Parallax

3 April, 1203

A sixteen-year-old duke disappears in Rouen castle

Arthur of Brittany had a better hereditary claim to England than his uncle King John, who held him prisoner. After Easter 1203 nobody outside the castle saw him again.

Rouen, Normandy

Arthur was born at Nantes in March 1187, seven months after his father Geoffrey, the fourth son of Henry II, died in Paris. That made him duke of Brittany from his first breath and, by strict descent, senior to Henry’s youngest son, John. When Richard I died without children in 1199, the barons of Anjou, Maine and Touraine declared for the twelve-year-old Arthur. England and Normandy took John, and Philip II of France played one against the other, recognising John in 1200 and then, two years later, declaring his French lands forfeit and giving most of them to Arthur.

In July 1202 Arthur, newly knighted by Philip and fifteen years old, led a force of Poitevin rebels against the castle of Mirebeau, where his grandmother Eleanor of Aquitaine, nearly eighty, had taken refuge. She got a message out. John, at Le Mans, covered some eighty miles in two days and burst into the town at dawn on 1 August while the besiegers were at breakfast. He captured Arthur, the Lusignan brothers and more than two hundred knights. It was the most complete victory of his life.

He threw it away. The prisoners were loaded with chains, and twenty-two of them are said to have been starved to death at Corfe. Arthur was held at Falaise under Hubert de Burgh. The chronicler Ralph of Coggeshall relates that John sent men to blind and castrate the boy, that Hubert stopped them, and that Hubert then announced Arthur was dead in the hope of quieting the Bretons, which had the opposite effect. Arthur was moved to the new tower at Rouen. John’s allies who had helped win Mirebeau, led by William des Roches, deserted him.

The fullest account of the end comes from the annals of Margam, a Cistercian abbey in Glamorgan whose patron, William de Briouze, had captured Arthur at Mirebeau and was with the king that spring. On the Thursday before Easter, they say, after dinner, when he was drunk and possessed by the devil, John killed Arthur with his own hand, tied a heavy stone to the body and threw it into the Seine. A fisherman’s net brought it up, and it was buried in secret at a priory of Bec for fear of the tyrant.

Easter in 1203 fell on 6 April, so that Thursday was the third. No body was ever shown and no announcement made. Philip declared that there would be no peace until Arthur was produced. He never was.

How it came to this

Henry II had assembled by inheritance and marriage a collection of lands running from the Scottish border to the Pyrenees, held under different titles and customs and, on the French side, owed in homage to the king in Paris. He had four sons who reached adulthood and no settled rule for dividing or passing on the whole. In the twelfth century it was an open legal question whether a dead elder brother’s son outranked a living younger brother. Norman and English custom leaned to the uncle, Angevin custom to the nephew.

Richard I had named Arthur his heir in a treaty of 1190 when the child was three, then on his deathbed designated John. Arthur had been raised partly at the French court, and his mother Constance, who governed Brittany and distrusted the Plantagenets, had placed him under Philip’s protection. To the Bretons he carried a name chosen to recall their legendary king. To Philip he was the lever with which the Plantagenet lands in France could be prised apart.

How each side saw it

King John and his defenders

John never admitted anything, and no order survives. His chancery records are silent, apart from a letter of 16 April 1203 telling his mother and others that the messenger could report how things stood and that God’s grace was with him more than the bearer could say, which F. M. Powicke read as a veiled reference to Arthur’s death. The case in his favour is that Arthur was no innocent child but a sworn vassal who had done homage to John, taken up arms and besieged his own grandmother. By the standards of the day a rebel captured in the field could expect harsh treatment, though not secret murder.

The Bretons

Brittany lost its duke and, in practice, its independence of manoeuvre. Breton nobles and bishops are reported to have met at Vannes and appealed to King Philip against John for the murder of their lord. Arthur’s elder sister Eleanor, who had the next claim, had been taken at Mirebeau too. John and then Henry III kept her in comfortable confinement in English castles for thirty-nine years until she died in 1241, unmarried and childless, so that her claim died with her. The duchy passed to Arthur’s infant half-sister Alix, whom Philip married to a French prince.

The French crown

Philip’s court poet and chaplain, William the Breton, wrote that John took Arthur out on the Seine by night in a small boat, ran him through with a sword and dropped the body in the river. For Philip the disappearance was a gift: it turned a feudal quarrel into a moral cause and loosened the loyalty of Norman lords. In 1216, when his son Louis invaded England, French envoys told the pope that John had been condemned to death for the murder by his peers in Philip’s court. No record of such a trial exists, and many historians think it was invented afterwards.

The Briouze family

William de Briouze almost certainly knew what had happened and was heavily rewarded in the following years. In 1208, when John demanded hostages from his barons, William’s wife Maud is reported by Roger of Wendover to have told the king’s messengers that she would not hand her sons to a man who had basely murdered his own nephew. John hunted the family down. William died an exile in France in 1211. Maud and her eldest son were imprisoned in 1210, at Windsor or Corfe, and starved to death. Their fate helped persuade the barons who drew up Magna Carta that no one was safe.

What is disputed

Nothing about Arthur’s death is certain, including the date. The Margam annals alone name the Thursday before Easter; their source was probably Briouze, an eyewitness with reasons of his own. Powicke and W. L. Warren accepted the outline, that John killed him or had him killed at Rouen in April 1203. Other contemporaries were unsure: one story held that Arthur drowned trying to escape, and a later accusation named Peter de Maulay as the killer on John’s orders. The Falaise episode with Hubert de Burgh, familiar from Shakespeare, rests on Coggeshall only. Roger of Wendover says simply that Arthur vanished.

What followed

Within fifteen months Philip had taken Normandy, Anjou, Maine and Touraine, ending a union of England and Normandy that had lasted since 1066. English kings became, for the first time in generations, rulers who lived in England, and John’s efforts to raise the money to win his lands back led directly to the baronial revolt and Magna Carta in 1215. Brittany moved into the orbit of the French crown. Arthur became a stock figure of wronged innocence, most famously in Shakespeare’s King John, and the name was not given to an heir to the English throne again until Henry VII’s eldest son.

Read further

  • F. M. Powicke, The Loss of Normandy, 1189-1204 (1913)
  • W. L. Warren, King John (1961)
  • Ralph of Coggeshall, Chronicon Anglicanum
  • John Gillingham, The Angevin Empire (1984)
  • Marc Morris, King John: Treachery, Tyranny and the Road to Magna Carta (2015)

Same day, other years

1922

Stalin is given an office job

Moscow, RussiaEurope

The day after the Eleventh Party Congress closed, the Central Committee of the Russian Communist Party created the post of General Secretary and elected Joseph Stalin to it, with Lenin’s backing. The position was meant to bring order to a sprawling organisation: it controlled appointments, files and the agenda. Few of the better-known Bolsheviks wanted it. Seven weeks later Lenin suffered the first of his strokes. In notes dictated that winter he observed that Stalin had concentrated unlimited authority in his hands, and added a postscript calling him too rude and proposing that the comrades find a way to remove him. They did not.

Seen from elsewhere. Trotsky portrayed Stalin as a mediocrity lifted by the machine, a view Stephen Kotkin and others reject: he was an able organiser whom Lenin chose. Kotkin has also questioned whether Lenin, by then gravely ill, dictated the famous testament at all; most historians still accept it as his. It was suppressed in the Soviet Union until 1956.

1948

The Jeju uprising begins

Jeju Island, KoreaAsia

Before dawn about 350 insurgents organised by the local branch of the South Korean Workers’ Party attacked a dozen police posts on Jeju, an island off the southern tip of Korea then under American military government. They were protesting against police violence, including the shooting of six people at a demonstration the year before, and against the separate election about to be held in the south, which they said would make the division of Korea permanent. The response, by police, soldiers and a mainland anti-communist youth militia, went on for years. Villages in the interior were burned and their inhabitants shot. A government commission in 2003 estimated 25,000 to 30,000 dead, about a tenth of the island.

Seen from elsewhere. For half a century the South Korean state described the event as a communist riot, and survivors could be punished for speaking of it. The commission attributed roughly four fifths of the killings to government forces, and President Roh Moo-hyun apologised. Some conservatives object that this plays down the insurgents’ own killings and their party’s ties to the north.

1973

A call from the pavement on Sixth Avenue

New York, United StatesThe Americas

Martin Cooper, an engineer at Motorola, stood on a Manhattan street before a press conference and made what is generally counted as the first public call from a hand-held cellular telephone. The prototype weighed over a kilogram, took about ten hours to charge and allowed roughly half an hour of talk. By his own account he rang Joel Engel, who led the rival programme at Bell Laboratories, to tell him where he was calling from. Motorola needed the demonstration to persuade American regulators not to hand the new radio spectrum to the Bell monopoly alone. A commercial version went on sale ten years later for nearly four thousand dollars.

Seen from elsewhere. Bell engineers had set out the cellular idea in 1947 and regarded the network, not the handset, as the real invention; car telephones had existed for decades. The only source for what was said on the call is Cooper, and Engel has said he does not remember it.

1984

The army takes power in Guinea

Conakry, GuineaAfrica

Ahmed Sekou Toure, who had led Guinea since it became the only French African colony to vote for immediate independence in 1958, died on 26 March 1984 during heart surgery in the United States. A week later, as his party’s leaders argued over the succession, Colonel Lansana Conte and a group of officers seized power without bloodshed, arrested the interim president, Louis Lansana Beavogui, and dissolved the ruling party and the constitution. They opened Camp Boiro, the Conakry prison where thousands of Toure’s real and supposed opponents had been starved, tortured or killed, and released its inmates. Conte ruled until his death in 2008.

Seen from elsewhere. Much of Africa honoured Toure as the man who had told de Gaulle that Guinea preferred poverty in freedom to riches in slavery, and his admirers saw the coup as a betrayal. Conte’s record was not gentle either: after a failed counter-coup in 1985 he had Toure’s relatives and ministers secretly executed.

Also on 3 April