Parallax

21 April, 1142

Peter Abelard dies under Cluny’s protection

The most brilliant and most quarrelsome teacher of his century ended as a condemned heretic in a quiet priory. The abbot who sheltered him then wrote to the one person who had a right to be told: Heloise.

Priory of Saint-Marcel, near Chalon-sur-Saone, Burgundy

In the summer of 1141 Peter Abelard, past sixty and unwell, set out from northern France to walk to Rome. A council of bishops at Sens had just condemned a list of propositions drawn from his theology, at the urging of Bernard of Clairvaux, and Abelard had refused to answer there and appealed to the pope instead. He got as far as the abbey of Cluny in Burgundy. Before he could go further, word came that Innocent II had confirmed the sentence, ordered his books burned and imposed perpetual silence on him.

The abbot of Cluny, Peter the Venerable, took him in. He arranged a meeting with Bernard at which the two men were formally reconciled, obtained the pope’s leave for Abelard to stay, and gave him a place among the monks. In a letter written afterwards he described a man who dressed more shabbily than anyone in the house, ate little, spoke only when asked, and was always reading, praying or dictating. When a skin disease and general weakness grew worse, the abbot moved him to the smaller priory of Saint-Marcel on the Saone, where the air was thought kinder.

He died there on 21 April 1142, having confessed and received the sacrament before the assembled brothers. He was about 63. No account from the bedside records any last words.

The letter Peter the Venerable then sent was addressed to the abbess of the Paraclete, a convent in Champagne. Heloise had been its head for more than a decade. Some twenty-five years earlier she had been Abelard’s pupil in Paris, then his lover, the mother of his son and, secretly, his wife, until her uncle’s hired men broke into his lodging at night and castrated him. Both had then entered religion, she on his instruction. The abbot told her that he had admired her learning since he was a young man, and that God was keeping Abelard for her, to be restored to her at the end.

He did more than write. Some time afterwards he had the body taken, without the Saint-Marcel monks knowing, and brought it himself to the Paraclete, which Abelard had founded and where he had asked to lie. Heloise wrote back to thank him and to ask two favours: a sealed document recording Abelard’s absolution, to hang on the tomb, and a church living for their son, Astralabe. The abbot sent the absolution and promised to try. She governed the Paraclete for another twenty years and was buried beside him.

How it came to this

Abelard was born about 1079 at Le Pallet near Nantes, the eldest son of a knight, and gave up his inheritance to study logic. He made his name by publicly out-arguing his own masters, and by about 1115 was the star of the cathedral school of Paris, drawing students from across Europe. His method, shown in a book called Sic et Non, was to set contradictory statements of the church fathers side by side and leave the student to reason a way through. His ethics located sin in intention rather than in the act.

The affair with Heloise, niece of a canon named Fulbert in whose house he lodged, ended that first career. His second, as a monk, was a run of disasters, which he narrated in a long letter known as the History of My Calamities. A council at Soissons in 1121 made him burn his own book on the Trinity. He offended the monks of Saint-Denis by doubting the identity of their patron saint, and fled an abbey in Brittany whose monks, he says, tried to poison him. When Heloise’s nuns were evicted from Argenteuil in 1129 he gave them the Paraclete. By the late 1130s he was teaching in Paris again, which is what brought Bernard down on him.

How each side saw it

Heloise

Her letters, written from the Paraclete after she had read his account of their story, are among the frankest documents of the Middle Ages. She says she had argued against the marriage, preferring to be called his mistress than an emperor’s wife, because marriage would ruin his career and add nothing to love freely given. She took the veil, she tells him, at his command and not for love of God, and can expect no reward from God for it. During Mass her mind still goes back to what they did together. She reproaches him for years of silence. Then, at his request, she turns to the practical question of a rule suitable for nuns.

Bernard of Clairvaux

Bernard’s letters to the pope and cardinals before and after Sens give the case against. Abelard, he wrote, puts human reasoning above faith, discusses the Trinity in the streets with boys, and sees nothing through a glass darkly but claims to look on everything face to face. For the leading Cistercian, the mysteries of faith were to be approached by prayer and love inside a monastery, not picked apart in a classroom for fees and applause. He regarded the old man’s personal history as proof of pride, and his popularity with students as the real danger.

Fulbert and his kin

The uncle left no statement, and everything known of him comes from the man he had mutilated. Even so the outline of his grievance is clear. He had taken a famous master into his house and given him charge of a niece whose learning was his pride; the master seduced her, removed her to Brittany to give birth, married her in secret and then, when the family made the marriage known, put her in a convent in a nun’s habit. Fulbert’s relatives read that as a man ridding himself of a wife. Two of the attackers were caught, blinded and castrated in turn. Fulbert lost his property for a time, but he reappears in the cathedral records a few years later.

Peter the Venerable

The abbot of Cluny was no ally of Abelard’s theology, and he was a friend of Bernard as well as a rival. His letters show a different idea of what a great monastery was for: a place where a broken and condemned man could be received without being made to grovel. To the pope he wrote of Abelard’s humility; to Heloise he called him the servant and true philosopher of Christ. It is thanks to his tact that the story ends with a burial at the Paraclete rather than an unmarked grave under papal ban.

What is disputed

The letters survive only in copies made over a century later, and some scholars, notably John Benton in the 1970s, suspected that Abelard or a later forger wrote Heloise’s side; most now accept them as genuine. Whether a separate set of anonymous love letters, attributed to the pair by Constant Mews in 1999, is really theirs remains contested. Heloise’s age is unknown: the tradition that she was a girl of 17 has no medieval basis, and Michael Clanchy and Mews think she was well into her twenties. Abelard himself admits using threats and blows when she resisted him, which shapes modern readings. The council of Sens is dated to 1140 or 1141. The despairing last words sometimes quoted are unattested.

What followed

The schools of Paris in which Abelard taught grew, two generations later, into a university, and the method of Sic et Non became the ordinary procedure of scholastic theology; Peter Lombard, whose textbook ruled the subject for four centuries, knew his work. The lovers’ own fame came later, through Jean de Meun in the thirteenth century, Alexander Pope in the eighteenth and Rousseau’s new Heloise. Their bones were moved repeatedly. Since 1817 a Gothic canopy in Pere-Lachaise cemetery in Paris has been presented as their tomb, though how much of either of them lies under it is uncertain.

Read further

  • Betty Radice (trans.), The Letters of Abelard and Heloise (1974)
  • M. T. Clanchy, Abelard: A Medieval Life (1997)
  • Constant J. Mews, The Lost Love Letters of Heloise and Abelard (1999)
  • Constant J. Mews, Abelard and Heloise (2005)
  • David Luscombe (ed.), The Letter Collection of Peter Abelard and Heloise (2013)

Same day, other years

753 BC

The traditional birthday of Rome

RomeEurope

Romans kept 21 April, the shepherds’ festival of the Parilia, as the day on which Romulus yoked a bull and a cow to a plough and cut the sacred boundary of his city round the Palatine hill. In the version told by Livy, his twin Remus jumped the half-built wall in mockery and was killed for it. The year 753 BC was worked out seven centuries later by the scholar Varro and became the starting point of the Roman calendar. Emperors celebrated the anniversary with games; Rome still marks it with a parade.

Seen from elsewhere. Other ancient writers put the foundation in 748, 729 or as early as 814 BC, and Greeks credited the Trojan Aeneas. Archaeology shows huts on the Palatine in the eighth century but settlement on the site long before. Most historians, T. J. Cornell among them, see a city that grew gradually; Andrea Carandini argues that a real founding act lies behind the legend.

1526

Babur wins at Panipat

Panipat, northern IndiaAsia

Babur, a descendant of Timur who had lost his homeland in central Asia and ruled from Kabul, met the army of Sultan Ibrahim Lodi of Delhi on the plain north of the city. By his own count he had some 12,000 men against 100,000 and a thousand elephants. He roped several hundred carts together as a barricade, placed matchlock men and cannon behind them in the Ottoman manner, and sent cavalry round both flanks. By noon Ibrahim was dead on the field. Babur occupied Delhi and Agra within days, and his descendants, the Mughals, ruled much of India for three centuries.

Seen from elsewhere. The figures come from Babur’s own memoirs, which are vivid and self-serving, and the Lodi numbers are certainly inflated. Ibrahim’s own Afghan nobles had invited the invader in. In India today Babur is remembered both as the founder of a great empire and as a foreign conqueror, an argument sharpened by the dispute over the mosque built in his name at Ayodhya.

1792

Tiradentes is hanged in Rio de Janeiro

Rio de Janeiro, BrazilThe Americas

Joaquim Jose da Silva Xavier was a cavalry ensign in the gold-mining captaincy of Minas Gerais who pulled teeth on the side, hence his nickname, the Tooth-puller. In 1789 he joined a plot among local officers, priests, poets and indebted tax contractors to proclaim a republic on the day the Portuguese Crown collected its arrears of gold tax. An informer betrayed them in return for having his own debts cancelled. After a three-year trial the queen commuted the other death sentences to exile in Africa. Tiradentes, who had taken the whole blame on himself, was hanged and quartered and his head displayed in Vila Rica.

Seen from elsewhere. To the Crown he was a traitor, and the court had his house razed and the ground salted. He was the poorest of the conspirators, most of whom owned slaves and made no clear promise of abolition. The republic founded in 1889 made him its martyr and painted him bearded and Christ-like; the day is a Brazilian national holiday.

1836

Eighteen minutes at San Jacinto

San Jacinto, Mexican TexasThe Americas

Six weeks after the fall of the Alamo, Sam Houston’s army of about 900 Texan rebels crossed open ground in mid-afternoon and fell on the camp of General Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna, president of Mexico, whose 1,300 soldiers were resting without proper pickets. The Mexican line broke in under twenty minutes. The killing went on much longer, as fugitives were shot down in the marshes; some 630 Mexicans died against nine or so Texans. Santa Anna was caught next day in a private’s uniform and, as a prisoner, signed an agreement to withdraw his armies beyond the Rio Grande.

Seen from elsewhere. Mexico’s congress repudiated a treaty signed under duress and never recognised Texan independence, a dispute that led to war with the United States in 1846. Mexican officers’ accounts describe men killed while trying to surrender. Mexico had abolished slavery in 1829 and the Texan constitution protected it; how central that was to the revolt is still argued.

Also on 21 April