Parallax

8 April, 1795

The Prince of Wales marries his cousin, drunk

George needed Parliament to pay his debts and Parliament wanted an heir. He had met his bride three days earlier and asked for brandy. He was already, in the eyes of his Church if not of the law, another woman’s husband.

Chapel Royal, St James’s Palace, London

Princess Caroline of Brunswick landed at Greenwich on Easter Sunday, 5 April 1795, after a winter journey across a continent at war. She was twenty-six, fair, talkative and unguarded. The diplomat who had been sent to fetch her, Lord Malmesbury, had spent the weeks on the road trying to prepare her, and noted in his diary that he had needed to speak to her, through a lady-in-waiting, about washing more thoroughly and changing her linen. The lady sent by the Prince to receive her at Greenwich was the Countess of Jersey, his mistress, who arrived late and criticised her dress.

That afternoon at St James’s the couple met for the first time. Malmesbury, the only other person in the room, recorded it. Caroline knelt, as she had been taught. George raised her, embraced her, said barely a word, walked to the far end of the room and called out: ‘Harris, I am not well; pray get me a glass of brandy.’ Malmesbury suggested water. The Prince swore and left to see his mother. Caroline said in French that she found him very fat and nothing like as handsome as his portrait.

The wedding took place three days later, on the evening of Wednesday 8 April, in the candlelit Chapel Royal. The bride, in silver tissue and a robe of velvet and ermine so heavy she could hardly walk, chattered happily while she waited. The groom arrived having drunk a good deal and had to be steadied by the two unmarried dukes who attended him. At one point he got up in the middle of a prayer, and the King had to step forward and persuade him to kneel again. He looked repeatedly at Lady Jersey.

The Archbishop of Canterbury, John Moore, knew the rumours. When he reached the passage asking whether anyone knew of an impediment, he put down the book and looked for a long moment at the Prince and then at the King. Nobody spoke. He also read twice the charge to the husband to live faithfully with his wife.

Caroline later said that her husband spent most of the wedding night insensible in the fireplace, where he had fallen and where she left him. George’s version, given to Malmesbury, was that he had forced himself to share her bed three times in all. Their only child, Princess Charlotte, was born on 7 January 1796, almost exactly nine months after the ceremony. By then they were living apart under the same roof.

How it came to this

George, eldest son of George III, was thirty-two, gifted, charming and ruinously extravagant. His rebuilding of Carlton House and his racing stable had run up debts of some 630,000 pounds, a sum Parliament would only take on if he married and produced a legitimate heir. The Royal Marriages Act of 1772 required the King’s consent, and the Act of Settlement required a Protestant, which narrowed the field to German princesses. Caroline was the daughter of the Duke of Brunswick and of George III’s own sister. The Prince chose her without having seen her; Queen Charlotte, who had heard unfavourable reports of her conduct, preferred another candidate and kept silent.

The difficulty was that on 15 December 1785 he had secretly gone through a marriage ceremony with Maria Fitzherbert, a twice-widowed Catholic, in her drawing room in Mayfair before an Anglican clergyman. Under the 1772 Act the marriage was void in English law. Under canon law, Anglican and Catholic, it was valid. His friends had denied it in the House of Commons in 1787. He had parted from Mrs Fitzherbert in 1794 under Lady Jersey’s influence, and it was Lady Jersey he appointed to his bride’s household.

How each side saw it

The Prince

George regarded himself as the victim of a transaction forced on him by his father and his creditors. He told Malmesbury that he had found his bride personally unclean and gave him to understand that he did not believe she had come to him a virgin. Three days after his daughter’s birth he wrote a long will leaving everything to ‘my Maria Fitzherbert, my wife, the wife of my heart and soul’, and to the Princess of Wales one shilling. In April 1796 he wrote to Caroline that their inclinations were not in their power and that they need not share a life. He was buried in 1830 wearing Mrs Fitzherbert’s miniature.

Caroline

Her account survives mainly in what she told her ladies, above all Lady Charlotte Campbell, who published a diary of her household. She said she had known within a day that she was unwanted, had been put under the supervision of her husband’s mistress, and had been kept from her daughter. A remark attributed to her, that she had committed adultery only once and that with the husband of Mrs Fitzherbert, sums up her view of the law of the case. After 1796 she lived as she pleased at Blackheath and then abroad, with a carelessness about appearances that her own advisers lamented.

The public of 1820

When George became king and had a bill introduced in the House of Lords to dissolve the marriage and strip Caroline of her title for adultery with her Italian chamberlain, Bartolomeo Pergami, the country took her side. Radicals such as William Cobbett wrote her replies; hundreds of loyal addresses arrived, many from meetings of women, who saw a wife discarded by a husband whose own infidelities were notorious. The historian Thomas Laqueur has shown how the affair gave popular politics a language of domestic melodrama. The bill passed its third reading by nine votes, and the government, knowing it would fail in the Commons, withdrew it.

Maria Fitzherbert and the Church of Rome

Mrs Fitzherbert never spoke publicly, kept her marriage certificate with the witnesses’ names cut out to protect them, and said only that she knew herself to be the Prince’s wife. When he sought to return to her she insisted on consulting Rome, and in 1800 received a papal brief confirming that she was his lawful wife in the sight of the Church and might live with him. They were together again until about 1809. On that view the ceremony of 8 April 1795 was bigamy, and Caroline, not Maria, the wronged outsider. Her papers were sealed at Coutts’s bank and not opened until 1905.

What is disputed

Whether Caroline did commit adultery with Pergami: most historians, including her biographer Flora Fraser, think it probable, though the Italian servants who testified in 1820 were paid and coached, and one became a byword for answering ‘I do not remember’. A royal commission in 1806 cleared her of the charge that a boy she had adopted, William Austin, was her own son, while censuring her conduct. Why George chose her is also argued: contemporaries said Lady Jersey promoted a bride unlikely to be a rival. The wedding-night stories each come from one of the spouses, told years later and in anger.

What followed

Princess Charlotte died in childbirth in 1817, which sent George’s ageing brothers hurrying to marry and so produced the future Queen Victoria. Caroline was turned away from the doors of Westminster Abbey at her husband’s coronation on 19 July 1821 and died nineteen days later; two men were shot dead when crowds forced her funeral procession through the City of London. She asked for a coffin plate reading ‘the injured Queen of England’. The scandal did lasting damage to the standing of the monarchy, which Victoria’s court later set itself to repair.

Read further

  • James Harris, Earl of Malmesbury, Diaries and Correspondence of James Harris, First Earl of Malmesbury (1844)
  • Flora Fraser, The Unruly Queen: The Life of Queen Caroline (1996)
  • Christopher Hibbert, George IV: Prince of Wales, 1762-1811 (1972)
  • E. A. Smith, A Queen on Trial: The Affair of Queen Caroline (1993)
  • Jane Robins, Rebel Queen: The Trial of Caroline (2006)

Same day, other years

AD 217

The emperor Caracalla is stabbed at the roadside

Near Carrhae (Harran), MesopotamiaMiddle East

Caracalla, aged twenty-nine, was wintering at Edessa while preparing a second campaign against Parthia. On 8 April he rode out with a small escort to visit the temple of the moon god near Carrhae. When he dismounted to relieve himself, a soldier named Julius Martialis, who bore him a grudge, came up as if to speak and stabbed him. The emperor’s Scythian bodyguards killed Martialis on the spot. Behind the attack was the praetorian prefect Macrinus, who had learned that a letter denouncing him was on its way to the emperor. Three days later the army acclaimed Macrinus, the first emperor who had never been a senator.

Seen from elsewhere. Our sources, the senator Cassius Dio and Herodian, loathed Caracalla, who had murdered his brother Geta and ordered a massacre at Alexandria. The soldiers, whose pay he had raised by half, mourned him and forced Macrinus to have him deified. His edict of 212 made nearly every free inhabitant of the empire a Roman citizen, which Dio dismissed as a tax measure.

1857

Mangal Pandey is hanged at Barrackpore

Barrackpore, Bengal, IndiaAsia

Ten days earlier Pandey, a sepoy of the 34th Bengal Native Infantry, had walked onto the parade ground with a loaded musket, called on his comrades to rise, and wounded the adjutant and the sergeant-major who tried to arrest him. Only one Indian soldier, Shaikh Paltu, went to the officers’ aid. Pandey then turned the gun on himself and survived. The army was already uneasy over a new rifle whose cartridges, bitten open in loading, were rumoured to be greased with cow and pig fat, offensive to Hindus and Muslims alike. A court martial of Indian officers condemned him, and he was hanged before the assembled garrison. The regiment was disbanded. A month later the troops at Meerut mutinied and marched on Delhi.

Seen from elsewhere. The trial record has Pandey saying he acted alone and had been taking bhang and opium. British soldiers took to calling all rebels ‘Pandies’. Indian nationalists from V. D. Savarkar onward made him the first martyr of a war of independence. The historian Rudrangshu Mukherjee has argued that he was an accidental hero, unconnected with the rising that followed.

1904

Britain and France sign the Entente Cordiale

London, EnglandEurope

Six years after the two powers had come close to war over a fort on the upper Nile, the British foreign secretary, Lord Lansdowne, and the French ambassador, Paul Cambon, signed a set of agreements settling their colonial quarrels around the world. France accepted Britain’s position in Egypt; Britain gave France a free hand in Morocco. Other clauses dealt with fishing rights off Newfoundland, borders in West Africa, spheres of influence in Siam and the future of the New Hebrides. It was not an alliance and promised no military help. But staff talks followed, and when war came in 1914 the understanding carried Britain in on the French side.

Seen from elsewhere. Neither Egyptians nor Moroccans were consulted, and secret articles provided for the eventual partition of Morocco between France and Spain; it became a French protectorate in 1912. Germany, which had counted on Anglo-French rivalry, saw the beginnings of encirclement, and the Kaiser’s landing at Tangier in 1905 was a failed attempt to break the agreement apart.

1953

Jomo Kenyatta is sentenced at Kapenguria

Kapenguria, KenyaAfrica

In a schoolroom in a remote district near the Ugandan border, chosen to keep crowds and reporters away, a British magistrate found Kenyatta and five other leaders of the Kenya African Union guilty of managing Mau Mau, the Kikuyu-based movement fighting colonial rule and settler landholding. Each received seven years’ hard labour, to be followed by restriction. They had been arrested in October 1952 on the night the governor declared a state of emergency. The defence, led by the British barrister D. N. Pritt with Indian, Nigerian and Kenyan Asian colleagues, argued that there was no evidence. Kenyatta was held until 1961, became prime minister in 1963 and was president until his death in 1978.

Seen from elsewhere. The chief prosecution witness, Rawson Macharia, swore in 1958 that he had been rewarded to lie. Archives later showed that the governor arranged a payment of 20,000 pounds to the magistrate. Kenyatta always denied leading Mau Mau and had condemned it in public. Its fighters felt abandoned by him in power; the movement remained a banned organisation in Kenya until 2003.

Also on 8 April