Parallax

17 February, 1673

Molière plays the invalid and dies the same night

France’s greatest comic playwright collapsed while acting a man who only imagines he is ill. Within hours he was dead, and the Church he had mocked would not at first give him a grave.

Paris, France

On Friday 17 February 1673 the Palais-Royal theatre in Paris gave the fourth performance of Le Malade imaginaire, a comedy with music and dance about Argan, a rich hypochondriac who is bled, purged and fleeced by his doctors. Argan was played by the author, Jean-Baptiste Poquelin, known for thirty years as Molière. He was 51, thin, and had been coughing for years with what was almost certainly tuberculosis of the lungs.

According to the earliest biography, written a generation later by Grimarest from the memories of the actor Michel Baron, Molière felt worse than usual that day. His wife Armande and the young Baron begged him not to go on. He is said to have answered that fifty poor workmen had only their day’s wage to live on, and asked what would become of them if the house stayed dark. The curtain went up at four.

He got through the play. In the closing burlesque, in which Argan is admitted as a doctor in dog-Latin and swears the oath with the word ‘Juro’, he was seized by a convulsion. Grimarest says he covered it with a forced laugh, and most of the audience seems to have noticed nothing. Afterwards he sat shivering in Baron’s dressing room, and was carried in a sedan chair the short distance to his house in the rue de Richelieu.

There he began to cough violently and brought up a great quantity of blood. Two nuns who lodged with the family while collecting alms in Paris stayed with him. Because actors were excluded from the sacraments unless they renounced the stage, a priest was needed quickly. By Armande’s account two priests of the parish of Saint-Eustache refused to come, and a third arrived too late. The company’s register, kept by the actor La Grange, records that he died at about ten in the evening.

The parish then refused burial in consecrated ground. Armande petitioned the Archbishop of Paris, Harlay de Champvallon, and went to plead with Louis XIV, who had protected Molière for years. The archbishop gave way on conditions: no solemn service, two priests only, and after dark. On the night of 21 February the coffin was carried to the cemetery of Saint-Joseph, followed by a crowd of several hundred people with torches. Armande had money handed out to the poor who gathered at the door.

The theatre stayed closed for a week. Then the company reopened with Le Misanthrope, and soon afterwards put Le Malade imaginaire back on, with another actor in the dead man’s chair.

How it came to this

Molière was the son of a prosperous Paris upholsterer who held a court appointment. In 1643 he gave up that inheritance to found a theatre company with the Béjart family. It went bankrupt, he was briefly imprisoned for debt, and the troupe spent thirteen years touring the provinces before returning to Paris in 1658 and winning the favour of the young king. From then on he was actor, manager and playwright at once, supplying both the town and the court.

His comedies made enemies. Tartuffe, about a religious fraud who worms his way into a family, was banned from public performance for five years after its first showing in 1664, and the Archbishop of Paris threatened to excommunicate anyone who watched or read it. Dom Juan was withdrawn. The medical faculty, repeatedly ridiculed, had no love for him either. Le Malade imaginaire was written for the court, but the composer Lully had by then secured a royal monopoly on musical spectacle, and Molière, working instead with Marc-Antoine Charpentier, opened it in his own theatre on 10 February 1673.

How each side saw it

The Church in Paris

The diocesan ritual listed actors with usurers, prostitutes and sorcerers as public sinners who could not receive communion or Christian burial unless they repented and gave up their trade. From the parish clergy’s side, Molière had died on the day he performed, without confession or renunciation, and he was the author of Tartuffe. The refusal followed the rules. Two decades later Bishop Bossuet, in his Maxims and Reflections on Comedy, wrote of him without pity as a man who passed from the jests of the theatre to the tribunal of the judge who said ‘Woe to you that laugh now’.

Armande Béjart, his widow

Armande’s petition to the archbishop survives. She states that her husband wished to die a good Christian, asked for a priest, and sent his servants repeatedly to Saint-Eustache, where two named priests refused and a third came after he was dead. She adds that he had received the sacraments the previous Easter from his confessor. Her case is that the Church was punishing a man for a delay its own clergy had caused. She was 31, an actress in the company, and the target of pamphlets that questioned her birth and her fidelity.

The company

For the actors the death was a professional catastrophe as well as a loss. La Grange’s register marks the date with a black lozenge and a few plain lines. Within weeks Lully obtained the Palais-Royal for his opera and four leading players left for a rival house. Armande and La Grange kept the rest together, moved to the rue Guénégaud and merged with the Marais troupe. La Grange later helped edit the first collected edition of the plays in 1682, with a preface that is the earliest account of his master’s life.

What is disputed

Molière did not die on stage, though the legend persists; he died at home some hours later. The details of his last day rest largely on Grimarest’s Life of 1705, which Boileau, who knew Molière, dismissed as full of errors, and modern biographers such as Georges Forestier treat the speech about the fifty workmen with caution. The theatrical superstition that green is unlucky is often traced to his costume that night, but there is no good evidence for it. It is also doubtful that the bones moved from Saint-Joseph in 1792, and reburied at Père Lachaise in 1817, are his.

What followed

In 1680 Louis XIV ordered the Paris troupes to merge, creating the Comédie-Française, which still calls itself the House of Molière and still performs his plays more often than any other author’s. An armchair said to be the one used in the last performance is kept there. In France the standing of actors before the Church remained a grievance for a century: Voltaire raged at the refusal of burial to the actress Adrienne Lecouvreur in 1730, and the civil disabilities of actors were lifted only in the Revolution.

Read further

  • Jean-Léonor Le Gallois de Grimarest, La Vie de M. de Molière (1705)
  • Charles Varlet de La Grange, Registre de La Grange, 1659-1685
  • Virginia Scott, Molière: A Theatrical Life (2000)
  • Georges Forestier, Molière (2018)

Same day, other years

1600

Giordano Bruno is burned in Rome

Campo de’ Fiori, RomeEurope

Giordano Bruno, a former Dominican friar from Nola near Naples, had spent fifteen years wandering Europe teaching that the universe was infinite, that the stars were suns with worlds of their own, and a good deal else about God, the soul and magic. Denounced in Venice in 1592, he was handed to the Roman Inquisition and held for seven years. He finally refused to retract. On 17 February 1600 he was led to the Campo de’ Fiori with his tongue clamped, stripped, tied to a stake and burned alive. A witness, Gaspar Schoppe, reported that he had told his judges they perhaps pronounced sentence with more fear than he received it.

Seen from elsewhere. The Church has held that Bruno was condemned for theology, including denial of the Trinity and of transubstantiation, not for astronomy; most of the trial record is lost, so the weight given to his cosmology is argued over. In 2000 Cardinal Sodano called the burning a sad episode without lifting the verdict. The statue on the spot was raised by anticlericals in 1889 over papal protest.

1909

Geronimo dies a prisoner of war

Fort Sill, OklahomaThe Americas

Goyahkla, the Bedonkohe Apache known to Mexicans and Americans as Geronimo, had fought both since Mexican soldiers killed his mother, wife and children in the 1850s. His surrender to General Nelson Miles in 1886, with fewer than forty followers, ended the Apache wars. The whole Chiricahua people, including scouts who had served the US Army against him, were then shipped to Florida, Alabama and finally Fort Sill as prisoners of war. He became a paid attraction at fairs and rode in Theodore Roosevelt’s inaugural parade in 1905, when he asked to go home to Arizona and was refused. In February 1909 he fell from his horse, lay out all night in the cold, and died of pneumonia on the 17th.

Seen from elsewhere. To settlers in Arizona and Sonora he was a murderer whose raids killed many civilians. Among Apaches the memory is divided too: some honoured him as the last to hold out, others blamed him for 27 years of exile imposed on the whole tribe. His nephew reported that he died regretting the surrender. The Chiricahuas were released only in 1913.

1979

China invades Vietnam

Sino-Vietnamese borderAsia

Before dawn on 17 February 1979 Chinese artillery opened fire along the whole Vietnamese frontier and some 200,000 or more troops crossed it. Weeks earlier Vietnam, newly allied to the Soviet Union, had invaded Cambodia and overthrown the Khmer Rouge, a Chinese client; Hanoi had also driven out large numbers of ethnic Chinese. Deng Xiaoping, just back from Washington, said Vietnam needed to be taught a lesson. The People’s Liberation Army, which had not fought a war for a generation, took heavy losses against border militia and regional forces, captured the town of Lang Son, declared its aims achieved and withdrew by mid-March, destroying infrastructure as it went.

Seen from elsewhere. Beijing calls it a ‘self-defensive counterattack’ and a success; Hanoi calls it a war against Chinese expansionism and a victory. Each side’s casualty claims are disputed, with outside estimates running to tens of thousands dead on each side. Vietnam stayed in Cambodia until 1989. Both governments now keep public commemoration muted.

2011

Libya’s ‘Day of Rage’

Benghazi, LibyaAfrica

Protests had begun in Benghazi two days earlier, after the arrest of Fathi Terbil, a lawyer for the families of some 1,200 prisoners killed at Abu Salim jail in 1996. Exiles and activists had called for a national day of protest on 17 February, the anniversary of a demonstration in the city that security forces had shot down in 2006. Crowds came out in Benghazi, Bayda, Zintan and elsewhere, and were fired on. Within days army units in the east defected and Benghazi was in rebel hands. A United Nations resolution in March authorised force to protect civilians, NATO aircraft intervened, and Muammar Gaddafi was captured and killed in October after 42 years in power.

Seen from elsewhere. Gaddafi called the protesters rats, drugged youths and agents of al-Qaeda. Russia, China, South Africa and the African Union argued that NATO stretched a mandate to protect civilians into the overthrow of a government. Libyans who still mark the date as a liberation, and those who mourn it, both point to the years of militia rule and civil war that followed.

Also on 17 February