Parallax

22 February, 1358

Murder in the Dauphin’s bedchamber

With the King of France a prisoner in England, the leader of the Paris merchants marched a crowd into the palace and had two royal marshals cut down in front of the eighteen-year-old heir. Then he put his own hood on the boy’s head.

Paris, France

On the morning of Thursday 22 February 1358 Etienne Marcel, a rich draper and provost of the merchants of Paris, the nearest thing the city had to a mayor, assembled some three thousand armed men of the guilds at the church of Saint-Eloi on the Ile de la Cite. Many wore the hood he had made the badge of his party, half red and half blue, the colours of the city.

On their way to the royal palace, a few hundred yards off, part of the crowd met Regnaut d’Acy, one of the Dauphin’s lawyers, who was walking home. They chased him into a pastry-cook’s shop and killed him there.

Marcel and a body of his men then climbed the stairs to the chamber of the Dauphin Charles, duke of Normandy, who had been governing the kingdom since his father’s capture. With the prince were two of his chief military officers: Jean de Conflans, marshal of Champagne, and Robert de Clermont, marshal of Normandy. According to the royal chronicle, Marcel told the Dauphin not to be alarmed by what he was about to see, for it had been decided and it had to be done. His men drew their weapons. Conflans was killed beside the prince’s bed. Clermont fled into an inner room and was killed there. The Dauphin’s robe was splashed with blood.

The prince begged for his life. Marcel told him he had nothing to fear, took off his own red and blue hood and placed it on the Dauphin’s head, and put on the prince’s hat in exchange. It was offered as protection and understood as humiliation. The marshals’ bodies were dragged down to the courtyard and left on the marble block in front of the palace steps, where the crowd could see them.

Marcel went on to the Place de Greve and told the people from a window that the deed had been done for the good of the realm and that the dead men were false and wicked traitors. The crowd shouted its approval. He then returned to the palace and obtained from the Dauphin a public statement that he pardoned and approved what had happened. A few weeks later the Dauphin slipped out of Paris, and did not come back until Marcel was dead.

How it came to this

In September 1356 an English army under the Black Prince destroyed the French host at Poitiers and captured King John II. The nobility, whose whole justification was defence of the kingdom, had failed, and a ransom of ruinous size was in prospect. The Estates-General, called to vote taxes, instead demanded control over how the money was spent and the dismissal of the king’s ministers. Marcel, speaking for the towns, and Robert le Coq, bishop of Laon, led the reformers, and in March 1357 they forced the Great Ordinance on the Dauphin, placing royal finance under supervision by the Estates.

Over the next year the reform movement narrowed to Paris and radicalised. The Dauphin evaded the ordinance and went on debasing the coinage. Marcel looked for a counterweight in Charles of Navarre, a royal cousin with his own claim to the throne. The immediate spark came in January 1358, when a money-changer’s apprentice who had killed the Dauphin’s treasurer was dragged out of a church sanctuary on Marshal Clermont’s orders and hanged. The city gave the murderer a grand funeral, and Marcel attended it.

How each side saw it

Etienne Marcel

Marcel’s case survives in letters he sent that year to the Dauphin and to the towns of Flanders. He presents himself as a loyal subject of the captive king, driven to act because evil counsellors had led the prince to break his sworn promises, leave the country undefended against English and Navarrese companies, and rob the people through bad money. The marshals, he says, were enemies of the common good, and the people of Paris acted as one. He never claimed to be overthrowing the monarchy. His aim, as he put it, was a well-governed kingdom in which the three estates held the crown’s officers to account.

The royal court

The official chronicle of the reign, written under the direction of the chancellor Pierre d’Orgemont, tells the story as an outrage: a subject laying hands on the royal household in the prince’s own chamber, the heir to the throne made to wear a rebel’s livery. It stresses that Clermont had been excommunicated by the bishop over the sanctuary affair, so that his body lay unburied, and that the Dauphin’s consent afterwards was extorted. For Charles, who became one of France’s most capable kings, the lesson was permanent. He later built the Bastille and moved the royal residence out of the old palace.

Jean de Venette, a friar of Paris

The Carmelite friar Jean de Venette, of peasant origin, wrote the one chronicle of these years that sides with the common people. He is scathing about nobles who taxed and pillaged the peasants they were meant to defend and then lost at Poitiers. He records the killing of the marshals without much grief and gives the Parisians’ reasons. Yet he grows steadily more troubled as Marcel’s party allies itself with armed outsiders, and he describes the terror of ordinary people caught between soldiers of every allegiance. His is the nearest thing we have to a view from below.

What is disputed

Whether Marcel planned the killings or merely unleashed them is unknown; the royal chronicle’s speech implies premeditation, but it is a hostile source written later. The larger dispute is about what he was. Nineteenth-century republicans made him a forerunner of 1789 and of parliamentary government, and Paris put up his equestrian statue beside the Hotel de Ville in 1888. Historians such as Raymond Cazelles saw a member of a rich merchant oligarchy with family grudges against royal financiers, using reform for a faction. His final dealings with Charles of Navarre and with English mercenaries have led others to call him a traitor. Details of the scene, including the exchange of hoods, rest on the chronicles alone.

What followed

The Dauphin rallied the nobility in the provinces and blockaded Paris. In May the peasant rising known as the Jacquerie broke out north of the city; Marcel tried to use it, and it was drowned in blood within weeks. Increasingly isolated, he let Navarre’s troops, English among them, into the capital. On the night of 31 July 1358, as he was about to hand over the keys of a city gate, he was killed by a group of Parisians led by Jean Maillart. The Dauphin re-entered Paris two days later. The Estates never again came so close to controlling the French crown.

Read further

  • Jonathan Sumption, The Hundred Years War, Volume II: Trial by Fire (1999)
  • Raymond Cazelles, Etienne Marcel: champion de l’unite francaise (1984)
  • Jean de Venette, The Chronicle of Jean de Venette, translated by Jean Birdsall (1953)
  • Justine Firnhaber-Baker, The Jacquerie of 1358: A French Peasants’ Revolt (2021)

Same day, other years

1632

Galileo’s Dialogue comes off the press

Florence, TuscanyEurope

On 22 February 1632 the first bound copy of Galileo’s Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems was presented to its dedicatee, Grand Duke Ferdinando II of Tuscany. Written in Italian, not Latin, so that any educated person could read it, it stages four days of conversation between Salviati, who argues for Copernicus, the open-minded Sagredo, and Simplicio, a defender of Aristotle who loses every round. Galileo had permission from the Church censors to treat the Earth’s motion as a hypothesis. By summer Rome had ordered sales stopped. Pope Urban VIII, once his admirer, found his own favourite argument placed in Simplicio’s mouth. Galileo was tried in 1633, made to abjure, and confined to his villa for life.

Seen from elsewhere. The Church’s case was that Galileo had been ordered in 1616 not to hold or defend Copernicanism and had concealed this when seeking his licence. There were also sound scientific objections at the time: no stellar parallax could be detected, and his proof from the tides was wrong. The book stayed on the Index until 1835. In 1992 John Paul II acknowledged that the judges had erred.

1819

Spain signs Florida away

Washington, DC, and FloridaThe Americas

On 22 February 1819 the US secretary of state, John Quincy Adams, and the Spanish minister, Luis de Onis, signed a treaty by which Spain ceded Florida and its claims to the Pacific north-west, and the United States took on up to five million dollars of its own citizens’ claims against Spain and gave up, for the time being, its pretensions to Texas. Spain, fighting independence movements across the Americas, could not hold the colony. General Andrew Jackson had shown as much the year before by invading it, seizing Spanish forts and executing two British subjects, on the grounds that Seminoles and people who had escaped slavery were raiding Georgia from Florida.

Seen from elsewhere. The Seminoles and the Black communities living among them were not consulted. For them Spanish Florida had been a refuge from American slavery and settlement; the transfer ended that. Pressure to remove them west led to the Second Seminole War of 1835-42, the longest and costliest of the United States’ wars against Native peoples, and some Seminoles never surrendered.

1986

Two defectors start the People Power revolt

Manila, PhilippinesAsia

Ferdinand Marcos had ruled the Philippines for twenty years, nine of them under martial law. A snap election on 7 February 1986 against Corazon Aquino, widow of an opposition leader murdered at Manila airport in 1983, was declared for Marcos amid open fraud; government tabulators walked out in protest. On 22 February the defence minister, Juan Ponce Enrile, and the deputy chief of staff, Fidel Ramos, whose coup plot had been discovered, barricaded themselves in two military camps and declared for Aquino. Cardinal Jaime Sin went on Catholic radio and asked people to protect them. Hundreds of thousands filled the avenue called EDSA, and nuns and families faced down tanks. Four days later Marcos left for Hawaii in American helicopters.

Seen from elsewhere. Marcos loyalists call it a coup backed by Washington and point out that he would not order troops to fire. Human rights groups count thousands killed and tens of thousands tortured or jailed under his rule, and billions stolen. Critics on the left say the old landed families simply returned. In 2022 Filipinos elected his son president by a wide margin.

2002

Jonas Savimbi is killed and Angola’s war ends

Moxico province, AngolaAfrica

Jonas Savimbi had led the UNITA movement since founding it in 1966, first against Portuguese rule and then, from independence in 1975, against the MPLA government in Luanda. The war became a front of the Cold War: Cuba and the Soviet Union armed the government, South Africa and the United States armed Savimbi, and Ronald Reagan received him at the White House. When he lost an election in 1992 he went back to the bush and financed himself with diamonds. At least half a million people died and about four million were displaced. On 22 February 2002 government troops caught up with him by a river in the remote east and shot him. Six weeks later his commanders signed a ceasefire that has held.

Seen from elsewhere. To many Ovimbundu of the central highlands he spoke for the rural interior against a coastal elite, and UNITA says the 1992 vote was rigged. Former comrades describe a leader who had rivals and their families killed and women burned as witches at his base in Jamba. The government kept his grave unmarked; his family was allowed to rebury him only in 2019.

Also on 22 February