Parallax

15 April, AD 73

The fall of Masada

A Roman legion built a ramp up a desert cliff to reach the last Jewish rebels and, by the only account we have, found 960 of them dead by their own hands. That account was written by a man who had changed sides.

Masada, Judaea

Masada is a flat-topped rock above the western shore of the Dead Sea, with cliffs of up to four hundred metres on the eastern side. Herod the Great had fortified it a century earlier as a refuge for himself, with a casemate wall round the summit, storehouses, cisterns cut to catch the winter floods, and a palace stepped down the northern prow. In the winter after the last other strongholds had fallen, the Roman governor of Judaea, Flavius Silva, marched there with the Tenth Legion, auxiliary cohorts and thousands of Jewish prisoners to carry water and food across the desert.

On the summit were some 960 men, women and children. They were Sicarii, the dagger-men, a faction that had seized the rock at the start of the revolt in 66 and held it throughout the war. Their leader was Eleazar ben Yair. Silva sealed them in with a stone wall more than four kilometres round, studded with eight camps whose outlines are still plain on the ground. Then his engineers chose a spur of rock on the western side and built on it a ramp of earth and timber, a platform on top of that, and an ironclad siege tower with a battering ram.

The ram broke the wall. The defenders had built a second behind it of timber beams packed with earth, which absorbed the blows, so the Romans set it on fire. For a moment a north wind blew the flames back on their own machines; then it swung round. By nightfall the inner wall was burning and the soldiers withdrew to wait for morning.

What happened next rests on one writer, Flavius Josephus. He says Eleazar gathered the men and spoke twice, arguing that God had turned against them, that death was freedom and that their wives should die undishonoured and their children without knowing slavery. Each man then killed his own family. Ten were chosen by lot to kill the rest, and one of the ten to kill the other nine, set fire to the palace and fall on his sword. They left the food stores intact, to show they had not been starved out.

The Romans came up at dawn armed for a fight and met silence. Two women and five children, who had hidden in a water channel, came out and told them what had been done. Josephus gives the date as the fifteenth of the month Xanthicus, and says the soldiers, when they found the rows of bodies, took no pleasure in it and wondered at the resolve of their enemies.

How it came to this

Judaea had been under Roman rule, direct or through client kings, since 63 BC. In 66, after years of misgovernment by procurators and violence between Jews and Greeks in the coastal cities, Jerusalem rose and wiped out its Roman garrison. The emperor Nero sent Vespasian with three legions. The rebels were divided among themselves from the start: priestly moderates, Zealots, and the followers of rival strongmen fought one another inside Jerusalem even as the legions closed in. Vespasian became emperor in 69, and his son Titus took the city in the summer of 70 and burned the Temple.

The Sicarii at Masada had played little part in any of this. Their first leader, Menahem, had been killed in Jerusalem by other Jews in 66, and his kinsman Eleazar withdrew with the survivors to the rock. Josephus says that from there they raided the surrounding country, and that at the nearby settlement of En Gedi they killed more than seven hundred women and children. After Jerusalem fell, Roman governors reduced the remaining fortresses of Herodium and Machaerus. Masada was the last.

How each side saw it

Josephus

Everything comes from the seventh book of his Jewish War. Born Yosef ben Matityahu, a priest, he commanded the rebels in Galilee, and when his own garrison at Jotapata fell in 67 he survived a suicide pact among its last defenders and went over to the Romans. He wrote in Rome on a Flavian pension. He loathed the Sicarii and blamed such men for the ruin of his nation, yet he gives Eleazar the noblest speeches in the book. He was not there. He says the story came from the surviving women, one of whom he calls intelligent and well educated.

Rabbinic tradition

The rabbis who rebuilt Jewish life after the destruction never mention Masada. The Mishnah and Talmud speak at length of the fall of Jerusalem and of the later revolt of Bar Kokhba, but not of Eleazar or his followers. Jewish law treats suicide as a grave sin, with narrow exceptions, and the sages had little sympathy for the factions whose violence they held partly responsible for the catastrophe. Josephus’s Greek text was preserved by Christian copyists. Jews in the Middle Ages knew the story mainly through a tenth-century Hebrew reworking, the Josippon, in which the defenders die fighting.

Zionist and Israeli tradition

In the 1920s the story was rediscovered as a tale of resistance. Yitzhak Lamdan’s Hebrew poem of 1927 supplied the line that Masada shall not fall again; youth movements hiked to the summit, and for decades Israeli armoured corps recruits took their oath there. Yigael Yadin, a former chief of staff turned archaeologist, excavated the site in 1963-65 with thousands of volunteers and presented his finds as confirmation of Josephus. In this telling the defenders were patriots, the raid on En Gedi dropped out of view, and the lesson was that Jews would never again be without the means to defend themselves.

Rome

No Roman account survives. For the empire Masada was a mopping-up operation at the edge of a province three years after the war had been won and celebrated; the triumph of Vespasian and Titus had already been held and the Judaea Capta coins already struck. Silva went on to hold the consulship in 81. What the Roman army left is physical: the siege wall, the camps and the ramp are the best-preserved Roman siege works anywhere. They show that the force was large and its commander thorough, and that a few hundred holdouts were thought worth the trouble as an example.

What is disputed

The year is uncertain: 73 is traditional, but Werner Eck argued from inscriptions on Silva’s career for 74. The day depends on which calendar Josephus meant by Xanthicus; 15 April and 16 April are both given, and neither is secure. The siege probably lasted weeks or a few months, not years. Whether the mass suicide happened as described is doubted: Shaye Cohen showed how closely the scene follows Greek literary convention, and the speeches are plainly Josephus’s own. Yadin found about twenty-eight skeletons, not hundreds, and the identity of those in a cave is contested. His ostraca bearing names, one of them ‘ben Yair’, may or may not be the lots.

What followed

Judaea was garrisoned and taxed, rose again under Bar Kokhba in 132-135, and was crushed with far greater loss. Masada was occupied briefly by Byzantine monks and then forgotten until American travellers identified it in 1838. In the 1990s the sociologist Nachman Ben-Yehuda traced how a story of a murderous faction’s suicide became a national myth of heroic last stand, and the Israeli army has largely stopped holding ceremonies there. It became a World Heritage Site in 2001 and is among the most visited places in Israel, by people who draw quite different lessons from it.

Read further

  • Flavius Josephus, The Jewish War, Book 7
  • Yigael Yadin, Masada: Herod’s Fortress and the Zealots’ Last Stand (1966)
  • Shaye J. D. Cohen, ‘Masada: Literary Tradition, Archaeological Remains, and the Credibility of Josephus’, Journal of Jewish Studies (1982)
  • Nachman Ben-Yehuda, The Masada Myth: Collective Memory and Mythmaking in Israel (1995)
  • Jodi Magness, Masada: From Jewish Revolt to Modern Myth (2019)

Same day, other years

1715

The Yamasee War begins at Pocotaligo

Pocotaligo, South CarolinaThe Americas

The Yamasee had been allies of the English colony of Carolina for a generation, raiding Spanish Florida with its traders and selling them deerskins and captives. By 1715 they owed those traders a debt they could never pay, and traders had begun seizing Yamasee women and children as slaves to cover it. A census of their towns that year looked to them like a preparation for enslaving them all. On Good Friday, 15 April, warriors at Pocotaligo killed a delegation sent to hear their complaints, among them the Indian agent Thomas Nairne, who was tortured to death. Creeks, Catawbas and others joined in. Some four hundred colonists died and the colony was nearly abandoned.

Seen from elsewhere. Carolina’s officials wrote of treachery and a Spanish plot. The Yamasee left no written account; their grievances are known from the colony’s own trade commission records, which had logged complaints of beatings, rape and enslavement for years without acting. The war ended when the Cherokee sided with the English. The surviving Yamasee fled to Florida.

1912

The Titanic goes down

North Atlantic, south of NewfoundlandWorldwide

The largest ship afloat, four days into her first crossing from Southampton to New York, struck an iceberg late on 14 April and sank at twenty past two the next morning. She carried about 2,200 people and lifeboats for 1,178, which was more than the law required. Several boats left partly empty. The band played on deck; the wireless operators kept sending until the power failed. The Cunard liner Carpathia arrived two hours later and picked up some 710 survivors from the boats. About 1,500 people died in water at two degrees below freezing. Almost all the children in first and second class were saved, and about a third of those in third class.

Seen from elsewhere. The American and British inquiries blamed speed in an ice field and outdated regulations, and largely cleared the owners. Third-class survivors spoke of gates and of being left to find their own way up; the British inquiry found no deliberate discrimination but heard only three of them. Captain Lord of the nearby Californian, blamed for not responding, protested his innocence for life.

1945

British troops enter Bergen-Belsen

Bergen-Belsen, GermanyEurope

The German army, fearing that typhus would spread into the countryside, negotiated a local truce and handed the camp over to the British 11th Armoured Division. The soldiers found about 60,000 people in the two compounds, most of them starving and sick, and some 13,000 unburied corpses lying between the huts. There had been no food or water for days. Belsen had no gas chambers; it had been overwhelmed in the last months by transports from camps further east. Anne Frank and her sister Margot had died there a few weeks earlier. Despite an improvised medical effort, nearly 14,000 more people died after the liberation. The BBC’s Richard Dimbleby had to insist before his report was broadcast.

Seen from elsewhere. The commandant, Josef Kramer, stayed to hand over and told his captors conditions were not his fault; a British court hanged him and ten others. Jewish survivors, who were the majority, protested that British reports called them simply nationals of various countries, and their displaced persons’ camp at Belsen became a centre of agitation for entry to Palestine.

1989

Hu Yaobang’s death brings students into Tiananmen Square

Beijing, ChinaAsia

Hu Yaobang had been general secretary of the Chinese Communist Party until 1987, when the party elders forced him out for being too soft on student protest and too keen on political reform. He had earlier overseen the rehabilitation of several million people persecuted under Mao, and was thought personally honest. He collapsed at a Politburo meeting and died a week later, on 15 April 1989. Within hours wreaths and posters appeared at Beijing’s universities, some saying that the wrong man had died. Mourning turned into marches, a sit-down before the Great Hall of the People, and by May an occupation of Tiananmen Square with demands for a free press and an end to official corruption.

Seen from elsewhere. A People’s Daily editorial of 26 April, reflecting Deng Xiaoping’s view, called the movement turmoil planned by a handful of conspirators to negate the party’s leadership. The army cleared central Beijing on the night of 3 to 4 June; estimates of the dead range from a few hundred to more than a thousand. The official verdict has not been revised, and public commemoration is banned in mainland China.

Also on 15 April