Parallax

17 April, 1790

Benjamin Franklin dies in Philadelphia

The printer who had charmed Versailles and helped write three founding documents spent his last weeks attacking slavery in the newspapers. His own country’s Senate declined to mourn him; France’s National Assembly wore black for three days.

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

For the last year of his life Benjamin Franklin hardly left his bedroom in the house off Market Street. Gout and a bladder stone kept him in bed, and he took laudanum for the pain, which he said left him little time in the day for anything else. He was 84. He still received visitors, still dictated letters, and in November 1789 told the French physicist Jean-Baptiste Le Roy that the new American constitution looked likely to last, although nothing in the world could be called certain except death and taxes.

His last public acts were about slavery. In February 1790, as president of the Pennsylvania Abolition Society, he signed a petition asking the first Congress to use its powers against the trade in human beings. Southern members were furious, and James Jackson of Georgia defended slavery on the floor of the House as sanctioned by scripture and necessity. Franklin answered in the Federal Gazette on 25 March with a hoax: a speech by one Sidi Mehemet Ibrahim of Algiers, supposedly delivered a century earlier, defending the enslavement of Christians in exactly Jackson’s terms. It was the last thing he published.

In early April he developed a fever and a pain in the chest. His physician, John Jones, recorded that an abscess formed in the left lung and then burst, after which breathing became a labour. His daughter Sarah Bache nursed him, with his grandsons Temple and Benjamin in the house. When she suggested he change position to breathe more easily he is reported to have answered that a dying man can do nothing easy. He sank into a stupor and died at about eleven at night on 17 April.

Four days later some 20,000 people, in a city of not many more than 40,000, followed the coffin to Christ Church burial ground, where he was laid beside his wife Deborah. The clergy of every denomination in Philadelphia walked at the front, the minister of the Jewish congregation among them. As a young man of 22 he had written a joking epitaph comparing his body to the cover of an old book, due to appear in a new edition corrected by the Author. His will ignored it and asked for a plain slab reading Benjamin and Deborah Franklin, 1790.

The House of Representatives, on James Madison’s motion, voted to wear mourning for a month. The Senate refused to follow. In Paris, when the news arrived in June, Mirabeau rose in the National Assembly and proposed three days of mourning for the man who, he said, had tamed both lightning and tyrants. It was carried by acclamation.

How it came to this

Franklin was born in Boston in 1706, the fifteenth child of a candle-maker, ran away from an apprenticeship to his brother at 17 and made a fortune as a printer in Philadelphia, largely from his newspaper and Poor Richard’s Almanack. He retired from business at 42. His experiments on electricity in the late 1740s, and the lightning rod that came out of them, made him the first American with a European reputation and won him the Royal Society’s Copley Medal.

He then spent most of thirty years abroad. In London he acted as agent for several colonies and long hoped to keep the empire together, until a public humiliation before the Privy Council in 1774 ended that hope. He returned to help draft the Declaration of Independence, sailed for France in 1776 and negotiated the alliance of 1778 without which the war could hardly have been won, then the peace of 1783. He came home in 1785 and sat, aged 81, in the convention that wrote the Constitution. He is the only man who signed all four documents.

How each side saw it

William Franklin and the Loyalists

Franklin’s only surviving son was the last royal governor of New Jersey and stayed loyal to the Crown. He was arrested in 1776, held for two years, part of it in a cell in Litchfield, and his wife died while he was a prisoner. He later directed Loyalist irregulars from New York and ended his life in exile in London. Father and son met once after the war, briefly and coldly. The will left William almost nothing, explaining that the part he had acted in the late war would account for it. To some 60,000 Loyalists who left the new country, Franklin was not a sage but a man who had broken an empire and his own family.

John Adams and Franklin’s American critics

Adams, who served beside him in Paris, thought Franklin lazy, vain, too fond of the French and too much adored by them. He predicted to Benjamin Rush that the history of the Revolution would be told as one long lie, in which Dr Franklin’s electrical rod struck the earth and out sprang General Washington. The Lee family of Virginia accused Franklin of tolerating corruption in the Paris mission. This hostility, together with Southern anger at the abolition petition, explains why the Senate would not adopt mourning, and why the official eulogy in Philadelphia a year later was delivered by a man who privately disliked him.

The people Franklin owned, and the abolitionists

Franklin held enslaved people for more than three decades. Peter and Jemima worked in his household; King ran away from him in England; his newspaper carried advertisements for slave sales and for runaways, and he profited from them. Those people left no testimony of their own and are known from his letters and account books. He turned against slavery late, in his seventies, and his will required his son-in-law to free a man named Bob. Quaker abolitionists such as Anthony Benezet had been pressing him for years. They welcomed his name on the 1790 petition, which Congress set aside, resolving that it had no power to interfere with slavery in the states.

Revolutionary France

To the French he was something America never quite allowed him to be: a philosopher in a fur cap, proof that natural genius needed neither birth nor a court. His face was on medallions, snuffboxes and, as he joked to his daughter, as well known as the moon’s. The men of 1789 claimed him as a forerunner. The eulogies by Mirabeau, Condorcet and the abbe Fauchet made him a patron of their own revolution, a use of his name that American Federalists soon found alarming.

What is disputed

How deep Franklin’s conversion on slavery went is argued. David Waldstreicher holds that he profited from the system all his working life and spoke against it only when it was safe; admirers point to the risk he took in 1790. Whether he personally flew the kite in a thunderstorm in 1752 has been doubted, notably by Tom Tucker, since the only detailed account was written by Joseph Priestley fifteen years later. The line about death and taxes was not original; versions appear in Christopher Bullock in 1716 and in Daniel Defoe. His dying remark comes from those at the bedside and may have been tidied in the retelling.

What followed

The slavery petition he signed was shelved, and Congress did not touch the subject seriously again for a generation. His Autobiography, unfinished and published after his death, became the model for the American story of self-improvement. He left 1,000 pounds each to Boston and Philadelphia to be lent to young tradesmen and to accumulate for two hundred years; the funds were finally paid out in the 1990s, worth several million dollars. His reputation has moved with the times: a symbol of thrift to the nineteenth century, of complacent materialism to D. H. Lawrence and Max Weber, and lately a test case for how the founders are to be judged on slavery.

Read further

  • Benjamin Franklin, The Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin
  • Edmund S. Morgan, Benjamin Franklin (2002)
  • Walter Isaacson, Benjamin Franklin: An American Life (2003)
  • David Waldstreicher, Runaway America: Benjamin Franklin, Slavery, and the American Revolution (2004)
  • Sheila L. Skemp, William Franklin: Son of a Patriot, Servant of a King (1990)

Same day, other years

1492

Columbus gets his contract

Santa Fe, near Granada, SpainEurope

In the siege camp from which Ferdinand and Isabella had taken Granada three months earlier, the royal secretary Juan de Coloma and a friar acting for Christopher Columbus agreed the terms of a westward voyage. The document, known as the Capitulations of Santa Fe, made the Genoese sailor Admiral of the Ocean Sea, viceroy and governor of whatever islands and mainlands he might find, with a tenth of all gold, pearls and spices, the titles to pass to his heirs. It was signed barely two weeks after the same monarchs ordered the Jews of Spain to convert or leave.

Seen from elsewhere. Nobody consulted the people who lived on the lands being granted. The Crown itself soon thought the terms absurdly generous, stripped Columbus of his governorship in 1500, and fought his heirs in the courts for decades. The original is lost; the text survives in registered copies, and whether it promised Asia or new lands is still debated.

1895

China signs away Taiwan at Shimonoseki

Shimonoseki, JapanAsia

After eight months of war in which Japan’s new army and navy had destroyed China’s, the elderly statesman Li Hongzhang signed a peace with Ito Hirobumi. China recognised the independence of Korea, ceded Taiwan, the Pescadores and the Liaodong peninsula, opened more ports and agreed to pay 200 million taels of silver. Li had been shot in the face by a Japanese nationalist during the talks and negotiated with the bullet still lodged below his eye. Within a week Russia, France and Germany forced Japan to hand Liaodong back for a further payment.

Seen from elsewhere. In Beijing, examination candidates led by Kang Youwei petitioned the throne to reject the treaty, the start of the reform movement. Officials and gentry on Taiwan declared a republic rather than be transferred, and resistance to the Japanese landing went on for months. Koreans, whose country the war was fought over, were party to nothing; Japan annexed Korea in 1910.

1961

The landing at the Bay of Pigs

Playa Giron, CubaThe Americas

About 1,400 Cuban exiles, trained and armed by the CIA in Guatemala, came ashore before dawn on the swampy south coast of Cuba. The plan, inherited by President Kennedy from Eisenhower, assumed that the landing would set off a rising against Fidel Castro. It did not. Kennedy, anxious to hide the American hand, had cut back the air strikes meant to destroy Castro’s small air force; the surviving planes sank the brigade’s supply ships. Within three days it was over. More than a hundred of the invaders were dead and nearly 1,200 were prisoners, later exchanged for food and medicine.

Seen from elsewhere. Cuba remembers Giron as the first defeat of the United States in Latin America, and Castro declared the revolution socialist on the eve of it. The exiles blamed Kennedy for abandoning them on the beach. The CIA’s own inspector general concluded that the agency had misled itself and the president about the chances.

1975

The Khmer Rouge empty Phnom Penh

Phnom Penh, CambodiaAsia

Five years of civil war ended when columns of young soldiers in black walked into the Cambodian capital. Many residents cheered them. Within hours the soldiers were ordering everyone out, saying the Americans were about to bomb and that people could return in three days. Some two million people, including patients pushed from hospitals in their beds, were driven into the countryside on foot. Officers and officials of the fallen republic were taken aside and killed. Over the next three years and eight months, between about 1.5 and 2 million Cambodians died from execution, overwork, hunger and untreated disease.

Seen from elsewhere. Khmer Rouge leaders, including Khieu Samphan at his trial decades later, said the evacuation was forced on them by food shortages and fear of bombing. Historians disagree on the toll and on how far the American bombing of 1969-73 drove recruits to the movement, but not on the regime’s responsibility for the deaths.

Also on 17 April