Parallax

7 April, 1862

The second day at Shiloh

On Sunday a Confederate army overran Ulysses Grant’s camps and telegraphed a victory to Richmond. On Monday Grant attacked at dawn. The two days cost more American casualties than all the country’s earlier wars together.

Pittsburg Landing, Tennessee, United States

The battle had begun at first light on 6 April 1862, when some 44,000 Confederates under Albert Sidney Johnston came out of the woods onto the Union camps around a log meeting house called Shiloh, on the west bank of the Tennessee River. Grant’s army of about 40,000 had not entrenched. Many of his regiments had never fired their muskets. All day they were pushed back towards the steamboat landing, and one division that held a sunken farm track for hours was surrounded and surrendered with more than two thousand men.

Johnston did not see it. In mid-afternoon, leading a charge near a peach orchard in blossom, he was struck behind the knee by a ball that cut the artery. He had sent his own surgeon to tend wounded prisoners, and bled to death within the hour, the highest-ranking officer killed on either side in the war. His second, P. G. T. Beauregard, took over, and near sunset called off the last assaults against a line of Union cannon above the landing. He wired Richmond that he had won a complete victory.

That night it rained hard. The wounded of both armies lay out between the lines, and two Union gunboats threw a shell into the Confederate bivouacs every quarter of an hour. Grant, on crutches after a fall from his horse, tried to sleep in a log house that turned out to be the surgeons’ operating room and went back out under a tree. William Tecumseh Sherman found him there with a cigar and a lantern. By Sherman’s later telling he said that they had had the devil’s own day, and Grant replied: ‘Yes. Lick ‘em tomorrow, though.’

He had reason. Through the night steamboats ferried over the leading divisions of Don Carlos Buell’s Army of the Ohio, and a stray division of his own under Lew Wallace finally arrived. At daybreak on Monday 7 April about 45,000 Union troops, half of them fresh, advanced against perhaps 28,000 tired Confederates who had spent the night plundering the captured camps. Beauregard’s men fought stubbornly back across the same fields, past the same church. Shortly after two in the afternoon, told by a staff officer that his army was like a lump of sugar soaked through and ready to dissolve, he ordered a retreat to Corinth, Mississippi.

Grant did not pursue far. The Union counted 13,047 killed, wounded and missing, the Confederacy 10,699. Grant wrote afterwards that one field was so covered with dead that a man could have crossed it in any direction without touching the ground.

How it came to this

In February 1862 Grant had taken Forts Henry and Donelson on the Tennessee and Cumberland rivers, capturing an army and opening both waterways into the heart of the Confederacy. Kentucky and most of middle Tennessee, including Nashville, fell with them. Johnston, commanding everything between the Appalachians and the Mississippi, pulled his scattered forces back and concentrated them at Corinth, a railway junction in northern Mississippi where the line from Memphis to the east crossed the line from the Gulf.

Corinth was the Union’s next objective. Grant was ordered to wait twenty-odd miles to the north at Pittsburg Landing until Buell’s army could march overland from Nashville to join him. Johnston and Beauregard resolved to destroy Grant before that happened. Their march from Corinth, planned for one day, took three in rain and confusion, and Beauregard wanted to call the attack off, certain that surprise was lost. Johnston is reported to have said that he would fight them if they were a million. On the Union side Sherman dismissed reports of enemy in the woods and Grant wrote to his superior that he had scarcely the faintest idea of an attack.

How each side saw it

The Confederate ‘lost opportunity’

Southern memory fixed on two moments: Johnston’s death and Beauregard’s order to halt on Sunday evening. Jefferson Davis, Johnston’s friend, wrote that the fortunes of the Confederacy in the west turned on that bullet, and Johnston’s son published a biography arguing that one more push would have driven Grant into the river. Beauregard answered for the rest of his life that the troops were exhausted, hungry, scattered through the Union camps and facing massed guns and gunboats across a flooded ravine. Most historians now side with Beauregard on the evening, while agreeing that his complicated attack plan had tangled the army from the first hour.

Buell’s army

Don Carlos Buell and his officers maintained that they had found Grant’s army beaten, with thousands of fugitives cowering under the river bluff, and that the Army of the Ohio had saved it. Buell set this out at length in the Century magazine in the 1880s. Grant and Sherman replied that the Confederate attack had already spent itself before a single one of Buell’s regiments fired, and that they would have attacked on Monday regardless. The quarrel between the veterans of the two armies ran for decades and shaped the monuments on the battlefield, where each state placed its markers to support its own account.

The Northern public

The casualty lists stunned a public that had expected a short war. Newspapers, led by a vivid dispatch from the young correspondent Whitelaw Reid, reported that Grant’s men had been bayoneted in their tents, which was untrue, and revived the old story that he drank. Governors and congressmen from Ohio and Iowa demanded his removal, and his superior Henry Halleck took the field in person and shelved him. Lincoln is said to have answered, ‘I can’t spare this man; he fights.’ The remark comes from a Pennsylvania politician’s memoir published thirty years later, and Grant’s biographer Brooks Simpson, among others, doubts it was ever said.

Men in the ranks

The clearest accounts came from privates and junior officers. Henry Morton Stanley, later the explorer of Africa, fought at twenty-one in an Arkansas regiment, described stepping over the first dead he had ever seen, and was captured on the second morning. Ambrose Bierce, a young soldier in Buell’s army, wrote of wounded men burned where they lay when the woods caught fire. Both sides’ letters dwell on thirst, on the rain, and on hogs among the dead. Thousands on each side ran on the first day. A pond near the peach orchard, where the wounded of both armies crawled to drink, was remembered as having turned red.

What is disputed

Whether Grant was surprised: he and Sherman always denied it, but neither had entrenched or posted adequate pickets, and most historians accept that they were caught unready if not literally asleep. The importance of the ‘Hornet’s Nest’ on the sunken road is also contested. The battlefield park’s first historian had fought there, and made it the hinge of the battle; Timothy Smith and others argue that the decisive fighting was on the flanks and that Confederate attention only turned to the position late. Lew Wallace’s seven-hour march on the wrong road was blamed on him by Grant, who later conceded the orders may have been unclear.

What followed

Corinth fell at the end of May and Memphis in June, opening the way down the Mississippi to Vicksburg. Shiloh’s larger effect was on expectations. Grant wrote that until then he had believed one great victory would end the rebellion, and that afterwards he gave up hope of saving the Union except by complete conquest. The total of 23,746 casualties was soon exceeded, at the Seven Days, Antietam and Gettysburg, but it was the first figure of that order. The battlefield became a national military park in 1894, and a national cemetery there holds some 3,500 Union dead, most of them unidentified. The Confederates lie in mass trenches.

Read further

  • Ulysses S. Grant, Personal Memoirs of U. S. Grant (1885)
  • Wiley Sword, Shiloh: Bloody April (1974)
  • Larry J. Daniel, Shiloh: The Battle That Changed the Civil War (1997)
  • Timothy B. Smith, Shiloh: Conquer or Perish (2014)
  • James Lee McDonough, Shiloh: In Hell before Night (1977)

Same day, other years

1521

Magellan’s ships anchor at Cebu

Cebu, PhilippinesAsia

Three weeks after sighting the islands later named the Philippines, Ferdinand Magellan brought his three remaining ships into the busy port of Cebu and fired a salute that terrified the town. Its ruler, Rajah Humabon, at first demanded the harbour dues that every trading vessel paid. Through Magellan’s Malay interpreter, Enrique, he was persuaded instead into a blood compact and an alliance with the king of Spain. A week later Humabon, his wife and several hundred followers were baptised, and the queen was given a small carved image of the Christ child. Magellan then undertook to force neighbouring chiefs to submit to his new ally, and on 27 April was killed on the beach at Mactan.

Seen from elsewhere. The only detailed account is by the Italian Antonio Pigafetta, who sailed with the fleet; the islanders left none. The Philippine state’s commemoration in 2021 centred on the victory of Lapulapu at Mactan, not the arrival. Filipino Catholics honour the image, the Santo Nino of Cebu, as the beginning of their faith. Humabon killed some two dozen Spaniards at a feast days after Magellan died.

1803

Toussaint Louverture dies in a French mountain fortress

Fort de Joux, Jura, FranceEurope

The gaoler found him in the morning seated by the fireplace of his cell, his head against the chimney, dead. Toussaint, born enslaved on a sugar plantation in Saint-Domingue, had become the leading general of the only successful slave revolution in history and, by 1801, governor for life of the colony under a constitution of his own. Napoleon Bonaparte sent an army of more than twenty thousand under his brother-in-law to remove him. In June 1802 Toussaint was invited to a meeting by a French general, seized, and shipped to France. He was held without trial through a winter in the Jura at nearly a thousand metres, with his firewood and food rationed and his servant taken away. Haiti declared independence nine months later.

Seen from elsewhere. The French autopsy recorded pneumonia and apoplexy; Haitians have always held that he was left to die. On St Helena Napoleon called the expedition one of his great mistakes. Toussaint’s own rule is debated: he abolished slavery but bound former slaves to the plantations under military discipline and had his nephew Moyse shot for leading labourers against it.

1831

The emperor of Brazil abdicates in favour of a five-year-old

Rio de Janeiro, BrazilThe Americas

Pedro I had proclaimed Brazil’s independence from Portugal in 1822 and then quarrelled with almost everyone who had supported him. He dissolved the first constituent assembly, lost a war and a province in the south, and was suspected, being Portuguese-born, of caring more about his daughter’s claim to the throne in Lisbon than about Brazil. In March 1831 Brazilians and Portuguese fought in the streets of Rio. When he dismissed a popular ministry on 5 April, a crowd of thousands gathered and the garrison joined it. In the small hours of 7 April he wrote out his abdication in favour of his son, boarded a British warship and left for Europe, where he died three years later.

Seen from elsewhere. Liberals hailed the day as the true completion of independence. The regency that governed for the child Pedro II faced a decade of provincial revolts, among them a rising of enslaved Muslims in Bahia in 1835. For the enslaved, a large part of the population, little changed: a law of the same year banning the Atlantic slave trade went largely unenforced for two decades.

1945

The battleship Yamato is sunk on a one-way mission

East China Sea, north of OkinawaAsia

The largest battleship ever built left the Inland Sea on 6 April with a light cruiser and eight destroyers and no air cover. Her orders were to fight through to Okinawa, where American forces had landed six days before, run aground and serve as a fixed battery until destroyed. American submarines reported her within hours. From half past twelve the next day nearly four hundred aircraft from the carriers of Task Force 58 attacked in waves. Yamato took at least ten torpedoes and several bombs, rolled over at 2.23 in the afternoon and blew up with an explosion seen from Kyushu, over a hundred miles away. About three thousand of her crew of 3,332 died. The Americans lost ten aircraft.

Seen from elsewhere. Yoshida Mitsuru, a young officer who survived, wrote that the junior officers argued on the way out about what their deaths were for. Senior commanders had opposed the sortie as waste; it went ahead, by several accounts, after the emperor asked whether the navy had no ships left to help Okinawa. In Japan the ship is remembered both as sacrifice and as futility.

Also on 7 April