Parallax

16 February, 1940

The Royal Navy boards the Altmark in a Norwegian fjord

A German ship with 299 British prisoners hidden below decks was running for home through neutral waters. Churchill ordered a destroyer in after her, and the neutrality of Norway did not survive the consequences.

Jossingfjord, Norway

The Altmark was a fast naval tanker that had spent the autumn of 1939 in the South Atlantic as supply ship to the pocket battleship Admiral Graf Spee. As the raider sank British merchantmen she passed their crews to the tanker, and when the Graf Spee was cornered and scuttled off Montevideo in December, the Altmark was left with 299 captive seamen in her holds. Her captain, Heinrich Dau, waited for the hunt to die down and then went north, round Iceland, and reached the Norwegian coast near Trondheim on 14 February 1940.

From there he meant to run down the Leads, the sheltered channel inside Norway’s islands, to the Skagerrak and Germany. Norwegian naval officers stopped the ship three times. Dau told them she was a state vessel on her way home, that her guns were stowed, and that she carried no one from a belligerent nation. The prisoners, hearing the boats alongside, hammered on the hatches and blew whistles; the crew ran the winches to cover the noise. The Norwegians did not go below. An admiral at Bergen who was not satisfied was overruled from Oslo, and the Altmark was let through under escort.

British aircraft found her on the afternoon of the 16th. Captain Philip Vian, with the destroyer Cossack and a small flotilla, closed in, and the tanker turned into Jossingfjord, a narrow, ice-choked inlet with cliffs on either side, while two small Norwegian torpedo boats placed themselves across the entrance. Their senior officer told Vian the ship had been examined, was unarmed and had permission to pass.

Vian withdrew and signalled London. Winston Churchill, First Lord of the Admiralty, consulted the Foreign Secretary and then sent the order himself: offer to escort the Altmark back to Bergen jointly with the Norwegians for a proper inspection, and if they refuse, board her. They refused. Late that night the Cossack went in past the Norwegian boats, which did not fire.

The Altmark, searchlights blazing, came astern through the ice to ram and drove herself aground instead. As the hulls ground together a boarding party jumped across with rifles and bayonets. There was a short fight on deck and on the ice as some of the crew ran for the shore; seven Germans were killed, by most counts, and one British sailor was wounded. Then the hatches were broken open. By the account that went round the world next morning, someone shouted down to ask if there were any Englishmen there, and on the answering yell called back: ‘The Navy’s here!’ The Cossack landed all 299 at Leith the following afternoon.

How it came to this

In the first winter of the war Norway mattered to both sides for one reason above others: iron ore. Germany’s steel industry depended on ore from northern Sweden, and when the Baltic froze it came out through the Norwegian port of Narvik and down the Leads, inside territorial waters, where the Royal Navy could not touch it. Churchill had been pressing since September to mine the channel. The Cabinet, anxious about neutral and American opinion, held back. The Soviet attack on Finland in November added a second motive, since any Allied force sent to help the Finns would cross Norway and Sweden and could sit on the ore fields.

Norway had stayed out of the previous war and meant to stay out of this one. Its government, under Johan Nygaardsvold with Halvdan Koht as foreign minister, had a small and long-neglected navy and a coastline of a thousand miles. Its sympathies were largely with Britain and its trade and merchant fleet tied to it, but it feared Germany more. In Berlin, the German naval staff and the Norwegian fascist Vidkun Quisling had already urged Hitler to occupy the country before Britain did; he had ordered a study in December.

How each side saw it

Norway

Oslo protested at once against a gross violation of its territory and demanded the return of the prisoners. Koht’s position was that the Altmark, as a ship in state service, was immune from search, and that nothing in the law of neutrality forbade a belligerent to carry prisoners through neutral waters. Privately Norwegian officers were bitter at having been lied to by Dau and ordered not to resist by their own government. The place gave the language a word: Norwegian Nazis used ‘jossing’ as an insult for pro-British compatriots, and under the occupation people adopted it as a name for patriots.

Germany

German propaganda called it piracy and murder, and published photographs of the dead with the claim that unarmed sailors had been shot on the ice as they fled. Dau’s report insisted his ship had obeyed neutrality rules and had been betrayed by Norwegian passivity. Hitler drew a strategic conclusion from that passivity: Norway either could not or would not keep the British out. Five days later he summoned General Nikolaus von Falkenhorst and gave him command of the operation to occupy Norway and Denmark. Admiral Raeder’s memoirs present the invasion as a move forced on Germany to forestall the Allies.

Britain and the freed seamen

In Britain, after six months of what was being called the phoney war, the rescue was greeted with something like delight. The government’s case was that the Altmark was an armed auxiliary using four hundred miles of neutral coast as a covered way home, which was not innocent passage, and that Norway had failed in a neutral’s duty to investigate. The press described a hell ship. The prisoners’ own later accounts were more measured: they had been cramped, underfed and kept in the dark for months, and they spoke without warmth of Dau, but most had not been physically ill-treated.

What is disputed

The legal question has never been closed. Many international lawyers at the time and since have held that Britain broke Norwegian neutrality and that Norway, by its perfunctory inspections, had already failed to uphold it; which breach came first, and which was graver, is a matter of emphasis. Whether German sailors were shot while trying to escape unarmed, or were firing from the ice, depends on which side’s witnesses are believed. German dead are given as seven or eight. The cry of ‘The Navy’s here’ is attributed to several different men. Historians also disagree on whether the incident caused the German invasion or only hastened a decision that was already forming.

What followed

On 8 April the Royal Navy finally mined the Leads. German warships were already at sea, and before dawn on the 9th troops landed at Oslo, Bergen, Trondheim, Narvik and other ports, and overran Denmark in a morning. The Allied campaign that followed failed and brought down Neville Chamberlain; Churchill, who bore much of the responsibility for it, became prime minister on 10 May. Norway was occupied for five years, its king and government in exile in London and its large merchant fleet in Allied service. The Altmark, renamed, blew up in Yokohama in 1942. The Cossack was torpedoed in the Atlantic in 1941.

Read further

  • Geirr H. Haarr, The Gathering Storm: The Naval War in Northern Europe, September 1939-April 1940 (2013)
  • Philip Vian, Action This Day: A War Memoir (1960)
  • Winston S. Churchill, The Gathering Storm (1948)
  • Francois Kersaudy, Norway 1940 (1990)
  • Willi Frischauer and Robert Jackson, The Navy’s Here! The Altmark Affair (1955)

Same day, other years

1918

Lithuania declares independence under German occupation

Vilnius, LithuaniaEurope

Lithuania had been part of the Russian empire since 1795 and under German military occupation since 1915. In a house on Pilies Street in Vilnius, the twenty members of the Council of Lithuania, chaired by the physician and folklorist Jonas Basanavicius, signed a short act proclaiming the restoration of an independent state with Vilnius as its capital, on democratic principles, free of all former ties to other nations. That last phrase was the bold part. Two months earlier, under German pressure, the same council had promised a permanent alliance with Germany. The occupation authorities confiscated the newspaper that printed the text. Independence became real only after Germany’s collapse that November, and had then to be fought for.

Seen from elsewhere. Germany intended a client kingdom and the council briefly elected a German duke as king. Poles, who with Jews formed most of Vilnius’s population, saw the city as theirs, and a Polish general seized it in 1920. The Bolsheviks proclaimed a Soviet Lithuania. The signed act itself vanished, and was found in a Berlin archive only in 2017.

1923

Howard Carter opens Tutankhamun’s burial chamber

Valley of the Kings, Luxor, EgyptAfrica

Three months after finding the steps to the tomb, Howard Carter stood on a wooden platform in its antechamber before about twenty invited guests, among them his patron Lord Carnarvon and Egyptian and French antiquities officials, and began to chip away the plastered doorway between two black and gold guardian statues. Within minutes his torch showed what looked like a wall of solid gold: the side of a gilded shrine that almost filled the room beyond. Inside it, as the next two years would show, were three more shrines, a stone sarcophagus and three nested coffins, the innermost of solid gold, holding the mummy of a king who had died at about nineteen around 1323 BC. No royal Egyptian burial had been found so nearly intact.

Seen from elsewhere. Egypt had become nominally independent in 1922, and its press resented Carnarvon’s sale of exclusive coverage to The Times of London. The nationalist government locked Carter out in 1924 and kept every object in Egypt. There is good evidence that Carter’s party had secretly entered the chamber months before the ceremony, and that he took some small pieces.

1942

Australian nurses are shot in the sea at Bangka Island

Bangka Island, Dutch East IndiesAsia

The steamer Vyner Brooke left Singapore three days before the surrender, crowded with civilians and sixty-five Australian army nurses. Japanese aircraft sank her off Sumatra on 14 February. Survivors drifted ashore on Bangka Island, where a group gathered on a beach with wounded men from another ship and decided to give themselves up. On 16 February a Japanese patrol arrived. The soldiers took the men round a headland and bayoneted and shot them. They then ordered twenty-two nurses and one civilian woman to walk into the sea and machine-gunned them from behind. Sister Vivian Bullwinkel, shot through the side, floated among the bodies until the patrol left. She was the only woman to survive, hid for twelve days, and spent the rest of the war in prison camps.

Seen from elsewhere. Bullwinkel testified at the Tokyo war crimes tribunal in 1946, but nobody was convicted of the killings. Research published in 2019 by Lynette Silver and others concluded that most of the nurses had been raped before they were shot, and that Bullwinkel had been instructed by Australian officials to leave this out of her evidence.

1959

Fidel Castro becomes prime minister of Cuba

Havana, CubaThe Americas

The dictator Fulgencio Batista had fled Cuba in the first hours of 1959, and the guerrilla leader who had beaten him had said more than once that he wanted no office. A provisional government of respected moderates took over, with a judge, Manuel Urrutia, as president and the lawyer Jose Miro Cardona as prime minister, while Castro kept command of the army and the crowds. It lasted six weeks. Miro Cardona resigned, saying that power lay elsewhere, and on 16 February Castro, aged thirty-two, was sworn in as prime minister with enlarged authority. Land reform, rent cuts and the seizure of foreign-owned estates followed. Urrutia was forced out in July. Castro led Cuba until illness made him step aside in 2006.

Seen from elsewhere. To supporters the revolution brought literacy, clinics and dignity to the poor and ended American control of the economy. To opponents it replaced one dictatorship with another: several hundred people were shot after summary trials in the first months, promised elections were never held, and hundreds of thousands left. Miro Cardona went into exile and headed the council behind the Bay of Pigs landing.

Also on 16 February