Catherine Benincasa died in Rome on Sunday 29 April 1380, in a house near the church of Santa Maria sopra Minerva, at about the age of thirty-three. For months she had taken almost no food and, for a time, had refused even water. Each morning, until she could no longer walk, she had dragged herself the mile to St Peter’s to pray for a Church that had just split in two. In the weeks before Lent she collapsed there, and told her followers she had felt the ship of the Church set down on her shoulders.
She was a dyer’s daughter from Siena, the twenty-third or twenty-fourth of twenty-five children, born in the year before the Black Death reached the city. By her confessor’s account she saw Christ above the Dominican church at six, vowed her virginity at seven, and in her teens cut off her hair to defeat her mother’s plans for a husband. She joined not a convent but the Mantellate, a group of lay Dominican women, mostly widows, who lived at home. After about three years shut in a small room of the family house she came out and began nursing the sick and gathering followers: friars, noblemen, a poet, a painter. They called her mamma.
She could not at first write, and she never learned Latin. She dictated, sometimes to several secretaries at once, and some 380 of her letters survive, in a Tuscan as direct as speech. They went to prisoners and prostitutes, to the English mercenary captain John Hawkwood, to the queen of Naples, to cardinals and to the pope. In June 1376 she arrived in Avignon, where the popes had lived for nearly seventy years, as an unofficial envoy of Florence, then at war with the papacy. The Florentines disowned her mission. She stayed to tell Gregory XI what she had already written to him: to come back to Rome, reform his clergy, and be a man about it.
Gregory left Avignon that September and entered Rome in January 1377. He died fourteen months later. Under pressure from a Roman crowd demanding an Italian, the cardinals elected the archbishop of Bari as Urban VI, found him violent and unmanageable, and within five months declared the election void and chose another pope, who went back to Avignon. Europe divided between them. Catherine had no doubts: Urban was the true pope, and the cardinals who had abandoned him were devils in human shape. He summoned her to Rome in November 1378, and she spent her last seventeen months there, writing to kings on his behalf and wasting away.
She was buried at the Minerva. Within a few years her head was detached and carried home to Siena, where it is still displayed in the church of San Domenico. A Sienese pope, Pius II, declared her a saint in 1461.
How it came to this
The popes had left Rome in the first years of the fourteenth century and settled at Avignon, on the Rhone, under the eye of the French crown. Seven French popes in succession ruled from there. Their administration was efficient and their court rich, and Italians from Petrarch downward called it the Babylonian captivity of the Church. Meanwhile the pope’s own territories in central Italy were governed by French legates and mercenary armies, and in 1375 Florence led many of those towns into open war against him. Gregory XI put Florence under interdict, which is how Catherine came to be travelling on its behalf.
She belonged to a recognisable type in the Italian towns of her century: the lay holy woman, attached to the friars but living in the world, whose authority came from visions and from visible austerity. Such women were admired and watched in equal measure. In 1374 Catherine was called before the Dominican chapter in Florence, evidently to be examined, and was afterwards given a learned friar, Raymond of Capua, as director. Another visionary, Bridget of Sweden, had spent twenty years in Rome demanding the pope’s return and died in 1373.