Parallax

24 February, 1525

A king captured on the emperor’s birthday

Charles V was born on 24 February, and on his twenty-fifth birthday his army took the King of France prisoner outside Pavia. Five years later to the day, a pope set the imperial crown on his head.

Pavia, Lombardy, Italy

Francis I of France had been besieging Pavia for four months. His army was camped in and around the great walled hunting park of the dukes of Milan, north of the city, and a hungry imperial garrison under the Spaniard Antonio de Leyva held out inside. An imperial relief army had been facing the French lines for three weeks. It was unpaid and close to breaking up, and its commanders, the viceroy of Naples Charles de Lannoy, the marquis of Pescara and the renegade French duke of Bourbon, decided to gamble.

In the dark and rain of the night of 23-24 February 1525, their sappers broke through the brick wall of the park with rams and picks. Before dawn columns of Spanish arquebusiers, German landsknechts under Georg von Frundsberg and light cavalry were pouring through the gaps, the men wearing white shirts over their armour to know each other.

As the mist lifted, Francis saw imperial horsemen in the open and led his armoured cavalry, the pride of France, in a charge that scattered them. He is said to have thought the day won. But the charge had carried him across the front of his own artillery, which had to stop firing, and into broken ground among woods and hedges where Pescara’s arquebusiers were waiting. Shooting from cover at close range, they brought down horses and riders in heaps.

The rest came apart piecemeal. The Black Band, German mercenaries in French pay, were surrounded by Frundsberg’s Germans and killed almost to a man. The Swiss pikemen, attacked from front and rear when Leyva’s garrison sallied out, broke and ran for the river Ticino, where many drowned. The rearguard under the king’s brother-in-law, the duke of Alencon, left the field without fighting.

Francis fought on until his horse was killed under him. Pinned and wounded in the face and hand, he was nearly cut to pieces by soldiers quarrelling over so valuable a prisoner before Lannoy arrived, knelt, and received his sword. It was over by about nine in the morning. Around him lay much of the high nobility of France, among them Bonnivet, the admiral who had urged the siege, the old marshal La Palice, and Richard de la Pole, the last Yorkist claimant to the English throne.

The news took two weeks to reach Madrid. Charles, recovering from a fever, went to pray, and forbade public rejoicing over a victory won with Christian blood.

How it came to this

Charles of Habsburg, born at Ghent on 24 February 1500, inherited more of Europe than anyone since Charlemagne: the Netherlands from his father, Spain, Naples and the new American conquests from his mother’s parents, the Austrian lands from his grandfather Maximilian. In 1519 he was elected Holy Roman Emperor, defeating Francis I, who had spent a fortune on the same electors. France was now ringed by Habsburg territory, and its king had a personal grievance as well.

The battleground was Italy, where French and Spanish armies had fought over Milan and Naples since 1494. Francis had won Milan at Marignano in 1515 and lost it in 1521. In 1523 the greatest noble in France, the constable of Bourbon, quarrelled with the king over an inheritance and defected to the emperor. An imperial invasion of Provence failed in 1524, and Francis chased the retreating army back over the Alps, retook Milan in October, and against the advice of his older captains sat down in front of Pavia for the winter, sending part of his army off towards Naples.

How each side saw it

Francis I and the French

From captivity Francis wrote to his mother, Louise of Savoy, regent in his absence, that of all things nothing remained to him but honour and his life, which was safe. Tradition shortened it to ‘All is lost save honour’. He also wrote a long verse account of the battle, blaming the flight of those who should have supported him. French memoirists such as Martin du Bellay agreed, and blamed Bonnivet’s advice too. In France the defeat was read as the failure of a rash but gallant king, and Louise’s steady government during his imprisonment won her lasting credit.

The emperor’s court

Charles’s chancellor, Mercurino Gattinara, saw the hand of God delivering universal monarchy and urged him to dismember France. Charles’s own letters are more cautious: he wanted Burgundy, his ancestral duchy, and a settled peace so that Christendom could turn on the Turks and on heresy. His soldiers wanted their arrears. Several Spaniards claimed the honour of having taken the king, and Charles later gave grants of arms to more than one. His English ally Henry VIII proposed a joint invasion and partition of France; Charles, with no money, declined, and the alliance cooled.

Italians

For the Italian states the battle exchanged one master for a heavier one. The Florentine historian Francesco Guicciardini, then a papal governor, wrote that the princes of Italy were seized with terror at seeing the emperor’s power left without a counterweight. Pope Clement VII and Venice promptly began intriguing to bring the French back. Lombard chroniclers describe what both armies had done to the countryside: villages emptied, plague and hunger following the troops. The city of Pavia, which had held for the emperor, was sacked by a French army two years later in revenge.

The Ottoman court

With her son a prisoner, Louise of Savoy sent envoys to Constantinople to ask Sultan Suleiman for help against the emperor, and a second envoy, the Croatian noble John Frangipani, got through in late 1525. Suleiman’s reply, preserved in the French archives, tells the king that it is no new thing for emperors to be defeated and taken, and that his horse is saddled and his sword girded day and night. Ottoman sources treat the Franks’ quarrel as an opportunity. The following summer Suleiman destroyed the Hungarian army at Mohacs.

What is disputed

Who actually took the king was contested from the first day; a Basque man-at-arms, Juan de Urbieta, and a Galician, Alonso Pita da Veiga, have the best documented claims. The battle is often called the triumph of the handgun over the armoured knight, but historians note that darkness, mist, broken ground and the French army’s scattered dispositions mattered as much, and the sources disagree on its sequence. French losses are given as anything from six to twelve thousand, imperial losses as a few hundred to fifteen hundred. The famous phrase about honour is a later condensation of a real letter. Charles’s birth date is secure; that 24 February was the feast of St Matthias he himself took as an omen.

What followed

Held in Madrid, Francis signed away Burgundy and his Italian claims in January 1526, handed over two young sons as hostages, and repudiated the treaty as soon as he was across the frontier. The pope joined him in a league against Charles, and in May 1527 the emperor’s unpaid army sacked Rome. Clement made his peace, and on 24 February 1530, at Bologna, crowned Charles emperor, the last time a pope ever did so. Habsburg and Valois went on fighting over Italy until 1559, and the Spanish dominance of the peninsula established at Pavia lasted nearly two centuries.

Read further

  • Geoffrey Parker, Emperor: A New Life of Charles V (2019)
  • R. J. Knecht, Renaissance Warrior and Patron: The Reign of Francis I (1994)
  • Angus Konstam, Pavia 1525: The Climax of the Italian Wars (1996)
  • Francesco Guicciardini, The History of Italy, translated by Sidney Alexander (1969)
  • Jean Giono, Le Desastre de Pavie (1963)

Same day, other years

1582

The pope orders ten days dropped from the calendar

RomeEurope

Julius Caesar’s calendar assumed a year of 365 and a quarter days, about eleven minutes too long. By the sixteenth century the error had pushed the spring equinox ten days away from the date on which the rules for calculating Easter assumed it fell. On 24 February 1582 Pope Gregory XIII signed the bull Inter gravissimas, adopting a scheme devised by the Calabrian physician Aloysius Lilius and worked out by the Jesuit astronomer Christopher Clavius. Ten days would be omitted, so that 4 October 1582 was followed by 15 October, and in future century years would be leap years only if divisible by 400. Spain, Portugal and most of Italy made the change that October, France in December.

Seen from elsewhere. Protestant and Orthodox countries saw a papal decree, not an astronomical correction, and refused it. Protestant Germany held out until 1700, Britain and its colonies until 1752, Russia until 1918 and Greece until 1923. Most Orthodox churches still calculate Easter by the Julian calendar.

1739

Nader Shah breaks the Mughal army at Karnal

Karnal, north of Delhi, IndiaAsia

Nader Shah, a soldier of obscure Turkmen origin who had made himself ruler of Iran, crossed the Khyber in late 1738 and marched on Delhi. The Mughal emperor Muhammad Shah came out to meet him with an army several times larger, encumbered by elephants and an immense camp. On 24 February 1739, at Karnal, Nader drew part of it into an ambush. His disciplined musketeers and light guns mounted on camels did great execution, and in about three hours the Mughal commander-in-chief was mortally wounded and another leading noble captured. The emperor submitted. In Delhi a riot against the occupiers provoked a massacre in which perhaps twenty to thirty thousand people died. Nader left with the Peacock Throne, the Koh-i-Noor and the treasure of two centuries.

Seen from elsewhere. Nader’s court historian presents the invasion as a response to Mughal failure to hand over Afghan fugitives. Indian writers of the time blamed the feud between the emperor’s great nobles, the Nizam and Saadat Khan, and hinted at treachery. Later historians see Karnal as the blow that exposed Mughal weakness to the Marathas, the Afghans and the East India Company.

1942

The refugee ship Struma is sunk

Black Sea, off Istanbul, TurkeyMiddle East

The Struma was a seventy-year-old former cattle barge that left the Romanian port of Constanta in December 1941 carrying nearly 800 Jews trying to reach Palestine. Its engine failed and it was towed into Istanbul, where it lay for ten weeks. Britain, holding to its 1939 limits on Jewish immigration to Palestine, refused visas; Turkey would not let the passengers land without them. On 23 February 1942 Turkish police boarded the ship, cut its anchor and towed it, still without a working engine, out into the Black Sea. The next morning it was torpedoed by a Soviet submarine and sank within minutes. One man, nineteen-year-old David Stoliar, was pulled from the water alive a day later.

Seen from elsewhere. British officials blamed Turkey for towing the ship out; Turkey blamed Britain for refusing entry. In Palestine, posters accused the British high commissioner of murder. That a Soviet submarine, under orders to sink shipping entering the Black Sea, had fired the torpedo was established from Soviet records only decades later. The exact number of dead, usually given as about 780 passengers and crew, is uncertain.

1966

Kwame Nkrumah is overthrown

Accra, GhanaAfrica

Kwame Nkrumah had led the Gold Coast to independence as Ghana in 1957, the first colony in sub-Saharan Africa to win it, and had become the continent’s most prominent voice for unity. By the mid-1960s he had made Ghana a one-party state with himself as president for life, opponents were held without trial, and a collapse in the price of cocoa had left the country deep in debt. On 24 February 1966, while he was in Beijing on his way to Hanoi with a peace plan for Vietnam, army and police officers led by Colonel Emmanuel Kotoka seized Accra. Crowds pulled down his statue. He went into exile in Guinea, whose president named him co-president, and died in 1972.

Seen from elsewhere. The officers said they had ended a dictatorship and economic ruin. Nkrumah, in his book Dark Days in Ghana, said the coup was the work of Western intelligence against African independence. Declassified American documents show Washington knew of the plotting and welcomed the result; whether the CIA did more is disputed. Ghana has since restored him as its founding father.

Also on 24 February