Parallax

25 February, 1841

A tailor’s son from Limoges

Renoir began by painting roses on teacups for a few sous a piece. He ended in a wheelchair in the south of France, still at the easel, loved by the public and argued over by almost everyone else.

Limoges, France

Pierre-Auguste Renoir was born in Limoges on 25 February 1841, the sixth child of Leonard Renoir, a tailor, and Marguerite Merlet, a seamstress. When he was three the family moved to Paris and took rooms in a run-down quarter that then stood between the Louvre and the Tuileries. He grew up within sight of the royal collections and with no money at all.

At thirteen he was apprenticed to a porcelain painter. He started on flower sprays and graduated to profiles of Marie Antoinette, and he was quick enough to earn a man’s wage while still a boy. Then transfer printing arrived and put the hand-painters out of work. He turned to fans, and to cloth blinds that missionaries carried abroad to serve as stained glass, saved what he could, and in 1862 entered the Ecole des Beaux-Arts and the teaching studio of Charles Gleyre. There he met Claude Monet, Alfred Sisley and Frederic Bazille.

In the summer of 1869 he and Monet set up their easels side by side at La Grenouillere, a floating cafe and bathing place on the Seine, and painted the broken light on the water in quick separate touches. Both were so poor that Renoir carried bread from his parents’ table to Monet’s household. The war of 1870 scattered them. Bazille was killed in it. Renoir was called up to a cavalry regiment, fell ill with dysentery and saw no fighting.

In April 1874 the group, tired of rejection by the official Salon, hired the former studio of the photographer Nadar on the boulevard des Capucines and showed on their own. Renoir hung the pictures and exhibited La Loge. The press was mostly derisive. Two years later the critic Albert Wolff, writing in Le Figaro, said that someone should explain to Monsieur Renoir that a woman’s torso was not a heap of decomposing flesh with green and purple patches. In the same year Renoir painted the Sunday dancers at the Moulin de la Galette in Montmartre under dappled sunlight.

Success came through portraits. His picture of Madame Charpentier and her children, shown at the Salon of 1879, brought commissions, and he stopped exhibiting with his old friends. A journey to Italy in 1881, where he studied Raphael and the wall paintings from Pompeii, left him convinced, as he later told the dealer Ambroise Vollard, that he had gone as far as Impressionism could take him and knew neither how to paint nor how to draw. He began again with harder outlines.

From the 1890s rheumatoid arthritis deformed his hands and then took his legs. He moved to Cagnes-sur-Mer on the Mediterranean, bought the olive farm of Les Collettes in 1907, and worked from a wheelchair with the brush placed between his fingers by an assistant. He died there on 3 December 1919, leaving some four thousand paintings.

How it came to this

French painting in Renoir’s youth was governed from the centre. The Academie des Beaux-Arts controlled the school, the prizes and the jury of the annual Salon, which was almost the only place a painter could find buyers. It ranked subjects in order of dignity, with history and myth at the top and landscape and everyday life near the bottom, and it expected a smooth finish in which the brush did not show. In 1863 so many works were refused that Napoleon III allowed a Salon des Refuses, at which Manet’s Dejeuner sur l’herbe caused a scandal and showed younger painters that there was an audience outside the system.

Other things had changed too. Paint now came in metal tubes, which made working outdoors practical. Railways put the riverside villages west of Paris within an hour of the city, and Haussmann’s rebuilding had filled the capital with boulevards, cafes and a middle class at leisure. Photography had taken over the job of exact likeness. Dealers, above all Paul Durand-Ruel, were starting to buy directly from artists and sell abroad, especially in the United States, which is how the Impressionists eventually found their market.

How each side saw it

The Salon critics of the 1870s

To Albert Wolff of Le Figaro, Louis Leroy of Le Charivari and most of the Paris press, the pictures shown in 1874 and 1876 were unfinished sketches passed off as paintings. Leroy’s mocking review gave the group its name. Their objection was not only taste. Finish stood for training, effort and respect for the public, and the visible brushstroke looked to them like a refusal of all three. Wolff described the 1876 exhibitors as lunatics. Within twenty years the same newspapers treated Renoir as a master, and the French state, which had refused part of the Caillebotte bequest of Impressionist pictures in the 1890s, bought his work.

The women who sat for him

Renoir’s art depends on women who left almost no words of their own. Lise Trehot, his model and companion in the 1860s, bore him a daughter, Jeanne, in 1870, whom he supported in secret for the rest of his life; the fact came to light only through letters studied long after his death. Aline Charigot, a dressmaker, lived with him for a decade before they married in 1890. Gabrielle Renard, hired as a nurse for his son Jean, posed for him for some twenty years. Renoir held that women should not be lawyers, writers or politicians. The art historian Tamar Garb and others have read his nudes in the light of those opinions.

Fellow painters and later detractors

Opinion among artists has never settled. Mary Cassatt, who had exhibited with the group, found the heavy, red-toned nudes of his last years distasteful and said so in her letters. Matisse and Picasso admired exactly those pictures, visited or collected him, and learned from them. The American collector Albert Barnes bought 181 of his works. During the Dreyfus affair Renoir sided against Dreyfus, and Julie Manet’s diary records anti-Jewish remarks he made at table, including about his old colleague Pissarro. In 2015 a small protest outside the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston demanded that his paintings be taken down as simply bad.

What is disputed

The date and place of birth are secure, from the Limoges civil register. Much else rests on two affectionate and unreliable books, Vollard’s record of conversations and the memoir his son Jean, the film director, wrote four decades after his death. The story that brushes were strapped to his hands is a legend: film shot at Cagnes in 1915 shows him holding the brush, and the linen strips protected his skin. Jean Renoir’s tale that a Communard official saved him from being shot as a spy in 1871 cannot be checked. A French court ruled in 1973 that the sculptures issued under his name were co-authored by Richard Guino, who modelled them.

What followed

The Louvre hung his portrait of Madame Charpentier in 1919, and he was carried through the galleries in a chair to see it a few months before he died. Les Collettes is now a museum. His second son, Jean, made La Grande Illusion and La Regle du jeu and wrote the memoir that fixed the image of a cheerful artisan who claimed only to make pretty things. The paintings sell for great sums and fill museum shops. Whether that popularity reflects his achievement or obscures it is the question art historians still put to him.

Read further

  • Barbara Ehrlich White, Renoir: An Intimate Biography (2017)
  • Jean Renoir, Renoir, My Father (1962)
  • Ambroise Vollard, Renoir: An Intimate Record (1925)
  • John Rewald, The History of Impressionism (1946)
  • Julie Manet, Growing Up with the Impressionists: The Diary of Julie Manet (1987)

Same day, other years

1870

Hiram Revels takes a seat in the United States Senate

Washington, DC, United StatesThe Americas

Hiram Rhodes Revels was born free in North Carolina in 1827, became a minister of the African Methodist Episcopal Church and raised Black regiments for the Union during the Civil War. In January 1870 the Reconstruction legislature of Mississippi chose him to fill a Senate seat left empty since the state seceded in 1861. When he presented himself in Washington, Democratic senators spent days arguing that he could not be seated. On 25 February the Senate voted 48 to 8 to admit him, and he was sworn in before crowded galleries as the first Black member of either house of Congress. He served just over a year.

Seen from elsewhere. His opponents argued from the Dred Scott ruling of 1857 that no Black man had been a citizen before 1868, so he could not meet the nine years of citizenship the constitution requires. Revels himself later broke with Mississippi’s Republicans and wrote to President Grant in 1875 criticising them. After 1881 no Black senator sat until 1967.

1956

Khrushchev denounces Stalin behind closed doors

Moscow, Soviet UnionEurope

In the early hours of 25 February 1956, with foreign guests excluded, Nikita Khrushchev spoke for about four hours to the delegates of the Twentieth Congress of the Soviet Communist Party. He told them that Stalin, dead for three years, had built a cult around himself, had ordered the torture and execution of loyal party members on invented charges, and had left the country unprepared for the German invasion of 1941. Delegates listened in silence; some were reported to have been taken ill. The text was read to party meetings across the country, reached the West through Poland and was published in the United States that June.

Seen from elsewhere. The speech blamed one man and left collectivisation, the famine and Khrushchev’s own part in the purges in Ukraine unmentioned. Mao’s China came to treat it as a betrayal, one root of the Sino-Soviet split. In Tbilisi, Georgians protesting in Stalin’s defence were shot in March. Hungarians who took the speech as a promise of change were crushed by Soviet tanks in November.

1986

Two presidents are sworn in, and one flees

Manila, PhilippinesAsia

Ferdinand Marcos had ruled the Philippines for twenty years, nine of them under martial law. After a snap election on 7 February 1986 that both he and Corazon Aquino, widow of the murdered opposition leader Benigno Aquino, claimed to have won, his defence minister and the deputy chief of the armed forces broke with him. Cardinal Jaime Sin called on people over Radio Veritas to protect the rebels, and hundreds of thousands filled the highway known as EDSA, blocking the tanks sent against them. On 25 February Aquino took the oath at a club in the suburbs and Marcos took his at the palace. That night American helicopters carried him and his family out, and they were flown on to Hawaii.

Seen from elsewhere. Marcos and his family maintained that he had asked to go to his home province in the north and was taken abroad against his will. His supporters credit him with order and public works and call the uprising a coup backed by Washington. Critics on the left argue it restored old landed families. His son was elected president in 2022.

1994

A massacre at prayer in Hebron

Hebron, West BankMiddle East

The building over the Cave of the Patriarchs in Hebron, revered as the burial place of Abraham, is the Ibrahimi Mosque to Muslims and a holy site to Jews, and both prayed there under Israeli military guard. At dawn on 25 February 1994, during Ramadan and on the Jewish festival of Purim, Baruch Goldstein, a doctor born in Brooklyn who lived in the nearby settlement of Kiryat Arba, entered the Muslim prayer hall in his army reserve uniform and fired an assault rifle into the rows of kneeling worshippers. He killed 29 people and wounded more than a hundred before survivors overpowered him and beat him to death. More Palestinians were killed by Israeli forces in the protests that followed.

Seen from elsewhere. Israel’s government condemned the attack and its Shamgar inquiry found that Goldstein acted alone. Palestinians noted that the measures which followed fell on them: a long curfew, the division of the mosque and the closing of Hebron’s main street. Some settlers honoured Goldstein’s grave until the army removed the shrine in 1999. Hamas cited the massacre for the suicide bombings it began that April.

Also on 25 February