Parallax

26 April, 1937

Three hours over Guernica

German and Italian aircraft burned a Basque market town in an afternoon. The men responsible denied it for forty years, and a painting made sure nobody forgot.

Guernica (Gernika), Basque Country, Spain

Monday 26 April 1937 was a clear afternoon in Guernica, a town of perhaps 5,000 people, swollen by refugees and by Basque soldiers falling back from a front some twelve miles to the east. Monday was market day. The Basque authorities had tried to suspend markets because of the danger, and how many farmers came in anyway is one of the things still argued over. At about half past four the bell of Santa Maria rang the air-raid warning and a single German bomber came up the valley, dropped its load and turned away.

It was the first of many. For some three hours aircraft of the German Condor Legion, with a few Italian machines, came over in relays from airfields at Vitoria and Burgos. Fighters flew low along the roads out of town, machine-gunning people who ran for the fields. Early in the evening the heavy Junkers 52s arrived in waves and unloaded high explosive followed by thousands of small incendiary bombs. The sequence was deliberate: explosive to break open roofs and water mains, fire to finish what had been opened.

By nightfall the centre was a single fire, visible from the hills miles away. Father Alberto Onaindia, a Basque priest who drove into the raid by chance, described women and children lying in the ditches and the town burning from end to end. Roughly three quarters of the buildings were destroyed. Three things were not: the Renteria bridge, which German officers later named as the target; the small-arms factory on the edge of town; and the assembly house with the old oak beside it, under which Basque liberties had been sworn for centuries.

Four foreign reporters reached the ruins that night. George Steer’s dispatch ran in The Times and the New York Times on 28 April. He had picked up German incendiary casings and said so, and he wrote that the object of the raid seemed to be the demoralisation of the civilian population and the destruction of the cradle of the Basque race. Franco’s headquarters answered that no aircraft had flown that day, and that the Basques and their ‘Red’ allies had dynamited and burned their own town as they retreated.

Nationalist troops occupied Guernica on 29 April and kept journalists under escort. In Paris, Pablo Picasso had been commissioned to paint a mural for the Spanish Republic’s pavilion at that summer’s international exhibition and had not yet settled on a subject. He read the reports and saw the photographs. He made his first sketches on 1 May. The canvas, more than seven and a half metres wide, in black, white and grey, was finished in about five weeks.

How it came to this

Spain’s civil war began in July 1936 when part of the army rose against the elected Popular Front government. Hitler and Mussolini sent the rebels aircraft, men and arms. The Condor Legion, about 5,000 German airmen and specialists rotating through Spain, flew under its own commanders, Hugo Sperrle and his chief of staff Wolfram von Richthofen, in support of Spanish operations. Having failed to take Madrid, Franco turned in the spring of 1937 on the isolated northern strip of Republican territory, with its iron mines and steelworks.

The Basques were an awkward enemy for a movement that called itself a Catholic crusade. They were devout and conservative, and they had sided with the Republic because it granted them self-government in October 1936; their president, Jose Antonio Aguirre, took his oath under the oak at Guernica. General Emilio Mola opened the northern offensive on 31 March with a proclamation threatening to raze Vizcaya to the ground if submission were not immediate. On the same day bombers hit the town of Durango, killing at least 250 people, among them priests and nuns at Mass.

How each side saw it

The Basque government and the survivors

President Aguirre told the world the next day that German airmen in the service of the Spanish rebels had bombed Guernica and burned the historic town. His government put the dead at 1,654. Survivors’ testimony, much of it collected decades later by the local history group Gernikazarra and by oral historians, describes hours in overcrowded shelters, the smell of burning and the strafing of the roads. For forty years under Franco they could not say in public who had done it, and the official version was taught in the town’s own schools. For Basques the choice of target was itself the message: the town of the oak.

Franco’s regime

Franco’s press office under Luis Bolin first denied that any raid had taken place, then held that whatever bombs fell had done little and that the fire was arson by retreating Asturian miners and anarchists, as had happened at Irun in 1936. The regime kept to this for decades. From the 1970s Nationalist military historians, notably Jesus Salas Larrazabal, accepted that the town had been bombed but argued that the dead numbered little over a hundred, that it was a legitimate target behind a collapsing front, and that the Germans had acted without the knowledge of Franco or Mola.

The Condor Legion

Richthofen’s diary treats the day as an operation against the bridge and road junction on the edge of the town, meant to trap retreating Basque battalions, and records afterwards, with professional satisfaction, that a town of 5,000 inhabitants had been literally levelled. German veterans later said smoke and dust hid the target from the later waves, who bombed blind. Critics answer that incendiaries are a strange weapon to use against a stone bridge. In 1997 the German president, Roman Herzog, sent a message to the survivors acknowledging the guilt of the German airmen.

Historians since 1975

Herbert Southworth’s Guernica! Guernica! (1977) took the denial apart document by document and remains the foundation. Since then the argument has moved to intent and command. Angel Vinas and Paul Preston hold that an attack of this size could not have been mounted without the approval of Mola’s staff, and that frightening Bilbao into surrender was the point. Xabier Irujo goes further and sees a planned experiment in destroying a town. Other historians of the Legion stress how routinely it bombed places behind the lines, which makes Guernica less an exception than the best reported case.

What is disputed

The death toll above all. The Basque government’s 1,654 was long standard; local researchers have documented about 126 named victims and many historians now accept 150 to 300, while Irujo argues for more than 2,000 on the grounds that refugees went uncounted and the occupiers destroyed records. Who gave the order, and whether Franco knew beforehand, is not settled by any surviving document. Whether a full market was under way is uncertain. Nor was Guernica the first town bombed from the air: Durango and Madrid came before it, as had colonial bombing in Morocco, Iraq and Ethiopia.

What followed

Bilbao fell on 19 June 1937 and the whole northern front by October. Picasso refused to let his painting go to Spain while Franco ruled. It spent four decades at the Museum of Modern Art in New York and arrived in Madrid in 1981, where it has hung in the Reina Sofia museum since 1992 despite repeated Basque requests to have it. A full-size woven copy hangs outside the United Nations Security Council chamber. The town’s name became shorthand for the bombing of civilians, applied since to Warsaw, Coventry, Dresden, Hiroshima and Aleppo alike.

Read further

  • G. L. Steer, The Tree of Gernika: A Field Study of Modern War (1938)
  • Herbert R. Southworth, Guernica! Guernica! A Study of Journalism, Diplomacy, Propaganda, and History (1977)
  • Paul Preston, The Destruction of Guernica (2012)
  • Xabier Irujo, Gernika, 1937: The Market Day Massacre (2015)
  • Gijs van Hensbergen, Guernica: The Biography of a Twentieth-Century Icon (2004)

Same day, other years

1478

Murder at High Mass in Florence

Florence, ItalyEurope

On Easter Sunday, during Mass in the cathedral of Florence, a group of conspirators fell on the two Medici brothers who ran the city from behind its republican institutions. Giuliano was stabbed nineteen times and died on the floor. Lorenzo, cut in the neck, fought his way into the sacristy and his friends slammed the bronze doors. Across town the archbishop of Pisa, Francesco Salviati, tried and failed to seize the government palace. Florentines sided with the Medici. By evening the archbishop, in his robes, and Francesco de’ Pazzi were hanging from the palace windows, and some eighty people were killed in the reprisals that followed.

Seen from elsewhere. The Pazzi cried ‘People and liberty’, and their case was that the Medici had turned a republic into a family possession. Pope Sixtus IV, whose nephew helped plan the attack, said he had wanted a change of government without bloodshed, then excommunicated Lorenzo for hanging an archbishop. A letter decoded in 2004 implicated the duke of Urbino as well.

1942

The deadliest mine disaster on record

Benxi, Liaoning, ChinaAsia

A gas and coal-dust explosion tore through the Benxihu colliery in Japanese-controlled Manchuria, sending flames out of the shaft entrance. The mine was run by a Japanese company for the war economy, and most of the men underground were Chinese, many of them conscripted or recruited under duress and held in guarded compounds. To put out the fire the managers shut off the ventilation and sealed the pit head. When the workings were reopened days later, 1,549 men were dead, 31 of them Japanese. A Soviet inquiry after the war concluded that most had died not in the blast but of carbon monoxide poisoning after the air was cut off.

Seen from elsewhere. Wartime censorship kept the scale quiet, and the company treated it as an industrial accident fought by the standard method of starving a fire of air. In China it is remembered as a crime of the occupation, marked by a memorial at the mass grave. The main evidence for the cause of death is the Soviet report; company records are thin.

1964

Tanganyika and Zanzibar become one country

Dar es Salaam, TanzaniaAfrica

Julius Nyerere of Tanganyika and Abeid Karume of Zanzibar exchanged the instruments that joined the mainland and the islands in a single republic, renamed Tanzania later that year. It came barely three months after a revolution on Zanzibar had overthrown the sultan and an Arab-led government newly independent of Britain, with the killing of several thousand Arabs and South Asians. Karume’s new regime included men trained in Cuba and China, and Washington and London feared an African Cuba off the coast. Nyerere, a committed pan-Africanist who also wanted the islands stabilised, moved fast: the deal was negotiated in secret within a few days and Zanzibar kept its own president and government.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Zanzibaris point out that the union was never put to a vote and question whether the islands’ Revolutionary Council ever properly ratified it; demands for greater autonomy recur at every election. The revolution is officially celebrated as the liberation of the African majority and mourned by the families of those killed, whose numbers are put anywhere from a few thousand to 20,000.

1986

Reactor four explodes at Chernobyl

Pripyat, Ukraine, Soviet UnionEurope

At 1.23 in the morning, during a safety test meant to show that the turbines could power the cooling pumps in a blackout, the fourth reactor at the Chernobyl nuclear station surged out of control. Two explosions blew off its thousand-tonne lid and threw burning graphite onto the roofs. Firemen who went up without protection received fatal doses. The nearby town of Pripyat, with nearly 50,000 people, was not evacuated for some thirty-six hours, and the Soviet government said nothing publicly until Swedish monitors detected the cloud two days later. Two men died that night and twenty-eight more of acute radiation sickness within months.

Seen from elsewhere. A Soviet court blamed the operators and jailed the plant’s managers. In 1992 the international nuclear safety advisers revised their finding and placed most weight on design faults in the reactor that the operators had not been told about. The eventual death toll is disputed, from about 4,000 in UN agency estimates to many tens of thousands in others.

Also on 26 April