Parallax

19 February, 1945

The Marines land on Iwo Jima

American planners expected to take eight square miles of volcanic rock in about a week. It took five, against a garrison that had been ordered to die underground and very nearly all did.

Iwo Jima, Volcano Islands, Japan

At about nine in the morning on 19 February 1945 the first waves of the US 4th and 5th Marine Divisions came ashore on the south-east beaches of Iwo Jima, a pork-chop-shaped island roughly halfway between the American bomber bases in the Marianas and Tokyo. For the first few minutes almost nothing was fired at them. The beach was steep terraces of soft black volcanic ash, in which men sank to their ankles and vehicles to their axles, and it filled quickly with troops and equipment.

That was what the Japanese commander, Lieutenant General Kuribayashi Tadamichi, had been waiting for. He had forbidden the defence at the waterline and the mass suicide charges that had wasted Japanese garrisons elsewhere. Instead his roughly 21,000 men had spent eight months digging: hundreds of concrete blockhouses, gun positions bored into the rock, and miles of tunnels, in sulphurous heat, linking them. After about an hour, with the beach crowded, his artillery and mortars opened on registered targets. By nightfall some 30,000 Americans were ashore and about 2,400 of them were casualties.

The Marine commanders had asked for ten days of preliminary naval bombardment and been given three. It had hardly touched the buried defences. From then on the battle was fought yard by yard with flamethrowers, demolition charges and tanks, against an enemy the attackers rarely saw. Mount Suribachi, the extinct volcano at the southern tip, was cut off and climbed on 23 February, where the raising of a flag was photographed. The larger and worse part of the fight, for the rocky plateau in the north, went on for another month.

Kuribayashi’s last message to Tokyo went out in mid-March. He is believed to have died around 26 March, in or after a final night attack on American tents near the airfields; his body was never identified. The island was declared secure that day.

Nearly 7,000 Americans had been killed and about 20,000 wounded, the only major battle of the Pacific war in which American casualties exceeded Japanese. Of the Japanese garrison only about a thousand were taken prisoner, some of them Korean conscript labourers. Small groups went on hiding in the caves; the last two surrendered in January 1949. The dead of both sides lay on an island a man could walk across in a couple of hours.

How it came to this

By late 1944 American B-29 bombers were flying from Saipan, Tinian and Guam against the Japanese home islands, a round trip of some 3,000 miles. Iwo Jima lay on the route. It had radar that gave Tokyo warning, airfields from which fighters could harass the bombers, and it was Japanese home territory, administered as part of Tokyo prefecture. American planners wanted it as a base for escort fighters and as an emergency field. The landing, Operation Detachment, was delayed while the fleet supported the reconquest of the Philippines.

The delay was Kuribayashi’s opportunity. A cavalry officer who had served as an attache in the United States and Canada and had a clear view of American industrial power, he arrived in June 1944, evacuated the island’s thousand or so civilians, and overruled subordinates who wanted to fight on the beaches. He told his men that each should kill ten of the enemy before dying. He knew no relief would come: the Japanese fleet had been broken at Leyte Gulf, and his task was to make the price of approaching Japan as high as possible.

How each side saw it

The Japanese garrison

Kuribayashi’s letters home, published in Japan long after the war, are those of a husband fussing about draughts in the kitchen floor and telling his children not to expect him back. Kakehashi Kumiko’s study of them shows a commander who thought the war lost and said so, yet built the most effective defence of the Pacific war. Few of his soldiers left testimony, because few lived. Survivors described thirst, heat so great they fought nearly naked, and comrades who killed themselves with grenades. Recovery of the dead continues: the remains of roughly half the garrison have never been found.

The Marines

For the men who landed, the island became the measure of everything else. Admiral Nimitz’s phrase that ‘uncommon valor was a common virtue’ was meant and received as plain fact, and 27 Medals of Honor were awarded, more than for any other single battle of the war. Veterans’ accounts dwell on the invisibility of the enemy and the randomness of death from mortars. Their commander ashore, General Holland Smith, blamed the navy bitterly for the short bombardment. Black Marines served in segregated ammunition and depot companies on the beaches under fire, and Navajo code talkers handled much of the radio traffic.

Koreans and islanders

Among the garrison were some hundreds of Korean labourers, conscripted by Japan to dig the fortifications; their numbers are uncertain and they appear in the record mainly as prisoners. The island’s own civilian population, farmers and sulphur miners, had been removed to the mainland in 1944, though some men were kept back as military labour and died there. The former residents and their descendants have never been allowed to resettle. The United States administered the island until 1968, and since then it has been a Japanese military base, open to them only for memorial visits.

What is disputed

Whether the island was worth its cost has been argued since 1945. The standard justification is that 2,251 B-29s later made emergency landings there, carrying some 24,000 airmen. The Marine historian Robert Burrell showed in 2006 that most of those landings were for refuelling or training and not emergencies, that fighter escorts flew few effective missions, and that the life-saving argument was assembled after the event to answer public shock at the casualties. Others reply that the planners judged on what they knew. The circumstances of Kuribayashi’s death are also unknown, and the identities of the men in the flag photograph were corrected as recently as 2016 and 2019.

What followed

The battle, and Okinawa after it, shaped American expectations of what invading Japan itself would cost, and so entered every later argument about the atomic bombs. Joe Rosenthal’s photograph of the second flag-raising on Suribachi became the most reproduced image of the war and the model for the Marine Corps memorial at Arlington. In Japan the battle was little discussed for decades. Joint memorial services by American and Japanese veterans and families began on the island in 1985. In 2007 Japan restored the island’s prewar name, Ioto.

Read further

  • Richard F. Newcomb, Iwo Jima (1965)
  • Robert S. Burrell, The Ghosts of Iwo Jima (2006)
  • Kumiko Kakehashi, So Sad to Fall in Battle: An Account of War Based on General Tadamichi Kuribayashi’s Letters from Iwo Jima (2007)
  • James Bradley with Ron Powers, Flags of Our Fathers (2000)

Same day, other years

1473

Copernicus is born

Torun, Royal Prussia, PolandEurope

Nicolaus Copernicus was born on 19 February 1473 to a merchant family in Torun, a Hanseatic town on the Vistula under the Polish crown. Orphaned young, he was raised by an uncle who became a bishop and who got him a lifelong post as a cathedral canon at Frombork on the Baltic. He studied at Krakow, Bologna and Padua, practised medicine, administered church estates and wrote on currency reform. In his spare time he worked out a system in which the Earth turned daily and circled the Sun yearly. He let a short sketch circulate in manuscript but held back the full book, On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres, until 1543, the year he died.

Seen from elsewhere. The book appeared with an unsigned preface by the Lutheran Andreas Osiander saying the theory was only a calculating device, which Copernicus had not approved. Rome placed it on the Index in 1616 ‘until corrected’. Poles and Germans later quarrelled over his nationality, a question that would have meant little to a Latin-writing subject of the Polish king.

1600

Huaynaputina explodes

Moquegua, southern PeruThe Americas

After days of earthquakes, a volcano called Huaynaputina, some seventy kilometres from the Spanish colonial city of Arequipa, blew apart on 19 February 1600. It was the largest eruption in South America in recorded history. The explosions went on into March. Ash buried a dozen or more Andean villages, killing perhaps 1,500 people, dammed the Tambo river, and darkened Arequipa for days while roofs collapsed under the weight. The damage to vineyards, fields and herds ruined the regional economy for a generation. Sulphur thrown into the stratosphere cooled the northern hemisphere: 1601 was among the coldest summers in six centuries, and the Russian famine of 1601-03, which killed a large part of the population, has been linked to it.

Seen from elsewhere. Spanish clergy described the event as divine punishment and led penitential processions. Colonial writers, who are our only source for Indigenous views, reported that Andean people believed the mountain was angry because its offerings had been abandoned under Christian rule, and that sacrifices were made to it before the eruption. The link to the Russian famine was proposed by scientists only in 2008.

1942

Roosevelt signs Executive Order 9066

Washington, DCThe Americas

Ten weeks after Pearl Harbor, President Franklin Roosevelt signed an order allowing the army to designate military areas from which any person could be excluded. It named no group, but it was used, on the urging of General John DeWitt and West Coast politicians, against people of Japanese descent. Over the following months about 120,000 men, women and children, some two-thirds of them American citizens, were removed from California, Oregon and Washington, held in assembly centres at racetracks and fairgrounds, and sent to ten camps in the interior behind barbed wire. Most lost homes, farms and businesses. The Supreme Court upheld the exclusion in the Korematsu case in 1944.

Seen from elsewhere. Officials pleaded military necessity. Yet naval intelligence and the FBI had advised that there was no significant threat, and no Japanese American was ever convicted of espionage or sabotage. A federal commission concluded in 1983 that the causes were race prejudice, war hysteria and a failure of political leadership. Congress apologised and paid surviving internees $20,000 each from 1988.

1997

Deng Xiaoping dies

Beijing, ChinaAsia

Deng Xiaoping died on 19 February 1997 aged 92, holding no office but still the final authority in China. A Communist since his student days in France in the 1920s and a veteran of the Long March, he was twice purged during the Cultural Revolution, when his son was crippled after a fall from a window while in the hands of Red Guards. After Mao’s death he outmanoeuvred Mao’s chosen successor and from 1978 dismantled the communes, opened the coast to foreign investment and let markets work, a course he restarted with his southern tour of 1992. Hundreds of millions of people left poverty in the decades that followed. At his own request his ashes were scattered at sea.

Seen from elsewhere. Deng also ran the Anti-Rightist Campaign of 1957 and, in June 1989, approved the use of the army against protesters around Tiananmen Square, where hundreds and possibly more than a thousand died. The party’s verdict is that he restored stability. The Tiananmen Mothers, relatives of the dead, have asked for decades for an accounting and still cannot mourn in public.

Also on 19 February