Parallax

2 April, AD 748

Charlemagne’s birthday, which his own biographer could not supply

A monastery calendar gives 2 April as the day the future emperor was born. Nobody wrote down the year or the place, and the man who knew him best said it would be absurd to try.

Francia (birthplace unknown)

The only evidence for the day is a line in a calendar kept at the abbey of Lorsch on the Rhine in the early ninth century, which notes the birth of the lord and most glorious Charles, emperor, on the fourth day before the Nones of April: 2 April. The year is another matter. Einhard, who lived at court for more than twenty years and wrote the emperor’s life after his death, declared that nothing had been written about Charles’s birth, infancy or boyhood, that nobody was left alive who could tell him, and that he would therefore pass over it.

Einhard did say that Charles died in January 814 in his seventy-second year, and from that later ages worked back to 742. The trouble is that his parents, Pippin, mayor of the palace to a powerless Merovingian king, and Bertrada, daughter of the count of Laon, are recorded in one set of annals as marrying in 744. A short set of annals, however, enters under 747 the words ‘in this year King Charles was born’. In that year 2 April was Easter Sunday, a coincidence no monk would have left unremarked. The German historian Matthias Becher pointed out that the annalist probably began his year at Easter, which in 748 fell on 21 April, so that a birth on 2 April 748 would still be written under 747.

On that reckoning the child was three when his father, with the pope’s approval, had the last Merovingian tonsured and sent to a monastery, and was himself made king of the Franks. He was five or six in the winter of 753-54 when Pope Stephen II crossed the Alps to ask for help against the Lombards, and the boy was sent ahead to meet him on the road. At Saint-Denis that summer the pope anointed Pippin again, and his two sons with him.

What followed is better recorded. Charles inherited half the kingdom in 768 and the whole of it when his brother Carloman died three years later. He took the Lombard crown in 774, fought the Saxons for three decades, destroyed the Avar state on the Danube and lost his rearguard to the Basques at Roncesvalles. On Christmas Day 800 Pope Leo III crowned him emperor in St Peter’s.

Einhard describes a tall, thick-necked man with a high voice who loved hot springs and roast meat, kept writing tablets under his pillow and never quite learned to form the letters. The bones preserved at Aachen suggest a height of about 1.84 metres, well above the average of his day. He died there on 28 January 814.

How it came to this

The Franks had ruled most of Gaul since the end of Roman government, under the long-haired kings of the Merovingian line. By the seventh century real power lay with the mayors of the palace, and from 687 that office was held by one family from the lands around the Meuse and Moselle. Charles Martel, the child’s grandfather, reunited the kingdom by force, beat back an Arab raiding army near Poitiers in 732 or 733, and ruled for his last years with no king on the throne at all.

His son Pippin wanted the title as well as the power. The papacy, threatened by the Lombards in Italy and estranged from the emperors in Constantinople, needed a protector. The exchange of 751-54, a crown sanctioned by Rome in return for Frankish armies in Italy, bound the new dynasty to the Church from its first day. It also meant that the family had an interest in how its origins were remembered, which may be one reason why the circumstances of the heir’s birth were allowed to fade.

How each side saw it

The Frankish court

Einhard’s Life, modelled on Suetonius’s lives of the Caesars, and the Royal Frankish Annals, compiled close to the palace, are the main narrative sources and both are partisan. They present an unbroken record of success and piety, and the Annals were later revised to admit defeats the first version had concealed, including Roncesvalles. Einhard claims that Charles disliked the imperial title so much that he would not have entered the church on Christmas Day had he known the pope’s intention, a statement most historians read as conventional modesty. A court poem of about 799 already calls him the father of Europe.

The Saxons

The Saxons were not literate and left no account of their own; their side survives in Frankish texts. Those record that in 782, after a Saxon force destroyed a Frankish army, Charles had 4,500 prisoners beheaded in a single day at Verden. A capitulary for the conquered territory made refusal of baptism, and eating meat in Lent, punishable by death. Even at court this was questioned: Alcuin of York wrote in 796 that faith is a matter of will, not compulsion, and that tithes had destroyed the Saxons’ belief. Thousands of families were deported into Francia. Their leader Widukind accepted baptism in 785.

Constantinople

To the Byzantines there was one Roman emperor and he sat in Constantinople. The coronation of a Frankish king by the bishop of Rome was, in their eyes, a usurpation made possible only because a woman, Irene, then held the throne. The chronicler Theophanes records, with evident distaste, a report that Charles proposed to marry her and unite the two halves. After a war over Venice and the Adriatic, Byzantine envoys at Aachen in 812 addressed him as basileus, emperor, but pointedly not as emperor of the Romans. Greek writers went on calling Westerners Franks for centuries.

France and Germany

Both nations claim him: Charlemagne in one, Karl der Grosse in the other, though he ruled before either existed and spoke a Germanic Frankish tongue. In the 1930s some Nazi ideologues, Alfred Rosenberg among them, denounced him as the butcher of the Saxons and honoured Widukind; Hitler overruled them, and an SS division of French volunteers later bore the name Charlemagne. Since 1950 the city of Aachen has awarded a Charlemagne Prize for services to European unity, treating him as the patron of a reconciled continent, a use of his memory that historians regard as no less selective than the others.

What is disputed

Almost everything about the birth. The year 742 rests on Einhard’s statement of his age; Karl Ferdinand Werner argued in 1973 for 747 and Matthias Becher in 1992 for 748, which Janet Nelson and most recent biographers accept. The day comes from a single calendar. The place is unknown: Herstal and Jupille near Liege, Aachen, Quierzy and others have all been proposed without evidence. A birth in 742, before his parents’ recorded marriage, would have made him illegitimate, which older historians took to explain Einhard’s silence. The figure of 4,500 at Verden is also doubted as too large, though few now deny the killing.

What followed

His empire did not outlast his grandsons, who divided it at Verdun in 843 into western, middle and eastern kingdoms, the remote ancestors of France and Germany and of the contested land between them. The imperial title was revived for the German kings in 962 and survived until 1806. More durable were the things his court standardised: a clear script from which modern lower-case letters descend, a silver coinage of pounds, shillings and pence, and the copying of Latin texts that would otherwise be lost. He was canonised in 1165 on the authority of an antipope, a status Rome never fully endorsed.

Read further

  • Einhard and Notker the Stammerer, Two Lives of Charlemagne, trans. Lewis Thorpe (1969)
  • Janet L. Nelson, King and Emperor: A New Life of Charlemagne (2019)
  • Rosamond McKitterick, Charlemagne: The Formation of a European Identity (2008)
  • Matthias Becher, Charlemagne (2003)
  • Alessandro Barbero, Charlemagne: Father of a Continent (2004)

Same day, other years

1513

Ponce de Leon comes ashore in a land he names Florida

Atlantic coast of FloridaThe Americas

Juan Ponce de Leon, a former governor of Puerto Rico, had sailed north-west with three ships and a royal licence to find and settle an island called Bimini. He sighted an unfamiliar coast in late March and, according to the later chronicler Antonio de Herrera, anchored on 2 April and went ashore, naming the country La Florida because it was the Easter season, Pascua Florida, and the land was green. He believed it to be an island. He then coasted south, met the Gulf Stream, which his pilot Anton de Alaminos would later use to carry treasure fleets home, and was driven off by Calusa warriors on the western shore.

Seen from elsewhere. Several hundred thousand people already lived there: Timucua, Ais, Tequesta, Calusa. Some reportedly greeted the ships with hostility and a few Spanish words, which suggests slave raiders had come before. The Calusa mortally wounded Ponce on his return in 1521. The fountain of youth appears in no document of his voyage; a rival chronicler added it later as mockery.

1801

Nelson ignores the signal at Copenhagen

Copenhagen, DenmarkEurope

A British fleet under Sir Hyde Parker had been sent to break the league of northern neutrals that threatened Britain’s access to Baltic timber and grain. Nelson took twelve ships of the line through the shoals to attack the Danish defence line, a row of warships and floating batteries moored before the city. After three hours of close-range gunnery Parker signalled him to break off. Nelson, by the account of an officer beside him, put his telescope to his blind eye and said he really did not see the signal. The Danish line was beaten down and a truce followed. Danish casualties were around 1,700 and British nearly a thousand.

Seen from elsewhere. Danes remember the Battle of the Roads as a defence by volunteers and citizens against an attack made without a declaration of war. Nelson’s truce letter warned that he would burn the captured batteries with their crews aboard; Danish writers call it a bluff by a man whose ships were aground. The British came back in 1807 and bombarded the city itself.

1930

Empress Zewditu dies and Ras Tafari takes the throne

Addis Ababa, EthiopiaAfrica

Zewditu, daughter of Menelik II, had reigned since 1916 as the first woman to head the Ethiopian state in modern times, with her young cousin Tafari Makonnen as regent and heir. The two stood for different courts: hers conservative and close to the Church, his set on schools, a written constitution and membership of the League of Nations. In March 1930 her estranged husband, Ras Gugsa Welle, rose in the north and was killed in battle on 31 March. Two days later the empress was dead, and Tafari was proclaimed emperor as Haile Selassie I. He was crowned in November before foreign delegations.

Seen from elsewhere. The palace said she died of illness, usually given as typhoid complicated by diabetes; rumour in Addis Ababa spoke of shock at her husband’s death, or poison, for which there is no evidence. Old nobles thought Tafari had taken power by stages. Rastafari in Jamaica soon hailed him as divine. Ethiopia’s own revolution deposed him in 1974.

1982

Argentina lands on the Falklands, or Malvinas

Stanley, Falkland IslandsThe Americas

Before dawn Argentine marines and commandos came ashore near Stanley, the capital of a British colony of about 1,800 people in the South Atlantic. A garrison of fewer than a hundred Royal Marines fought for a few hours around Government House before the governor, Rex Hunt, ordered them to lay down their arms. In Buenos Aires crowds filled the Plaza de Mayo to cheer a military junta they had been demonstrating against three days earlier. Britain sent a task force eight thousand miles. The war ended with the Argentine surrender on 14 June and cost the lives of 649 Argentines, 255 British servicemen and three islanders.

Seen from elsewhere. Argentina holds that it inherited the islands from Spain and that Britain expelled its authorities in 1833; 2 April is a national day for veterans and the fallen, though many Argentines distinguish the claim from the dictatorship that acted on it. The islanders say the decision is theirs, and in 2013 voted almost unanimously to stay British.

Also on 2 April