Parallax

9 April, 1492

Lorenzo de’ Medici dies at Careggi

The banker’s grandson who ran Florence for twenty-two years without a title died at forty-three in a hillside villa. Within hours his doctor was at the bottom of a well, and within days two rival accounts of his deathbed were in circulation.

Careggi, near Florence

In the early spring of 1492 Lorenzo de’ Medici had himself carried from the family palace in Via Larga to the villa at Careggi, in the hills north of Florence. He was forty-three and could barely walk. The inherited disease the family called gout, which had crippled his father Piero and killed him at fifty-three, had spread from his joints through his whole body, and he was running a slow fever. He had directed the affairs of Florence for twenty-two years without holding any office that said so.

The doctors did what the age knew how to do. His own physician, Pier Leoni of Spoleto, counselled warmth and rest. Ludovico Sforza of Milan sent a celebrated Lombard doctor, Lazzaro of Pavia, who prescribed a draught of ground pearls and precious stones. The humanist Angelo Poliziano, who was in the house and described these days in a long Latin letter to Jacopo Antiquario, records the preparing of the medicine and the patient’s calm questions about it. It did no good.

Florence looked for signs and found them. On the night of 5 April lightning struck the lantern of the cathedral dome and sent blocks of marble crashing down on the side that faced the Medici palace. Told of it, Lorenzo is reported to have said that he was a dead man. He spoke at length with his eldest son Piero, who was twenty, about how to carry himself in a city that distrusted display. He received the last sacrament, getting out of bed to do so. He told Poliziano and Giovanni Pico della Mirandola that he wished death had waited until he had finished building up their library.

Then Girolamo Savonarola came. The Dominican prior of San Marco, a convent the Medici had rebuilt and paid for, had spent the past year preaching against the rich and the powerful of the city. What passed between the two men is the most argued-over scene in Lorenzo’s life. Poliziano, who says he was there, wrote that the friar urged the dying man to hold to the faith, to amend his life if he lived and to meet death bravely if he did not, and that Lorenzo asked for his blessing and was given it.

He died in the night of 8 to 9 April, having listened to the Passion read aloud and kissed a silver crucifix. The next morning Pier Leoni was found dead in a well at a villa outside the city. The household said he had thrown himself in from shame; plenty of Florentines believed he had been pushed. Lorenzo’s body was carried down to the church of San Lorenzo and buried with little ceremony beside his brother Giuliano, who had been stabbed to death in the cathedral fourteen years before.

How it came to this

The Medici were bankers, and Florence was in law a republic governed by guildsmen chosen by lot for two-month terms. Lorenzo’s grandfather Cosimo had learned to control the names that went into the electoral bags without ever abolishing them. Lorenzo inherited that system in 1469, aged twenty. In April 1478 the rival Pazzi family, backed by Pope Sixtus IV, tried to kill him and his brother at High Mass. Giuliano died; Lorenzo escaped into the sacristy with a neck wound. The conspirators were hanged from the windows of the government palace, and a war with the pope and Naples followed, which Lorenzo ended by sailing to Naples in person to bargain with King Ferrante.

He came home a hero and tightened his grip with a new Council of Seventy. He wrote some of the best Tuscan verse of the century, kept Poliziano, Ficino and Pico near him, and took the teenage Michelangelo into his household. He was a poor banker. The London, Bruges and Lyon branches failed under his management, and his enemies said he covered the losses from public money.

How each side saw it

Poliziano and the Medici household

Angelo Poliziano’s letter to Jacopo Antiquario, written within weeks, is the only detailed account by someone in the house. It shows a philosopher’s death: composed, devout, witty to the end, mourned by scholars who owed him everything. Poliziano was Lorenzo’s friend, his children’s tutor and a dependant of the family, and the letter was meant to be circulated. It presents Savonarola’s visit as a courtesy between a prior and his convent’s patron, ending in a blessing. For the Medici circle the death was the loss of the one man who could keep both Florence and Italy quiet.

Savonarola’s followers

The friars of San Marco told it differently. In the early lives of Savonarola, including those by Placido Cinozzi and the one long attributed to Pacifico Burlamacchi, Lorenzo sends for the prior to confess. Savonarola sets three conditions: that he trust in God’s mercy, that he give back what he has wrongly taken, and that he restore liberty to the people of Florence. To the third Lorenzo turns his face to the wall, and the friar leaves without absolving him. These accounts were written after Savonarola’s execution in 1498 by men who revered him as a martyr.

Florentine republicans and the people of Volterra

Not everyone in Florence thought him magnificent. Alamanno Rinuccini, a patrician who had served the state, wrote a dialogue On Liberty in 1479 that he kept private; it calls Lorenzo a tyrant who had emptied the republic’s institutions and ruled by fear and favour. The exiled Pazzi and their kin remembered the hangings of 1478. In Volterra, a subject town that rebelled over an alum mine in 1472, the memory was of the sack that followed its surrender to Florence’s hired army under Federico da Montefeltro, for which Lorenzo, who had pressed for the hard line, was held responsible.

Guicciardini and the historians

Francesco Guicciardini, whose family had worked with the Medici, weighed him twice. In his youthful History of Florence he listed the vices, suspicion, vanity, meddling in private marriages, misuse of public funds, and concluded that if the city had to have a tyrant it could not have found a better or more agreeable one. In the later History of Italy, written after the invasions, Lorenzo becomes the balance that had kept the peninsula at peace. Machiavelli ended his Florentine Histories at this deathbed for the same reason. Both were writing with the disasters of 1494 in mind.

What is disputed

The day itself is unsettled. He died late at night, and most modern Italian reference works give 8 April, while many English-language ones, and the tradition followed here, give 9 April. The Savonarola scene is contested: Poliziano was an eyewitness but a partisan, the friars’ version is later and hagiographic, and Pasquale Villari in the nineteenth century gave it more credit than most scholars do now. Whether Lorenzo raided the public dowry fund was long treated as slander; archival work, notably by Alison Brown, has found evidence that public money did reach him. His reputation as the keeper of Italy’s peace owes much to hindsight.

What followed

Piero lasted two and a half years. When Charles VIII of France invaded Italy in 1494 he surrendered Florence’s fortresses without a fight and was driven out, and Savonarola became the moral master of a restored republic until he was hanged and burned in 1498. The Medici came back with a Spanish army in 1512. Lorenzo’s son Giovanni became Pope Leo X the next year, his nephew Giulio became Clement VII, and his great-granddaughter Catherine became queen of France. The argument about him, patron or boss, is still how people argue about private wealth and public power.

Read further

  • Angelo Poliziano, Letter to Jacopo Antiquario (1492)
  • Francesco Guicciardini, The History of Florence
  • Nicolai Rubinstein, The Government of Florence under the Medici, 1434 to 1494 (1966)
  • Raymond de Roover, The Rise and Decline of the Medici Bank, 1397-1494 (1963)
  • Lauro Martines, April Blood: Florence and the Plot against the Medici (2003)

Same day, other years

1241

A Mongol army destroys the Silesian host at Legnica

Legnica, Silesia (now Poland)Europe

Duke Henry II of Silesia, called the Pious, gathered what he could: his own knights, Polish levies, miners from Zlotoryja, some Templars and Hospitallers. On a plain outside Legnica they met a Mongol force under the princes Baidar and Kadan. It was a detachment, sent north to stop the Poles and Bohemians from helping Hungary, where the main army under Batu and Subutai was heading. Feigned retreat drew Henry’s cavalry away from his infantry, and the army was cut to pieces. Henry was killed and his head carried on a lance before the walls of Legnica. Two days later the main Mongol army broke the Hungarians at Mohi.

Seen from elsewhere. The Mongol record barely notices the battle; for them it was a sideshow. The fullest account is by Jan Dlugosz, writing more than two centuries later, and details such as the nine sacks of severed ears are his. Polish tradition holds that Henry’s stand saved Europe. The Mongols withdrew in 1242 for reasons historians still debate.

1288

The tide and the stakes at Bach Dang

Bach Dang river, Dai Viet (now northern Vietnam)Asia

Kublai Khan’s third invasion of Dai Viet had stalled for want of food, and the Yuan fleet under Omar was withdrawing down the Bach Dang river to the sea. The Vietnamese commander Tran Hung Dao had iron-tipped stakes driven into the riverbed where the tide would cover them. Small boats attacked at high water and then fled, drawing the heavy Yuan ships after them. When the tide fell the ships were caught on the stakes and attacked from the banks and with fire rafts. Some four hundred vessels were reported taken and Omar was captured. Ngo Quyen had beaten a Chinese fleet on the same river with the same trick in 938.

Seen from elsewhere. The Chinese History of Yuan records the defeat briefly and treats the campaign as a withdrawal that went wrong. The figures come from the Vietnamese court chronicle and may be inflated. The Tran court followed its victory by sending tribute and a formal apology to Kublai, accepting his nominal overlordship as the price of being left alone.

1865

Lee surrenders at Appomattox

Appomattox Court House, VirginiaThe Americas

With his army starving and Union infantry across his line of retreat, Robert E. Lee rode to the house of Wilmer McLean and met Ulysses S. Grant in the parlour. Lee wore a full dress uniform; Grant arrived in a mud-spattered private’s coat. The terms were generous: about 28,000 men of the Army of Northern Virginia would be paroled and sent home, officers would keep their sidearms, and men who owned their horses could take them for the spring ploughing. Grant sent rations across the lines. The document was written out by his secretary Ely Parker, a Seneca. Other Confederate armies remained in the field for weeks.

Seen from elsewhere. Lee’s farewell order told his men they had yielded to overwhelming numbers and resources, the germ of the later Lost Cause tradition, which left slavery out. For four million freed people the day meant that emancipation would stand, and Black regiments of the United States Colored Troops were among those who had blocked Lee’s road.

1948

The killings at Deir Yassin

Deir Yassin, near Jerusalem, Mandatory PalestineMiddle East

About 120 fighters of the Irgun and Lehi, two Zionist paramilitary groups, attacked the Arab village of Deir Yassin on the western edge of Jerusalem at dawn. The village had a non-aggression understanding with the neighbouring Jewish suburb of Givat Shaul. The attackers met rifle fire, took casualties and fought house to house with grenades, with some help from a Haganah unit. By the end at least a hundred villagers were dead, among them women, children and old men. A figure of 254, announced at the time and repeated by all sides, is now thought too high; a Birzeit University study counted 107. News of it spread panic and hastened the Palestinian flight.

Seen from elsewhere. Irgun veterans, and Menachem Begin in The Revolt, described a hard battle preceded by a loudspeaker warning, and denied a massacre. Survivors and the Red Cross delegate Jacques de Reynier described killing after resistance had ended. The Jewish Agency condemned the attack at the time. For Palestinians it remains the emblem of the Nakba.

Also on 9 April