Parallax

23 April, 1661

Charles II is crowned at Westminster

England staged the most splendid coronation it could afford, with new regalia to replace the set the republic had melted down. The banquet was held in the hall where the king’s father had been condemned, under a roof on which Oliver Cromwell’s head was fixed to a pole.

Westminster, London

Samuel Pepys, a young clerk at the Navy Board, got up at four on the morning of St George’s Day 1661 and talked his way into Westminster Abbey, where he found a seat high on a scaffold at the north end and sat until eleven waiting for the king. The day before he had watched the procession from the Tower to Whitehall from an upstairs window in Cornhill: nobles and their footmen passing under four wooden triumphal arches, so covered in gold and silver, he wrote, that the eye could not bear to look at them.

Charles came to the Abbey on foot from Westminster Hall over blue cloth, under a canopy carried by the barons of the Cinque Ports, in a procession of bishops and peers bearing the sword, the sceptre and the crown. Every one of those objects was new. Parliament had ordered the medieval regalia broken up and sold in 1649, and the goldsmith Robert Vyner had been paid more than 12,000 pounds to remake them. Only a twelfth-century anointing spoon, bought at the sale by a royal servant and handed back, came from the old set.

The service followed the ancient order: the people asked whether they would have him, the oath, the anointing, the crowning. The archbishop of Canterbury, William Juxon, set the crown on his head. Juxon was 78 and so frail that the bishop of London performed most of the rest; twelve years earlier he had stood beside Charles I on the scaffold. From his perch Pepys could see almost nothing of this and heard only a great shout. He was also, he records, badly in need of a privy, and left before the end.

He was in Westminster Hall in time for the banquet. The king dined at the high table with his crown on. The hereditary champion, Sir Edward Dymoke, rode into the hall in full armour, threw down his gauntlet three times and challenged anyone who denied Charles Stuart’s right to fight him. Nobody did. Pepys begged four rabbits and a pullet from a lord’s table and ate them standing with his friends.

It had been fair all day. As the king left the hall it began to thunder and rain as heavily as Pepys had seen in years, and people argued over whether that was a blessing or a warning. That night the City was ringed with bonfires and men were made to kneel in the street and drink the king’s health. Pepys did so repeatedly, and records that he woke the next morning having been sick in his bed.

How it came to this

Charles had been king in name since the morning of 30 January 1649, when his father was beheaded outside the Banqueting House after a trial in Westminster Hall. He was then 18 and in exile. The Scots crowned him at Scone on New Year’s Day 1651, having first made him swear to a Presbyterian covenant he despised; Cromwell beat his army at Worcester that September, and he spent six weeks as a fugitive before escaping to France and nine years of poverty.

The republic did not long survive Cromwell’s death in 1658. As its generals and politicians fell out, General George Monck marched from Scotland and recalled the old Parliament, which invited the king home. From Breda Charles promised a pardon to all but those Parliament excepted, and liberty to tender consciences. He entered London on his thirtieth birthday, 29 May 1660. That October ten men who had signed his father’s death warrant or helped carry it out were hanged, drawn and quartered. In January 1661 the bodies of Cromwell, Ireton and Bradshaw were dug up, hanged at Tyburn and beheaded, and the heads set above Westminster Hall.

How each side saw it

Samuel Pepys

The diary is the best account of the day and it is not a simple one. Pepys had been a schoolboy in the crowd at the execution of Charles I and had approved of it, a fact he feared an old schoolfellow might recall. He owed his post to a patron who had served Cromwell and then helped bring the king back. His delight in the show is real, and so is his eye for what went wrong: the crush, the drunkenness, the quarrel between the king’s footmen and the barons of the Cinque Ports over who should keep the canopy. He ends by noting, with satisfaction, that he need never see such a thing again.

Republicans and dissenters

For those who had fought for Parliament the day marked a defeat they explained as God’s judgment on their own failings. Edmund Ludlow, a regicide who escaped to Switzerland, wrote in his memoirs of a nation running back to bondage. John Milton, who had defended the execution in print, had been briefly jailed and was living quietly and blind, at work on Paradise Lost. Lucy Hutchinson recorded her husband’s imprisonment and death. Quakers and Baptists were already filling the prisons after a small millenarian rising in London that January, and the promise of liberty of conscience was not kept.

Scottish Covenanters

Presbyterian Scots had a particular grievance: this king had sworn their Covenant with his own hand in 1650 and been crowned on the strength of it. In March 1661 his Scottish parliament annulled every law passed since 1633, and bishops were restored the following year. The Marquis of Argyll, who had placed the crown on Charles’s head at Scone, was beheaded in Edinburgh a month after the Westminster coronation. Ministers who would not conform were put out of their parishes and preached in the fields. The histories written by their heirs, Robert Wodrow above all, treat the reign as an age of persecution.

Irish Catholics

Many Irish Catholic landowners had fought for the Stuarts and followed Charles into exile, and they expected the Restoration to undo Cromwell’s confiscations, which had transferred most of the good land in Ireland to Protestant soldiers and investors. The king was sympathetic but needed the men in possession. The settlement acts of the 1660s restored a favoured minority and left the Cromwellian grants largely standing. Catholic petitions and the later Gaelic poets speak of a king who rewarded his enemies and forgot his friends.

What is disputed

How general the rejoicing was is argued. Ronald Hutton and Tim Harris both show real popular royalism in 1660-61, but Harris stresses that the celebrations were also organised and policed, and that opinion was divided from the start. The cost is usually put at over 30,000 pounds, though the accounts are incomplete. Charles’s reputation as an easy-going Merry Monarch is questioned by historians who see a secretive and ruthless politician. He acknowledged at least a dozen illegitimate children, fewer than the numbers sometimes claimed, and no legitimate one. His religion is the deepest puzzle: he promised Louis XIV in 1670 to declare himself Catholic, and did so only on his deathbed.

What followed

The Parliament elected that spring imposed a narrow Anglican settlement, and on St Bartholomew’s Day 1662 some 2,000 ministers who would not accept the prayer book lost their livings, the origin of English Nonconformity. Plague, the fire of London and a Dutch fleet in the Medway soon dimmed the glow. Charles died in 1685 without a lawful heir; his Catholic brother James lasted three years. St Edward’s Crown, made for 1661, is the one still used, most recently for Charles III in 2023. Cromwell’s head stayed on its pole above the hall for more than twenty years.

Read further

  • Samuel Pepys, The Diary of Samuel Pepys, ed. Robert Latham and William Matthews (1970-83)
  • Ronald Hutton, Charles II: King of England, Scotland, and Ireland (1989)
  • Tim Harris, Restoration: Charles II and His Kingdoms, 1660-1685 (2005)
  • Antonia Fraser, King Charles II (1979)
  • John Ogilby, The Entertainment of His Most Excellent Majestie Charles II (1662)

Same day, other years

1014

Brian Boru dies winning at Clontarf

Clontarf, near Dublin, IrelandEurope

On Good Friday the army of Brian Boru, king of Munster and for a dozen years the acknowledged high king of Ireland, fought all day on the north shore of Dublin Bay against the king of Leinster, the Norse of Dublin and Viking allies from Orkney and the Isle of Man. By evening the Leinstermen and their allies had broken and many drowned in the rising tide. Brian, in his seventies or older and too frail to fight, was cut down in his tent by fleeing Norsemen. His son and grandson died too, and his dynasty never again held the supremacy he had won.

Seen from elsewhere. The story of a Christian king freeing Ireland from the heathen comes from a saga written a century later to glorify his descendants. Irishmen fought on both sides, the Norse king of Dublin kept his town for another twenty years, and many historians since the 1930s have treated the battle as a Leinster revolt. Icelandic saga tells it from the Viking side.

1616

Shakespeare and Cervantes: the same date, not the same day

Stratford-upon-Avon and MadridEurope

William Shakespeare died at Stratford on 23 April 1616, aged 52, and was buried in Holy Trinity church two days later. Miguel de Cervantes is recorded as buried in Madrid on 23 April 1616, having died the previous day. The coincidence is the reason UNESCO chose the date for World Book Day. But England still used the Julian calendar and Spain the Gregorian, ten days ahead, so Shakespeare outlived Cervantes by about eleven days. The tradition that Shakespeare was also born on 23 April is a guess from his baptism on the 26th.

Seen from elsewhere. Nothing certain is known of how Shakespeare died. A Stratford vicar noted fifty years later that he had caught a fever after drinking with Ben Jonson and Michael Drayton, which is hearsay. The Peruvian-born chronicler known as the Inca Garcilaso de la Vega, son of a conquistador and an Inca noblewoman, died in Spain in the same days and is often left out.

1920

A rival parliament opens in Ankara

Ankara, TurkeyMiddle East

A month after British troops occupied Constantinople and the last Ottoman parliament was dissolved, deputies who had escaped the capital joined newly elected ones in a provincial town in Anatolia. After Friday prayers and the sacrifice of sheep they opened the Grand National Assembly in a former clubhouse lit by oil lamps. Next day they chose Mustafa Kemal as its president. The assembly declared that sovereignty belonged to the nation, while still claiming to act for a sultan held captive by foreigners. It raised an army, rejected the partition treaty the sultan’s ministers signed that August, and in 1923 proclaimed a republic.

Seen from elsewhere. The sultan’s government had its chief cleric declare the nationalists rebels whom it was a duty to kill, and sentenced Kemal to death in his absence. For Greeks and Armenians the assembly’s victory meant the destruction of Smyrna, the expulsions of 1923 and the end of any return. Kurdish deputies who sat in it as partners saw their identity denied within five years.

1949

The Communists take Nanjing

Nanjing, ChinaAsia

Peace talks between China’s Nationalist government and the Communists collapsed on 20 April, and that night the People’s Liberation Army began crossing the Yangtze on a front of hundreds of miles, using thousands of junks and fishing boats. The Nationalist river defences gave way almost at once, and some units changed sides. On 23 April Communist troops entered Nanjing, the capital, which the government had abandoned for Guangzhou; soldiers were photographed on the roof of the presidential palace. Shanghai fell a month later. Mao proclaimed the People’s Republic in October, and Chiang Kai-shek withdrew to Taiwan.

Seen from elsewhere. The Nationalists’ acting president, Li Zongren, had hoped to hold the south behind the river, and blamed Chiang for keeping the best troops and the gold reserves for Taiwan. Whether Stalin urged Mao to stop at the Yangtze is disputed among historians. The Republic of China still exists on Taiwan, and the question left open in 1949 remains so.

Also on 23 April