MoonWorldwide

After a run of failed attempts, a Soviet probe set a small, petal-sided capsule down intact on the Ocean of Storms and switched on its camera. The pictures it sent over the following days, of rocks and a near horizon under a black sky, were the first ever taken from the surface of another world. They also settled a practical argument. Some scientists had predicted that the Moon was covered in deep, soft dust that would swallow a spacecraft; Luna 9 sat on firm ground. Sergei Korolev, the engineer who had directed the Soviet space effort from Sputnik onward, had died on an operating table three weeks before.

Seen from elsewhere. The first pictures the world saw were not released by Moscow. The Jodrell Bank observatory in England picked up the transmission, recognised it as a standard newspaper wire-photo signal, borrowed a receiver from the Daily Express and published. Soviet scientists were annoyed, and pointed out that the British had printed the images at the wrong proportions.

1969

A parcel bomb kills Eduardo Mondlane

Dar es Salaam, TanzaniaAfrica

Eduardo Mondlane, a herder’s son from southern Mozambique who had become a sociologist in the United States and a United Nations official, had led the Mozambique Liberation Front, FRELIMO, since its founding in exile in 1962. Its guerrillas had been fighting Portuguese rule since 1964. On the morning of 3 February 1969 he collected his post and went to work at a friend’s beach house in Dar es Salaam. One parcel held a book with a bomb inside. It killed him as he opened it. He was 48. Samora Machel emerged from the succession struggle and led Mozambique to independence in 1975.

Seen from elsewhere. Portugal denied involvement. Tanzanian police and later research traced the device to the Portuguese secret police, the PIDE, and its associates. But it reached Mondlane through FRELIMO’s own channels, and the movement accused internal rivals of complicity; some of them were later executed without public trial. Who inside, if anyone, helped has never been established.

1989

Paraguay’s dictator is overthrown by his son’s father-in-law

Asuncion, ParaguayThe Americas

General Alfredo Stroessner had ruled Paraguay since 1954, re-elected eight times under a near-permanent state of siege. On the night of 2 February 1989 tanks commanded by General Andres Rodriguez, his second-in-command and a relative by marriage, attacked the presidential guard. By morning, after several hours of fighting whose death toll was never officially stated, Stroessner had signed his resignation. He was flown to Brazil and died there in 2006, never having faced a court. Rodriguez promised elections, won them himself, and handed over to a civilian in 1993. In 1992 a lawyer and former prisoner, Martin Almada, found the regime’s police archive in a suburban station.

Seen from elsewhere. Stroessner’s Colorado Party stayed in power until 2008, and some Paraguayans still credit him with roads, order and the Itaipu dam. A truth commission reported in 2008 that more than 400 people had been killed or made to disappear and close to 20,000 detained, most of them tortured. The archive also documented Operation Condor, the cooperation of South American dictatorships against exiles.

Also on 3 February