Parallax

29 April, 1380

Catherine of Siena dies in Rome

A dyer’s daughter with no schooling lectured two popes, dictated one of the first great books in Italian and starved herself to death at thirty-three. How much she changed is still debated.

Rome, Italy

Catherine Benincasa died in Rome on Sunday 29 April 1380, in a house near the church of Santa Maria sopra Minerva, at about the age of thirty-three. For months she had taken almost no food and, for a time, had refused even water. Each morning, until she could no longer walk, she had dragged herself the mile to St Peter’s to pray for a Church that had just split in two. In the weeks before Lent she collapsed there, and told her followers she had felt the ship of the Church set down on her shoulders.

She was a dyer’s daughter from Siena, the twenty-third or twenty-fourth of twenty-five children, born in the year before the Black Death reached the city. By her confessor’s account she saw Christ above the Dominican church at six, vowed her virginity at seven, and in her teens cut off her hair to defeat her mother’s plans for a husband. She joined not a convent but the Mantellate, a group of lay Dominican women, mostly widows, who lived at home. After about three years shut in a small room of the family house she came out and began nursing the sick and gathering followers: friars, noblemen, a poet, a painter. They called her mamma.

She could not at first write, and she never learned Latin. She dictated, sometimes to several secretaries at once, and some 380 of her letters survive, in a Tuscan as direct as speech. They went to prisoners and prostitutes, to the English mercenary captain John Hawkwood, to the queen of Naples, to cardinals and to the pope. In June 1376 she arrived in Avignon, where the popes had lived for nearly seventy years, as an unofficial envoy of Florence, then at war with the papacy. The Florentines disowned her mission. She stayed to tell Gregory XI what she had already written to him: to come back to Rome, reform his clergy, and be a man about it.

Gregory left Avignon that September and entered Rome in January 1377. He died fourteen months later. Under pressure from a Roman crowd demanding an Italian, the cardinals elected the archbishop of Bari as Urban VI, found him violent and unmanageable, and within five months declared the election void and chose another pope, who went back to Avignon. Europe divided between them. Catherine had no doubts: Urban was the true pope, and the cardinals who had abandoned him were devils in human shape. He summoned her to Rome in November 1378, and she spent her last seventeen months there, writing to kings on his behalf and wasting away.

She was buried at the Minerva. Within a few years her head was detached and carried home to Siena, where it is still displayed in the church of San Domenico. A Sienese pope, Pius II, declared her a saint in 1461.

How it came to this

The popes had left Rome in the first years of the fourteenth century and settled at Avignon, on the Rhone, under the eye of the French crown. Seven French popes in succession ruled from there. Their administration was efficient and their court rich, and Italians from Petrarch downward called it the Babylonian captivity of the Church. Meanwhile the pope’s own territories in central Italy were governed by French legates and mercenary armies, and in 1375 Florence led many of those towns into open war against him. Gregory XI put Florence under interdict, which is how Catherine came to be travelling on its behalf.

She belonged to a recognisable type in the Italian towns of her century: the lay holy woman, attached to the friars but living in the world, whose authority came from visions and from visible austerity. Such women were admired and watched in equal measure. In 1374 Catherine was called before the Dominican chapter in Florence, evidently to be examined, and was afterwards given a learned friar, Raymond of Capua, as director. Another visionary, Bridget of Sweden, had spent twenty years in Rome demanding the pope’s return and died in 1373.

How each side saw it

Raymond of Capua

Her confessor from 1374, later head of the Dominican order, finished his Life of her in 1395 with canonisation in view. His Catherine is above all obedient and miraculous: she receives a wedding ring from Christ that only she can see, the wounds of the crucifixion at Pisa in 1375, likewise invisible, and lives for long periods on the eucharist alone. He names his witnesses carefully, her mother among them, and confesses his own early doubts in order to overcome them. He says much less about her politics, which had ended in schism, and it was his portrait that the Church canonised.

Catherine in her own letters

The letters show someone the Life tones down. She writes ‘I will’ to popes. She tells Gregory XI to be manly and not fearful, tells Urban VI to govern his temper, and urges both, repeatedly, to launch a crusade against the Turks, partly as a way of sending Italy’s mercenaries somewhere else. She describes holding the head of a young man, Niccolo di Toldo, as he was beheaded in Siena, and her joy at being drenched in his blood. Her Dialogue, dictated in 1377-78, is a work of theology by a woman with no formal education, and the reason Paul VI named her a Doctor of the Church in 1970.

The Avignon obedience

France, Scotland, Castile, Aragon and Naples followed the Avignon pope, Clement VII. For them Urban’s election had been extorted by a mob, and the return to Rome was the mistake that made it possible. The Dominican preacher Vincent Ferrer, later a saint himself, wrote a treatise for Clement’s cause. In that camp Catherine was a partisan, not a prophet. A generation later the Paris theologian Jean Gerson, arguing for caution about visionaries, reported that Gregory XI on his deathbed had warned those around him against men and women who peddle visions under cover of religion, because by listening to them he had brought the Church to the edge of schism.

Modern historians

Rudolph Bell’s Holy Anorexia read her fasting as a medieval form of the eating disorder, a struggle for autonomy fought on her own body. Caroline Walker Bynum answered that food and hunger carried religious meanings for medieval women that a modern diagnosis misses. Robert Fawtier, in the 1920s, attacked the reliability of the early sources and suspected that her age at death had been adjusted to match Christ’s. More recently F. Thomas Luongo has shown how closely her career was bound up with papal and Sienese faction, and that her missions served interests her admirers preferred not to dwell on.

What is disputed

How far she moved Gregory XI is the central question. He had intended to return since his election, Bridget of Sweden had pressed the same demand for years, and the revolt of the Papal States gave him practical reasons to go; most historians credit Catherine with stiffening a decision already taken, not with making it. Her birth year, 1347, depends on Raymond. Whether she ever learned to write, as one letter says she did by a miracle in 1377, is doubted. The popular claim that she ended the Avignon papacy single-handed belongs to the hagiographic tradition more than to the documents.

What followed

The schism she died trying to heal lasted until 1417 and at one stage produced three rival popes. Raymond of Capua led a reform of the Dominican order in her name. She was made a patron of Italy in 1939, a Doctor of the Church in 1970, among the first women so named, and a patron of Europe in 1999. Her letters and Dialogue are counted among the early classics of Italian prose, a rare case of a medieval woman from the artisan class whose own words survive in quantity.

Read further

  • Catherine of Siena, The Dialogue, translated by Suzanne Noffke (1980)
  • Raymond of Capua, The Life of Catherine of Siena, translated by Conleth Kearns (1980)
  • F. Thomas Luongo, The Saintly Politics of Catherine of Siena (2006)
  • Caroline Walker Bynum, Holy Feast and Holy Fast: The Religious Significance of Food to Medieval Women (1987)
  • Rudolph M. Bell, Holy Anorexia (1985)

Same day, other years

1770

Cook’s first landing in Australia is opposed

Kamay (Botany Bay), AustraliaOceania

HMS Endeavour anchored in a wide bay on the east coast of the continent, and Lieutenant James Cook took two boats towards a group of bark huts on the southern shore. Two men of the Gweagal clan came down to the rocks with spears and shouted at the strangers, by every sign telling them to leave. Cook fired a musket between them, then small shot, which hit the older man in the legs. The men threw spears, fetched a shield, and withdrew after a third shot. The British landed, took forty or fifty spears from the huts and left beads in exchange. They stayed eight days, during which Joseph Banks collected so many plants that Cook named the place Botany Bay.

Seen from elsewhere. The words the men shouted, written down as ‘warra warra wai’, were long glossed as ‘go away’. Dharawal speakers say they mean something closer to ‘you are all dead’, a warning about spirits. Cook’s orders spoke of taking possession with the consent of the inhabitants; none was sought. Four of the spears were returned by Cambridge to the community in 2024.

1916

The garrison at Kut surrenders

Kut al-Amara, IraqMiddle East

After a siege of 147 days in a loop of the Tigris, Major-General Charles Townshend surrendered some 13,000 British and Indian soldiers and camp followers to the Ottoman army of Halil Pasha. They had been advancing on Baghdad and been driven back; relief forces lost 23,000 men trying to reach them. By the end the garrison was eating its horses and mules, and a British offer of a million pounds in gold, then two, for its release was refused with contempt. It was the largest surrender of a British army to that date. The men were marched north across the desert to labour camps in Anatolia. About 4,000 died in captivity. Townshend passed the rest of the war in a villa near Constantinople.

Seen from elsewhere. For the Ottomans it was a triumph to set beside Gallipoli, and the anniversary was a Turkish military holiday until 1952. Townspeople of Kut accused of helping the British were hanged. Two thirds of the garrison were Indian, and their experience is thinly recorded; the Bengali medical orderly Sisir Sarbadhikari’s memoir is among the few accounts from the ranks.

1991

A cyclone drowns the coast of Bangladesh

Chittagong, BangladeshAsia

A cyclone with winds of about 250 kilometres an hour came ashore near Chittagong late at night, at high tide, pushing a wall of water some six metres high across the low islands and mudflats of the south-east coast. On Sandwip, Kutubdia and other islands whole villages were swept away. About 138,000 people died, most of them by drowning, and a disproportionate number were women, children and the old. Up to ten million were left homeless. The storm had been tracked for days and warnings had been broadcast, but there were only a few hundred shelters for millions of people, and many did not leave. A new elected government, weeks old, appealed for foreign help.

Seen from elsewhere. Survivors told researchers why they stayed: earlier warnings had come to nothing, they feared losing cattle and land to thieves, and women were reluctant to go to crowded public shelters. Bangladesh then built thousands of shelters and a volunteer warning network. A cyclone of similar strength in 2007 killed about 3,400.

1992

Los Angeles burns after the Rodney King verdict

Los Angeles, United StatesThe Americas

In the afternoon a jury in suburban Simi Valley, with no Black members, acquitted four Los Angeles police officers of assaulting Rodney King, a Black motorist whose beating after a car chase in March 1991 had been filmed by a bystander and seen around the world. Within hours crowds gathered at the corner of Florence and Normandie in South Central. The police withdrew. Over six days of arson, looting and shooting, sixty-three people died, more than 2,000 were injured and about 12,000 arrested; damage reached a billion dollars. Order was restored by the National Guard, soldiers and Marines. Two of the officers were later convicted on federal civil rights charges.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Black residents call it an uprising against decades of policing, not a riot. Korean Americans, whose shops took much of the damage, call it Sa-i-gu, ‘four-two-nine’, and remember being left undefended. Behind that hostility lay the killing of fifteen-year-old Latasha Harlins by a Korean shopkeeper in 1991, punished with probation.

Also on 29 April