Parallax

5 April, 1794

Danton goes to the guillotine he helped set up

The loudest voice of the French Revolution was condemned by the tribunal he had created, after a trial in which the government passed a law to stop him speaking.

Place de la Revolution, Paris

They came for Georges-Jacques Danton in the night of 30 March 1794, 10 Germinal of Year II by the revolutionary calendar. Friends had warned him for weeks and urged him to strike first or run. He is said to have answered that a man does not carry his country away on the soles of his shoes. Arrested with him were the journalist Camille Desmoulins, who had been at school with Robespierre, and two other deputies. Next morning in the Convention the butcher Legendre asked that the accused be heard at the bar. Robespierre replied that anyone who trembled was guilty, and Legendre sat down.

The trial opened on 2 April before the Revolutionary Tribunal. To blur the politics, the prosecutor Fouquier-Tinville put sixteen defendants in the dock together: Danton’s group alongside deputies charged with a share-dealing fraud over the East India Company, and a handful of foreign bankers. Asked his name and address, Danton said that his dwelling would soon be in nothingness and his name in the pantheon of history. Then he began to speak, in the voice that had carried across the Champ de Mars, demanding witnesses and his accusers face to face. The windows were open and the crowd outside, as far as the river, could hear him.

By the third day the judges were alarmed. Fouquier sent a note to the Committee of Public Safety saying the accused were appealing to the people. Saint-Just went to the Convention with a report of a prison plot to free them, involving Desmoulins’s wife Lucile, and obtained a decree that any prisoner who resisted or insulted national justice could be removed from the hearing. On the morning of 5 April it was read out in court. The jury declared itself sufficiently informed, and sentence was passed in the defendants’ absence.

They were executed the same afternoon. Three carts carried fifteen men across Paris to the Place de la Revolution. Desmoulins tore his shirt struggling and shouting to the crowd; Danton told him to leave that vile rabble alone. Passing the house where Robespierre lodged in the Rue Saint-Honore he is supposed to have called out that Robespierre would follow him.

He went last, at dusk, having watched the others. When the executioner pulled him away from embracing Herault de Sechelles, he reportedly said that their heads would kiss in the basket anyway. A witness, the playwright Arnault, recorded his final words to the executioner: ‘Show my head to the people. It is worth the trouble.’ He was thirty-four.

How it came to this

Danton was a provincial lawyer from Champagne, huge, pockmarked and scarred from a childhood encounter with a bull, who made his name in 1789-91 as the orator of the Cordeliers district on the Left Bank. After the overthrow of the monarchy on 10 August 1792 he became minister of justice, and as the Prussians advanced that September he gave the speech calling for boldness, more boldness, always boldness. In the same days Paris crowds massacred more than a thousand prisoners, which he did nothing to stop. In March 1793 he proposed the Revolutionary Tribunal, and in April he sat on the first Committee of Public Safety.

Dropped from the Committee that July, widowed and remarried to a girl of sixteen, he withdrew for a time to his home town. He came back in November 1793 to find the Terror in full operation and began, with Desmoulins’s newspaper Le Vieux Cordelier, to argue for clemency and an end to the emergency. That set his circle, nicknamed the Indulgents, against both the governing Committee and the extreme faction around Hebert. The Committee destroyed the Hebertists first, on 24 March. Danton’s turn came six days later.

How each side saw it

The Committee of Public Safety

Saint-Just’s indictment, drafted from notes supplied by Robespierre that still survive, accused Danton of serving every enemy of the Revolution in turn: Mirabeau, the Duke of Orleans, the traitor general Dumouriez, foreign bankers. It charged him with enriching himself, with idleness and loose living, and with wanting to halt the Revolution before the Republic was safe. Robespierre had defended Danton in public as late as December 1793 and hesitated before agreeing to the arrest. The Committee’s case was that in wartime a campaign for clemency led by a compromised man was a rallying point for counter-revolution, and that the Republic could not survive two governments.

The Dantonist tradition

For Michelet, and for the Third Republic, Danton was the Revolution’s human face: patriot of 1792, organiser of national defence, a man who wanted to end the bloodshed and died for it. Alphonse Aulard, first holder of the Sorbonne’s chair in the history of the Revolution, made him its hero against a cold and fanatical Robespierre. Paris put up his statue at the Carrefour de l’Odeon in 1891. Georg Buchner’s play Danton’s Death, written in 1835, and Andrzej Wajda’s film of 1983, made in the shadow of martial law in Poland, both used him as the figure of a revolution devouring its own.

Mathiez and the case for the prosecution

Albert Mathiez, Aulard’s pupil turned adversary, spent years in the archives demonstrating that Danton took money. A letter of Mirabeau from March 1791 mentions thirty thousand livres paid to him from the court’s secret funds; his debts vanished and he bought land around Arcis far beyond a lawyer’s means; his accounts as minister were never produced. To Mathiez and the Marxist historians who followed, Robespierre was the principled democrat and Danton a venal opportunist whose clemency was a cover for making peace with the Revolution’s enemies. Norman Hampson’s biography of 1978 concluded that the corruption was probable but that treason was never shown.

The wives

Lucile Desmoulins, aged twenty-four, was arrested on the day her husband was condemned, on the strength of the alleged prison plot, and guillotined on 13 April. Her last letter to her mother survives. Danton’s second wife, Louise Gely, still in her teens, was left with his two young sons from his first marriage and a confiscated estate. She later remarried, became a baroness under the Empire, lived until 1856 and is said never to have spoken of him. The women appear in the record almost entirely through the men’s trial papers and letters.

What is disputed

Whether Danton was corrupt, and whether it matters, divided French historians for a century along the line between Aulard and Mathiez; the documents favour Mathiez on money and neither side on treason. His part in the September Massacres is argued too: he did not order them, but as minister of justice he let them run. The best-known sayings of his last week come from memoirs written long afterwards, Arnault’s in the 1830s, and the official trial record was doctored to remove most of his defence. The words to Robespierre’s window and about the basket are tradition, not testimony.

What followed

The Convention’s deputies concluded that no one was now safe. Less than four months later, on 9 Thermidor, a coalition of frightened men shouted Robespierre down, and one deputy is reported to have cried that Danton’s blood was choking him. He and Saint-Just were guillotined the next day on the same square, and the Terror was wound down. Fouquier-Tinville was himself tried and executed in 1795, pleading that he had only obeyed. The trial became the model case of a revolutionary court used by a government against its own founders, cited whenever later revolutions staged the same thing.

Read further

  • Norman Hampson, Danton (1978)
  • Albert Mathiez, Autour de Danton (1926)
  • R. R. Palmer, Twelve Who Ruled: The Year of the Terror in the French Revolution (1941)
  • Francois Furet and Mona Ozouf, A Critical Dictionary of the French Revolution (1989)
  • David Lawday, Danton: The Gentle Giant of Terror (2009)

Same day, other years

1614

Pocahontas is married to John Rolfe

Jamestown, VirginiaThe Americas

The daughter of Wahunsenaca, paramount chief of the Powhatan, had been lured aboard an English ship a year earlier and held as a hostage to force her father to return prisoners and weapons. In captivity she was instructed in Christianity and baptised as Rebecca. John Rolfe, a widowed planter who was experimenting with the tobacco that would make the colony pay, wrote to the governor asking leave to marry her, protesting at length that he acted for the good of the plantation and her soul and not from desire. The colonist Ralph Hamor dates the wedding to about 5 April. Her father sent an uncle and two brothers and did not attend. Some years of peace followed.

Seen from elsewhere. She left no words of her own; every contemporary account is English. Mattaponi oral tradition, published in 2007, holds that she already had a husband, Kocoum, and was assaulted while a prisoner. Historians are cautious about a tradition written down so late, but agree that a hostage of about seventeen was in no position to refuse.

1722

A Dutch squadron sights Rapa Nui on Easter Sunday

Rapa Nui (Easter Island), Pacific OceanOceania

Jacob Roggeveen, a 63-year-old lawyer sailing for the Dutch West India Company in search of a supposed southern continent, came upon a small island more than two thousand kilometres from any other inhabited land and named it for the day. His three ships stood off for several days. When a party of about 130 men finally landed, nervous sailors opened fire on the crowd that pressed around them and killed ten or twelve islanders. The visitors stayed a single day. Roggeveen’s journal describes fertile gardens, a population he put in the thousands, and enormous stone figures standing upright along the shore, which he could not understand a people without heavy timber or strong rope having raised.

Seen from elsewhere. Polynesians had settled the island some five centuries earlier. The popular account says they ruined it themselves by felling every tree before Europeans came. The archaeologists Terry Hunt and Carl Lipo, among others, argue that the collapse came after contact, from disease and from the Peruvian slave raids of 1862-63, which left only 111 islanders by 1877.

1976

Mourners for Zhou Enlai are cleared from Tiananmen Square

Beijing, ChinaAsia

Premier Zhou Enlai had died in January, and the radical leaders around Mao’s wife Jiang Qing had kept official mourning brief. At the Qingming festival, when Chinese families honour their dead, hundreds of thousands of people came to the Monument to the People’s Heroes over several days with wreaths and handwritten poems, some of them thinly veiled attacks on the radicals and on Mao himself. During the night of 4 April the authorities removed the wreaths. The next day an angry crowd overturned vehicles and set fire to a security post. That evening militia with clubs emptied the square. The Politburo declared the affair counter-revolutionary and stripped Deng Xiaoping of his posts.

Seen from elsewhere. The leadership said Deng had directed a plot; the participants said they had come to mourn. After Mao’s death and the arrest of the Gang of Four the verdict was reversed in 1978 and the protest renamed a revolutionary action. How many were beaten, jailed or killed has never been established. Thirteen years later the same square saw a far bloodier clearance.

1992

Fujimori shuts down Peru’s Congress

Lima, PeruThe Americas

On a Sunday night President Alberto Fujimori appeared on television to announce that he was dissolving Congress, suspending the constitution and reorganising the courts. Tanks were already outside the legislature and opposition leaders and journalists were being detained. Fujimori, elected in 1990 as an outsider, argued that a corrupt and obstructive political class was preventing him from dealing with economic collapse and with the Shining Path, a Maoist insurgency whose war with the state had by then cost tens of thousands of lives. Polls showed that a large majority of Peruvians approved. The insurgents’ leader was captured five months later, and a new constitution followed in 1993.

Seen from elsewhere. Supporters still credit him with ending hyperinflation and terror. Opponents point to what the closed institutions could no longer check: an army death squad that killed students and families, a campaign of coerced sterilisations among Indigenous women, and corruption run by his intelligence chief. Fujimori was convicted in 2009 and sentenced to twenty-five years.

Also on 5 April