Parallax

20 February, 1810

Andreas Hofer is shot at Mantua

An innkeeper and cattle dealer had driven Napoleon’s allies out of the Tyrol three times in one year. Abandoned by the emperor he fought for, he was betrayed for a reward and executed on Napoleon’s direct order.

Mantua, northern Italy

Shortly before eleven on the morning of 20 February 1810, a tall, heavy man of 42 with a black beard down to his chest was marched out to the bastion by the Porta Ceresa in the fortress of Mantua. Andreas Hofer had been tried the day before by a French court martial whose verdict had been settled in advance. Napoleon had written to his stepson Eugene, the viceroy of Italy, that Hofer was to be brought before a military commission and shot within twenty-four hours.

He had spent his last night writing. A letter to a friend in the Passeier valley arranges for his debts to be paid and for a funeral mass and a meal of soup, meat and wine for the mourners at his own inn, and ends by bidding the wicked world farewell, saying that dying came so easily to him that his eyes were not even wet. He gave away his last coins to the soldiers of the escort.

By the accounts of those present, including the priest who attended him, Hofer refused a blindfold and would not kneel. He is said to have given the order to fire himself. The first volley brought him to his knees and the second did not kill him either; a corporal finished it with a shot to the head. The remark often put in his mouth at this point, a complaint about how badly the grenadiers shot, is tradition and cannot be securely traced to a witness.

Six months earlier this man had been living in the imperial palace at Innsbruck as regent of the Tyrol, signing decrees in the name of the Austrian emperor. He had come to it by leading the armed peasantry of the valleys, organised in their old rifle companies, against the Bavarian government installed in 1806 and against the French and Saxon troops sent to support it. On the Bergisel, the hill above Innsbruck, his men had won in April, in May and again in August 1809.

Then Austria made peace and gave the Tyrol up. Hofer submitted, was persuaded by hotter heads that the peace was a lie, took up arms again in November and was beaten. With a price of 1,500 gulden on his head he hid through the winter with his wife, his son and his young secretary in a herdsman’s hut high on the Pfandler alp. A neighbour, Franz Raffl, told the French where he was. Italian troops climbed up in the dark and took him on 28 January.

How it came to this

The Tyrol had belonged to the Habsburgs since 1363 and had an unusual constitution: its peasants were free, sat in the provincial diet, and under a charter of 1511 owed military service only in defence of their own land. After the Austrian defeat at Austerlitz, the Treaty of Pressburg handed the province to Bavaria, Napoleon’s ally. The Bavarian minister Montgelas was a man of the Enlightenment in a hurry. His officials abolished the diet, raised taxes, devalued the Austrian paper money people held, and removed the very name of Tyrol from the map.

They also reached into the churches. Midnight mass at Christmas, processions, pilgrimages and the ringing of bells against storms were banned, religious holidays were cut, priests who objected were deported, and smallpox vaccination was made compulsory, which many took for an attack on God’s providence. The final provocation was conscription into the Bavarian army in early 1809. When Austria went to war with France that April, its agents had already agreed a rising with Hofer and other local leaders.

How each side saw it

The Bavarian administration

Montgelas and his officials saw themselves as bringing rational government, equality before the law, public health and schooling to a backward mountain province ruled by monks and custom. Their reports describe the rising as fanaticism whipped up by friars, above all the red-bearded Capuchin Joachim Haspinger, and paid for with Austrian and English money. Bavarian accounts also record what happened when the insurgents took Innsbruck in April 1809: officials were beaten, and the houses of the town’s Jewish families were plundered. The reforms the Tyroleans fought against, vaccination among them, were later kept by Austria.

The court in Vienna

Emperor Francis I encouraged the rising, sent Hofer a gold chain, and promised in a handwritten note of May 1809 that he would never sign a peace separating the Tyrol from Austria. After the defeat at Wagram he signed exactly that at Schonbrunn in October, and his envoys told the Tyroleans to lay down their arms. Vienna made no serious attempt to save Hofer. Three weeks after the execution the emperor’s daughter Marie Louise was married by proxy to Napoleon. The dynasty later ennobled Hofer’s family and brought his body home, embracing a loyalty it had found inconvenient at the time.

Modern Tyrolean and Austrian historians

For two centuries Hofer was the freedom hero of the German Tyrol, claimed in turn by Habsburg loyalists, German nationalists, National Socialists and South Tyrolean campaigners against Italian rule. Since the 1980s historians such as Meinrad Pizzinini, Andreas Oberhofer and Laurence Cole have drawn a different figure from his surviving letters: a devout, hesitant, not very decisive man, pushed forward by others, whose aims were the old religion and the old privileges. As regent he issued decrees against dancing and against women showing bare arms. His rising, on this reading, was a conservative revolt against modernity, and the hero was largely made afterwards.

What is disputed

The details of the execution vary between witnesses, and the famous last words are unverified. More substantial is the argument over what kind of event 1809 was: a national war of liberation, as the nineteenth century had it, or a defence of Catholic custom and local privilege with little ‘German’ or even ‘Austrian’ feeling in it. Italian-speaking Tyroleans from the Trentino took part too, which complicates later nationalist uses. Raffl, the informer, has been called the Judas of Tyrol; why he acted, for the reward or from a grudge, is unknown. Hofer’s renewed revolt in November, after he had accepted the amnesty, is the reason Napoleon gave for denying him mercy.

What followed

In 1823 Tyrolean riflemen dug up Hofer’s remains at Mantua without authority and carried them to Innsbruck, where they lie in the court church. Julius Mosen’s poem of 1831, set to music as ‘Zu Mantua in Banden’, became the anthem of the Austrian state of Tyrol in 1948. The Tyrol returned to Austria in 1814. After 1919, when the land south of the Brenner, including Hofer’s own valley, passed to Italy, his name became a rallying point in the long dispute over South Tyrol, and the anniversaries of 1809 are still marked on both sides of the border.

Read further

  • F. Gunther Eyck, Loyal Rebels: Andreas Hofer and the Tyrolean Uprising of 1809 (1986)
  • Meinrad Pizzinini, Andreas Hofer: Seine Zeit, sein Leben, sein Mythos (1984)
  • Andreas Oberhofer, Der Andere Hofer: Der Mensch hinter dem Mythos (2009)
  • Laurence Cole, ‘Fur Gott, Kaiser und Vaterland’: Nationale Identitat der deutschsprachigen Bevolkerung Tirols 1860-1914 (2000)

Same day, other years

1835

An earthquake destroys Concepcion, and Darwin takes notes

Concepcion and Valdivia, ChileThe Americas

On the morning of 20 February 1835 Charles Darwin, ashore from HMS Beagle, was lying in a wood near Valdivia when the ground began to move. It lasted two minutes and made him giddy. Two hundred miles north the same earthquake flattened the city of Concepcion, and a series of great waves swept its port, Talcahuano, carrying a schooner into the middle of the ruins. Arriving two weeks later, Darwin found not a house standing. Captain FitzRoy measured beds of dead mussels lifted up to ten feet above the tide line on a nearby island. For Darwin it was proof of what Charles Lyell had argued: that mountains are raised little by little, by forces still at work.

Seen from elsewhere. Darwin recorded that the death toll was low, perhaps under a hundred, because people ran outdoors at the first tremor. He also noted that poorer townspeople blamed the disaster on old Indigenous women who had stopped up a volcano out of spite. Mapuche tradition has its own account of earthquakes and floods, as the struggle of two great serpents, of land and sea.

1947

Britain names the date for leaving India

London, and British IndiaAsia

On 20 February 1947 the prime minister, Clement Attlee, told the House of Commons that Britain would hand over power in India not later than June 1948, to a single government if Indians could agree on one and otherwise to whatever authorities seemed best. He announced at the same time that Lord Mountbatten would replace Lord Wavell as viceroy. Britain was close to bankrupt, its administration in India was failing, and communal killing had been spreading since the Calcutta riots of August 1946. Once in Delhi, Mountbatten brought the date forward to 15 August 1947 and accepted partition. The border was drawn in five weeks and published two days after independence.

Seen from elsewhere. Churchill called it a shameful flight. The Congress welcomed the deadline; the Muslim League read it as a reason to hold out for Pakistan. Historians still dispute whether the fixed date and its acceleration forced a settlement or set off the scramble in Punjab, where between several hundred thousand and two million people died and more than ten million fled.

1962

John Glenn orbits the Earth

Cape Canaveral, FloridaThe Americas

After ten postponements, the Marine pilot John Glenn was launched on an Atlas rocket on the morning of 20 February 1962 and circled the Earth three times in a capsule he had named Friendship 7. The flight lasted just under five hours. During it a signal suggested that the heat shield had come loose, and controllers had him keep the retro-rocket pack strapped on through re-entry in the hope it would hold the shield in place; the signal proved false. Before launch Glenn had asked that the computer’s trajectory figures be checked by hand by the mathematician Katherine Johnson. He came home to a parade in New York and a welcome of a kind not seen since Lindbergh.

Seen from elsewhere. The Soviet Union had put Yuri Gagarin in orbit ten months earlier, and Gherman Titov had already spent a full day in space. Later in 1962 Glenn told a congressional hearing on whether women should be astronauts that men flying and women staying home was simply a fact of the social order. Thirteen women had privately passed the same medical tests.

1988

Nagorno-Karabakh votes to leave Azerbaijan

Stepanakert (Khankendi), Soviet AzerbaijanAsia

Nagorno-Karabakh was a mountainous region with an Armenian majority that Soviet authorities had placed inside the Azerbaijani republic in the early 1920s. On 20 February 1988, emboldened by Gorbachev’s reforms and by a week of rallies, its regional council voted 110 to 17 to ask Moscow to transfer it to Soviet Armenia. Huge crowds gathered in Yerevan in support. Moscow refused. Within days there was a pogrom against Armenians in the Azerbaijani town of Sumgait, and Azerbaijanis were being driven from Armenia. As the Soviet Union dissolved the dispute became a war that killed some 30,000 people and displaced about a million before a ceasefire in 1994 left Armenians holding the region and the districts around it.

Seen from elsewhere. Armenians invoked self-determination and an injustice of the 1920s. Azerbaijanis invoked territorial integrity, noted that Azerbaijani deputies took no part in the vote, and pointed to the expulsion of hundreds of thousands of their own people. Azerbaijan retook the territory in 2020 and 2023, and almost its entire Armenian population, about 100,000 people, left.

Also on 20 February