Parallax

6 April, 1199

Richard the Lionheart dies of a crossbow wound at a minor siege

The most celebrated soldier in Christendom was shot from the wall of a small castle in the Limousin by a man said to have been using a frying pan as a shield. He took eleven days to die.

Chalus, Limousin, France

In Lent 1199 Richard I, king of England and duke of Normandy and Aquitaine, was in the Limousin with a force of mercenaries under his captain Mercadier, burning the lands of the viscount of Limoges. One of the viscount’s castles, Chalus-Chabrol, was held by a garrison of perhaps forty men, only a few of them knights. Richard’s sappers were working at the base of the walls under cover of crossbow fire.

On the evening of 26 March the king went out after supper to look at the progress, wearing a helmet but no mail and carrying a shield. According to the English chronicler Ralph of Coggeshall, there was one defender on the rampart who had spent the whole day catching bolts on a frying pan and picking his moments to shoot back. Richard, who was himself an expert with the crossbow, is said to have applauded him. He was slow to duck. The bolt went in at the left shoulder by the neck.

He rode back to his quarters without fuss and tried to pull it out, and the shaft snapped. A surgeon in Mercadier’s company cut for the iron head by torchlight and mangled the shoulder getting it. The wound turned gangrenous. Richard kept to his tent, admitting only a few companions so that the news would not spread, and wrote to his mother. Eleanor of Aquitaine, about seventy-five, came across country from the abbey of Fontevraud in time.

The castle fell while he lay dying, and the defenders were hanged, all but the bowman. Roger of Howden tells what followed as a set scene: the prisoner was brought to the bedside, the king asked what harm he had done him, and the man answered that Richard had killed his father and two brothers with his own hand and could do what he liked. Richard forgave him and ordered him freed with a hundred shillings. Howden adds that after the king’s death Mercadier had the man flayed alive.

Richard named his brother John as heir to all his lands, confessed and received communion, and died as evening fell on Tuesday 6 April, aged forty-one. His body was carried to Fontevraud and buried at his father’s feet. His heart went to the cathedral at Rouen, and his entrails stayed at Chalus.

How it came to this

Richard was the third son of Henry II and Eleanor, raised to rule his mother’s duchy of Aquitaine, and he spent his youth there putting down its barons and, twice, making war on his father. He became king in 1189, emptied the treasury to go on crusade, and in a ten-year reign passed about six months in England. In Palestine he retook Acre and Jaffa and won at Arsuf but judged Jerusalem impossible to hold, and made a truce with Saladin in 1192.

On the way home he was seized near Vienna by the duke of Austria and sold on to the German emperor, who released him in 1194 for a ransom of 150,000 marks, several times the English crown’s annual income. Meanwhile Philip II of France had taken castles along the Norman border. Richard spent his last five years winning them back and building Chateau Gaillard on the Seine. The Limousin campaign of 1199 was part of the same war: its lords had been drawn into alliance with Philip, and a truce in the north had freed Richard to deal with them.

How each side saw it

Saladin’s secretaries

The Muslim historians who faced him recorded both admiration and horror. Baha al-Din ibn Shaddad, who served in Saladin’s household, described the king of England as a man of great courage and spirit, of sound judgment in war, and more renowned as a soldier than the French king though lower in rank. He also gives the fullest account of 20 August 1191, when Richard, the ransom for Acre’s garrison being overdue, had some 2,700 bound prisoners led out and killed in sight of the Muslim lines. Ibn al-Athir called him the most remarkable man of his age for bravery and cunning, and a calamity for the Muslims.

The Limousin and Aquitaine

In the south he was a harsh overlord of thirty years’ standing, nicknamed ‘Yes and No’ by the troubadour Bertran de Born. Bernard Itier, librarian of the abbey of Saint-Martial at Limoges, noted the death in his chronicle, named Peter Basil as the man who shot him, and recorded that the king had been making war on the viscount. Yet the finest lament for Richard is in Occitan: Gaucelm Faidit’s planh, written within weeks, calls it a cruel thing that he must sing the death of the brave and mighty king of the English. Local tradition at Chalus long pointed out the rock from which the bolt was shot.

England, which paid

English chroniclers praised his prowess and counted the cost. The ransom required a quarter of every man’s income and movable goods, the wool crop of the Cistercians and the plate from church altars, on top of the crusade taxes. His coronation in 1189 was followed by attacks on Jews in London and other towns, and in March 1190 about 150 Jews died in the royal castle at York, most by their own hands, rather than fall to the mob; Richard punished the ringleaders lightly. The Victorian bishop and historian William Stubbs summed him up as a bad son, a bad husband, a selfish ruler and a vicious man.

Modern historians

John Gillingham overturned Stubbs’s verdict from the 1970s onward, arguing that medieval kings were judged by their success in defending their inheritance, that Richard did so against a formidable opponent, and that the charge of neglecting England applies a modern national standard to a ruler whose lands were mostly in France. Critics such as Ralph Turner and Richard Heiser accept his military ability but stress that the financial strain he imposed left John an empire already close to breaking. Jean Flori sees a man who shaped his own conduct on the model of the knights of romance.

What is disputed

Why he was at Chalus at all. Howden and other chroniclers say a peasant had ploughed up a hoard of ancient gold which the viscount refused to hand over; Gillingham argued in 1979 that this was moralising gossip and that Richard was simply suppressing a rebellion. The bowman has four names in four sources: Bertran de Gourdon, Peter Basil, John Sabraz and Dudo. The deathbed pardon may be a literary flourish. Since 1948 it has often been said that Richard was homosexual, on the strength of a hermit’s rebuke and a report that he once shared a bed with Philip of France; Gillingham rejects this, Flori thinks it possible.

What followed

John succeeded, his nephew Arthur of Brittany contested it, and within five years Normandy and Anjou had been lost to France. Whether Richard could have prevented that is one of the standing questions of English medieval history. His reputation only grew: by the next century he was the hero of romances, later of the Robin Hood stories, and in 1860 a bronze of him on horseback was set up outside Parliament, an institution he never dealt with. In 2013 French scientists who had analysed the remains of his heart at Rouen reported it had been embalmed with frankincense, myrtle and mercury.

Read further

  • John Gillingham, Richard I (1999)
  • Roger of Howden, Chronica, ed. William Stubbs (1868-71)
  • Baha al-Din Ibn Shaddad, The Rare and Excellent History of Saladin, trans. D. S. Richards (2001)
  • Jean Flori, Richard the Lionheart: King and Knight (2006)
  • Ralph V. Turner and Richard R. Heiser, The Reign of Richard Lionheart (2000)

Same day, other years

1652

The Dutch East India Company lands at the Cape

Table Bay, South AfricaAfrica

Jan van Riebeeck, a company surgeon turned merchant, anchored in Table Bay with three ships and about ninety people. His orders were to build a fort and plant a garden so that fleets on the eight-month voyage between the Netherlands and Java could take on fresh water, vegetables and meat; a colony was not intended. The livestock had to come from the Khoikhoi, herders who had grazed the peninsula for centuries and had traded with passing ships for decades. Within five years the company released some of its servants to farm on their own account, and within six it was importing enslaved people from Angola, West Africa and later the Indian Ocean.

Seen from elsewhere. Van Riebeeck’s own journal records Khoikhoi leaders asking in 1660, after a first war over pasture, whether they would be allowed to do the same if they came to Holland. Under apartheid 6 April was a public holiday, Founders’ Day. It was abolished in 1994, and Khoi and San descendants mark the date as the beginning of dispossession.

1909

Peary claims the North Pole

Arctic OceanWorldwide

After more than twenty years of Arctic expeditions the American naval engineer Robert Peary recorded that he had reached the Pole across the sea ice from northern Ellesmere Island. With him on the final stage were Matthew Henson, a Black American who had travelled with him since 1887 and spoke Inuktun, and four Inuit men from north-west Greenland: Ootah, Egingwah, Seegloo and Ooqueah. On returning he learned that a former colleague, Frederick Cook, claimed to have got there a year earlier. Cook’s claim collapsed, and Congress and the National Geographic Society endorsed Peary’s. He had taken no trained navigator on the last stretch to confirm his sightings.

Seen from elsewhere. Doubt centres on the speeds his diary implies once the last witness able to navigate had turned back. The explorer Wally Herbert, given access to the papers, concluded in 1989 that Peary fell short by perhaps fifty miles. Henson said he was the first to arrive. The Inuit, without whom nobody would have come close, went unhonoured for decades.

1930

Gandhi picks up salt on the beach at Dandi

Dandi, Gujarat, IndiaAsia

Twenty-four days earlier Mohandas Gandhi, aged sixty, had left his ashram near Ahmedabad with seventy-eight followers to walk some 390 kilometres to the sea. The colonial government held a monopoly on making and selling salt and taxed it, a burden that fell on every household in India whatever its religion or caste. Early on the morning of 6 April, after prayers and a bathe in the sea, he stooped and lifted a lump of natural salt from the mud, breaking the law. Across the country people began boiling seawater and selling the result. More than sixty thousand were jailed within months, Gandhi among them, and police beatings of unresisting volunteers at the Dharasana salt works were reported around the world.

Seen from elsewhere. The Viceroy, Lord Irwin, at first thought the march could be ignored and then negotiated with Gandhi as an equal, which appalled Winston Churchill. The salt tax itself survived until 1947. Most Muslim leaders stayed aloof from the campaign, and B. R. Ambedkar disputed the Congress’s claim to speak for India’s untouchables.

1994

The Rwandan president’s aircraft is shot down

Kigali, RwandaAfrica

At about twenty past eight in the evening a jet bringing President Juvenal Habyarimana back from peace talks in Tanzania was hit by surface-to-air missiles on its approach to Kigali and crashed in the grounds of his own residence. Everyone aboard died, including the president of Burundi, Cyprien Ntaryamira. Within the hour soldiers and militia were setting up roadblocks. The next morning they killed the prime minister, Agathe Uwilingiyimana, and ten Belgian peacekeepers guarding her. Over about a hundred days, organised killing by the army, the Interahamwe militia and ordinary neighbours took the lives of between half a million and a million people, most of them Tutsi, along with Hutu who opposed it.

Seen from elsewhere. Who fired is unresolved. A French judge in 2006 accused the Tutsi-led rebel front of Paul Kagame; a Rwandan inquiry and a later French ballistic study placed the launch near a camp held by the presidential guard, pointing to Hutu extremists. French courts dropped the case. Lists of victims and arms had been prepared well before the crash.

Also on 6 April