Parallax

27 April, 1521

Magellan dies in the shallows off Mactan

He had crossed the Pacific and converted a king. Then he picked a fight on behalf of his new ally with a chief who would not bow, and waded ashore with forty-nine men.

Mactan, Philippines

A little before dawn on Saturday 27 April 1521, three longboats sat off the island of Mactan, in the central Philippines, unable to get closer than two crossbow shots from the beach because of the reef. In them were sixty Europeans in breastplates and helmets and their captain-general, a lame Portuguese of about forty in the service of Spain, known to his crews as Fernando de Magallanes. Behind them, in twenty or thirty local boats, the ruler of neighbouring Cebu waited with his own fighting men. Magellan had told him to stay there and watch how Christians fought.

He had come to burn a village. Three weeks earlier his fleet, the three ships left of the five that had sailed from Spain in 1519, had anchored at Cebu after crossing an ocean no European had known to be so wide. Its raja, Humabon, had accepted baptism along with hundreds of his people, and an alliance with the king of Spain. Magellan then demanded that the neighbouring chiefs acknowledge Humabon as their overlord. On Mactan one of them, whom the expedition’s chronicler Antonio Pigafetta calls Cilapulapu, refused. Magellan’s companions begged him not to go in person. He went.

Forty-nine men waded ashore through thigh-deep water, leaving eleven with the boats, whose small guns were out of range. Pigafetta, who was in the water with them, says more than 1,500 islanders came at them in three bodies, shouting, and that the musketeers and crossbowmen shot for half an hour and hit little: the defenders leapt aside and covered themselves with wooden shields. Magellan sent men to set fire to houses, which enraged the islanders further. They began aiming at the Europeans’ unarmoured legs with bamboo spears, fire-hardened stakes, stones and arrows.

A poisoned arrow struck Magellan in the right leg and he ordered a slow retreat. Most of his men ran. A handful stayed with him as he backed into the shallows, fighting for an hour or more by Pigafetta’s reckoning. His helmet was knocked off twice. A spear wound in the arm stopped him drawing his sword more than halfway; a blow from a large cutlass to his left leg brought him down on his face in the water, and the islanders closed over him. Pigafetta wrote that they had killed ‘our mirror, our light, our comfort and our true guide’.

Eight Europeans died with him and four of Humabon’s baptised followers; Pigafetta counted fifteen of the defenders killed. The victors refused to give up the body at any price, and it was never recovered. Four days later Humabon invited the expedition’s new leaders to a feast and had some two dozen of them killed. The survivors burned one ship for lack of hands and fled south. One vessel, the Victoria, reached Spain in September 1522 under Juan Sebastian Elcano with eighteen Europeans aboard, having sailed round the world.

How it came to this

Magellan was a minor Portuguese nobleman who had spent eight years in the East, including the taking of Malacca in 1511, and had come home with a limp from a later campaign in Morocco, a Malay slave known as Enrique, and a grievance: King Manuel refused him a rise in his allowance. In 1517 he took himself to Spain with a proposal. The treaty of Tordesillas had divided the non-Christian world between the two Iberian crowns along a line in the Atlantic, and nobody knew where that line fell on the far side of the globe. Magellan argued that the Spice Islands, the source of cloves, lay in Spain’s half and could be reached by sailing west.

The young King Charles gave him five old ships and some 240 to 270 men of a dozen nations. The Spanish captains resented a Portuguese commander, and at Port St Julian in Patagonia in April 1520 they mutinied. He put the rising down, had one captain beheaded and marooned another. He found the strait that bears his name that October, lost one ship to wreck and another to desertion, and then spent more than three months crossing the Pacific while his crews ate leather and rats and died of scurvy.

How each side saw it

Antonio Pigafetta

Almost everything known of the battle comes from this gentleman volunteer from Vicenza, who was wounded in it and revered his commander. His narrative, written for European princes, makes Magellan a Christian knight who died covering his men’s retreat, turning back again and again to see whether they had reached the boats. Pigafetta is also the expedition’s ethnographer: he compiled a Cebuano word list, described feasts, houses and tattoos, and recorded the islanders’ reply before the battle, that they too had lances, of bamboo and fire-hardened wood. He does not say who struck the fatal blow, and does not say that the chief himself was on the beach.

Lapulapu and Filipino memory

The people of Mactan left no account. Their leader appears in a few European sentences and then vanishes from the record; nothing certain is known of his age, his faith or his later life. Since the nineteenth century Filipinos have made him the first to resist colonial rule. A statue stands near the supposed site, his image is on the seal of the national police, a city bears his name, and since 2018 the law has marked 27 April as Lapu-Lapu Day. The 2021 quincentenary was officially styled the Victory at Mactan. Stories that he was a Muslim from Borneo or Sulu, or killed Magellan in single combat, are later traditions without support in the early sources.

The surviving officers and the Spanish court

The men who got home had little reason to praise him. Deserters aboard the San Antonio reached Seville first, in 1521, and told the court that Magellan was a tyrant who had killed Spanish officers. Elcano, questioned at Valladolid in 1522, had himself been among the mutineers and gave no generous account. The royal instructions had told the commander not to risk his person or the fleet in local quarrels; by that standard Mactan was disobedience as well as a blunder. Maximilian of Transylvania, who interviewed the survivors for his printed report of 1523, presented the fight as one that need not have happened.

Modern historians

Laurence Bergreen and most popular writers present a great navigator undone by one rash day. Felipe Fernandez-Armesto’s Straits argues instead that the voyage failed by its own terms, since the westward route to the spices proved useless, and that its commander, increasingly possessed by a sense of divine mission after the mass baptisms, courted a knightly death. Historians of the Philippines such as William Henry Scott shift attention to the Visayans: Humabon was using the strangers in a local rivalry, baptism looked to him like an alliance rite, and the Europeans were minor players in someone else’s politics.

What is disputed

Pigafetta’s 1,500 defenders is the impression of a man in a fight and probably too high. Whether Humabon, or Magellan’s own disaffected officers, hoped he would fail is suspected and unprovable; the failure of the boats to support him was noticed at the time. Enrique, the slave, was accused of helping to plan the killings of 1 May after being refused the freedom Magellan’s will promised him. If he came originally from the Visayas, which is not known, he and not Elcano was the first person to circle the globe. The exact site of the battle is not established.

What followed

The Victoria’s cargo of cloves paid for the whole expedition. Spain sent further fleets, and in 1565 Miguel Lopez de Legazpi founded a permanent settlement at Cebu, where his men found in a burned house a small image of the Christ Child, held to be the one Magellan’s party gave Humabon’s wife; it is still venerated there. Spanish rule lasted 333 years and left the Philippines the largest Christian nation in Asia. The country now commemorates the same weeks twice over, for the first baptisms and for the first defeat of a European invader.

Read further

  • Antonio Pigafetta, The First Voyage Around the World, 1519-1522, edited by Theodore J. Cachey Jr. (2007)
  • Maximilian of Transylvania, De Moluccis Insulis (1523)
  • William Henry Scott, Barangay: Sixteenth-Century Philippine Culture and Society (1994)
  • Laurence Bergreen, Over the Edge of the World: Magellan’s Terrifying Circumnavigation of the Globe (2003)
  • Felipe Fernandez-Armesto, Straits: Beyond the Myth of Magellan (2022)

Same day, other years

1667

Milton sells Paradise Lost for five pounds

London, EnglandEurope

John Milton, fifty-eight, blind, and lucky to have escaped the scaffold for defending the execution of Charles I, signed an agreement with the printer Samuel Simmons for a poem of more than ten thousand lines that he had dictated to relatives and friends. He received five pounds, with five more promised when each of the first three printings sold out. The first edition, in ten books, went on sale that year for three shillings. Milton collected the second five pounds in 1669 and died in 1674; his widow sold her remaining rights to Simmons for eight pounds. The contract survives in the British Library and is the earliest known agreement of its kind between an English author and a publisher.

Seen from elsewhere. The sum became a byword for the neglect of genius, but book historians point out that the terms were ordinary for the time and the print runs large. To many contemporaries the scandal lay elsewhere: the author was a notorious republican whose books had been burned by the hangman in 1660.

1865

The steamboat Sultana explodes on the Mississippi

Near Memphis, Tennessee, United StatesThe Americas

At about two in the morning, a few miles above Memphis, the boilers of the side-wheeler Sultana burst and the vessel burned to the waterline in a river swollen by flood. She was licensed to carry 376 people and had more than 2,000 aboard, most of them Union soldiers just released from the Confederate prison camps at Andersonville and Cahaba, weak from hunger and disease. The government paid a fee per head for carrying them home, and officers at Vicksburg had packed them onto one boat with a hastily patched boiler. Estimates of the dead run from about 1,200 to 1,800. It remains the worst maritime disaster in United States history.

Seen from elsewhere. Coming days after Lincoln’s murder, it drew little notice, and no one was punished; the one officer convicted by court martial had the verdict overturned. A former Confederate agent was later reported to have claimed he sabotaged the boat with a bomb disguised as coal. Most historians blame the boiler, the overcrowding and the bribes.

1978

The Saur Revolution in Kabul

Kabul, AfghanistanAsia

Tanks from a base outside Kabul rolled into the city and surrounded the presidential palace while air force jets rocketed it. The officers belonged to the small, Soviet-aligned People’s Democratic Party, whose leaders President Mohammed Daoud Khan had just arrested after a protest funeral for a murdered party ideologue. By the next morning Daoud and some eighteen members of his family were dead in the palace. The party’s leader, Nur Muhammad Taraki, became head of state. His government decreed land redistribution and changes to marriage law, tore up the old flag for a red one, and filled Pul-e-Charkhi prison. Revolts spread within a year, and in December 1979 the Soviet army came in.

Seen from elsewhere. The party called it a people’s revolution against a feudal aristocracy, and noted that Daoud had himself taken power by coup in 1973. Its opponents call it a putsch by a few hundred officers that opened more than four decades of war. Soviet archives suggest Moscow was taken by surprise rather than giving the order.

1994

South Africa votes

South AfricaAfrica

For the first time South Africans of every colour voted in the same election. Queues a mile long formed before dawn outside schools and churches, and many people stood in them all day. Nelson Mandela, seventy-five, cast the first vote of his life at a school in Inanda, near Durban, beside the grave of the African National Congress’s first president. The weeks before had been bloody: bombs set by white extremists killed twenty-one people, and the Inkatha Freedom Party agreed to take part only a week ahead, so that its name was added to the ballot papers by sticker. At midnight, as the main day of voting began, the old flag came down and an interim constitution took effect. The ANC won just under 63 per cent.

Seen from elsewhere. The count in KwaZulu-Natal was chaotic and its result owed something to bargaining between the parties, as electoral officials later conceded. The day is a public holiday, Freedom Day. Shack dwellers’ movements have marked it as ‘UnFreedom Day’, arguing that the vote changed who governs far more than who owns.

Also on 27 April